Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2003.04683 · Physical Review A

Quantum measurements of sums

Juzar Thingna, Peter Talkner A

Published Jul 13, 2020• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A method is proposed that allows one to infer the sum of the values of an observable taken during contacts with a pointer state. Hereby, the state of the pointer is updated while contacted with the system and remains unchanged between contacts while the system evolves in time. After a prescribed number of such contacts, the position of the pointer is determined by means of a projective measurement. The outcome is specified in terms of a probability distribution function for unitary and Markovian dissipative dynamics and compared with the results of the same number of generalized Gaussian measurements of the considered observable. As a particular example, a qubit is considered with an observable contacting to the pointer that does not commute with the system Hamiltonian.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.102.012213

Related papers

What quantum measurements measure

Robert B. Griffiths

A solution to the second measurement problem, determining what prior microscopic properties can be inferred from measurement outcomes (``pointer positions''), is worked out for projective and generalized (POVM) measurements, using consistent histories. The result supports the idea that equipment properly designed and calibrated reveals the properties it was designed to measure. Applications include Einstein's hemisphere and Wheeler's delayed choice paradoxes, and a method for analyzing weak measurements without recourse to weak values. Quantum measurements are noncontextual in the original sense employed by Bell and Mermin: if $[A,B]=[A,C]=0,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[B,C]\ensuremath{\ne}0$, the outcome of an $A$ measurement does not depend on whether it is measured with $B$ or with $C$. An application to Bohm's model of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen situation suggests that a faulty understanding of quantum measurements is at the root of this paradox.

arXiv:1704.08725•Physical Review A•Sep 13, 2017•46 citations

Does Decoherence Select the Pointer Basis of a Quantum Meter?

Abraham G. Kofman, Gershon Kurizki

The consensus regarding quantum measurements rests on two statements: (i) von Neumann’s standard quantum measurement theory leaves undetermined the basis in which observables are measured, and (ii) the environmental decoherence of the measuring device (the “meter”) unambiguously determines the measuring (“pointer”) basis. The latter statement means that the environment monitors (measures) selected observables of the meter and (indirectly) of the system. Equivalently, a measured quantum state must end up in one of the “pointer states” that persist in the presence of the environment. We find that, unless we restrict ourselves to projective measurements, decoherence does not necessarily determine the pointer basis of the meter. Namely, generalized measurements commonly allow the observer to choose from a multitude of alternative pointer bases that provide the same information on the observables, regardless of decoherence. By contrast, the measured observable does not depend on the pointer basis, whether in the presence or in the absence of decoherence. These results grant further support to our notion of Quantum Lamarckism, whereby the observer’s choices play an indispensable role in quantum mechanics.

Entropy•Jan 10, 2022•5 citations

Quantum measurements without Schrödinger cat states

Dominique Spehner, Fritz Haake

We report and give an alternative derivation of some results on a model for a quantum measurement studied in [1]. The measured microscopic system is coupled to the position of a macroscopic pointer, which itself interacts with its environment via its momentum. The entanglement between the system and the pointer produced by their mutual interaction is simultaneous with the decoherence of distinct pointer readings resulting from leakage of information to the environment. After a discussion on the various time scales in the model we calculate the matrix elements of the system-pointer density operator between eigenstates of the measured observable with distinct eigenvalues. In general, the decay with time of these coherences is neither exponential nor gaussian. We determine the decoherence (decay) time in terms of the strength of the system-pointer and pointer-environment couplings. This decoherence time does not depend upon the details of the pointer-bath coupling as soon as it is smaller than the bath correlation time (non-Markov regime). In contrast, in the Markov regime it depends strongly on whether this coupling is Ohmic or super-Ohmic.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2007•1 citation

Path summation and quantum measurements

D. Sokolovski, R. Sala Mayato

We propose a general theoretical approach to quantum measurements based on the path (histories) summation technique. For a given dynamical variable A, the Schrödinger state of a system in a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensionality is decomposed into a set of substates, each of which corresponds to a particular detailed history of the system. The coherence between the substates may then be destroyed by meter(s) to a degree determined by the nature and the accuracy of the measurement(s) which may be of von Neumann, finite-time or continuous type. Transformations between the histories obtained for non-commuting variables and construction of simultaneous histories for non-commuting observables are discussed. Important cases of a particle described by Feynman paths in the coordinate space and a qubit in a two dimensional Hilbert space are studied in some detail.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407043•Jul 6, 2004•0 citations

Characterizing entangled state update in different reference frames with weak measurements

J. Allam, A. Matzkin

As per the projection postulate, the evolution of the quantum state of a system upon measurement results in state update. In this work we investigate the characterization of updated states of multipartite entangled qubit states with nondestructive weak measurements, involving weakly coupling a pointer to each qubit while considering a relativistic setup involving different reference frames. As is well known, the updated state at intermediate times is frame dependent and outcome randomness, intrinsic to projective measurements, prevents any information from being acquired on the updated state. Here we will see that when weak measurements are implemented there is instead an interplay between randomness and interference, depending on the number of qubits, so as to maintain consistency between descriptions in arbitrary reference frames. Analytical results are given for a small or infinite number of qubits, while for a finite number of qubits we resort to Monte Carlo sampling in order to simulate numerically the results of weak measurements. As a by-product, we show how a single-shot measurement of the pointers' positions allows us to make quantitative predictions on the outcomes that can be obtained for any observable measured on a distant qubit of the multipartite state.

arXiv:2410.20450•Physical Review A•Feb 4, 2025•0 citations

Puentes, Hermosa, and Torres Reply:

Graciana Puentes, Nathaniel Hermosa, Juan P. Torres

In a preceding Comment [1] to our Letter [2] concerning weak measurements with orbital-angular-momentum (OAM) pointer states [2], Pan and Panigrahi show that the real and imaginary parts of higher-order weak values can be made accessible using Gaussian pointer states.In [2], our goal is to show that by using pointer states embedded with OAM it is possible to extract higher-order weak values where pointer states with a Gaussian shape cannot.As a consequence, our work put forward a new tool for weak amplification schemes, i.e., the use of pointer states with more general spatial forms that could be advantageous in some scenarios.We did not intend to claim that a pointer state with orbital angular momentum was needed to extract higherorder weak values in general.We clarify our point with this Reply.In our Letter we consider a specific Hamiltonian of interaction of the form H ¼ g A AP x þ g B BP y , where A, B are operators, (P x , P y ) are the pointer momentum operators, conjugate to the pointer position operators (X, Y), and g A;B are coupling constants.Moreover, we calculate the two-dimensional pointer displacement hXYi, corresponding to a specific measurement.We emphasize that we consider a particular interaction and a specific measurement, which are generally dictated by the physical system under investigation.The result, Eq. ( 4) of our Letter, shows that pointer states with OAM (l ¼ Æ1) can be used to retrieve the imaginary part of the higher-order weak values hA 2 i w and hB 2 i w , whereas this is not possible with pointer states with no OAM (l ¼ 0).In addition, Eq. ( 9) of our Letter shows, by means of a specific example with B ¼ 0, that hXYi ¼ 0 for Gaussian pointer states.On the contrary, a pointer state with l ¼ Æ1 allows us to extract the imaginary part of the weak value hA 2 i w .Pan and Panigrahi show that by measuring hX 2 i one can obtain the real part of the weak value hA 2 i w using a Gaussian pointer [see Eq. ( 4) of [1]].However, in order to access its imaginary part, they are forced to use a different interaction Hamiltonian, and a measurement observable involving noncommuting operators.The work of Pan and Panigrahi proves the strength of our proposal: One

Physical Review Letters•Jul 10, 2013•1 citation
A method is proposed that allows one to infer the sum of the values of an observable taken during contacts with a pointer state. Hereby, the state of the pointer is updated while contacted with the system and remains unchanged between contacts while the system evolves in time. After a prescribed number of such contacts, the position of the pointer is determined by means of a projective measurement. The outcome is specified in terms of a probability distribution function for unitary and Markovian dissipative dynamics and compared with the results of the same number of generalized Gaussian measurements of the considered observable. As a particular example, a qubit is considered with an observable contacting to the pointer that does not commute with the system Hamiltonian.
A solution to the second measurement problem, determining what prior microscopic properties can be inferred from measurement outcomes (``pointer positions''), is worked out for projective and generalized (POVM) measurements, using consistent histories. The result supports the idea that equipment properly designed and calibrated reveals the properties it was designed to measure. Applications include Einstein's hemisphere and Wheeler's delayed choice paradoxes, and a method for analyzing weak measurements without recourse to weak values. Quantum measurements are noncontextual in the original sense employed by Bell and Mermin: if $[A,B]=[A,C]=0,\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}[B,C]\ensuremath{\ne}0$, the outcome of an AAA measurement does not depend on whether it is measured with BBB or with CCC. An application to Bohm's model of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen situation suggests that a faulty understanding of quantum measurements is at the root of this paradox.
The consensus regarding quantum measurements rests on two statements: (i) von Neumann’s standard quantum measurement theory leaves undetermined the basis in which observables are measured, and (ii) the environmental decoherence of the measuring device (the “meter”) unambiguously determines the measuring (“pointer”) basis. The latter statement means that the environment monitors (measures) selected observables of the meter and (indirectly) of the system. Equivalently, a measured quantum state must end up in one of the “pointer states” that persist in the presence of the environment. We find that, unless we restrict ourselves to projective measurements, decoherence does not necessarily determine the pointer basis of the meter. Namely, generalized measurements commonly allow the observer to choose from a multitude of alternative pointer bases that provide the same information on the observables, regardless of decoherence. By contrast, the measured observable does not depend on the pointer basis, whether in the presence or in the absence of decoherence. These results grant further support to our notion of Quantum Lamarckism, whereby the observer’s choices play an indispensable role in quantum mechanics.
We report and give an alternative derivation of some results on a model for a quantum measurement studied in [1]. The measured microscopic system is coupled to the position of a macroscopic pointer, which itself interacts with its environment via its momentum. The entanglement between the system and the pointer produced by their mutual interaction is simultaneous with the decoherence of distinct pointer readings resulting from leakage of information to the environment. After a discussion on the various time scales in the model we calculate the matrix elements of the system-pointer density operator between eigenstates of the measured observable with distinct eigenvalues. In general, the decay with time of these coherences is neither exponential nor gaussian. We determine the decoherence (decay) time in terms of the strength of the system-pointer and pointer-environment couplings. This decoherence time does not depend upon the details of the pointer-bath coupling as soon as it is smaller than the bath correlation time (non-Markov regime). In contrast, in the Markov regime it depends strongly on whether this coupling is Ohmic or super-Ohmic.
We propose a general theoretical approach to quantum measurements based on the path (histories) summation technique. For a given dynamical variable A, the Schrödinger state of a system in a Hilbert space of arbitrary dimensionality is decomposed into a set of substates, each of which corresponds to a particular detailed history of the system. The coherence between the substates may then be destroyed by meter(s) to a degree determined by the nature and the accuracy of the measurement(s) which may be of von Neumann, finite-time or continuous type. Transformations between the histories obtained for non-commuting variables and construction of simultaneous histories for non-commuting observables are discussed. Important cases of a particle described by Feynman paths in the coordinate space and a qubit in a two dimensional Hilbert space are studied in some detail.
As per the projection postulate, the evolution of the quantum state of a system upon measurement results in state update. In this work we investigate the characterization of updated states of multipartite entangled qubit states with nondestructive weak measurements, involving weakly coupling a pointer to each qubit while considering a relativistic setup involving different reference frames. As is well known, the updated state at intermediate times is frame dependent and outcome randomness, intrinsic to projective measurements, prevents any information from being acquired on the updated state. Here we will see that when weak measurements are implemented there is instead an interplay between randomness and interference, depending on the number of qubits, so as to maintain consistency between descriptions in arbitrary reference frames. Analytical results are given for a small or infinite number of qubits, while for a finite number of qubits we resort to Monte Carlo sampling in order to simulate numerically the results of weak measurements. As a by-product, we show how a single-shot measurement of the pointers' positions allows us to make quantitative predictions on the outcomes that can be obtained for any observable measured on a distant qubit of the multipartite state.
In a preceding Comment [1] to our Letter [2] concerning weak measurements with orbital-angular-momentum (OAM) pointer states [2], Pan and Panigrahi show that the real and imaginary parts of higher-order weak values can be made accessible using Gaussian pointer states.In [2], our goal is to show that by using pointer states embedded with OAM it is possible to extract higher-order weak values where pointer states with a Gaussian shape cannot.As a consequence, our work put forward a new tool for weak amplification schemes, i.e., the use of pointer states with more general spatial forms that could be advantageous in some scenarios.We did not intend to claim that a pointer state with orbital angular momentum was needed to extract higherorder weak values in general.We clarify our point with this Reply.In our Letter we consider a specific Hamiltonian of interaction of the form H ¼ g A AP x þ g B BP y , where A, B are operators, (P x , P y ) are the pointer momentum operators, conjugate to the pointer position operators (X, Y), and g A;B are coupling constants.Moreover, we calculate the two-dimensional pointer displacement hXYi, corresponding to a specific measurement.We emphasize that we consider a particular interaction and a specific measurement, which are generally dictated by the physical system under investigation.The result, Eq. ( 4) of our Letter, shows that pointer states with OAM (l ¼ Æ1) can be used to retrieve the imaginary part of the higher-order weak values hA 2 i w and hB 2 i w , whereas this is not possible with pointer states with no OAM (l ¼ 0).In addition, Eq. ( 9) of our Letter shows, by means of a specific example with B ¼ 0, that hXYi ¼ 0 for Gaussian pointer states.On the contrary, a pointer state with l ¼ Æ1 allows us to extract the imaginary part of the weak value hA 2 i w .Pan and Panigrahi show that by measuring hX 2 i one can obtain the real part of the weak value hA 2 i w using a Gaussian pointer [see Eq. ( 4) of [1]].However, in order to access its imaginary part, they are forced to use a different interaction Hamiltonian, and a measurement observable involving noncommuting operators.The work of Pan and Panigrahi proves the strength of our proposal: One