Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1910.09478

Benchmarking quantum computers for real-time evolution of a $(1+1)$ field theory with error mitigation

Erik Gustafson, Patrick Dreher, Zheyue Hang, Yannick Meurice

Published Oct 21, 2019• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum computers open the possibility of performing real-time calculations for quantum field theory scattering processes. We propose to use an index averaging the absolute value of the difference between the accurately calculated Trotter evolution of site occupations and their actual measurements on NISQ machines. The average is over all the qubits for a certain number of Trotter steps. We use this metric to quantify the progress made in successive state-of-the-art machines and error-mitigation techniques. We illustrate the concept with the transverse Ising model in one spatial dimension with four sites using three of IBM's quantum computers (Almaden, Boeblingen, and Melbourne). We discuss the size of the Trotter steps needed to achieve physics goals. Using the proposed metric, we show that readout mitigation methods and Richardson extrapolations of mitigated measurements are very effective for specific numbers of Trotter steps of a chosen size. This specific choice can be applied to other machines and noise mitigation methods. On the other hand, a reliable algorithmic mitigation would require a significantly larger number of smaller Trotter steps.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1910.09478

Related papers

Quantum simulation of scattering in the quantum Ising model

Erik Gustafson, Yannick Meurice, Judah Unmuth-Yockey

We discuss real-time evolution for the quantum Ising model in one spatial dimension with ${N}_{s}$ sites. In the limit where the nearest-neighbor interactions $J$ in the spatial directions are small, there is a simple physical picture where qubit states can be interpreted as approximate particle occupations. Using exact diagonalization, for initial states with one or two particles, we show that for small $J$, discrete Bessel functions provide very accurate expressions for the evolution of the occupancies corresponding to initial states with one and two particles. Boundary conditions play an important role when the evolution time is long enough. We discuss a Trotter procedure to implement the evolution on existing quantum computers and discuss the error associated with the Trotter step size. We discuss the effects of gate and measurement errors on the evolution of one- and two-particle states using four and eight-qubits circuits approximately corresponding to existing or near-term quantum computers.

arXiv:1901.05944•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 23, 2019•70 citations

Simulating Field Theories with Quantum Computers

Muhammad Asaduzzaman, Simon M. Catterall, Yannick Meurice +1 more

In this study, we investigate Trotter evolution in the Gross-Neveu and hyperbolic Ising models in two spacetime dimensions, using quantum computers. We identify different sources of errors prevalent in various quantum processing units and discuss challenges to scale up the size of the computation. We present benchmark results obtained on a variety of platforms and employ a range of error mitigation techniques to address coherent and incoherent noise. By comparing these mitigated outcomes with exact diagonalization results and density matrix renormalization group calculations, we assess the effectiveness of our approaches. Moreover, we demonstrate the implementation of an out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC) protocol using IBM's quantum computers.

arXiv:2401.01962•International Symposium on Lattice Field Theory (LATTICE)•May 4, 2024•0 citations

Applying the noiseless extrapolation error mitigation protocol to calculate real-time quantum field theory scattering phase shifts

Zachary P. Parks, Arnaud Carignan-Dugas, Erik Gustafson +2 more

Real-time scattering calculations on a noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) quantum computer are disrupted by errors that accumulate throughout the circuits. To improve the accuracy of such physics simulations, one can supplement the application circuits with a recent error mitigation strategy known as noiseless output extrapolation (NOX). We tested these error mitigation protocols on a transverse field Ising model and improved upon previous phase shift calculations. Our proof-of-concept 4-qubit application circuits were run on several IBM quantum computing hardware architectures. We introduce metrics that show between 22% and 73% error reduction for circuit depths ranging from 13 to 37 hard cycles, confirming that the NOX technique applies to circuits with a broad range of failure rates. We also observed an approximate 28% improvement in the accuracy of the time delay calculation of the scattering phase shift. These observations on different cloud-accessible devices confirm that NOX improves performance even when circuits are executed in substantially time-separated batches. Finally, we provide a heuristic method to obtain systematic error bars on the mitigated results, compare them with empirical errors and discuss their effects on phase shift estimates.

arXiv:2212.05333•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jan 10, 2024•6 citations

Quantum Error Mitigation in Optimized Circuits for Particle-Density Correlations in Real-Time Dynamics of the Schwinger Model

Domenico Pomarico, Mahul Pandey, Riccardo Cioli +5 more

Quantum computing gives direct access to the study of the real-time dynamics of quantum many-body systems. In principle, it is possible to directly calculate non-equal-time correlation functions, from which one can detect interesting phenomena, such as the presence of quantum scars or dynamical quantum phase transitions. In practice, these calculations are strongly affected by noise, due to the complexity of the required quantum circuits. As a testbed for the evaluation of the real-time evolution of observables and correlations, the dynamics of the Zn Schwinger model in a one-dimensional lattice is considered. To control the computational cost, we adopt a quantum-classical strategy that reduces the dimensionality of the system by restricting the dynamics to the Dirac vacuum sector and optimizes the embedding into a qubit model by minimizing the number of three-qubit gates. The time evolution of particle-density operators in a non-equilibrium quench protocol is both simulated in a bare noisy condition and implemented on a physical IBM quantum device. In either case, the convergence towards a maximally mixed state is targeted by means of different error mitigation techniques. The evaluation of the particle-density correlation shows a well-performing post-processing error mitigation for properly chosen coupling regimes.

arXiv:2501.10831•Entropy•Apr 14, 2025•5 citations

Mitigating algorithmic errors in a Hamiltonian simulation

Suguru Endo, Qi Zhao, Ying Li +2 more

Quantum computers can efficiently simulate many-body systems. As a widely used Hamiltonian simulation tool, the Trotter-Suzuki scheme splits the evolution into the number of Trotter steps $N$ and approximates the evolution of each step by a product of exponentials of each individual term of the total Hamiltonian. The algorithmic error due to the approximation can be reduced by increasing $N$, which however requires a longer circuit and hence inevitably introduces more physical errors. In this work, we first study such a trade-off and numerically find the optimal number of Trotter steps ${N}_{\mathrm{opt}}$ given a physical error model in a near-term quantum hardware. Practically, physical errors can be suppressed using recently proposed error mitigation methods. We then extend physical error mitigation methods to suppress the algorithmic error in Hamiltonian simulation. By exploiting the simulation results with different numbers of Trotter steps $N\ensuremath{\le}{N}_{\mathrm{opt}}$, we can infer the exact simulation result within a higher accuracy and hence mitigate algorithmic errors. We numerically test our scheme with a five-qubit system and show significant improvements in the simulation accuracy by applying both physical and algorithmic error mitigations.

arXiv:1808.03623•Physical Review A•Jan 18, 2019•83 citations

Error-mitigated simulation of quantum many-body scars on quantum computers with pulse-level control

I-Chi Chen, Benjamin Burdick, Yongxin Yao +2 more

Quantum many-body scars are an intriguing dynamical regime in which quantum systems exhibit coherent dynamics and long-range correlations when prepared in certain initial states. We use this combination of coherence and many-body correlations to benchmark the performance of present-day quantum computing devices by using them to simulate the dynamics of an antiferromagnetic initial state in mixed-field Ising chains of up to 19 sites. In addition to calculating the dynamics of local observables, we also calculate the Loschmidt echo and a nontrivial unequal-time connected correlation function that witnesses long-range many-body correlations in the scarred dynamics. We find coherent dynamics to persist over up to 40 Trotter steps even in the presence of various sources of error. To obtain these results, we leverage a variety of error-mitigation techniques including noise tailoring, zero-noise extrapolation, dynamical decoupling, and physically motivated postselection of measurement results. Crucially, we also find that using pulse-level control to implement the Ising interaction yields a substantial improvement over the standard controlled-not-based compilation of this interaction. Our results demonstrate the power of error-mitigation techniques and pulse-level control to probe many-body coherence and correlation effects on present-day quantum hardware.

arXiv:2203.08291•Physical Review Research•Oct 13, 2022•63 citations
Benchmarking quantum computers for real-time evolution of a (1+1)(1+1)(1+1) field theory with error mitigation
Quantum computers open the possibility of performing real-time calculations for quantum field theory scattering processes. We propose to use an index averaging the absolute value of the difference between the accurately calculated Trotter evolution of site occupations and their actual measurements on NISQ machines. The average is over all the qubits for a certain number of Trotter steps. We use this metric to quantify the progress made in successive state-of-the-art machines and error-mitigation techniques. We illustrate the concept with the transverse Ising model in one spatial dimension with four sites using three of IBM's quantum computers (Almaden, Boeblingen, and Melbourne). We discuss the size of the Trotter steps needed to achieve physics goals. Using the proposed metric, we show that readout mitigation methods and Richardson extrapolations of mitigated measurements are very effective for specific numbers of Trotter steps of a chosen size. This specific choice can be applied to other machines and noise mitigation methods. On the other hand, a reliable algorithmic mitigation would require a significantly larger number of smaller Trotter steps.
We discuss real-time evolution for the quantum Ising model in one spatial dimension with Ns{N}_{s}Ns​ sites. In the limit where the nearest-neighbor interactions JJJ in the spatial directions are small, there is a simple physical picture where qubit states can be interpreted as approximate particle occupations. Using exact diagonalization, for initial states with one or two particles, we show that for small JJJ, discrete Bessel functions provide very accurate expressions for the evolution of the occupancies corresponding to initial states with one and two particles. Boundary conditions play an important role when the evolution time is long enough. We discuss a Trotter procedure to implement the evolution on existing quantum computers and discuss the error associated with the Trotter step size. We discuss the effects of gate and measurement errors on the evolution of one- and two-particle states using four and eight-qubits circuits approximately corresponding to existing or near-term quantum computers.
In this study, we investigate Trotter evolution in the Gross-Neveu and hyperbolic Ising models in two spacetime dimensions, using quantum computers. We identify different sources of errors prevalent in various quantum processing units and discuss challenges to scale up the size of the computation. We present benchmark results obtained on a variety of platforms and employ a range of error mitigation techniques to address coherent and incoherent noise. By comparing these mitigated outcomes with exact diagonalization results and density matrix renormalization group calculations, we assess the effectiveness of our approaches. Moreover, we demonstrate the implementation of an out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC) protocol using IBM's quantum computers.
Real-time scattering calculations on a noisy intermediate scale quantum (NISQ) quantum computer are disrupted by errors that accumulate throughout the circuits. To improve the accuracy of such physics simulations, one can supplement the application circuits with a recent error mitigation strategy known as noiseless output extrapolation (NOX). We tested these error mitigation protocols on a transverse field Ising model and improved upon previous phase shift calculations. Our proof-of-concept 4-qubit application circuits were run on several IBM quantum computing hardware architectures. We introduce metrics that show between 22% and 73% error reduction for circuit depths ranging from 13 to 37 hard cycles, confirming that the NOX technique applies to circuits with a broad range of failure rates. We also observed an approximate 28% improvement in the accuracy of the time delay calculation of the scattering phase shift. These observations on different cloud-accessible devices confirm that NOX improves performance even when circuits are executed in substantially time-separated batches. Finally, we provide a heuristic method to obtain systematic error bars on the mitigated results, compare them with empirical errors and discuss their effects on phase shift estimates.
Quantum computing gives direct access to the study of the real-time dynamics of quantum many-body systems. In principle, it is possible to directly calculate non-equal-time correlation functions, from which one can detect interesting phenomena, such as the presence of quantum scars or dynamical quantum phase transitions. In practice, these calculations are strongly affected by noise, due to the complexity of the required quantum circuits. As a testbed for the evaluation of the real-time evolution of observables and correlations, the dynamics of the Zn Schwinger model in a one-dimensional lattice is considered. To control the computational cost, we adopt a quantum-classical strategy that reduces the dimensionality of the system by restricting the dynamics to the Dirac vacuum sector and optimizes the embedding into a qubit model by minimizing the number of three-qubit gates. The time evolution of particle-density operators in a non-equilibrium quench protocol is both simulated in a bare noisy condition and implemented on a physical IBM quantum device. In either case, the convergence towards a maximally mixed state is targeted by means of different error mitigation techniques. The evaluation of the particle-density correlation shows a well-performing post-processing error mitigation for properly chosen coupling regimes.
Quantum computers can efficiently simulate many-body systems. As a widely used Hamiltonian simulation tool, the Trotter-Suzuki scheme splits the evolution into the number of Trotter steps NNN and approximates the evolution of each step by a product of exponentials of each individual term of the total Hamiltonian. The algorithmic error due to the approximation can be reduced by increasing NNN, which however requires a longer circuit and hence inevitably introduces more physical errors. In this work, we first study such a trade-off and numerically find the optimal number of Trotter steps Nopt{N}_{\mathrm{opt}}Nopt​ given a physical error model in a near-term quantum hardware. Practically, physical errors can be suppressed using recently proposed error mitigation methods. We then extend physical error mitigation methods to suppress the algorithmic error in Hamiltonian simulation. By exploiting the simulation results with different numbers of Trotter steps $N\ensuremath{\le}{N}_{\mathrm{opt}}$, we can infer the exact simulation result within a higher accuracy and hence mitigate algorithmic errors. We numerically test our scheme with a five-qubit system and show significant improvements in the simulation accuracy by applying both physical and algorithmic error mitigations.
Quantum many-body scars are an intriguing dynamical regime in which quantum systems exhibit coherent dynamics and long-range correlations when prepared in certain initial states. We use this combination of coherence and many-body correlations to benchmark the performance of present-day quantum computing devices by using them to simulate the dynamics of an antiferromagnetic initial state in mixed-field Ising chains of up to 19 sites. In addition to calculating the dynamics of local observables, we also calculate the Loschmidt echo and a nontrivial unequal-time connected correlation function that witnesses long-range many-body correlations in the scarred dynamics. We find coherent dynamics to persist over up to 40 Trotter steps even in the presence of various sources of error. To obtain these results, we leverage a variety of error-mitigation techniques including noise tailoring, zero-noise extrapolation, dynamical decoupling, and physically motivated postselection of measurement results. Crucially, we also find that using pulse-level control to implement the Ising interaction yields a substantial improvement over the standard controlled-not-based compilation of this interaction. Our results demonstrate the power of error-mitigation techniques and pulse-level control to probe many-body coherence and correlation effects on present-day quantum hardware.