Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1905.08109 · The Journal of Chemical Physics

Exact and approximate symmetry projectors for the electronic structure problem on a quantum computer

Tzu-Ching Yen, Robert A. Lang, Artur F. Izmaylov

Published Oct 24, 2019• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Solving the electronic structure problem on a universal-gate quantum computer within the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) methodology requires constraining the search procedure to a subspace defined by relevant physical symmetries. Ignoring symmetries results in convergence to the lowest eigenstate of the Fock space for the second quantized electronic Hamiltonian. Moreover, this eigenstate can be symmetry broken due to limitations of the wavefunction ansatz. To address this VQE problem, we introduce and assess methods of exact and approximate projectors to irreducible eigensubspaces of available physical symmetries. Feasibility of symmetry projectors in the VQE framework is discussed, and their efficiency is compared with symmetry constraint optimization procedures. Generally, projectors introduce a higher number of terms for VQE measurement compared to the constraint approach. On the other hand, the projection formalism improves accuracy of the variational wavefunction ansatz without introducing additional unitary transformations, which is beneficial for reducing depths of quantum circuits.

DOI
10.1063/1.5110682

Related papers

Constrained Variational Quantum Eigensolver: Quantum Computer Search Engine in the Fock Space

Ilya G. Ryabinkin, Scott N. Genin, Artur F. Izmaylov

Variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is an efficient computational method promising chemical accuracy in electronic structure calculations on a universal-gate quantum computer. However, such a simple task as computing the electronic energy of a hydrogen molecular cation, H 2 +, is not possible for a general VQE protocol because the calculation will invariably collapse to a lower energy of the corresponding neutral form, H 2 . The origin of the problem is that VQE effectively performs an unconstrained energy optimization in the Fock space of the original electronic problem. We show how this can be avoided by introducing necessary constraints directing VQE toward the electronic state of interest. The proposed constrained VQE can find an electronic state with a certain number of electrons, a certain spin, or any other property. Moreover, the new algorithm naturally removes unphysical kinks in potential energy surfaces (PESs), which frequently appeared in the regular VQE and required significant additional quantum resources for their removal. We demonstrate the performance of the constrained VQE by simulating PESs of various states of H 2 and H 2 O on Rigetti Computing Inc.’s 19Q-Acorn quantum processor.

arXiv:1806.00461•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Dec 4, 2018•145 citations

Recent Developments and Perspectives in Variational Quantum Eigensolvers for Molecular Electronic Structure: Methods, Tradeoffs, and Benchmarking

Taylor Harville, Rishu Khurana, Vitor F. Grizzi +1 more

The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware to estimate eigenvalues of many-body Hamiltonians. Unlike fully quantum approaches such as quantum phase estimation (QPE), VQE trades deep coherent circuits for repeated state preparation, measurement, and classical optimization, making it more compatible with limited qubit counts and finite coherence times. Recent developments have focused on reducing quantum resource requirements while retaining chemically meaningful wavefunction structure. In this paper, we examine recent progress in VQE methods for molecular electronic structure with an emphasis on three themes: (i) strategies for circuit and ansatz complexity reduction, including adaptive and selectively screened approaches, (ii) chemically motivated workflows that combine VQE with orbital optimization, fragmentation, and localized active-space ideas to better address strong correlation, and (iii) extensions of VQE to excited-state calculations. Throughout, we emphasize the tradeoffs among parameter count, gate depth, symmetry preservation, measurement overhead, and classical preprocessing, and discuss where these approaches may become most useful for chemically challenging active spaces. We also highlight benchmarking considerations for assessing both accuracy and resource requirements, and conclude with a perspective on regimes in which VQE may offer the greatest long-term value, particularly multireference active spaces and low-lying excited-state manifolds.

quant-pharXiv:2602.11384•Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics•Feb 13, 2026•5 citations

On Construction of Projection Operators

Artur F. Izmaylov

The problem of construction of projection operators on eigensubspaces of symmetry operators is considered. This problem arises in many approximate methods for solving time-independent and time-dependent quantum problems, and its solution ensures proper physical symmetries in development of approximate methods. The projector form is sought as a function of symmetry operators and their eigenvalues characterizing the eigensubspace of interest. This form is obtained in two steps: (1) identification of algebraic structures within a set of symmetry operators (e.g., groups and Lie algebras) and (2) construction of the projection operators for individual symmetry operators. The first step is crucial for efficient projection operator construction because it allows for use of information on irreducible representations of the present algebraic structure. The discussed approaches have potential to stimulate further developments of variational approaches for electronic structure of strongly correlated systems and in quantum computing.

arXiv:1902.07865•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Mar 27, 2019•12 citations

Algebraic Tools for Quantum Simulations of Electronic Structure

Smik Patel

Accurately predicting the properties of molecules and materials from first principles requires solving the electronic structure problem. However, the computational cost of solving the electronic structure problem scales prohibitively in the number of atoms, and the usual approximate methods designed to reduce the overhead are often inaccurate for strongly correlated systems. For this reason, quantum algorithms have been developed as a promising alternative. In this work, we develop algebraic tools to improve the efficiency of three quantum algorithms for the electronic structure problem, addressing key bottlenecks for both near-term and fault-tolerant quantum computers. The first is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE), which suffers from a large measurement overhead needed to estimate the Hamiltonian expectation value. To this end, we introduce a general class of measurable fragments of the electronic Hamiltonian, which enable partitioning schemes that significantly reduce the sampling cost for energy estimation. The second are quantum subspace methods (QSMs). We introduce a new QSM, the quantum seniority-based subspace expansion algorithm, which is a scalable alternative to VQE that alleviates VQE's state preparation, measurement, and optimization challenges while reducing qubit requirements. The third is quantum phase estimation (QPE), which requires an encoding of the electronic Hamiltonian directly on the quantum computer, the cost of which scales indirectly with the Hamiltonian spectral range. To address this, we develop linear programming approaches to implement the Block Invariant Symmetry Shift protocol, a method which reduces the spectral range of the Hamiltonian, improving its block-encoding cost for QPE. Collectively, these methods demonstrate that one can exploit the Hamiltonian's algebraic structure to mitigate computational costs, accelerating the path toward practical quantum advantage for electronic structure.

•Mar 1, 2026•0 citations

Determination of Molecular Symmetry Adapted Eigenroots in the Variational Quantum Eigensolver Framework

Dibyendu Mondal, Rahul Maitra

ABSTRACT Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) provides a lucrative platform to determine molecular energetics in near‐term quantum devices. While the VQE is traditionally tailored to determine the ground state wavefunction with the underlying Rayleigh‐Ritz principle, for molecules characterized by a given point group symmetry, we propose to unify the VQE framework to treat the lowest energy states of any irreducible representation and spin‐multiplicity. The method relies on the construction of a symmetry adapted multi determinantal reference where the constituent determinants are entangled through appropriate Clebsch‐Gordan coefficients to ensure the desired spin‐multiplicity. The unitary operator, defined in terms of totally symmetric spin‐free generators, safeguards the method against variational collapse to symmetry broken solutions. We also propose an energy sorting based adaptive ansatz construction algorithm starting from a pool of totally symmetric spin‐free unitary generators to come up with dynamically optimal ansatz. The proposed methodology allows us to build up further search algorithms within a reduced dimensional symmetry‐adapted sub‐Hilbert‐space. With a highly compact circuit structure, it is expected to be realized in the near‐term quantum devices to study emerging chemical phenomena and exploration of novel chemical space.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Mar 28, 2025•5 citations

Improving the Accuracy of Variational Quantum Eigensolvers with Fewer Qubits Using Orbital Optimization

Joel Bierman, Yingzhou Li, Jianfeng Lu

Near-term quantum computers will be limited in the number of qubits on which they can process information as well as the depth of the circuits that they can coherently carry out. To date, experimental demonstrations of algorithms such as the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) have been limited to small molecules using minimal basis sets for this reason. In this work we propose incorporating an orbital optimization scheme into quantum eigensolvers wherein a parametrized partial unitary transformation is applied to the basis functions set in order to reduce the number of qubits required for a given problem. The optimal transformation is found by minimizing the ground state energy with respect to this partial unitary matrix. Through numerical simulations of small molecules up to 16 spin orbitals, we demonstrate that this method has the ability to greatly extend the capabilities of near-term quantum computers with regard to the electronic structure problem. We find that VQE paired with orbital optimization consistently achieves lower ground state energies than traditional VQE when using the same number of qubits and even frequently achieves lower ground state energies than VQE methods using more qubits.

arXiv:2208.14431•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jan 25, 2023•29 citations
Solving the electronic structure problem on a universal-gate quantum computer within the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) methodology requires constraining the search procedure to a subspace defined by relevant physical symmetries. Ignoring symmetries results in convergence to the lowest eigenstate of the Fock space for the second quantized electronic Hamiltonian. Moreover, this eigenstate can be symmetry broken due to limitations of the wavefunction ansatz. To address this VQE problem, we introduce and assess methods of exact and approximate projectors to irreducible eigensubspaces of available physical symmetries. Feasibility of symmetry projectors in the VQE framework is discussed, and their efficiency is compared with symmetry constraint optimization procedures. Generally, projectors introduce a higher number of terms for VQE measurement compared to the constraint approach. On the other hand, the projection formalism improves accuracy of the variational wavefunction ansatz without introducing additional unitary transformations, which is beneficial for reducing depths of quantum circuits.
Variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is an efficient computational method promising chemical accuracy in electronic structure calculations on a universal-gate quantum computer. However, such a simple task as computing the electronic energy of a hydrogen molecular cation, H 2 +, is not possible for a general VQE protocol because the calculation will invariably collapse to a lower energy of the corresponding neutral form, H 2 . The origin of the problem is that VQE effectively performs an unconstrained energy optimization in the Fock space of the original electronic problem. We show how this can be avoided by introducing necessary constraints directing VQE toward the electronic state of interest. The proposed constrained VQE can find an electronic state with a certain number of electrons, a certain spin, or any other property. Moreover, the new algorithm naturally removes unphysical kinks in potential energy surfaces (PESs), which frequently appeared in the regular VQE and required significant additional quantum resources for their removal. We demonstrate the performance of the constrained VQE by simulating PESs of various states of H 2 and H 2 O on Rigetti Computing Inc.’s 19Q-Acorn quantum processor.
The variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) is a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm designed for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) hardware to estimate eigenvalues of many-body Hamiltonians. Unlike fully quantum approaches such as quantum phase estimation (QPE), VQE trades deep coherent circuits for repeated state preparation, measurement, and classical optimization, making it more compatible with limited qubit counts and finite coherence times. Recent developments have focused on reducing quantum resource requirements while retaining chemically meaningful wavefunction structure. In this paper, we examine recent progress in VQE methods for molecular electronic structure with an emphasis on three themes: (i) strategies for circuit and ansatz complexity reduction, including adaptive and selectively screened approaches, (ii) chemically motivated workflows that combine VQE with orbital optimization, fragmentation, and localized active-space ideas to better address strong correlation, and (iii) extensions of VQE to excited-state calculations. Throughout, we emphasize the tradeoffs among parameter count, gate depth, symmetry preservation, measurement overhead, and classical preprocessing, and discuss where these approaches may become most useful for chemically challenging active spaces. We also highlight benchmarking considerations for assessing both accuracy and resource requirements, and conclude with a perspective on regimes in which VQE may offer the greatest long-term value, particularly multireference active spaces and low-lying excited-state manifolds.
The problem of construction of projection operators on eigensubspaces of symmetry operators is considered. This problem arises in many approximate methods for solving time-independent and time-dependent quantum problems, and its solution ensures proper physical symmetries in development of approximate methods. The projector form is sought as a function of symmetry operators and their eigenvalues characterizing the eigensubspace of interest. This form is obtained in two steps: (1) identification of algebraic structures within a set of symmetry operators (e.g., groups and Lie algebras) and (2) construction of the projection operators for individual symmetry operators. The first step is crucial for efficient projection operator construction because it allows for use of information on irreducible representations of the present algebraic structure. The discussed approaches have potential to stimulate further developments of variational approaches for electronic structure of strongly correlated systems and in quantum computing.
Accurately predicting the properties of molecules and materials from first principles requires solving the electronic structure problem. However, the computational cost of solving the electronic structure problem scales prohibitively in the number of atoms, and the usual approximate methods designed to reduce the overhead are often inaccurate for strongly correlated systems. For this reason, quantum algorithms have been developed as a promising alternative. In this work, we develop algebraic tools to improve the efficiency of three quantum algorithms for the electronic structure problem, addressing key bottlenecks for both near-term and fault-tolerant quantum computers. The first is the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE), which suffers from a large measurement overhead needed to estimate the Hamiltonian expectation value. To this end, we introduce a general class of measurable fragments of the electronic Hamiltonian, which enable partitioning schemes that significantly reduce the sampling cost for energy estimation. The second are quantum subspace methods (QSMs). We introduce a new QSM, the quantum seniority-based subspace expansion algorithm, which is a scalable alternative to VQE that alleviates VQE's state preparation, measurement, and optimization challenges while reducing qubit requirements. The third is quantum phase estimation (QPE), which requires an encoding of the electronic Hamiltonian directly on the quantum computer, the cost of which scales indirectly with the Hamiltonian spectral range. To address this, we develop linear programming approaches to implement the Block Invariant Symmetry Shift protocol, a method which reduces the spectral range of the Hamiltonian, improving its block-encoding cost for QPE. Collectively, these methods demonstrate that one can exploit the Hamiltonian's algebraic structure to mitigate computational costs, accelerating the path toward practical quantum advantage for electronic structure.
ABSTRACT Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) provides a lucrative platform to determine molecular energetics in near‐term quantum devices. While the VQE is traditionally tailored to determine the ground state wavefunction with the underlying Rayleigh‐Ritz principle, for molecules characterized by a given point group symmetry, we propose to unify the VQE framework to treat the lowest energy states of any irreducible representation and spin‐multiplicity. The method relies on the construction of a symmetry adapted multi determinantal reference where the constituent determinants are entangled through appropriate Clebsch‐Gordan coefficients to ensure the desired spin‐multiplicity. The unitary operator, defined in terms of totally symmetric spin‐free generators, safeguards the method against variational collapse to symmetry broken solutions. We also propose an energy sorting based adaptive ansatz construction algorithm starting from a pool of totally symmetric spin‐free unitary generators to come up with dynamically optimal ansatz. The proposed methodology allows us to build up further search algorithms within a reduced dimensional symmetry‐adapted sub‐Hilbert‐space. With a highly compact circuit structure, it is expected to be realized in the near‐term quantum devices to study emerging chemical phenomena and exploration of novel chemical space.
Near-term quantum computers will be limited in the number of qubits on which they can process information as well as the depth of the circuits that they can coherently carry out. To date, experimental demonstrations of algorithms such as the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) have been limited to small molecules using minimal basis sets for this reason. In this work we propose incorporating an orbital optimization scheme into quantum eigensolvers wherein a parametrized partial unitary transformation is applied to the basis functions set in order to reduce the number of qubits required for a given problem. The optimal transformation is found by minimizing the ground state energy with respect to this partial unitary matrix. Through numerical simulations of small molecules up to 16 spin orbitals, we demonstrate that this method has the ability to greatly extend the capabilities of near-term quantum computers with regard to the electronic structure problem. We find that VQE paired with orbital optimization consistently achieves lower ground state energies than traditional VQE when using the same number of qubits and even frequently achieves lower ground state energies than VQE methods using more qubits.