Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1902.07865 · The Journal of Physical Chemistry A

On Construction of Projection Operators

Artur F. Izmaylov

Published Mar 27, 2019• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The problem of construction of projection operators on eigensubspaces of symmetry operators is considered. This problem arises in many approximate methods for solving time-independent and time-dependent quantum problems, and its solution ensures proper physical symmetries in development of approximate methods. The projector form is sought as a function of symmetry operators and their eigenvalues characterizing the eigensubspace of interest. This form is obtained in two steps: (1) identification of algebraic structures within a set of symmetry operators (e.g., groups and Lie algebras) and (2) construction of the projection operators for individual symmetry operators. The first step is crucial for efficient projection operator construction because it allows for use of information on irreducible representations of the present algebraic structure. The discussed approaches have potential to stimulate further developments of variational approaches for electronic structure of strongly correlated systems and in quantum computing.

DOI
10.1021/acs.jpca.9b01103

Related papers

Exact and approximate symmetry projectors for the electronic structure problem on a quantum computer

Tzu-Ching Yen, Robert A. Lang, Artur F. Izmaylov

Solving the electronic structure problem on a universal-gate quantum computer within the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) methodology requires constraining the search procedure to a subspace defined by relevant physical symmetries. Ignoring symmetries results in convergence to the lowest eigenstate of the Fock space for the second quantized electronic Hamiltonian. Moreover, this eigenstate can be symmetry broken due to limitations of the wavefunction ansatz. To address this VQE problem, we introduce and assess methods of exact and approximate projectors to irreducible eigensubspaces of available physical symmetries. Feasibility of symmetry projectors in the VQE framework is discussed, and their efficiency is compared with symmetry constraint optimization procedures. Generally, projectors introduce a higher number of terms for VQE measurement compared to the constraint approach. On the other hand, the projection formalism improves accuracy of the variational wavefunction ansatz without introducing additional unitary transformations, which is beneficial for reducing depths of quantum circuits.

arXiv:1905.08109•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 24, 2019•44 citations

Projection operator techniques in physics

Wesley E. Brittin, A.Y. Sakakura

A systematic account of projection operators (projectors) and orthogonalization techniques together with applications to selected areas of physics is presented. This unified approach is shown to have advantages over other approaches in that the mathematical statements are more precise. The mathematical level, however, is aimed at the practicing physicist and lies between rigorous mathematics and current use in physics. Further, the techniques presented have practical applications as is demonstrated by examples in the quantum theory of measurement, in the relationship between second quantization and configuration space techniques, and in an account of generalized Wannier and Bloch functions. Attention is paid to the problem of construction of orthogonal projection operators (orthogonal projectors). The construction of orthogonal projectors even in approximate form would allow the solution of many practical problems ranging from the eigenvalue spectrum problem to the construction of states for many-body systems. One can almost say that any problem in quantum mechanics can be formulated as a problem involving the construction of projectors.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1984•6 citations

Theory of the Matchgate Commutant

Piotr Sierant, Xhek Turkeshi, Poetri Sonya Tarabunga

In quantum information theory and statistical physics, symmetries of multiple copies, or replicas, of a system play a pivotal role. For unitary ensembles, these symmetries are encoded in the replicated commutant: the algebra of operators commuting with the ensemble across $k$ replicas. Determining the commutant is straightforward for the full unitary group, but remains a major obstacle for structured, computationally relevant circuit families. We solve this problem for matchgate circuits, which prepare fermionic Gaussian states on $n$ qubits. Using a Majorana fermion representation, we show that operators coupling different system copies generate the orthogonal Lie algebra $\mathfrak{so}(k)$, endowing the space of invariants with rich and tractable structure. This underlying symmetry decomposes the matchgate commutant into irreducible sectors, which we completely resolve via a Gelfand--Tsetlin construction. We provide an explicit orthonormal basis of the matchgate commutant for all $k$ and $n$, together with a formula for its dimension that grows polynomially in $n$. Furthermore, we characterize the commutant of the Clifford--matchgate subgroup, showing that restricting to signed permutations of Majorana modes yields a commutant that qualitatively diverges from the matchgate case for $k \geq 4$ replicas. Ultimately, our orthonormal basis turns algebraic classification into a working toolbox. Using it, we derive closed-form expressions for matchgate twirling channels and a fermionic analogue of Weingarten calculus, the projector encoding all moments of the Gaussian state orbit, state and unitary frame potentials, the average nonstabilizerness of fermionic Gaussian states, a systematic hierarchy of non-Gaussianity measures, and a fermionic de Finetti theorem.

quant-pharXiv:2603.12392•Mar 16, 2026•34 citations

Projection Operators in Quantum-Mechanical Perturbation Theory

W. R. Salzman, M. E. Baur

The construction of operator functionals of the full Hamiltonian of a quantum-mechanical system which act as projection operators for a specified exact eigenstate is studied. In general these operator functionals are not equivalent to the formal operator |ψ〉〈ψ|, where |ψ〉 is the state of interest, and are not always idempotent. A formal method by which standard perturbation theoretic expansions for the exact ground-state vector and ground-state energy of the system can be recovered by expansion of a certain operator functional of this type is presented. Related work is briefly discussed.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•May 1, 1965•3 citations

Model Wavefunction Forms to Describe Strong Correlation in Quantum Chemistry

Paul A. Johnson

Standard approaches to approximating solutions to the Schroedinger equation rely upon the assumption that there is a single dominant electronic configuration with a small number of low-lying excited states. As such, they are referred to as single reference approaches and are accurate only when the band gap is small in comparison with the inter-electronic repulsion of the valence electrons. Systems for which this is the case are weakly-correlated. If the inter-electronic repulsion larger than the band gap, then a single electronic reference is not an appropriate ansatz for the physical wavefunction. As the strength of the interaction is increased many Slater determinants become near-degenerate, each providing non-negligible contributions. Such systems are strongly-correlated. The goal of the thesis was to employ wavefunctions which are: non-trivial, tractable, size-consistent and extensive, and not given in an active space. We have outlined approaches based on wavefunction forms more suited to describe strong correlation. Built on the Lie algebra su(2), our first trial wavefunction was the Bethe ansatz solution to the reduced BCS Hamiltonian derived by Richardson. This wavefunction is expressed as a product of quasi-particles each parametrized in terms of quasi-momenta. Consistency among the quasi-momenta is ensured by a set of non-linear equations to be solved numerically. This approach is feasible in both variational and projected flavours. We next considered a wavefunction of the same form without requiring it to be an eigenvector of the reduced BCS Hamiltonian. A variational approach in this case is only feasible provided there are two equivalent descriptions in terms of particles and holes. In any case, a bivariational principle and a projected approach are both feasible. Also based on su(2), there is AP1roG (coupled cluster pair doubles). Open-shell singlets and triplets were constructed with the Lie algebras sp(N) and so(4N). The resulting formulae appear to be infeasible unless it is possible to efficiently compute generalizations of determinants to three-dimensional objects. Treating each spatial orbital individually, all four possible occupations close the Lie superalgebra gl(2|2).

•Jan 6, 2015•4 citations

ODE/IM Correspondence in Toda Field Theories and Fermionic Basis in sin(h)-Gordon Model

Stefano Negro

The first part of this work consists of a study of the ODE/IM correspondence for simply-laced affine Toda field theories. It is a first step towards a full generalisation of the results of Lukyanov and Zamolodchikov on $\hat{\mathfrak a}_1$ to a general affine Lie-Kač-Moody algebra $\hat{\mathfrak g}$. In order to achieve our goal, we investigate the structure of evaluation representations of $\hat{\mathfrak g}$ and show how their tensor products are related by what we call projected isomorphisms. These isomorphisms are used to construct a set of quadratic functional relations, called $ψ$-system, for the solutions to complex differential equations associated to $\hat{\mathfrak g}$. Finally, from the $ψ$-system for the algebras $\mathfrak a$ and $\mathfrak d$, we derive a set of Bethe Ansatz equations satisfied by the eigenvalues of some particular boundary problem for the above mentioned differential equations. The second part of this work deals with the study of one-point functions in sine- and sinh-Gordon models. The approach to the computation of these quantities follows a powerful method, which we call fermionic basis, developed by Boos et al. for the XXZ, quantum Liouville and quantum sine-Gordon models. We show how the determinant formula for one-point functions obtained there can be generalised to the sinh-Gordon model. In doing so we give an interpretation of the fermionic basis in terms of certain symmetries of the system. This new perspective will also allow us to solve trivially the reflection relations introduced by Fateev et al. We then provide analytical and numerical results supporting our finding.

arXiv:1702.06657•Feb 22, 2017•7 citations
The problem of construction of projection operators on eigensubspaces of symmetry operators is considered. This problem arises in many approximate methods for solving time-independent and time-dependent quantum problems, and its solution ensures proper physical symmetries in development of approximate methods. The projector form is sought as a function of symmetry operators and their eigenvalues characterizing the eigensubspace of interest. This form is obtained in two steps: (1) identification of algebraic structures within a set of symmetry operators (e.g., groups and Lie algebras) and (2) construction of the projection operators for individual symmetry operators. The first step is crucial for efficient projection operator construction because it allows for use of information on irreducible representations of the present algebraic structure. The discussed approaches have potential to stimulate further developments of variational approaches for electronic structure of strongly correlated systems and in quantum computing.
Solving the electronic structure problem on a universal-gate quantum computer within the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) methodology requires constraining the search procedure to a subspace defined by relevant physical symmetries. Ignoring symmetries results in convergence to the lowest eigenstate of the Fock space for the second quantized electronic Hamiltonian. Moreover, this eigenstate can be symmetry broken due to limitations of the wavefunction ansatz. To address this VQE problem, we introduce and assess methods of exact and approximate projectors to irreducible eigensubspaces of available physical symmetries. Feasibility of symmetry projectors in the VQE framework is discussed, and their efficiency is compared with symmetry constraint optimization procedures. Generally, projectors introduce a higher number of terms for VQE measurement compared to the constraint approach. On the other hand, the projection formalism improves accuracy of the variational wavefunction ansatz without introducing additional unitary transformations, which is beneficial for reducing depths of quantum circuits.
A systematic account of projection operators (projectors) and orthogonalization techniques together with applications to selected areas of physics is presented. This unified approach is shown to have advantages over other approaches in that the mathematical statements are more precise. The mathematical level, however, is aimed at the practicing physicist and lies between rigorous mathematics and current use in physics. Further, the techniques presented have practical applications as is demonstrated by examples in the quantum theory of measurement, in the relationship between second quantization and configuration space techniques, and in an account of generalized Wannier and Bloch functions. Attention is paid to the problem of construction of orthogonal projection operators (orthogonal projectors). The construction of orthogonal projectors even in approximate form would allow the solution of many practical problems ranging from the eigenvalue spectrum problem to the construction of states for many-body systems. One can almost say that any problem in quantum mechanics can be formulated as a problem involving the construction of projectors.
In quantum information theory and statistical physics, symmetries of multiple copies, or replicas, of a system play a pivotal role. For unitary ensembles, these symmetries are encoded in the replicated commutant: the algebra of operators commuting with the ensemble across kkk replicas. Determining the commutant is straightforward for the full unitary group, but remains a major obstacle for structured, computationally relevant circuit families. We solve this problem for matchgate circuits, which prepare fermionic Gaussian states on nnn qubits. Using a Majorana fermion representation, we show that operators coupling different system copies generate the orthogonal Lie algebra so(k)\mathfrak{so}(k)so(k), endowing the space of invariants with rich and tractable structure. This underlying symmetry decomposes the matchgate commutant into irreducible sectors, which we completely resolve via a Gelfand--Tsetlin construction. We provide an explicit orthonormal basis of the matchgate commutant for all kkk and nnn, together with a formula for its dimension that grows polynomially in nnn. Furthermore, we characterize the commutant of the Clifford--matchgate subgroup, showing that restricting to signed permutations of Majorana modes yields a commutant that qualitatively diverges from the matchgate case for k≥4k \geq 4k≥4 replicas. Ultimately, our orthonormal basis turns algebraic classification into a working toolbox. Using it, we derive closed-form expressions for matchgate twirling channels and a fermionic analogue of Weingarten calculus, the projector encoding all moments of the Gaussian state orbit, state and unitary frame potentials, the average nonstabilizerness of fermionic Gaussian states, a systematic hierarchy of non-Gaussianity measures, and a fermionic de Finetti theorem.
The construction of operator functionals of the full Hamiltonian of a quantum-mechanical system which act as projection operators for a specified exact eigenstate is studied. In general these operator functionals are not equivalent to the formal operator |ψ〉〈ψ|, where |ψ〉 is the state of interest, and are not always idempotent. A formal method by which standard perturbation theoretic expansions for the exact ground-state vector and ground-state energy of the system can be recovered by expansion of a certain operator functional of this type is presented. Related work is briefly discussed.
Standard approaches to approximating solutions to the Schroedinger equation rely upon the assumption that there is a single dominant electronic configuration with a small number of low-lying excited states. As such, they are referred to as single reference approaches and are accurate only when the band gap is small in comparison with the inter-electronic repulsion of the valence electrons. Systems for which this is the case are weakly-correlated. If the inter-electronic repulsion larger than the band gap, then a single electronic reference is not an appropriate ansatz for the physical wavefunction. As the strength of the interaction is increased many Slater determinants become near-degenerate, each providing non-negligible contributions. Such systems are strongly-correlated. The goal of the thesis was to employ wavefunctions which are: non-trivial, tractable, size-consistent and extensive, and not given in an active space. We have outlined approaches based on wavefunction forms more suited to describe strong correlation. Built on the Lie algebra su(2), our first trial wavefunction was the Bethe ansatz solution to the reduced BCS Hamiltonian derived by Richardson. This wavefunction is expressed as a product of quasi-particles each parametrized in terms of quasi-momenta. Consistency among the quasi-momenta is ensured by a set of non-linear equations to be solved numerically. This approach is feasible in both variational and projected flavours. We next considered a wavefunction of the same form without requiring it to be an eigenvector of the reduced BCS Hamiltonian. A variational approach in this case is only feasible provided there are two equivalent descriptions in terms of particles and holes. In any case, a bivariational principle and a projected approach are both feasible. Also based on su(2), there is AP1roG (coupled cluster pair doubles). Open-shell singlets and triplets were constructed with the Lie algebras sp(N) and so(4N). The resulting formulae appear to be infeasible unless it is possible to efficiently compute generalizations of determinants to three-dimensional objects. Treating each spatial orbital individually, all four possible occupations close the Lie superalgebra gl(2|2).
The first part of this work consists of a study of the ODE/IM correspondence for simply-laced affine Toda field theories. It is a first step towards a full generalisation of the results of Lukyanov and Zamolodchikov on a^1\hat{\mathfrak a}_1a^1​ to a general affine Lie-Kač-Moody algebra g^\hat{\mathfrak g}g^​. In order to achieve our goal, we investigate the structure of evaluation representations of g^\hat{\mathfrak g}g^​ and show how their tensor products are related by what we call projected isomorphisms. These isomorphisms are used to construct a set of quadratic functional relations, called ψψψ-system, for the solutions to complex differential equations associated to g^\hat{\mathfrak g}g^​. Finally, from the ψψψ-system for the algebras a\mathfrak aa and d\mathfrak dd, we derive a set of Bethe Ansatz equations satisfied by the eigenvalues of some particular boundary problem for the above mentioned differential equations. The second part of this work deals with the study of one-point functions in sine- and sinh-Gordon models. The approach to the computation of these quantities follows a powerful method, which we call fermionic basis, developed by Boos et al. for the XXZ, quantum Liouville and quantum sine-Gordon models. We show how the determinant formula for one-point functions obtained there can be generalised to the sinh-Gordon model. In doing so we give an interpretation of the fermionic basis in terms of certain symmetries of the system. This new perspective will also allow us to solve trivially the reflection relations introduced by Fateev et al. We then provide analytical and numerical results supporting our finding.