Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1908.02887

Quantum state change in light of changes in valuational entropies

Arkady Bolotin

Published Aug 8, 2019• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the statement "The vector is an element of the closed linear subspace of the Hilbert space H", the predicate "... is an element of ..." might be not only determined, that is, either true or false (depending on whether set membership is applicable or inapplicable to the specified vector and subspace) but also undetermined, that is, neither true nor false. To evaluate the vagueness of set membership among arbitrary vectors and closed linear subspaces of H, the notion of the entropy of the predicate "... is an element of ..." is introduced in the present paper. Since each closed linear subspace in H uniquely represents the atomic proposition P about a quantum system, the entropy of this predicate can also be considered as the valuational entropy that measures the uncertainty about the assignment of truth values to the proposition P. As it is demonstrated in the paper, in the Hilbert space H of the dimension greater than or equal to 2, there always exists a nonempty set S of the closed linear subspaces in H, such that the entropy of the predicate "... is an element of ..." on the given vector of H and all the subspaces of S cannot be zero. This implies the existence of two different processes of the pure quantum state change: the process which yields no changes in the valuational entropies of the propositions (corresponding to the deterministic and reversible evolution) and the process which brings forth changes in the valuational entropies (corresponding to the gain or loss of information in a quantum measurement).

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1908.02887

Related papers

Probabilities in the logic of quantum propositions

Arkady Bolotin

In quantum logic, i.e., within the structure of the Hilbert lattice imposed on all closed linear subspaces of a Hilbert space, the assignment of truth values to quantum propositions (i.e., experimentally verifiable propositions relating to a quantum system) is unambiguously determined by the state of the system. So, if only pure states of the system are considered, can a probability measure mapping the probability space for truth values to the unit interval be assigned to quantum propositions? In other words, is a probability concept contingent or emergent in the logic of quantum propositions? Until this question is answered, the cause of probabilities in quantum theory cannot be completely understood. In the present paper it is shown that the interaction of the quantum system with its environment causes the irreducible randomness in the relation between quantum propositions and truth values.

arXiv:1812.01937•Dec 5, 2018•0 citations

A New Logical Measure for Quantum Information

David Ellerman

Abstract Starting at the logical level of the logic of partitions, dual to the usual Boolean logic of subsets, the notion of logical entropy, i.e., information as distinctions, is developed as the quantification of the distinctions of partitions—just as probability theory starts with the quantification of elements of subsets. Logical entropy is compared and contrasted with the usual notion of Shannon entropy. Then a semi-algorithmic procedure (from the mathematical folklore) is used to translate the notion of logical entropy at the set level to the corresponding notion of quantum logical entropy at the (Hilbert) vector space level. Examples and some important propositions relate quantum logical entropy to projective measurement and to the Hilbert-Schmidt distance. Overall, the approach demonstrates the logical basis and naturality of this notion of entropy for quantum mechanics.

Quantum Information and Computation•Feb 25, 2025•2 citations

Classical and quantum relative entropy

Patrícia Szokol

The concept of entropy rst arose in the study of thermodynamics and statistical me- chanics. In information theory the so-called Shannon entropy plays a signi cant role, which measures how much information we gain, on average, when we learn the value of a random variable. An alternative interpretation is that the entropy of the random variable quanti es the amount of uncertainty about the random variable before we learn its value. The concept was introduced by Claude E. Shannon in his 1948 paper "A Mathematical Theory of Communication". In the rst part of the present work we consider this fundamental measure of information and show some of its properties, such as non-negativity. The relative entropy or the Kullback-Leibler divergence is a very useful measure of the distance between two prob- ability distributions. After introducing its de nition and other notions (joint entropy, conditional entropy or mutual information) we can prove additional assertions about the Shannon entropy and present statements about the relations between the above men- tioned quantities. In quantum information theory, there is a quantity, namely von Neumann entropy, which corresponds to Shannon entropy and originates from it. In the section Von Neu- mann entropy we will introduce this quantity which is a continuous functional on the states, or on their mathematical representatives, the density operators, and it ful ls in- equalities such as subadditivity and strong subaddititvity. Just as with the Shannon entropy, it is extremely useful to de ne a quantum version of the relative entropy, which is one of the most important numerical quantities appearing in quantum information theory. It is used as a measure of distinguishability between quantum states. Among others its properties are jointly convexity, monotonicity which are speci cally convenient. Transformations on structures which preserve operations, quantities or relations among elements appear in many areas of mathematics. These are the so-called preservers which show up also in physics and even in chemistry where they are usually called symmetries. Therefore, the study of preserver transformations is an important area of research. The third section of this work is based on a paper, in which Lajos Molnár described the structure every bijective map on the space of all density operators on a given Hilbert space, which preserves the relative entropy. This result is closely related to Wigner's famous theorem on the form of quantum mechanical symmetry transformations. The above theorem of Molnár can be extended into two directions. On the one hand, the result holds also in the case when the transformation under consideration acts on the space of all positive semide nite operators not only on density operators (i.e., we omit the condition of unit trace). On the other hand the statement remains valid even if we omit the strongly restrictive condition that the transformation is bijective. The second result is a joint work with Prof. Lajos Molnár which appeared in the journal Linear Algebra and Its Applications.

•May 6, 2010•0 citations

Algebraic assignments of truth values to experimental quantum propositions

Arkady Bolotin

Of what are experimental quantum propositions primary bearers? As it is widely accepted in the modern literature, rather than being bearers of truth and falsity, these entities are bearers of probability values. Consequently, their truth values can be regarded as no more than degenerate probabilities (i.e., ones that have only the values 0 and 1). The mathematical motivation for precedence of probabilistic semantics over propositional semantic for the logic of experimental quantum propositions is Gleason's theorem. It proves that the theory of probability measures on closed linear subspaces of a Hilbert space (which represent experimental quantum propositions) does not admit any probability measure having only the values 0 and 1. -- By contrast, in the present paper, it is proclaimed that experimental propositions about quantum systems are primary bearers of truth values. As this paper demonstrates, algebraic properties of separable Hilbert spaces of finite dimension equal or greater than 2 do not allow in valuations (that is, truth assignments) which are dispersion-free, i.e., total functions from the set of atomic propositions to the set of two objects, true and false. Providing a probability function can be interpreted as a measure of the (un)certainty in the assignment of truth values, the fact that valuations cannot be dispersion-free gives rise to probabilistic semantics for the logic of experimental quantum propositions.

arXiv:1910.11078•Oct 24, 2019•0 citations

The Reduction of the State Vector and Limitations on Measurement in the Quantum Mechanics of Closed Systems

James B. Hartle

Measurement is a fundamental notion in the usual approximate quantum mechanics of measured subsystems. Probabilities are predicted for the outcomes of measurements. State vectors evolve unitarily in between measurements and by reduction of the state vector at measurements. Probabilities are computed by summing the squares of amplitudes over alternatives which could have been measured but weren't. Measurements are limited by uncertainty principles and by other restrictions arising from the principles of quantum mechanics. This essay examines the extent to which those features of the quantum mechanics of measured subsystems that are explicitly tied to measurement situations are incorporated or modified in the more general quantum mechanics of closed systems in which measurement is not a fundamental notion. There, probabilities are predicted for decohering sets of alternative time histories of the closed system, whether or not they represent a measurement situation. Reduction of the state vector is a necessary part of the description of such histories. Uncertainty principles limit the possible alternatives at one time from which histories may be constructed. Models of measurement situations are exhibited within the quantum mechanics of the closed system containing both measured subsystem and measuring apparatus. Limitations are derived on the existence of records for the outcomes of measurements when the initial density matrix of the closed system is highly impure. (Festschrift for Dieter Brill).

arXiv:gr-qc/9301011•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 16, 1956•22 citations

Resolution of the Quantum Measurement Problem Based on Entropy

John Joseph Winders

The measurement problem in quantum mechanics can be characterized as explaining the question of definite outcomes, where a measurement of a superposed quantum state only gives a single definite outcome. According to quantum mechanics, the wave function, ψ, defines the state of the system, while the Schrödinger equation is a linear superposition of states that evolves deterministically. When a measurement is made, the outcome always uncovers the physical system as being in a definite state, and the future evolution of the wave function is amended based on the state that was measured. This change is often referred to as the “collapse” of the wave function. The problem concerns the question of what and how the measurement affected the system and why this changed the wave function. This paper addresses the measurement problem by separating it into five separate questions that are resolved through linking measurements to an entropy transfer from the superposed state to the environment. The underlying premise is the wave function is descriptive and not prescriptive, and entropy—the metric of quantum uncertainty and uncertainty in general—is the fundamental property rather than the wave function.

•May 10, 2026•0 citations
In the statement "The vector is an element of the closed linear subspace of the Hilbert space H", the predicate "... is an element of ..." might be not only determined, that is, either true or false (depending on whether set membership is applicable or inapplicable to the specified vector and subspace) but also undetermined, that is, neither true nor false. To evaluate the vagueness of set membership among arbitrary vectors and closed linear subspaces of H, the notion of the entropy of the predicate "... is an element of ..." is introduced in the present paper. Since each closed linear subspace in H uniquely represents the atomic proposition P about a quantum system, the entropy of this predicate can also be considered as the valuational entropy that measures the uncertainty about the assignment of truth values to the proposition P. As it is demonstrated in the paper, in the Hilbert space H of the dimension greater than or equal to 2, there always exists a nonempty set S of the closed linear subspaces in H, such that the entropy of the predicate "... is an element of ..." on the given vector of H and all the subspaces of S cannot be zero. This implies the existence of two different processes of the pure quantum state change: the process which yields no changes in the valuational entropies of the propositions (corresponding to the deterministic and reversible evolution) and the process which brings forth changes in the valuational entropies (corresponding to the gain or loss of information in a quantum measurement).
In quantum logic, i.e., within the structure of the Hilbert lattice imposed on all closed linear subspaces of a Hilbert space, the assignment of truth values to quantum propositions (i.e., experimentally verifiable propositions relating to a quantum system) is unambiguously determined by the state of the system. So, if only pure states of the system are considered, can a probability measure mapping the probability space for truth values to the unit interval be assigned to quantum propositions? In other words, is a probability concept contingent or emergent in the logic of quantum propositions? Until this question is answered, the cause of probabilities in quantum theory cannot be completely understood. In the present paper it is shown that the interaction of the quantum system with its environment causes the irreducible randomness in the relation between quantum propositions and truth values.
Abstract Starting at the logical level of the logic of partitions, dual to the usual Boolean logic of subsets, the notion of logical entropy, i.e., information as distinctions, is developed as the quantification of the distinctions of partitions—just as probability theory starts with the quantification of elements of subsets. Logical entropy is compared and contrasted with the usual notion of Shannon entropy. Then a semi-algorithmic procedure (from the mathematical folklore) is used to translate the notion of logical entropy at the set level to the corresponding notion of quantum logical entropy at the (Hilbert) vector space level. Examples and some important propositions relate quantum logical entropy to projective measurement and to the Hilbert-Schmidt distance. Overall, the approach demonstrates the logical basis and naturality of this notion of entropy for quantum mechanics.
The concept of entropy rst arose in the study of thermodynamics and statistical me- chanics. In information theory the so-called Shannon entropy plays a signi cant role, which measures how much information we gain, on average, when we learn the value of a random variable. An alternative interpretation is that the entropy of the random variable quanti es the amount of uncertainty about the random variable before we learn its value. The concept was introduced by Claude E. Shannon in his 1948 paper "A Mathematical Theory of Communication". In the rst part of the present work we consider this fundamental measure of information and show some of its properties, such as non-negativity. The relative entropy or the Kullback-Leibler divergence is a very useful measure of the distance between two prob- ability distributions. After introducing its de nition and other notions (joint entropy, conditional entropy or mutual information) we can prove additional assertions about the Shannon entropy and present statements about the relations between the above men- tioned quantities. In quantum information theory, there is a quantity, namely von Neumann entropy, which corresponds to Shannon entropy and originates from it. In the section Von Neu- mann entropy we will introduce this quantity which is a continuous functional on the states, or on their mathematical representatives, the density operators, and it ful ls in- equalities such as subadditivity and strong subaddititvity. Just as with the Shannon entropy, it is extremely useful to de ne a quantum version of the relative entropy, which is one of the most important numerical quantities appearing in quantum information theory. It is used as a measure of distinguishability between quantum states. Among others its properties are jointly convexity, monotonicity which are speci cally convenient. Transformations on structures which preserve operations, quantities or relations among elements appear in many areas of mathematics. These are the so-called preservers which show up also in physics and even in chemistry where they are usually called symmetries. Therefore, the study of preserver transformations is an important area of research. The third section of this work is based on a paper, in which Lajos Molnár described the structure every bijective map on the space of all density operators on a given Hilbert space, which preserves the relative entropy. This result is closely related to Wigner's famous theorem on the form of quantum mechanical symmetry transformations. The above theorem of Molnár can be extended into two directions. On the one hand, the result holds also in the case when the transformation under consideration acts on the space of all positive semide nite operators not only on density operators (i.e., we omit the condition of unit trace). On the other hand the statement remains valid even if we omit the strongly restrictive condition that the transformation is bijective. The second result is a joint work with Prof. Lajos Molnár which appeared in the journal Linear Algebra and Its Applications.
Of what are experimental quantum propositions primary bearers? As it is widely accepted in the modern literature, rather than being bearers of truth and falsity, these entities are bearers of probability values. Consequently, their truth values can be regarded as no more than degenerate probabilities (i.e., ones that have only the values 0 and 1). The mathematical motivation for precedence of probabilistic semantics over propositional semantic for the logic of experimental quantum propositions is Gleason's theorem. It proves that the theory of probability measures on closed linear subspaces of a Hilbert space (which represent experimental quantum propositions) does not admit any probability measure having only the values 0 and 1. -- By contrast, in the present paper, it is proclaimed that experimental propositions about quantum systems are primary bearers of truth values. As this paper demonstrates, algebraic properties of separable Hilbert spaces of finite dimension equal or greater than 2 do not allow in valuations (that is, truth assignments) which are dispersion-free, i.e., total functions from the set of atomic propositions to the set of two objects, true and false. Providing a probability function can be interpreted as a measure of the (un)certainty in the assignment of truth values, the fact that valuations cannot be dispersion-free gives rise to probabilistic semantics for the logic of experimental quantum propositions.
Measurement is a fundamental notion in the usual approximate quantum mechanics of measured subsystems. Probabilities are predicted for the outcomes of measurements. State vectors evolve unitarily in between measurements and by reduction of the state vector at measurements. Probabilities are computed by summing the squares of amplitudes over alternatives which could have been measured but weren't. Measurements are limited by uncertainty principles and by other restrictions arising from the principles of quantum mechanics. This essay examines the extent to which those features of the quantum mechanics of measured subsystems that are explicitly tied to measurement situations are incorporated or modified in the more general quantum mechanics of closed systems in which measurement is not a fundamental notion. There, probabilities are predicted for decohering sets of alternative time histories of the closed system, whether or not they represent a measurement situation. Reduction of the state vector is a necessary part of the description of such histories. Uncertainty principles limit the possible alternatives at one time from which histories may be constructed. Models of measurement situations are exhibited within the quantum mechanics of the closed system containing both measured subsystem and measuring apparatus. Limitations are derived on the existence of records for the outcomes of measurements when the initial density matrix of the closed system is highly impure. (Festschrift for Dieter Brill).
The measurement problem in quantum mechanics can be characterized as explaining the question of definite outcomes, where a measurement of a superposed quantum state only gives a single definite outcome. According to quantum mechanics, the wave function, ψ, defines the state of the system, while the Schrödinger equation is a linear superposition of states that evolves deterministically. When a measurement is made, the outcome always uncovers the physical system as being in a definite state, and the future evolution of the wave function is amended based on the state that was measured. This change is often referred to as the “collapse” of the wave function. The problem concerns the question of what and how the measurement affected the system and why this changed the wave function. This paper addresses the measurement problem by separating it into five separate questions that are resolved through linking measurements to an entropy transfer from the superposed state to the environment. The underlying premise is the wave function is descriptive and not prescriptive, and entropy—the metric of quantum uncertainty and uncertainty in general—is the fundamental property rather than the wave function.