Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.12568 · Physical Review Research

Realizing the Hayden-Preskill protocol with coupled Dicke models

Yanting Cheng, Chang Liu, Jinkang Guo, Yu Chen, Pengfei Zhang, Hui Zhai

Published Oct 5, 2020• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Hayden and Preskill proposed a thought experiment in which Bob can recover the information Alice throws into a black hole if he has a quantum computer entangled with the black hole, and for which Yoshida and Kitaev recently proposed a concrete decoding scheme.In the context of quantum many-body physics, the parallel question is that after a small system is thermalized with a large system, how can one decode the initial state information with the help of two entangled many-body systems?Here, we propose to realize this decoding protocol in a physical system of two Dicke models, with two cavity fields prepared in a thermofield double state.We show that the Yoshida-Kitaev protocol allows us to read out the initial spin information after it is scrambled into the cavity.We show that the readout efficiency reaches a maximum when the model parameters are tuned to the regime where the system is the most chaotic, characterized by the shortest scrambling time in the out-of-time-ordered correlation function.Our proposal opens up the possibility of discussing this profound thought experiment in a realistic setting.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.2.043024

Related papers

Efficient decoding for the Hayden-Preskill protocol

Beni Yoshida, Alexei Kitaev

We present two particular decoding procedures for reconstructing a quantum state from the Hawking radiation in the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment. We work in an idealized setting and represent the black hole and its entangled partner by $n$ EPR pairs. The first procedure teleports the state thrown into the black hole to an outside observer by post-selecting on the condition that a sufficient number of EPR pairs remain undisturbed. The probability of this favorable event scales as $1/d_{A}^2$, where $d_A$ is the Hilbert space dimension for the input state. The second procedure is deterministic and combines the previous idea with Grover's search. The decoding complexity is $\mathcal{O}(d_{A}\mathcal{C})$ where $\mathcal{C}$ is the size of the quantum circuit implementing the unitary evolution operator $U$ of the black hole. As with the original (non-constructive) decoding scheme, our algorithms utilize scrambling, where the decay of out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs) guarantees faithful state recovery.

arXiv:1710.03363•Oct 10, 2017•237 citations

Bidirectional teleportation using scrambling dynamics: a practical protocol

Amit Vikram, Edwin Chaparro, Muhammad Miskeen Khan +3 more

We show that quantum information scrambling can enable a generic SWAP gate between collective degrees of freedom in systems without universal local control. Our protocol combines the Hayden-Preskill recovery scheme, associated with the black hole information paradox, with quantum teleportation and runs them in parallel and in opposite directions, enabling bidirectional exchange of quantum states through global interactions alone. This approach cleanly distinguishes the roles of information spreading, entanglement, and chaos for enabling both coherent state transfer and recovery. We propose an experimental realization using the Dicke model, which can be realized in cavity-QED and trapped-ion platforms, highlighting the utility of holography in designing practical quantum gates.

quant-pharXiv:2601.15536•Physical Review Letters•Jan 23, 2026•6 citations

Black holes as clouded mirrors: the Hayden-Preskill protocol with symmetry

Yoshifumi Nakata, Eyuri Wakakuwa, Masato Koashi

The Hayden-Preskill protocol is a qubit-toy model of the black hole information paradox. Based on the assumption of scrambling, it was revealed that quantum information is instantly leaked out from the quantum many-body system that models a black hole. In this paper, we extend the protocol to the case where the system has symmetry and investigate how the symmetry affects the leakage of information. We especially focus on the conservation of the number of up-spins. Developing a partial decoupling approach, we first show that the symmetry induces a delay of leakage and an information remnant. We then clarify the physics behind them: the delay is characterized by thermodynamic properties of the system associated with the symmetry, and the information remnant is closely related to the symmetry-breaking of the initial state. These relations bridge the information leakage problem to macroscopic physics of quantum many-body systems and allow us to investigate the information leakage only in terms of physical properties of the system.

arXiv:2007.00895•Quantum•Feb 21, 2023•27 citations

Quantum information recovery from a black hole with a projective measurement

Ran Li, Jin Wang

We studied the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment with the local projective measurement. Compared to the original model, the measurement is applied to the Hawking radiation that was emitted after throwing the quantum diary into the black hole. Within this setup, we explored the information recovery from the black hole utilizing the Yoshida-Kitaev probabilistic strategy and demonstrated a perfect decoding in the ideal case. Additionally, we analyzed the decoherence effects from the environment on the decoding protocol. It shows that errors represented by the depolarizing channel can reduce the decoding probability and fidelity, while errors represented by the dephasing channel do not affect the decoding protocol. Furthermore, we discussed various aspects of the current model, including its relation to the black hole final state proposal and the quantum simulations of the decoding protocols. Especially, employing the graphical representations, we provide an intuitive derivation of the equivalence between the Yoshida-Kitaev protocol and Petz recovery map.

arXiv:2401.14207•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 18, 2024•3 citations

Repeated Extraction of Scrambled Quantum Data: Sustainability of the Hayden-Preskill Type Protocols

Seok Hyung Lie, Yong Siah Teo, Hyunseok Jeong

We introduce and study the problem of scrambler hacking, which is the procedure of quantum information extraction from and installation on a quantum scrambler given only partial access. This problem necessarily emerges from a central topic in contemporary physics - information recovery from systems undergoing scrambling dynamics, such as the Hayden-Preskill protocol in black hole studies - because one must replace quantum data with another when extracting it due to the no-cloning theorem. For large scramblers, we supply analytical formulas for the optimal hacking fidelity, a quantitative measure of the effectiveness of scrambler hacking with limited access. In the two-user scenario where Bob attempts to hack Alice's data, we find that the optimal fidelity converges to $64/(9π^2)\approx0.72$ with increasing Bob's hacking space relative to Alice's user space. We applied our results to the black hole information problem and showed that the limited hacking fidelity implies the reflectivity decay of a black hole as an information mirror, which questions the solvability of the black hole information paradox through the Hayden-Preskill type protocol.

arXiv:2204.00374•Apr 1, 2022•2 citations

The Petz (lite) recovery map for the scrambling channel

Yasuaki Nakayama, Akihiro Miyata, Tomonori Ugajin

Abstract We study properties of the Petz recovery map in chaotic systems, such as the Hayden–Preskill setup for evaporating black holes and the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev (SYK) model. Since these systems exhibit the phenomenon called scrambling, we expect that the expression of the recovery channel $\mathcal {R}$ gets simplified, given by just the adjoint $\mathcal {N}^{\dagger }$ of the original channel $\mathcal {N}$ which defines the time evolution of the states in the code subspace embedded into the physical Hilbert space. We check this phenomenon in two examples. The first one is the Hayden–Preskill setup described by Haar random unitaries. We compute the relative entropy $S(\mathcal {R}\left[\mathcal {N}[\rho ]\right] ||\rho )$ and show that it vanishes when the decoupling is archived. We further show that the simplified recovery map is equivalent to the protocol proposed by Yoshida and Kitaev. The second example is the SYK model where the 2D code subspace is defined by an insertion of a fermionic operator, and the system is evolved by the SYK Hamiltonian. We check the recovery phenomenon by relating some matrix elements of an output density matrix $\langle{T}|\mathcal {R}[\mathcal {N}[\rho ]]|{T^{\prime }}\rangle$ to Rényi-two modular flowed correlators, and show that they coincide with the elements for the input density matrix with small error after twice the scrambling time.

Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Dec 1, 2023•8 citations
Hayden and Preskill proposed a thought experiment in which Bob can recover the information Alice throws into a black hole if he has a quantum computer entangled with the black hole, and for which Yoshida and Kitaev recently proposed a concrete decoding scheme.In the context of quantum many-body physics, the parallel question is that after a small system is thermalized with a large system, how can one decode the initial state information with the help of two entangled many-body systems?Here, we propose to realize this decoding protocol in a physical system of two Dicke models, with two cavity fields prepared in a thermofield double state.We show that the Yoshida-Kitaev protocol allows us to read out the initial spin information after it is scrambled into the cavity.We show that the readout efficiency reaches a maximum when the model parameters are tuned to the regime where the system is the most chaotic, characterized by the shortest scrambling time in the out-of-time-ordered correlation function.Our proposal opens up the possibility of discussing this profound thought experiment in a realistic setting.
We present two particular decoding procedures for reconstructing a quantum state from the Hawking radiation in the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment. We work in an idealized setting and represent the black hole and its entangled partner by nnn EPR pairs. The first procedure teleports the state thrown into the black hole to an outside observer by post-selecting on the condition that a sufficient number of EPR pairs remain undisturbed. The probability of this favorable event scales as 1/dA21/d_{A}^21/dA2​, where dAd_AdA​ is the Hilbert space dimension for the input state. The second procedure is deterministic and combines the previous idea with Grover's search. The decoding complexity is O(dAC)\mathcal{O}(d_{A}\mathcal{C})O(dA​C) where C\mathcal{C}C is the size of the quantum circuit implementing the unitary evolution operator UUU of the black hole. As with the original (non-constructive) decoding scheme, our algorithms utilize scrambling, where the decay of out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs) guarantees faithful state recovery.
We show that quantum information scrambling can enable a generic SWAP gate between collective degrees of freedom in systems without universal local control. Our protocol combines the Hayden-Preskill recovery scheme, associated with the black hole information paradox, with quantum teleportation and runs them in parallel and in opposite directions, enabling bidirectional exchange of quantum states through global interactions alone. This approach cleanly distinguishes the roles of information spreading, entanglement, and chaos for enabling both coherent state transfer and recovery. We propose an experimental realization using the Dicke model, which can be realized in cavity-QED and trapped-ion platforms, highlighting the utility of holography in designing practical quantum gates.
The Hayden-Preskill protocol is a qubit-toy model of the black hole information paradox. Based on the assumption of scrambling, it was revealed that quantum information is instantly leaked out from the quantum many-body system that models a black hole. In this paper, we extend the protocol to the case where the system has symmetry and investigate how the symmetry affects the leakage of information. We especially focus on the conservation of the number of up-spins. Developing a partial decoupling approach, we first show that the symmetry induces a delay of leakage and an information remnant. We then clarify the physics behind them: the delay is characterized by thermodynamic properties of the system associated with the symmetry, and the information remnant is closely related to the symmetry-breaking of the initial state. These relations bridge the information leakage problem to macroscopic physics of quantum many-body systems and allow us to investigate the information leakage only in terms of physical properties of the system.
We studied the Hayden-Preskill thought experiment with the local projective measurement. Compared to the original model, the measurement is applied to the Hawking radiation that was emitted after throwing the quantum diary into the black hole. Within this setup, we explored the information recovery from the black hole utilizing the Yoshida-Kitaev probabilistic strategy and demonstrated a perfect decoding in the ideal case. Additionally, we analyzed the decoherence effects from the environment on the decoding protocol. It shows that errors represented by the depolarizing channel can reduce the decoding probability and fidelity, while errors represented by the dephasing channel do not affect the decoding protocol. Furthermore, we discussed various aspects of the current model, including its relation to the black hole final state proposal and the quantum simulations of the decoding protocols. Especially, employing the graphical representations, we provide an intuitive derivation of the equivalence between the Yoshida-Kitaev protocol and Petz recovery map.
We introduce and study the problem of scrambler hacking, which is the procedure of quantum information extraction from and installation on a quantum scrambler given only partial access. This problem necessarily emerges from a central topic in contemporary physics - information recovery from systems undergoing scrambling dynamics, such as the Hayden-Preskill protocol in black hole studies - because one must replace quantum data with another when extracting it due to the no-cloning theorem. For large scramblers, we supply analytical formulas for the optimal hacking fidelity, a quantitative measure of the effectiveness of scrambler hacking with limited access. In the two-user scenario where Bob attempts to hack Alice's data, we find that the optimal fidelity converges to 64/(9π2)≈0.7264/(9π^2)\approx0.7264/(9π2)≈0.72 with increasing Bob's hacking space relative to Alice's user space. We applied our results to the black hole information problem and showed that the limited hacking fidelity implies the reflectivity decay of a black hole as an information mirror, which questions the solvability of the black hole information paradox through the Hayden-Preskill type protocol.
Abstract We study properties of the Petz recovery map in chaotic systems, such as the Hayden–Preskill setup for evaporating black holes and the Sachdev–Ye–Kitaev (SYK) model. Since these systems exhibit the phenomenon called scrambling, we expect that the expression of the recovery channel R\mathcal {R}R gets simplified, given by just the adjoint N†\mathcal {N}^{\dagger }N† of the original channel N\mathcal {N}N which defines the time evolution of the states in the code subspace embedded into the physical Hilbert space. We check this phenomenon in two examples. The first one is the Hayden–Preskill setup described by Haar random unitaries. We compute the relative entropy S(R[N[ρ]]∣∣ρ)S(\mathcal {R}\left[\mathcal {N}[\rho ]\right] ||\rho )S(R[N[ρ]]∣∣ρ) and show that it vanishes when the decoupling is archived. We further show that the simplified recovery map is equivalent to the protocol proposed by Yoshida and Kitaev. The second example is the SYK model where the 2D code subspace is defined by an insertion of a fermionic operator, and the system is evolved by the SYK Hamiltonian. We check the recovery phenomenon by relating some matrix elements of an output density matrix ⟨T∣R[N[ρ]]∣T′⟩\langle{T}|\mathcal {R}[\mathcal {N}[\rho ]]|{T^{\prime }}\rangle⟨T∣R[N[ρ]]∣T′⟩ to Rényi-two modular flowed correlators, and show that they coincide with the elements for the input density matrix with small error after twice the scrambling time.