Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2007.00895 · Quantum

Black holes as clouded mirrors: the Hayden-Preskill protocol with symmetry

Yoshifumi Nakata, Eyuri Wakakuwa, Masato Koashi

Published Feb 21, 2023• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Hayden-Preskill protocol is a qubit-toy model of the black hole information paradox. Based on the assumption of scrambling, it was revealed that quantum information is instantly leaked out from the quantum many-body system that models a black hole. In this paper, we extend the protocol to the case where the system has symmetry and investigate how the symmetry affects the leakage of information. We especially focus on the conservation of the number of up-spins. Developing a partial decoupling approach, we first show that the symmetry induces a delay of leakage and an information remnant. We then clarify the physics behind them: the delay is characterized by thermodynamic properties of the system associated with the symmetry, and the information remnant is closely related to the symmetry-breaking of the initial state. These relations bridge the information leakage problem to macroscopic physics of quantum many-body systems and allow us to investigate the information leakage only in terms of physical properties of the system.

DOI
10.22331/q-2023-02-21-928

Related papers

Symmetry hinders quantum information recovery

Hiroyasu Tajima, Keiji Saito

Quantum information is scrambled via a chaotic time evolution in many-body systems. Clarifying how and to what extent we can recover the quantum information from the scrambled state is a central issue of today's physics, since it commonly appears as an essential factor in various topics including irreversibility of quantum chaotic dynamics, fault-tolerant quantum computation, and black hole information paradox. In realistic settings, symmetry can ubiquitously exist in scrambling dynamics. Here we establish fundamental limitations on the information recovery arising from the Lie group symmetries in the scrambling dynamics. The results are applicable to many situations, including the Hayden-Preskill black hole model with symmetry where the success rate of the information recovery qualitatively changes from the original no-symmetry case. Our findings show a close relationship between information recovery, symmetry, and quantum coherence, and that symmetry hinders the quantum information recovery.

•Mar 2, 2021•5 citations

Entanglement asymmetry in the Hayden-Preskill protocol

Hui-Huang Chen, Zi-Jun Tang

In this paper, we consider the time evolution of entanglement asymmetry of the black hole radiation in the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment. We assume the black hole is initially in a mixed state since it is entangled with the early radiation. Alice throws a diary maximally entangled with a reference system into the black hole. After the black hole has absorbed the diary, Bob tries to recover the information that Alice thought should be destroyed by the black hole. In this protocol, we found that a U ( 1 ) symmetry of the radiation emerges before a certain transition time (the time when the vanishing entanglement asymmetry begins to grow). This emergent symmetry is exact in the thermodynamic limit and can be characterized by the vanishing entanglement asymmetry of the radiation. The transition time depends on the initial entropy and the size of the diary. What is more, when the initial state of the black hole is maximally mixed, this emergent symmetry survives during the whole procedure of the black hole radiation. We successfully explained this novel phenomenon using the decoupling inequality.

arXiv:2411.17695•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 3, 2025•17 citations

Universal limitation of quantum information recovery: symmetry versus coherence

Hiroyasu Tajima, Keiji Saito

Quantum information is scrambled via chaotic time evolution in many-body systems. The recovery of initial information embedded locally in the system from the scrambled quantum state is a fundamental concern in many contexts. From a dynamical perspective, information recovery can measure dynamical instability in quantum chaos, fault-tolerant quantum computing, and the black hole information paradox. This article considers general aspects of quantum information recovery when the scrambling dynamics have conservation laws due to Lie group symmetries. Here, we establish fundamental limitations on the information recovery from scrambling dynamics with arbitrary Lie group symmetries. We show universal relations between information recovery, symmetry, and quantum coherence, which apply to many physical situations. The relations predict that the behavior of the Hayden-Preskill black hole model changes qualitatively under the assumption of the energy conservation law. Consequently, we can rigorously prove that under the energy conservation law, the error of the information recovery from a small black hole remains unignorably large until it completely evaporates. Moreover, even when the black hole is very large, the recovery of information thrown into the black hole is not completed until most of the black hole evaporates. The relations also provide a unified view of the symmetry restrictions on quantum information processing, such as the approximate Eastin-Knill theorem and the Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem for unitary gates.

arXiv:2103.01876•Mar 2, 2021•43 citations

Repeated Extraction of Scrambled Quantum Data: Sustainability of the Hayden-Preskill Type Protocols

Seok Hyung Lie, Yong Siah Teo, Hyunseok Jeong

We introduce and study the problem of scrambler hacking, which is the procedure of quantum information extraction from and installation on a quantum scrambler given only partial access. This problem necessarily emerges from a central topic in contemporary physics - information recovery from systems undergoing scrambling dynamics, such as the Hayden-Preskill protocol in black hole studies - because one must replace quantum data with another when extracting it due to the no-cloning theorem. For large scramblers, we supply analytical formulas for the optimal hacking fidelity, a quantitative measure of the effectiveness of scrambler hacking with limited access. In the two-user scenario where Bob attempts to hack Alice's data, we find that the optimal fidelity converges to $64/(9π^2)\approx0.72$ with increasing Bob's hacking space relative to Alice's user space. We applied our results to the black hole information problem and showed that the limited hacking fidelity implies the reflectivity decay of a black hole as an information mirror, which questions the solvability of the black hole information paradox through the Hayden-Preskill type protocol.

arXiv:2204.00374•Apr 1, 2022•2 citations

Demonstration of the Hayden-Preskill Protocol via Mutual Information

Jeong-Myeong Bae, Subeom Kang, Dong-han Yeom +1 more

We construct the Hayden-Preskill protocol by using a system of spin-1/2 particles and demonstrate information flows of this system which can mimic black holes. We first define an analogous black hole A as a collection of such particles. Second, we take the particles from inside to outside the black hole to define an analogous system of Hawking radiation B as outside particles. When the black hole and the radiation have the maximum entanglement at the Page time, we take an entangled pair system C and D. The particles of C fall into the black hole while their counterparts of D remain outside. If we assume rapid mixing of the particle states in the black hole A ⋃ C , can the information of C rapidly escape from the black hole like a mirror? We numerically show that if we turn on the rapid mixing in the black hole, the original information of C rapidly escapes from the black hole to outside in the form of the mutual information between B and D. On the other hand, if the mixing between A and C is not enough, the information escapes slowly. Hence, we explicitly demonstrate the original conjecture of Hayden and Preskill. We emphasize that enough mixing is an essential condition to make the Hayden-Preskill protocol functionally work.

arXiv:1907.13290•Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Dec 1, 2019•2 citations

Black Holes are about Quantum Information

Aude Corbeel, Sebastian De Haro

We review and analyse quantum information-theoretic approaches to black hole evaporation that purport to bring us closer to a resolution of the black hole information paradox. Our focus is on the Page-time paradox and on the contribution of the Hayden-Preskill model to understanding information release under the assumption of unitary evaporation. In this model, the black hole is taken to be a finite-dimensional quantum system whose dynamics can be represented by a quantum circuit, and its information-processing and communication abilities are studied. We identify the assumptions underlying this modelling and highlight two key features, fast scrambling dynamics and entanglement as a resource, that underpin the information release in the model. We argue that this reasoning exemplifies a broader change in how information is used in black hole physics, in which quantum information theory now provides a useful operational modelling framework. This application avoids earlier philosophical objections insofar as it is not based on epistemic ignorance and does not regard information as a substance. This line of reasoning has become central to the debate and, as such, warrants greater attention from the philosophy of physics community.

physics.hist-phCross-listedarXiv:2610.28185•Oct 21, 2026•3 citations
The Hayden-Preskill protocol is a qubit-toy model of the black hole information paradox. Based on the assumption of scrambling, it was revealed that quantum information is instantly leaked out from the quantum many-body system that models a black hole. In this paper, we extend the protocol to the case where the system has symmetry and investigate how the symmetry affects the leakage of information. We especially focus on the conservation of the number of up-spins. Developing a partial decoupling approach, we first show that the symmetry induces a delay of leakage and an information remnant. We then clarify the physics behind them: the delay is characterized by thermodynamic properties of the system associated with the symmetry, and the information remnant is closely related to the symmetry-breaking of the initial state. These relations bridge the information leakage problem to macroscopic physics of quantum many-body systems and allow us to investigate the information leakage only in terms of physical properties of the system.
Quantum information is scrambled via a chaotic time evolution in many-body systems. Clarifying how and to what extent we can recover the quantum information from the scrambled state is a central issue of today's physics, since it commonly appears as an essential factor in various topics including irreversibility of quantum chaotic dynamics, fault-tolerant quantum computation, and black hole information paradox. In realistic settings, symmetry can ubiquitously exist in scrambling dynamics. Here we establish fundamental limitations on the information recovery arising from the Lie group symmetries in the scrambling dynamics. The results are applicable to many situations, including the Hayden-Preskill black hole model with symmetry where the success rate of the information recovery qualitatively changes from the original no-symmetry case. Our findings show a close relationship between information recovery, symmetry, and quantum coherence, and that symmetry hinders the quantum information recovery.
In this paper, we consider the time evolution of entanglement asymmetry of the black hole radiation in the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment. We assume the black hole is initially in a mixed state since it is entangled with the early radiation. Alice throws a diary maximally entangled with a reference system into the black hole. After the black hole has absorbed the diary, Bob tries to recover the information that Alice thought should be destroyed by the black hole. In this protocol, we found that a U ( 1 ) symmetry of the radiation emerges before a certain transition time (the time when the vanishing entanglement asymmetry begins to grow). This emergent symmetry is exact in the thermodynamic limit and can be characterized by the vanishing entanglement asymmetry of the radiation. The transition time depends on the initial entropy and the size of the diary. What is more, when the initial state of the black hole is maximally mixed, this emergent symmetry survives during the whole procedure of the black hole radiation. We successfully explained this novel phenomenon using the decoupling inequality.
Quantum information is scrambled via chaotic time evolution in many-body systems. The recovery of initial information embedded locally in the system from the scrambled quantum state is a fundamental concern in many contexts. From a dynamical perspective, information recovery can measure dynamical instability in quantum chaos, fault-tolerant quantum computing, and the black hole information paradox. This article considers general aspects of quantum information recovery when the scrambling dynamics have conservation laws due to Lie group symmetries. Here, we establish fundamental limitations on the information recovery from scrambling dynamics with arbitrary Lie group symmetries. We show universal relations between information recovery, symmetry, and quantum coherence, which apply to many physical situations. The relations predict that the behavior of the Hayden-Preskill black hole model changes qualitatively under the assumption of the energy conservation law. Consequently, we can rigorously prove that under the energy conservation law, the error of the information recovery from a small black hole remains unignorably large until it completely evaporates. Moreover, even when the black hole is very large, the recovery of information thrown into the black hole is not completed until most of the black hole evaporates. The relations also provide a unified view of the symmetry restrictions on quantum information processing, such as the approximate Eastin-Knill theorem and the Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem for unitary gates.
We introduce and study the problem of scrambler hacking, which is the procedure of quantum information extraction from and installation on a quantum scrambler given only partial access. This problem necessarily emerges from a central topic in contemporary physics - information recovery from systems undergoing scrambling dynamics, such as the Hayden-Preskill protocol in black hole studies - because one must replace quantum data with another when extracting it due to the no-cloning theorem. For large scramblers, we supply analytical formulas for the optimal hacking fidelity, a quantitative measure of the effectiveness of scrambler hacking with limited access. In the two-user scenario where Bob attempts to hack Alice's data, we find that the optimal fidelity converges to 64/(9π2)≈0.7264/(9π^2)\approx0.7264/(9π2)≈0.72 with increasing Bob's hacking space relative to Alice's user space. We applied our results to the black hole information problem and showed that the limited hacking fidelity implies the reflectivity decay of a black hole as an information mirror, which questions the solvability of the black hole information paradox through the Hayden-Preskill type protocol.
We construct the Hayden-Preskill protocol by using a system of spin-1/2 particles and demonstrate information flows of this system which can mimic black holes. We first define an analogous black hole A as a collection of such particles. Second, we take the particles from inside to outside the black hole to define an analogous system of Hawking radiation B as outside particles. When the black hole and the radiation have the maximum entanglement at the Page time, we take an entangled pair system C and D. The particles of C fall into the black hole while their counterparts of D remain outside. If we assume rapid mixing of the particle states in the black hole A ⋃ C , can the information of C rapidly escape from the black hole like a mirror? We numerically show that if we turn on the rapid mixing in the black hole, the original information of C rapidly escapes from the black hole to outside in the form of the mutual information between B and D. On the other hand, if the mixing between A and C is not enough, the information escapes slowly. Hence, we explicitly demonstrate the original conjecture of Hayden and Preskill. We emphasize that enough mixing is an essential condition to make the Hayden-Preskill protocol functionally work.
We review and analyse quantum information-theoretic approaches to black hole evaporation that purport to bring us closer to a resolution of the black hole information paradox. Our focus is on the Page-time paradox and on the contribution of the Hayden-Preskill model to understanding information release under the assumption of unitary evaporation. In this model, the black hole is taken to be a finite-dimensional quantum system whose dynamics can be represented by a quantum circuit, and its information-processing and communication abilities are studied. We identify the assumptions underlying this modelling and highlight two key features, fast scrambling dynamics and entanglement as a resource, that underpin the information release in the model. We argue that this reasoning exemplifies a broader change in how information is used in black hole physics, in which quantum information theory now provides a useful operational modelling framework. This application avoids earlier philosophical objections insofar as it is not based on epistemic ignorance and does not regard information as a substance. This line of reasoning has become central to the debate and, as such, warrants greater attention from the philosophy of physics community.