Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1909.10064

Ontological Foundations of the Variational Principles and the Path Integral Formalism

Vladislav Terekhovich

Published Sep 22, 2019• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, I consider the issue of how two mathematical models of modern physics, the variational principles and the quantum path integral formalism, relate to reality. I assume that the observed phenomena are consistent with the calculations because both of these models have some common ontological foundations. According to the hypothesis of the summation of coexisting alternative possibilities, at the quantum level, the system at once moves along all histories that possible in given boundary conditions. The actual history is a mere result of the summation of all these alternative possible histories. This resultant history differs from others with the minimal action and maximal probability. I observe this history as a macroscopic trajectory of the system.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1909.10064

Related papers

On the Physics of History Space: The Ensemble of Histories and Quantum Reality as an Ontological Foundation

Jincheng Zhang

If Richard Feynman's path integral formulation had been proposed not merely as a computational tool for probability amplitudes, but as a fundamental physical ontology—namely, that "all histories collectively constitute reality"—the foundational paradigm of physics would have undergone a profound transformation. Traditional physics treats a single trajectory of a system in spacetime as the primary object and path integration as a summation technique over possible paths. This paper systematically develops an alternative framework: Physics of History Space, where the ensemble of all possible histories serves as the irreduceable primary object of physical description. Within this paradigm, physical reality is defined by the topology, measure, and algebraic structures over the space of histories, rather than being restricted to a single actualized trajectory. We establish the mathematical formulation of history space and re-examine the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the problem of initial conditions in cosmology, and the philosophy of time. We demonstrate that classical single-trajectory spacetime emerges merely as a low-dimensional projection of history space under decoherence and stationary phase limits.

•Jul 25, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Reality

Virendra Singh

We begin by discussing ``What exists?'', i.e. ontology, in Classical Physics which provided a description of physical phenomena at the macroscopic level. The microworld however necessitates a introduction of Quantum ideas for its understanding. It is almost certain that the world is quantum mechanical at both microscopic as well as at macroscopic level. The problem of ontology of a Quantum world is a difficult one. It also depends on which interpretation is used. We first discuss some interpretations in which Quantum Mechanics does not provide a complete framework but has to be supplemented by extra ingredients e.g. (i) Copenhagen group of interpretations associated with the names of Niels Bohr, Heisenberg, von-Neumann, and (ii) de-Broglie-Bohm interpretations. We then look at some interpretations in which Quantum mechanics is supposed to provide the entire framework such as (i) Everett-deWitt many world, (ii) quantum histories interpretations. We conclude with some remarks on the rigidity of the formalism of quantum mechanics, which is sharp contrast to it's ontological fluidity.

arXiv:quant-ph/0412148•Dec 20, 2004•4 citations

The Action Scale and The Emergence of Classical Dynamics in Quantum Systems

Rodika Utama, Rustaman

The principle of action plays a central role in both classical and quantum mechanics, yet its physical meaning is often introduced in a purely formal manner. In this work, the concept of action is examined from a scale-based perspective that clarifies its role in the quantum–classical correspondence. By emphasizing the dimensionless ratio S/ℏ, we show that the emergence of classical dynamics can be understood as a consequence of quantum phase coherence rather than as an independent postulate. Within the path integral formulation, classical trajectories arise naturally from stationary-phase conditions when the action associated with a physical process becomes large compared to Planck’s constant. This interpretation provides a unified conceptual framework in which variational principles, quantum interference, and classical determinism are linked through the scale of action. The analysis highlights the role of Planck’s constant as a universal parameter governing the physical relevance of alternative histories, analogous to the function of Boltzmann’s constant in statistical physics. Beyond its theoretical implications, the proposed perspective offers pedagogical value by providing a coherent bridge between classical and quantum mechanics suitable for advanced undergraduate and early graduate physics education.

JURNAL ARMADA PENDIDIKAN•Apr 30, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Interference from a Single Physical History: A Single-History Record Framework for Slit Experiments

Tong Wang

Quantum interference is conventionally formulated using complex amplitudes associated with quantum alternatives or through Feynman’s path integral over possible trajectories. This article investigates a different ontology, the Single-History Record Framework (SHRF), in which a physical system has one realized history together with a record space of phase-carrying contributions associated with that history. Observable amplitudes are obtained through History-Record Summation (HRS). SHRF deliberately retains established quantum ingredients wherever possible, including complex-amplitude addition, the Born probability rule, propagation phases, and marker-state overlaps. These mathematical devices are used as predictive rules and do not imply that multiple physical histories, paths, or marker outcomes coexist.A preliminary model is developed in which rapidly varying regions of record space largely cancel while coherent record bands provide the dominant detector amplitude. For double-slit geometry, two aperture-selected bands give A(x)≈H_A (x)+H_B (x).With the established propagation phases H_A=Ce^(ikL_A ),H_B=Ce^(ikL_B ),SHRF recovers the textbook far-field fringe spacing Δx=λD/d.The same formal structure is applied to single-slit diffraction, multiple slits, which-path marking, partial distinguishability, and quantum-eraser subensembles. In particular, marker records modify the interference term through the standard overlap factor ⟨M_A∣M_B⟩,without requiring a physical superposition of marker records. The present model assumes rather than derives its phase law, record-space measure, and Born rule. It is therefore a recovery-oriented consistency construction and ontological reinterpretation, not an independent replacement for standard quantum mechanics.

•Aug 27, 2026•0 citations

PATH INTEGRALS AND THE HOLISTIC APPROACH TO THEORETICAL PHYSICS

The development of modern physics can be viewed from so many different directions that almost every author presents a different perspective. In this chapter we shall look at the very recent history of physics and try to discern the role which the concepts of path integration have played. Of course, we are interested in the future and in the way in which path integration might influence the future interpretation of reality. We follow Ref. 1. To summarize the thesis of this chapter: it appears to us that theoretical physics is loosing its classical form of a local and deterministic theory and is acquiring a more global and organic form. Moreover, it will be argued that path integration is a very appropriate mathematical language for this new, more holistic form of physical theory. In order to clarify these matters we briefly sketch some relevant features of the recent history of physics.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Sep 1, 1986•0 citations

费曼路径积费曼路径积分与薛定谔表象的等效性: 意义及其证明 The Equivalence of Feynman's Path Integral and the Schrödinger Picture: Meaning and Proof

ming Cheng

Quantum mechanics presents two seemingly distinct theoretical pictures: the unitary evolution of state vectors in the Schrödinger picture, and the summation over all possible paths in Feynman's path integral formulation. This article systematically argues that the equivalence between these two pictures is a rigorous mathematical fact rather than a choice between competing physical mechanisms. We analyze the meaning of this equivalence at three levels—physical, mathematical, and philosophical—and explore its implications for the generation of entanglement, many-body systems, and quantum field theory. The complete mathematical proof of the equivalence, from unitary evolution to the path integral, is provided in the appendix, along with a detailed construction of quantum entanglement from the path integral framework. Building on this analysis, we distill a broader philosophical thesis: every physical theory, no matter how successful, is a representation of the natural world rather than the world itself. Physical theories are like maps to a territory—they can be extraordinarily precise, yet they are never the territory. The Schrödinger equation, the path integral, and Heisenberg's matrix mechanics are three different maps of the same "quantum territory." Asking whether the wave function "really exists" or whether a particle "really travels along all paths" commits a category mistake—conflating mathematical entities internal to a theory with ontological reality beyond it. The history of physics—from Newtonian gravity to general relativity, from thermodynamics to statistical mechanics, from field-based to action-at-a-distance formulations of electrodynamics—repeatedly teaches this lesson: ontological claims are relative to a given theoretical framework and carry no absolute significance beyond it. The principle of "representational freedom" is thus proposed: when multiple mathematically equivalent formulations of a physical theory yield strictly identical predictions for all observables, no experiment can adjudicate among them ontologically. Choosing one formulation as a calculational tool is a pragmatic decision, not an ontological verdict. The ultimate conclusion is that the path integral is simply the integral representation of the time-evolution operator in the position basis; neither picture enjoys ontological primacy. To claim that "the path sum really happens" or that "the state vector really evolves" is to cross the same boundary. True scientific wisdom lies in knowing where the boundary between representation and reality lies—and then, with ontological humility, continuing to explore the deeper structures that lie beyond it.

•Jun 11, 2026•0 citations
In this paper, I consider the issue of how two mathematical models of modern physics, the variational principles and the quantum path integral formalism, relate to reality. I assume that the observed phenomena are consistent with the calculations because both of these models have some common ontological foundations. According to the hypothesis of the summation of coexisting alternative possibilities, at the quantum level, the system at once moves along all histories that possible in given boundary conditions. The actual history is a mere result of the summation of all these alternative possible histories. This resultant history differs from others with the minimal action and maximal probability. I observe this history as a macroscopic trajectory of the system.
If Richard Feynman's path integral formulation had been proposed not merely as a computational tool for probability amplitudes, but as a fundamental physical ontology—namely, that "all histories collectively constitute reality"—the foundational paradigm of physics would have undergone a profound transformation. Traditional physics treats a single trajectory of a system in spacetime as the primary object and path integration as a summation technique over possible paths. This paper systematically develops an alternative framework: Physics of History Space, where the ensemble of all possible histories serves as the irreduceable primary object of physical description. Within this paradigm, physical reality is defined by the topology, measure, and algebraic structures over the space of histories, rather than being restricted to a single actualized trajectory. We establish the mathematical formulation of history space and re-examine the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the problem of initial conditions in cosmology, and the philosophy of time. We demonstrate that classical single-trajectory spacetime emerges merely as a low-dimensional projection of history space under decoherence and stationary phase limits.
We begin by discussing ``What exists?'', i.e. ontology, in Classical Physics which provided a description of physical phenomena at the macroscopic level. The microworld however necessitates a introduction of Quantum ideas for its understanding. It is almost certain that the world is quantum mechanical at both microscopic as well as at macroscopic level. The problem of ontology of a Quantum world is a difficult one. It also depends on which interpretation is used. We first discuss some interpretations in which Quantum Mechanics does not provide a complete framework but has to be supplemented by extra ingredients e.g. (i) Copenhagen group of interpretations associated with the names of Niels Bohr, Heisenberg, von-Neumann, and (ii) de-Broglie-Bohm interpretations. We then look at some interpretations in which Quantum mechanics is supposed to provide the entire framework such as (i) Everett-deWitt many world, (ii) quantum histories interpretations. We conclude with some remarks on the rigidity of the formalism of quantum mechanics, which is sharp contrast to it's ontological fluidity.
The principle of action plays a central role in both classical and quantum mechanics, yet its physical meaning is often introduced in a purely formal manner. In this work, the concept of action is examined from a scale-based perspective that clarifies its role in the quantum–classical correspondence. By emphasizing the dimensionless ratio S/ℏ, we show that the emergence of classical dynamics can be understood as a consequence of quantum phase coherence rather than as an independent postulate. Within the path integral formulation, classical trajectories arise naturally from stationary-phase conditions when the action associated with a physical process becomes large compared to Planck’s constant. This interpretation provides a unified conceptual framework in which variational principles, quantum interference, and classical determinism are linked through the scale of action. The analysis highlights the role of Planck’s constant as a universal parameter governing the physical relevance of alternative histories, analogous to the function of Boltzmann’s constant in statistical physics. Beyond its theoretical implications, the proposed perspective offers pedagogical value by providing a coherent bridge between classical and quantum mechanics suitable for advanced undergraduate and early graduate physics education.
Quantum interference is conventionally formulated using complex amplitudes associated with quantum alternatives or through Feynman’s path integral over possible trajectories. This article investigates a different ontology, the Single-History Record Framework (SHRF), in which a physical system has one realized history together with a record space of phase-carrying contributions associated with that history. Observable amplitudes are obtained through History-Record Summation (HRS). SHRF deliberately retains established quantum ingredients wherever possible, including complex-amplitude addition, the Born probability rule, propagation phases, and marker-state overlaps. These mathematical devices are used as predictive rules and do not imply that multiple physical histories, paths, or marker outcomes coexist.A preliminary model is developed in which rapidly varying regions of record space largely cancel while coherent record bands provide the dominant detector amplitude. For double-slit geometry, two aperture-selected bands give A(x)≈H_A (x)+H_B (x).With the established propagation phases H_A=Ce^(ikL_A ),H_B=Ce^(ikL_B ),SHRF recovers the textbook far-field fringe spacing Δx=λD/d.The same formal structure is applied to single-slit diffraction, multiple slits, which-path marking, partial distinguishability, and quantum-eraser subensembles. In particular, marker records modify the interference term through the standard overlap factor ⟨M_A∣M_B⟩,without requiring a physical superposition of marker records. The present model assumes rather than derives its phase law, record-space measure, and Born rule. It is therefore a recovery-oriented consistency construction and ontological reinterpretation, not an independent replacement for standard quantum mechanics.
The development of modern physics can be viewed from so many different directions that almost every author presents a different perspective. In this chapter we shall look at the very recent history of physics and try to discern the role which the concepts of path integration have played. Of course, we are interested in the future and in the way in which path integration might influence the future interpretation of reality. We follow Ref. 1. To summarize the thesis of this chapter: it appears to us that theoretical physics is loosing its classical form of a local and deterministic theory and is acquiring a more global and organic form. Moreover, it will be argued that path integration is a very appropriate mathematical language for this new, more holistic form of physical theory. In order to clarify these matters we briefly sketch some relevant features of the recent history of physics.
Quantum mechanics presents two seemingly distinct theoretical pictures: the unitary evolution of state vectors in the Schrödinger picture, and the summation over all possible paths in Feynman's path integral formulation. This article systematically argues that the equivalence between these two pictures is a rigorous mathematical fact rather than a choice between competing physical mechanisms. We analyze the meaning of this equivalence at three levels—physical, mathematical, and philosophical—and explore its implications for the generation of entanglement, many-body systems, and quantum field theory. The complete mathematical proof of the equivalence, from unitary evolution to the path integral, is provided in the appendix, along with a detailed construction of quantum entanglement from the path integral framework. Building on this analysis, we distill a broader philosophical thesis: every physical theory, no matter how successful, is a representation of the natural world rather than the world itself. Physical theories are like maps to a territory—they can be extraordinarily precise, yet they are never the territory. The Schrödinger equation, the path integral, and Heisenberg's matrix mechanics are three different maps of the same "quantum territory." Asking whether the wave function "really exists" or whether a particle "really travels along all paths" commits a category mistake—conflating mathematical entities internal to a theory with ontological reality beyond it. The history of physics—from Newtonian gravity to general relativity, from thermodynamics to statistical mechanics, from field-based to action-at-a-distance formulations of electrodynamics—repeatedly teaches this lesson: ontological claims are relative to a given theoretical framework and carry no absolute significance beyond it. The principle of "representational freedom" is thus proposed: when multiple mathematically equivalent formulations of a physical theory yield strictly identical predictions for all observables, no experiment can adjudicate among them ontologically. Choosing one formulation as a calculational tool is a pragmatic decision, not an ontological verdict. The ultimate conclusion is that the path integral is simply the integral representation of the time-evolution operator in the position basis; neither picture enjoys ontological primacy. To claim that "the path sum really happens" or that "the state vector really evolves" is to cross the same boundary. True scientific wisdom lies in knowing where the boundary between representation and reality lies—and then, with ontological humility, continuing to explore the deeper structures that lie beyond it.