arXiv:2610.28185
Black Holes are about Quantum Information
Aude Corbeel, Sebastian De Haro
Abstract
We review and analyse quantum information-theoretic approaches to black hole evaporation that purport to bring us closer to a resolution of the black hole information paradox. Our focus is on the Page-time paradox and on the contribution of the Hayden-Preskill model to understanding information release under the assumption of unitary evaporation. In this model, the black hole is taken to be a finite-dimensional quantum system whose dynamics can be represented by a quantum circuit, and its information-processing and communication abilities are studied. We identify the assumptions underlying this modelling and highlight two key features, fast scrambling dynamics and entanglement as a resource, that underpin the information release in the model. We argue that this reasoning exemplifies a broader change in how information is used in black hole physics, in which quantum information theory now provides a useful operational modelling framework. This application avoids earlier philosophical objections insofar as it is not based on epistemic ignorance and does not regard information as a substance. This line of reasoning has become central to the debate and, as such, warrants greater attention from the philosophy of physics community.
AI Summary
This paper reviews and philosophically analyses quantum-information models of black-hole evaporation, focusing on what the Page and Hayden–Preskill frameworks establish about information release conditional on unitary evolution. It asks how these models explain recoverability and whether their operational use of information avoids objections to epistemic interpretations of black-hole entropy or to treating information as a substance. The analysis organises the Hayden–Preskill model around nine assumptions, including the central dogma of a finite-dimensional, unitarily evolving black hole, scrambling dynamics, approximate recovery, an old black hole, and access to its early radiation. It distinguishes state-level entanglement typicality from dynamical scrambling, and identifies two roles for entanglement: protecting the diary against subsystem erasure and assisting recovery through previously emitted radiation. The quantitative results reviewed are established Hayden–Preskill bounds, not new derivations. For an $a$-qubit diary, Haar-random dynamics give an average decoupling error of order $2^{-k}$ after $d=a+k$ additional qubits escape; decoupling of the reference from the remaining black hole guarantees a decoder on the accessible radiation. Suitable approximate unitary 2-designs reproduce this behaviour with accuracy-dependent corrections. The recovery delay includes scrambling, with an estimated timescale $t_{\mathrm{scr}}\sim r_S\log(r_S/\ell_{\mathrm{Pl}})$, plus emission of those qubits. The paper stresses that the model assumes rather than proves unitarity, does not describe the interior, and lacks direct experimental validation. Unlimited radiation control is infeasible for astrophysical black holes, and decoder existence does not establish efficient implementation. Its philosophical conclusion concerns operational modelling, not an information-based microscopic ontology.
Error found: The Page-entropy formula uses O(e^{2d-b}) where qubit counting requires O(2^{2d-b}), giving an incorrect asymptotic bound on the entropy deficit. The claim that abandoning the central dogma necessarily abandons a statistical-mechanical explanation of black hole thermodynamics is unjustified, because rejecting unitary dynamics alone does not eliminate microscopic states or statistical mechanics.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.