Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1710.09136 · IEEE Transactions on Terahertz Science and Technology

Engineering Physics of Superconducting Hot-Electron Bolometer Mixers

T. M. Klapwijk, A. V. Semenov

Published Nov 1, 2017• 40 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superconducting hot-electron bolometers are presently the best performing mixing devices for the frequency range beyond 1.2 THz, where good-quality superconductor-insulator-superconductor devices do not exist. Their physical appearance is very simple: an antenna consisting of a normal metal, sometimes a normal-metal-superconductor bilayer, connected to a thin film of a narrow short superconductor with a high resistivity in the normal state. The device is brought into an optimal operating regime by applying a dc current and a certain amount of local-oscillator power. Despite this technological simplicity, its operation has found to be controlled by many different aspects of superconductivity, all occurring simultaneously. A core ingredient is the understanding that there are two sources of resistance in a superconductor: a charge-conversion resistance occurring at a normal-metal-superconductor interface and a resistance due to time-dependent changes of the superconducting phase. The latter is responsible for the actual mixing process in a nonuniform superconducting environment set up by the bias conditions and the geometry. The present understanding indicates that further improvement needs to be found in the use of other materials with a faster energy relaxation rate. Meanwhile, several empirical parameters have become physically meaningful indicators of the devices, which will facilitate the technological developments.

DOI
10.1109/tthz.2017.2758267

Related papers

Superconducting hot-electron bolometer mixers and their applications

Wen Zhang, Wei Miao, Yuan Ren +2 more

Superconducting hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are the most sensitive heterodyne detectors at frequencies beyond 1 THz, and are used for many astronomical observations. HEB, consisting of a narrow and short superconducting thin film patch connected to an antenna via contact pads, is brought into a highly sensitive operating regime by applying a DC current and a certain amount of local-oscillator power. Potentially, superconducting HEB mixers are capable of exhibiting high sensitivity for frequencies up to several tens of THz, as their output noise and conversion gain are nearly frequency independent according to the mixing mechanism. Moreover, the understanding of mixing mechanism has evolved over time from lumped-element model to distributed hot-spot model. In this review, we provide an overview of theoretical and experimental studies on HEBs and their applications, especially in astronomical observations on ground, airborne and space telescopes.

Superconductivity•May 8, 2022•18 citations

Study of the superconductor-normal metal interface in hot-electron bolometer mixers

Ю.Д. Третьяков, Matvey I. Finkel, P. Larionov +5 more

During the last few years significant progress has been made in the field of hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers. It has been possible to combine a low noise temperature and high stability of phonon-cooled HEBs with an ultrawide gain bandwidth of the diffusion-cooled HEBs in a single device and thus create HEB mixers which offer a noise temperature of 5hν/kB across a 7-GHz band. The essential ingredient of this success is the in situ fabrication technology, where the deposition of the gold contacts follows the deposition of the superconducting film without vacuum breaking. Despite the evident technological breakthrough, the details of certain physical processes occurring both at the superconductor-normal metal (SN) interface and in the superconducting bridge are not completely understood in terms of their influence on the mixer performance. In particular, it is still unclear to what extent the properties of the SN interface are affected by the deposition temperatures of the superconductor and the normal metal, and also by the time interval elapsed between the deposition processes. We will gain some insight into the matter by studying the behaviour of the superconducting transition as a function of the deposition temperatures and time delay. A better understanding of this issue will allow us to move forward the HEB mixer technology towards new applications.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Technology and Performance of THz Hot-Electron Bolometer Mixers

K. Ilin, Axel Stockhausen, A. Scheuring +4 more

Hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are a complex multi-layer thin film structure containing an ultra-thin superconducting film of NbN as a detecting element and a thick normal metal layer as an antenna structure. We have optimized the fabrication process starting with ultra-thin NbN films, Au films for antenna structures and their patterning using e-beam lithography and lift-off. The coupling between normal conducting antenna and NbN detector has been improved by introducing an intermediate NbN film to reduce proximity suppression of superconductivity in the detecting element. A critical temperature of about 9.5 K is reached for NbN films with a thickness between 5 nm and 6 nm. A twofold increase of the film thickness increases the critical temperature to 12 K. We have shown that a 20 nm thick buffer layer of NbN under a much thicker Au layer is sufficient to ensure a critical temperature of the bi-layer of 9 K. This value is close to the critical temperature of 5.5 nm thick HEB devices. The noise temperature of HEB mixer made using improved technology is about 800 K and was measured in a liquid cryogen free system with a quantum cascade laser as 2.5 THz local oscillator.

IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity•Jun 1, 2009•8 citations

Superconductive Hot Electron Bolometer Mixers

William R. McGrath, Boris S. Karasik, Anders J. Skalare +2 more

Hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixers have made exceptional progress in recent years. These superconductive devices can operate well above the energy gap where current state-of-the-art SIS mixers begin to fail. Mixing results have been reported throughout the submillimeter range, up to several THz. The bolometer consists of a simple nanobridge that is biased near the center of the superconductive transition. Only about 0.1μW of LO power is required. HEB mixers are expected to play a central role in astrophysical observations at THz frequencies and are currently under development for ground, aircraft, and space-borne observatories. This paper gives a short introduction to these unique sensors, a brief survey of the current status of the field, and some discussion of important topics related to future development.

•Jan 1, 2002•5 citations

DC and IF Bandwidth Measurements of Superconducting Diffusion-Cooled Hot Electron Bolometer Mixers based on Nb/Au Bilayer

X. Lefoul, Pavel A. Yagoubov, Merlijn Hajenius +5 more

Hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixers based on a superconductor-normal metal bilayer [1] are expected to improve the overall performance, in comparison with existing Nb or NbN mixers: lower mixer noise, larger intermediate frequency (IF) bandwidth, and in particular, lower LO power requirement. The bilayer takes advantage of the idea that one

•Mar 1, 2002•1 citation

Concept of a mixer based on a cold-electron bolometer

Michael A. Tarasov, L. S. Kuzmin

A phase-sensitive terahertz heterodyne mixer of a new type based on a cold-electron bolometer is proposed. In this mixer, a normal-metal thin-film absorber is connected to a planar antenna via superconductor-insulator-normal metal (SIN) tunnel junctions, thus forming a SINIS structure. The SINIS mixer combines the advantages of a hot-electron bolometer (HEB), such as a high signal frequency at a small local oscillator power, with the advantages of an SIS mixer, including low noise level, a high intermediate frequency, and wide working temperature range (up to a critical temperature of the superconductor). In contrast to the HEB and SIS mixers, the proposed device is less sensitive to external magnetic noise and exhibits no additional noise related to the superconducting transition and the Josephson effect.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•May 1, 2005•6 citations
Superconducting hot-electron bolometers are presently the best performing mixing devices for the frequency range beyond 1.2 THz, where good-quality superconductor-insulator-superconductor devices do not exist. Their physical appearance is very simple: an antenna consisting of a normal metal, sometimes a normal-metal-superconductor bilayer, connected to a thin film of a narrow short superconductor with a high resistivity in the normal state. The device is brought into an optimal operating regime by applying a dc current and a certain amount of local-oscillator power. Despite this technological simplicity, its operation has found to be controlled by many different aspects of superconductivity, all occurring simultaneously. A core ingredient is the understanding that there are two sources of resistance in a superconductor: a charge-conversion resistance occurring at a normal-metal-superconductor interface and a resistance due to time-dependent changes of the superconducting phase. The latter is responsible for the actual mixing process in a nonuniform superconducting environment set up by the bias conditions and the geometry. The present understanding indicates that further improvement needs to be found in the use of other materials with a faster energy relaxation rate. Meanwhile, several empirical parameters have become physically meaningful indicators of the devices, which will facilitate the technological developments.
Superconducting hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are the most sensitive heterodyne detectors at frequencies beyond 1 THz, and are used for many astronomical observations. HEB, consisting of a narrow and short superconducting thin film patch connected to an antenna via contact pads, is brought into a highly sensitive operating regime by applying a DC current and a certain amount of local-oscillator power. Potentially, superconducting HEB mixers are capable of exhibiting high sensitivity for frequencies up to several tens of THz, as their output noise and conversion gain are nearly frequency independent according to the mixing mechanism. Moreover, the understanding of mixing mechanism has evolved over time from lumped-element model to distributed hot-spot model. In this review, we provide an overview of theoretical and experimental studies on HEBs and their applications, especially in astronomical observations on ground, airborne and space telescopes.
During the last few years significant progress has been made in the field of hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers. It has been possible to combine a low noise temperature and high stability of phonon-cooled HEBs with an ultrawide gain bandwidth of the diffusion-cooled HEBs in a single device and thus create HEB mixers which offer a noise temperature of 5hν/kB across a 7-GHz band. The essential ingredient of this success is the in situ fabrication technology, where the deposition of the gold contacts follows the deposition of the superconducting film without vacuum breaking. Despite the evident technological breakthrough, the details of certain physical processes occurring both at the superconductor-normal metal (SN) interface and in the superconducting bridge are not completely understood in terms of their influence on the mixer performance. In particular, it is still unclear to what extent the properties of the SN interface are affected by the deposition temperatures of the superconductor and the normal metal, and also by the time interval elapsed between the deposition processes. We will gain some insight into the matter by studying the behaviour of the superconducting transition as a function of the deposition temperatures and time delay. A better understanding of this issue will allow us to move forward the HEB mixer technology towards new applications.
Hot-electron bolometer (HEB) mixers are a complex multi-layer thin film structure containing an ultra-thin superconducting film of NbN as a detecting element and a thick normal metal layer as an antenna structure. We have optimized the fabrication process starting with ultra-thin NbN films, Au films for antenna structures and their patterning using e-beam lithography and lift-off. The coupling between normal conducting antenna and NbN detector has been improved by introducing an intermediate NbN film to reduce proximity suppression of superconductivity in the detecting element. A critical temperature of about 9.5 K is reached for NbN films with a thickness between 5 nm and 6 nm. A twofold increase of the film thickness increases the critical temperature to 12 K. We have shown that a 20 nm thick buffer layer of NbN under a much thicker Au layer is sufficient to ensure a critical temperature of the bi-layer of 9 K. This value is close to the critical temperature of 5.5 nm thick HEB devices. The noise temperature of HEB mixer made using improved technology is about 800 K and was measured in a liquid cryogen free system with a quantum cascade laser as 2.5 THz local oscillator.
Hot electron bolometer (HEB) mixers have made exceptional progress in recent years. These superconductive devices can operate well above the energy gap where current state-of-the-art SIS mixers begin to fail. Mixing results have been reported throughout the submillimeter range, up to several THz. The bolometer consists of a simple nanobridge that is biased near the center of the superconductive transition. Only about 0.1μW of LO power is required. HEB mixers are expected to play a central role in astrophysical observations at THz frequencies and are currently under development for ground, aircraft, and space-borne observatories. This paper gives a short introduction to these unique sensors, a brief survey of the current status of the field, and some discussion of important topics related to future development.
A phase-sensitive terahertz heterodyne mixer of a new type based on a cold-electron bolometer is proposed. In this mixer, a normal-metal thin-film absorber is connected to a planar antenna via superconductor-insulator-normal metal (SIN) tunnel junctions, thus forming a SINIS structure. The SINIS mixer combines the advantages of a hot-electron bolometer (HEB), such as a high signal frequency at a small local oscillator power, with the advantages of an SIS mixer, including low noise level, a high intermediate frequency, and wide working temperature range (up to a critical temperature of the superconductor). In contrast to the HEB and SIS mixers, the proposed device is less sensitive to external magnetic noise and exhibits no additional noise related to the superconducting transition and the Josephson effect.