A certain school of physicists based on the following assumptions: (i) Photons acquire a polarization state only after they have passed through a polarizer (which some claim to be a stipulation of one of the postulates of the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics), (ii) The states of twin photons are correctly represented by , where u is an arbitrary state (of polarization) and v is orthogonal to u, and (iii) Numerous experiments directly or indirectly confirm the theoretical predictions. , concludes that there exists an extraordinary entangled state of both photons, which permits that each of the photons somehow be sensible to the interaction which affects the other one, notwithstanding the great distance which might exist between them. In the present exposition I show that: (i) There are experimental reasons to maintain that photons have a definite polarization state before and after having passed through a polarizer, (ii) According to the principles of Quantum Mechanics the "official" representation can not be right., and (iii)Significant doubts exist concerning the accuracy of the critical measurements and their interpretation . At the last I conclude that the alleged extraordinary entanglement of well separated photons might be a delusion. Finally, to settle the matter, I propose a crucial experiment.
A certain school of physicists based on the following assumptions: (i) Photons acquire a polarization state only after they have passed through a polarizer (which some claim to be a stipulation of one of the postulates of the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics), (ii) The states of twin photons are correctly represented by , where u is an arbitrary state (of polarization) and v is orthogonal to u, and (iii) Numerous experiments directly or indirectly confirm the theoretical predictions. , concludes that there exists an extraordinary entangled state of both photons, which permits that each of the photons somehow be sensible to the interaction which affects the other one, notwithstanding the great distance which might exist between them. In the present exposition I show that: (i) There are experimental reasons to maintain that photons have a definite polarization state before and after having passed through a polarizer, (ii) According to the principles of Quantum Mechanics the "official" representation can not be right., and (iii)Significant doubts exist concerning the accuracy of the critical measurements and their interpretation . At the last I conclude that the alleged extraordinary entanglement of well separated photons might be a delusion. Finally, to settle the matter, I propose a crucial experiment.
Abstract In Quantum Mechanics, two particles are entangled if their physical states depend on one another's so that if we find one of them in state A, for example, we will be sure that the other is in state B. However, until the state of a quantum particle is measured, it will be in a superposition of states, being in neither one nor the other until then, so when an entangled particle is measured, its pair also assumes a state instantly and regardless of how far away it is from the other particle at that time. As promising as it could be to use this fact for instantaneous communication, Quantum Mechanics seems to claim this is impossible, as no method ever invented to do this has worked until today. What we demonstrate here theoretically is that with a protocol and simple optical devices, two people who share polarized entangled pairs of photons can send information to each other faster than light. If this model of communication proves to be experimentally functional, we will have a contradiction to Einstein's theories of relativity, and otherwise, we will have Quantum Mechanics predicting something that does not happen in real life. This result, therefore, shows there is something fundamental about the universe we do not know yet. One of these theories must be mistaken and both deal with fundamental aspects of reality, such as the dynamics of space and time, and the particles that almost all matter around us are made of. Besides, this result is of great relevance also because it has immediate applications in several areas if the model works experimentally, as in space exploration and security, since it will allow the creation of non-interceptable instantaneous communication technologies.
Entanglement lies at the heart of quantum mechanics, and has sparked fierce debate between physicists over the years. The phenomenon, whereby two particles become inextricably linked without actually interacting with each other, certainly goes against intuition. For instance, two photons can be created in an experiment such that if one is polarized in the vertical direction, the other is always polarized horizontally. By measuring the polarization state of one entangled photon, we therefore immediately know the state of the other – no matter how far apart the photons are.
Although most physics experiments are carried out with independent particles, it is the collective nature of entangled particles that reveals the most fascinating and unexpected aspects of the quantum world. It was Erwin Schrodinger who first said “entanglement is not one but rather the characteristic trait of quantum mechanics”. One curious aspect of the behavior of a pair of particles in an entangled state is that, though each individual particle exhibits an inherent uncertainty, the joint entity of an entangled pair can exhibit no such uncertainty. As an example, while the time of arrival of an individual particle may be totally random, an entangled pair must always arrive simultaneously. This property offers a unique tool for carrying out absolute measurements. Our goal here is to explore the myriad implications and significance of entanglement and to exploit it for the development of a new type of optical measurement—quantum optical metrology. The existence of unique non-classical correlations between twin photons generated in the nonlinear process of spontaneous parametric origins. The non-classical link between such twin quanta is not diminished by arbitrarily large separations between the twins, even when they lie outside the light cone. Twin states have been used with great effectiveness over the past two decades for carrying out definitive quantum experiments that lead to counterintuitive results; among these are those arising from the EinsteinPodolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox such as various tests of Bell’s inequalities [1-12], as well as non-local dispersion cancellation, entangled-photon–induced transparency, and entangled-photon spectroscopy with monochromatic light. The availability of these twin beams has made it possible to conduct such experiments without having to resort to
Abstract In this work, we show that Quantum Mechanics predicts that two people who share entangled polarized pairs of photons can communicate faster than light. We show this communication only occurs in one direction, from person B to A. Person B can send information to A by measuring the polarization of his photons in different directions. Person A can find out in which direction B has measured his photons by measuring how much light passes through an optical circuit. We show this communication is instantaneous because it is based on the collapse of the wave function of the entangled pair, which collapse is instantaneous. We conclude that regardless of whether this method of communication works or not in practice, we have something new because if it works, it would be a contradiction to the theories of Relativity, and if it does not work, Quantum Mechanics would be predicting something that does not happen in real life.
We propose experiments of quantum entanglement for investigating the EPR problem with the polarization directions of photons. These experiments are performed to investigate whether or not the polarization directions in an entangled state are affected through quantum entanglement. EPR-type sequential experiments can be performed using a twin-photon beam and two pairs of linear polarization analyzers. If one of the linear polarization analyzers in the second pair is set at a different angle to the first one, it indicates that one of the entangled state photons has changed its polarization direction. In this experiment, we can predict the following two answers. (1) The first pair of linear polarization analyzers projects the entangled state on a nonentangled state, or (2) the "continuity of entanglement" under a pure Hamiltonian evolution is detected.
According to quantum theory, two ensembles of quantum systems that are described by the same density operator are indistinguishable. For example, unpolarized light can be obtained either by an incoherent mixture of two orthogonal pure states or by tracing out a photon from a maximally polarization-entangled photon pair. In both cases, one is unable to guess with probability greater than 50% the outcome of any polarization measurement, but the reasons are conceptually different: whereas the first case is a matter of classical ignorance (the photons were prepared in a definite but unknown way), the second one is of the quantum ignorance kind - if one cannot access the other degrees of freedom of the quantum state, there is no information that could be used to predict a measurement result. We use these concepts to discuss the quantum-physical interpretation of partially polarized light from the point of view of quantum communication and whether a polarization scrambler can really depolarize light. A novel definition of the degree of polarization of a single photon which does not depend on classical ignorance is also provided.