Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1901.02752 · Physical Review Research

Realization of the tradeoff between internal and external entanglement

Jie Zhu, Meng-Jun Hu, Yue Dai, Yan-Kui Bai, S. Camalet, Chengjie Zhang, Chuan-Feng Li, Guang-Can Guo, Yong-Sheng Zhang

Published Oct 13, 2020• 8 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We experimentally realize the internal and external entanglement tradeoff, which is a kind of entanglement monogamy relation different from that usually discussed.Using a source of twin photons, we find that the external entanglement in the twin photons and the path-polarization internal entanglement of one photon limit each other.In the extreme case, when the internal state is maximally entangled, the external entanglement must be vanishing, which illustrates entanglement monogamy.Our results of the experiment coincide with the theoretical predictions and therefore provide a direct experimental observation of the internal and external entanglement monogamy relations.

DOI
10.1103/physrevresearch.2.043068

Related papers

Realization of the tradeoff between internal and external entanglement

Jie Zhu, Mengjun Hu, Yue Dai +6 more

We experimentally realize the internal and external entanglement tradeoff, which is a new kind of entanglement monogamy relation different from that usually discussed. Using a source of twin photons, we find that the external entanglement in polarization of twin photons, and the path-polarization internal entanglement of one photon, limit each other. In the extreme case, when the internal state is maximally entangled, the external entanglement must be vanishing, that illustrate entanglement monogamy. Our results of the experiment coincide with the theoretical predictions, and therefore provide a direct experimental observation of the internal and external entanglement monogamy relation.

•Jan 22, 2019•5 citations

Observation of the tradeoff between internal quantum nonseparability and external classical correlations

Jie Zhu, Yue Dai, S. Camalet +5 more

The monogamy relations of entanglement are highly significant. However, they involve only amounts of entanglement shared by different subsystems. Results on monogamy relations between entanglement and other kinds of correlations, and particularly classical correlations, are very scarce. Here we experimentally observe a tradeoff relation between internal quantum nonseparability and external total correlations in a photonic system and found that even purely classical external correlations have a detrimental effect on internal nonseparability. The nonseparability we consider, measured by the concurrence, is between different degrees of freedom within the same photon, and the external classical correlations, measured by the standard quantum mutual information, are generated between the photons of a photon pair using the time-bin method. Our observations show that to preserve the internal entanglement in a system, it is necessary to maintain low external correlations, including classical ones, between the system and its environment.

arXiv:2103.04276•Physical Review A•Dec 28, 2021•4 citations

Tight Trade-off Between Internal, Assisted, and External Entanglement

Limin Gao, Chenxiao Wang

We derive a tight and saturable monogamy relation for three-qubit pure states that bounds the sum of concurrence and concurrence of assistance by the entanglement with an external qubit. The bound decreases strictly with increasing external entanglement, establishing a precise trade-off between internal and environment-induced entanglement. Equivalent formulations in terms of negativity and its convex-roof extensions follow. Our result provides a unified and quantitative constraint on entanglement distribution in open multipartite quantum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2604.17867•Apr 21, 2026•0 citations

IS THERE REALLY AN ENTANGLED STATE FOR FAR AWAY TWIN PHOTONS?

Holger G. Valqui

A certain school of physicists based on the following assumptions: (i) Photons acquire a polarization state only after they have passed through a polarizer (which some claim to be a stipulation of one of the postulates of the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics), (ii) The states of twin photons are correctly represented by , where u is an arbitrary state (of polarization) and v is orthogonal to u, and (iii) Numerous experiments directly or indirectly confirm the theoretical predictions. , concludes that there exists an extraordinary entangled state of both photons, which permits that each of the photons somehow be sensible to the interaction which affects the other one, notwithstanding the great distance which might exist between them. In the present exposition I show that: (i) There are experimental reasons to maintain that photons have a definite polarization state before and after having passed through a polarizer, (ii) According to the principles of Quantum Mechanics the "official" representation can not be right., and (iii)Significant doubts exist concerning the accuracy of the critical measurements and their interpretation . At the last I conclude that the alleged extraordinary entanglement of well separated photons might be a delusion. Finally, to settle the matter, I propose a crucial experiment.

High Energy Physics•Apr 1, 2006•0 citations

Limitations to sharing entanglement

Jeong San Kim, Gilad Gour, Barry C. Sanders

We discuss limitations to sharing entanglement known as monogamy of entanglement. Our pedagogical approach commences with simple examples of limited entanglement sharing for pure three-qubit states and progresses to the more general case of mixed-state monogamy relations with multiple qudits.

arXiv:1112.1776•Contemporary Physics•Sep 1, 2012•57 citations

Monogamy Equalities for Qubit Entanglement from Lorentz Invariance

Christopher Eltschka, Jens Siewert

A striking result from nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is the monogamy of entanglement, which states that a particle can be maximally entangled only with one other party, not with several ones. While there is the exact quantitative relation for three qubits and also several inequalities describing monogamy properties, it is not clear to what extent exact monogamy relations are a general feature of quantum mechanics. We prove that in all many-qubit systems there exist strict monogamy laws for quantum correlations. They come about through the curious relationship between the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics of qubits and Minkowski space. We elucidate the origin of entanglement monogamy from this symmetry perspective and provide recipes to construct new families of such equalities.

arXiv:1407.8195•Physical Review Letters•Apr 7, 2015•56 citations
We experimentally realize the internal and external entanglement tradeoff, which is a kind of entanglement monogamy relation different from that usually discussed.Using a source of twin photons, we find that the external entanglement in the twin photons and the path-polarization internal entanglement of one photon limit each other.In the extreme case, when the internal state is maximally entangled, the external entanglement must be vanishing, which illustrates entanglement monogamy.Our results of the experiment coincide with the theoretical predictions and therefore provide a direct experimental observation of the internal and external entanglement monogamy relations.
We experimentally realize the internal and external entanglement tradeoff, which is a new kind of entanglement monogamy relation different from that usually discussed. Using a source of twin photons, we find that the external entanglement in polarization of twin photons, and the path-polarization internal entanglement of one photon, limit each other. In the extreme case, when the internal state is maximally entangled, the external entanglement must be vanishing, that illustrate entanglement monogamy. Our results of the experiment coincide with the theoretical predictions, and therefore provide a direct experimental observation of the internal and external entanglement monogamy relation.
The monogamy relations of entanglement are highly significant. However, they involve only amounts of entanglement shared by different subsystems. Results on monogamy relations between entanglement and other kinds of correlations, and particularly classical correlations, are very scarce. Here we experimentally observe a tradeoff relation between internal quantum nonseparability and external total correlations in a photonic system and found that even purely classical external correlations have a detrimental effect on internal nonseparability. The nonseparability we consider, measured by the concurrence, is between different degrees of freedom within the same photon, and the external classical correlations, measured by the standard quantum mutual information, are generated between the photons of a photon pair using the time-bin method. Our observations show that to preserve the internal entanglement in a system, it is necessary to maintain low external correlations, including classical ones, between the system and its environment.
We derive a tight and saturable monogamy relation for three-qubit pure states that bounds the sum of concurrence and concurrence of assistance by the entanglement with an external qubit. The bound decreases strictly with increasing external entanglement, establishing a precise trade-off between internal and environment-induced entanglement. Equivalent formulations in terms of negativity and its convex-roof extensions follow. Our result provides a unified and quantitative constraint on entanglement distribution in open multipartite quantum systems.
A certain school of physicists based on the following assumptions: (i) Photons acquire a polarization state only after they have passed through a polarizer (which some claim to be a stipulation of one of the postulates of the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics), (ii) The states of twin photons are correctly represented by , where u is an arbitrary state (of polarization) and v is orthogonal to u, and (iii) Numerous experiments directly or indirectly confirm the theoretical predictions. , concludes that there exists an extraordinary entangled state of both photons, which permits that each of the photons somehow be sensible to the interaction which affects the other one, notwithstanding the great distance which might exist between them. In the present exposition I show that: (i) There are experimental reasons to maintain that photons have a definite polarization state before and after having passed through a polarizer, (ii) According to the principles of Quantum Mechanics the "official" representation can not be right., and (iii)Significant doubts exist concerning the accuracy of the critical measurements and their interpretation . At the last I conclude that the alleged extraordinary entanglement of well separated photons might be a delusion. Finally, to settle the matter, I propose a crucial experiment.
A striking result from nonrelativistic quantum mechanics is the monogamy of entanglement, which states that a particle can be maximally entangled only with one other party, not with several ones. While there is the exact quantitative relation for three qubits and also several inequalities describing monogamy properties, it is not clear to what extent exact monogamy relations are a general feature of quantum mechanics. We prove that in all many-qubit systems there exist strict monogamy laws for quantum correlations. They come about through the curious relationship between the nonrelativistic quantum mechanics of qubits and Minkowski space. We elucidate the origin of entanglement monogamy from this symmetry perspective and provide recipes to construct new families of such equalities.