Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2102.05786 · Physical Review Letters

Dipole-Dipole Frequency Shifts in Multilevel Atoms

A. Cidrim, Asier Piñeiro Orioli, Christian Sanner, Ross B. Hutson, Jun Ye, Romain Bachelard, Ana María Rey

Published Jun 30, 2021• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Dipole-dipole interactions lead to frequency shifts that are expected to limit the performance of next-generation atomic clocks. In this work, we compute dipolar frequency shifts accounting for the intrinsic atomic multilevel structure in standard Ramsey spectroscopy. When interrogating the transitions featuring the smallest Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, we find that a simplified two-level treatment becomes inappropriate, even in the presence of large Zeeman shifts. For these cases, we show a net suppression of dipolar frequency shifts and the emergence of dominant nonclassical effects for experimentally relevant parameters. Our findings are pertinent to current generations of optical lattice and optical tweezer clocks, opening a way to further increase their current accuracy, and thus their potential to probe fundamental and many-body physics.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.127.013401

Related papers

Controlling dipole-dipole frequency shifts in a lattice-based optical atomic clock

Darrick E. Chang, Jun Ye, Mikhail D. Lukin

Motivated by the ideas of using cold alkaline-earth atoms trapped in an optical lattice for realization of optical atomic clocks, we investigate theoretically the perturbative effects of atom-atom interactions on a clock transition frequency. These interactions are mediated by the dipole fields associated with the optically excited atoms. We predict resonancelike features in the frequency shifts when constructive interference among atomic dipoles occur. We theoretically demonstrate that by fine tuning the coherent dipole-dipole couplings in appropriately designed lattice geometries, the undesirable frequency shifts can be greatly suppressed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0308068•Physical Review A•Feb 24, 2004•91 citations

Synthetic frequency protocol for Ramsey spectroscopy of clock transitions

Valeriy I. Yudin, A. V. Taǐchenachev, M. Yu. Basalaev +1 more

We develop a universal method to significantly suppress probe-induced shifts in any type of atomic clock using Ramsey spectroscopy. Our approach is based on the adaptation of the synthetic frequency concept [V. I. Yudin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 030801 (2011)] (previously developed for blackbody radiation shift suppression) to Ramsey spectroscopy with the use of interrogations with different dark time intervals. The most significant suppression of the shift is obtained in combination with the so-called hyper-Ramsey spectroscopy technique [V. I. Yudin et al., Phys. Rev. A 82, 011804(R) (2010)]. In this case, the probe-induced frequency shifts can be suppressed considerably from metrologically significant levels to below a fractional level of ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}18}$ for practically any optical atomic clocks. The main advantage of our method in comparison with other hyper-Ramsey approaches [R. Hobson et al., Phys. Rev. A 93, 010501(R) (2016); T. Zanon-Willette et al., Phys. Rev. A 93, 042506 (2016)] derives from its much greater efficiency and robustness in the presence of decoherence.

arXiv:1602.00331•Physical Review A•Nov 7, 2016•29 citations

Spectroscopy schemes for improved optical clock stability

Filip Butuc-Mayer

Frequency metrology underpins precise measurements. At the forefront of this field are optical clocks which can perform measurements that are accurate to more digits than those in the number representing seconds elapsed from the beginning of the universe. Frequency estimation errors in the operation of optical clocks lead to frequency instability, prohibiting them from reaching high accuracies on short to medium time scales, and limiting access to interesting measurements of the atomic environment and exotic external perturbations such as gravity fields or fields of fundamentally new physical origins. Optical lattice traps are typically employed in state-of-the-art optical clocks to suppress Doppler effects. By carefully tuning the optical lattice to the magic wavelength, unwanted Stark shifts can be suppressed significantly, allowing operation with thousands of atoms and minimising the fundamental source of frequency estimation errors, namely the quantum projection noise, to around 3 × 10−17 at 1 s. In this thesis, the status of the two Strontium optical lattice clocks at NPL, Sr1 and Sr2, is presented going over a few interesting measurement campaigns from the past years involving Sr1 and the latest experimental efforts to re-enable operation of Sr2. A model of clock stability is developed by incorporating known and new frameworks to characterise the relation between the operating parameters of optical clocks and their performance, with relevance to the NPL lattice clocks and beyond. In particular, a method is identified for addressing the main technical noise for optical lattice clocks, the Dick effect, which typically has a magnitude of 10−16 at 1 s and prevents optical lattice clocks from reaching the quantum projection noise level. By taking advantage of dynamical decoupling we can engineer an optimised duty cycle with benefits in general for systems limited by the optical coherence of the clock laser. Moreover, a study of other noise sources in the NPL lattice clocks is conducted using synchronous measurements between Sr1 and Sr2, revealing a large contribution from linear Zeeman shifts, also at the 10−16 level, and a plan to tackle them is detailed. A hybrid clock architecture is discussed showing how optical lattice clocks can improve the optical coherence of ion clocks thanks to their higher servo rate, and a preliminary experimental demonstration is reported. Finally, a new type of spectroscopy is presented which completely avoids aliasing of linear Zeeman shifts by simultaneously driving transitions with opposite Zeeman sensitivities. Such a technique also enables the continuous interrogation of atoms, a crucial missing component in the Dick-free conveyor belt lattice clock concept heralded as the next standard of stable optical clocks.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Autobalanced Ramsey Spectroscopy Improving Clock Accuracy and Testing Fundamental Physics

Christian Sanner, Nils Huntemann, R. Lange +2 more

Everyone is trying to make frequency measurements as accurate as possible. But what if the measurement process itself becomes a major source of error? This issue is particularly relevant in the context of state-of-the-art atomic clocks where errors at the 18th decimal place are not negligible anymore. In order to spectroscopically interrogate an atomic clock transition without compromising the clock's accuracy, we devise a perturbation-immune version of Ramsey's method of separated oscillatory fields. By actively balancing the spectroscopic responses from phase-congruent Ramsey probe cycles of unequal durations, we eliminate a wide variety of interrogation-induced line shifts often encountered in high precision spectroscopy, among them, in particular, light shifts, phase chirps, and transient Zeeman shifts. We experimentally demonstrate autobalanced Ramsey spectroscopy on the light shift prone171Yb+electric octupole optical clock transition and show that interrogation defects are not turned into clock errors. This opens up frequency accuracy perspectives below the 10-18level for the Yb+system and for other types of optical clocks. Further applications of this simple and universal approach include next generation coherent population trapping clocks and perturbation-immune readout of quantum sensors. Future long-term clock comparisons searching for physics beyond the standard model will also benefit from this technique.

Joint Conference of the European Frequency and Time Forum and IEEE International Frequency Control Symposium (EFTF/IFCS)•Apr 1, 2019•0 citations

In-Situ Differential-Light-Shift Cancellation for Trapped-Atom Clocks

Jan Simon Haase, Alexander Fieguth, Igor Bröckel +2 more

Differential light shifts (DLS) induced by optical trapping fields fundamentally limit the stability and accuracy of trapped-atom microwave clocks. We demonstrate an in-situ method to cancel DLS by simultaneously interrogating multiple spatially separated atomic ensembles at different trap intensities generated from a common light source. By operating the ensembles at set intensity ratios and performing Ramsey spectroscopy, the intensity-dependent frequency shifts are measured within each experimental cycle and extrapolated to the zero-intensity limit. This approach effectively enables shot-to-shot determination of a DLS-free frequency without requiring magic wavelengths or species-specific cancellation schemes. We validate the method for Rb atoms trapped in time-averaged potentials by introducing controlled variations of the total trap power and show that the extrapolated frequency remains insensitive to these fluctuations. The technique is general and can be extended to other systematic shifts, providing a scalable route toward improved stability and accuracy in compact trapped-atom clocks and related quantum sensors relying on optical dipole traps

physics.atom-phCross-listedarXiv:2603.26398•Mar 30, 2026•0 citations

Frequency Shifts in an Optical Lattice Clock Due to Magnetic-Dipole and Electric-Quadrupole Transitions

А. В. Тайченачев, Valeriy I. Yudin, Vitalii D Ovsiannikov +2 more

We report a hitherto undiscovered frequency shift for forbidden J = 0-->J = 0 clock transitions excited in atoms confined to an optical lattice. These shifts result from magnetic-dipole and electric-quadrupole transitions, which have a spatial dependence in an optical lattice that differs from that of the stronger electric-dipole transitions. In combination with the residual translational motion of atoms in an optical lattice, this spatial mismatch leads to a frequency shift via differential energy level spacing in the lattice wells for ground state and excited state atoms. We estimate that this effect could lead to fractional frequency shifts as large as 10(-16), which might prevent lattice-based optical clocks from reaching their predicted performance levels. Moreover, these effects could shift the magic wavelength in lattice clocks in three dimensions by as much as 100 MHz, depending on the lattice configuration.

arXiv:0803.1039•Physical Review Letters•Nov 4, 2008•55 citations
Dipole-dipole interactions lead to frequency shifts that are expected to limit the performance of next-generation atomic clocks. In this work, we compute dipolar frequency shifts accounting for the intrinsic atomic multilevel structure in standard Ramsey spectroscopy. When interrogating the transitions featuring the smallest Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, we find that a simplified two-level treatment becomes inappropriate, even in the presence of large Zeeman shifts. For these cases, we show a net suppression of dipolar frequency shifts and the emergence of dominant nonclassical effects for experimentally relevant parameters. Our findings are pertinent to current generations of optical lattice and optical tweezer clocks, opening a way to further increase their current accuracy, and thus their potential to probe fundamental and many-body physics.
Motivated by the ideas of using cold alkaline-earth atoms trapped in an optical lattice for realization of optical atomic clocks, we investigate theoretically the perturbative effects of atom-atom interactions on a clock transition frequency. These interactions are mediated by the dipole fields associated with the optically excited atoms. We predict resonancelike features in the frequency shifts when constructive interference among atomic dipoles occur. We theoretically demonstrate that by fine tuning the coherent dipole-dipole couplings in appropriately designed lattice geometries, the undesirable frequency shifts can be greatly suppressed.
We develop a universal method to significantly suppress probe-induced shifts in any type of atomic clock using Ramsey spectroscopy. Our approach is based on the adaptation of the synthetic frequency concept [V. I. Yudin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 030801 (2011)] (previously developed for blackbody radiation shift suppression) to Ramsey spectroscopy with the use of interrogations with different dark time intervals. The most significant suppression of the shift is obtained in combination with the so-called hyper-Ramsey spectroscopy technique [V. I. Yudin et al., Phys. Rev. A 82, 011804(R) (2010)]. In this case, the probe-induced frequency shifts can be suppressed considerably from metrologically significant levels to below a fractional level of ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}18}$ for practically any optical atomic clocks. The main advantage of our method in comparison with other hyper-Ramsey approaches [R. Hobson et al., Phys. Rev. A 93, 010501(R) (2016); T. Zanon-Willette et al., Phys. Rev. A 93, 042506 (2016)] derives from its much greater efficiency and robustness in the presence of decoherence.
Frequency metrology underpins precise measurements. At the forefront of this field are optical clocks which can perform measurements that are accurate to more digits than those in the number representing seconds elapsed from the beginning of the universe. Frequency estimation errors in the operation of optical clocks lead to frequency instability, prohibiting them from reaching high accuracies on short to medium time scales, and limiting access to interesting measurements of the atomic environment and exotic external perturbations such as gravity fields or fields of fundamentally new physical origins. Optical lattice traps are typically employed in state-of-the-art optical clocks to suppress Doppler effects. By carefully tuning the optical lattice to the magic wavelength, unwanted Stark shifts can be suppressed significantly, allowing operation with thousands of atoms and minimising the fundamental source of frequency estimation errors, namely the quantum projection noise, to around 3 × 10−17 at 1 s. In this thesis, the status of the two Strontium optical lattice clocks at NPL, Sr1 and Sr2, is presented going over a few interesting measurement campaigns from the past years involving Sr1 and the latest experimental efforts to re-enable operation of Sr2. A model of clock stability is developed by incorporating known and new frameworks to characterise the relation between the operating parameters of optical clocks and their performance, with relevance to the NPL lattice clocks and beyond. In particular, a method is identified for addressing the main technical noise for optical lattice clocks, the Dick effect, which typically has a magnitude of 10−16 at 1 s and prevents optical lattice clocks from reaching the quantum projection noise level. By taking advantage of dynamical decoupling we can engineer an optimised duty cycle with benefits in general for systems limited by the optical coherence of the clock laser. Moreover, a study of other noise sources in the NPL lattice clocks is conducted using synchronous measurements between Sr1 and Sr2, revealing a large contribution from linear Zeeman shifts, also at the 10−16 level, and a plan to tackle them is detailed. A hybrid clock architecture is discussed showing how optical lattice clocks can improve the optical coherence of ion clocks thanks to their higher servo rate, and a preliminary experimental demonstration is reported. Finally, a new type of spectroscopy is presented which completely avoids aliasing of linear Zeeman shifts by simultaneously driving transitions with opposite Zeeman sensitivities. Such a technique also enables the continuous interrogation of atoms, a crucial missing component in the Dick-free conveyor belt lattice clock concept heralded as the next standard of stable optical clocks.
Everyone is trying to make frequency measurements as accurate as possible. But what if the measurement process itself becomes a major source of error? This issue is particularly relevant in the context of state-of-the-art atomic clocks where errors at the 18th decimal place are not negligible anymore. In order to spectroscopically interrogate an atomic clock transition without compromising the clock's accuracy, we devise a perturbation-immune version of Ramsey's method of separated oscillatory fields. By actively balancing the spectroscopic responses from phase-congruent Ramsey probe cycles of unequal durations, we eliminate a wide variety of interrogation-induced line shifts often encountered in high precision spectroscopy, among them, in particular, light shifts, phase chirps, and transient Zeeman shifts. We experimentally demonstrate autobalanced Ramsey spectroscopy on the light shift prone171Yb+electric octupole optical clock transition and show that interrogation defects are not turned into clock errors. This opens up frequency accuracy perspectives below the 10-18level for the Yb+system and for other types of optical clocks. Further applications of this simple and universal approach include next generation coherent population trapping clocks and perturbation-immune readout of quantum sensors. Future long-term clock comparisons searching for physics beyond the standard model will also benefit from this technique.
Differential light shifts (DLS) induced by optical trapping fields fundamentally limit the stability and accuracy of trapped-atom microwave clocks. We demonstrate an in-situ method to cancel DLS by simultaneously interrogating multiple spatially separated atomic ensembles at different trap intensities generated from a common light source. By operating the ensembles at set intensity ratios and performing Ramsey spectroscopy, the intensity-dependent frequency shifts are measured within each experimental cycle and extrapolated to the zero-intensity limit. This approach effectively enables shot-to-shot determination of a DLS-free frequency without requiring magic wavelengths or species-specific cancellation schemes. We validate the method for Rb atoms trapped in time-averaged potentials by introducing controlled variations of the total trap power and show that the extrapolated frequency remains insensitive to these fluctuations. The technique is general and can be extended to other systematic shifts, providing a scalable route toward improved stability and accuracy in compact trapped-atom clocks and related quantum sensors relying on optical dipole traps
We report a hitherto undiscovered frequency shift for forbidden J = 0-->J = 0 clock transitions excited in atoms confined to an optical lattice. These shifts result from magnetic-dipole and electric-quadrupole transitions, which have a spatial dependence in an optical lattice that differs from that of the stronger electric-dipole transitions. In combination with the residual translational motion of atoms in an optical lattice, this spatial mismatch leads to a frequency shift via differential energy level spacing in the lattice wells for ground state and excited state atoms. We estimate that this effect could lead to fractional frequency shifts as large as 10(-16), which might prevent lattice-based optical clocks from reaching their predicted performance levels. Moreover, these effects could shift the magic wavelength in lattice clocks in three dimensions by as much as 100 MHz, depending on the lattice configuration.