Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1710.07256 · Physical Review X

Disjointness of Stabilizer Codes and Limitations on Fault-Tolerant Logical Gates

Tomas Jochym-O’Connor, Aleksander Kubica, Theodore J. Yoder

Published May 21, 2018• 60 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A new analysis quantifies computational limitations on stabilizer codes (codes that correct errors in quantum information) for practical operations and provides insight into how to design stabilizer codes for useful and interesting applications.
DOI
10.1103/physrevx.8.021047

Related papers

Fault-Tolerant Logical Gates in Holographic Stabilizer Codes Are Severely Restricted

Sam Cree, Kfir Dolev, Vladimir Calvera +1 more

The future of holographic stabilizer codes for achieving universal fault-tolerant quantum computation does not appear promising: severe limitations on its usefulness are conceptually presented and theoretically verified.

arXiv:2103.13404•PRX Quantum•Aug 31, 2021•13 citations

Theory of fault-tolerant quantum computation

Daniel Gottesman

In order to use quantum error-correcting codes to improve the performance of a quantum computer, it is necessary to be able to perform operations fault-tolerantly on encoded states. I present a theory of fault-tolerant operations on stabilizer codes based on symmetries of the code stabilizer. This allows a straightforward determination of which operations can be performed fault-tolerantly on a given code. I demonstrate that fault-tolerant universal computation is possible for any stabilizer code. I discuss a number of examples in more detail, including the five-quantum-bit code.

arXiv:quant-ph/9702029•Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1998•1,048 citations

From Syndromes to Computation: A General Framework for Logical Operations in Quantum Error-Correcting Codes

Hunter Nelson, Arshag Danageozian, ChunJun Cao +2 more

Fault-tolerant quantum computation requires error-correcting codes that not only protect quantum information but also support useful logical operations with practical physical realizations. Here we develop a general framework in which the stabilizer syndromes of commuting Pauli rotations directly organize logical-gate design. We derive an exact codespace-preservation condition valid at arbitrary rotation angles, providing a common stabilizer-level description for CSS and non-CSS codes and for both Clifford and non-Clifford operations. A particularly useful equal-syndrome specialization reduces Clifford gate design to stabilizer factorization, yields a general generator weight bound of $\lceil d/2\rceil$ for distance-$d$ codes, and systematically extends to logical rotations higher in the Clifford hierarchy. Applied to bivariate-bicycle (BB) and non-CSS Mirror qLDPC codes, the framework gives explicit low-weight Clifford and controlled-phase gates. Our implementations yield new low-weight gates, including an addressed $T$ gate on the $[[16,4,4]]$ BB code, $T$-type rotations on the $[[64,8,8]]$ BB code, and CCZ-, CS-, and $T$-type operations on the $[[36,6,6]]$ Mirror code. We also develop analytic constructions using Clifford algebra bases, which turn the syndrome constraints into explicit algebraic relations and provide a systematic route to logical addressability. We use this approach to analytically construct addressed CNOT, SWAP, controlled, and CCZ-type gates on recursive hypercube codes. An independent construction on middle quantum Reed--Muller codes yields C${}^r$Z gates that saturate the equal-syndrome weight bound. These results establish stabilizer syndromes as a constructive link between the stabilizer structure of a quantum code, the logical computations it can directly support, and the fault-tolerance properties of their physical realizations.

quant-pharXiv:2610.17612•Oct 14, 2026•0 citations

Stabilizer Codes and Quantum Error Correction

Daniel Gottesman

Controlling operational errors and decoherence is one of the major challenges facing the field of quantum computation and other attempts to create specified many-particle entangled states. The field of quantum error correction has developed to meet this challenge. A group-theoretical structure and associated subclass of quantum codes, the stabilizer codes, has proved particularly fruitful in producing codes and in understanding the structure of both specific codes and classes of codes. I will give an overview of the field of quantum error correction and the formalism of stabilizer codes. In the context of stabilizer codes, I will discuss a number of known codes, the capacity of a quantum channel, bounds on quantum codes, and fault-tolerant quantum computation.

arXiv:quant-ph/9705052•May 28, 1997•2,856 citations

Practical fault-tolerant quantum computation

Theodore J. Yoder

For the past two and a half decades, a subset of the physics community has been focused on building a new type of computer, one that exploits the superposition, interference, and entanglement of quantum states to compute faster than a classical computer on select tasks. Manipulating quantum systems requires great care, however, as they are quite sensitive to many sources of noise. Surpassing the limits of hardware fabrication and control, quantum error-correcting codes can reduce error-rates to arbitrarily low levels, albeit with some overhead. This thesis takes another look at several aspects of stabilizer code quantum error-correction to discover solutions to the practical problems of choosing a code, using it to correct errors, and performing fault-tolerant operations. Our first result looks at limitations on the simplest implementation of fault-tolerant operations, transversality. By defining a new property of stabilizer codes, the disjointness, we find transversal operations on stabilizer codes are limited to the Clifford hierarchy and thus are not universal for computation. Next, we address these limitations by designing non-transversal fault-tolerant operations that can be used to universally compute on some codes. The key idea in our constructions is that error-correction is performed at various points partway through the non-transversal operation (even at points when the code is not-necessarily still a stabilizer code) to catch errors before they spread. Since the operation is thus divided into pieces, we dub this pieceable fault-tolerance. In applying pieceable fault tolerance to the Bacon-Shor family of codes, we find an interesting tradeoff between space and time, where a fault-tolerant controlled-controlled-Z operation takes less time as the code becomes more asymmetric, eventually becoming transversal. Further, with a novel error-correction procedure designed to preserve the coherence of errors, we design a reasonably practical implementation of the controlled-controlled-Z operation on the smallest Bacon-Shor code. Our last contribution is a new family of topological quantum codes, the triangle codes, which operate within the limits of a 2-dimensional plane. These codes can perform all encoded Clifford operations within the plane. Moreover, we describe how to do the same for the popular family of surface codes, by relation to the triangle codes.

•Jan 1, 2018•1 citation

Finding the disjointness of stabilizer codes is NP-complete

John Bostanci, Aleksander Kubica

The disjointness of a stabilizer code is a quantity used to constrain the level of the logical Clifford hierarchy attainable by transversal gates and constant-depth quantum circuits. We show that for any positive integer constant $c$, the problem of calculating the $c$-disjointness, or even approximating it to within a constant multiplicative factor, is NP-complete. We provide bounds on the disjointness for various code families, including the Calderbank-Shor-Steane codes, concatenated codes, and hypergraph product codes. We also describe numerical methods of finding the disjointness, which can be readily used to rule out the existence of any transversal gate implementing some non-Clifford logical operation in small stabilizer codes. Our results indicate that finding fault-tolerant logical gates for generic quantum error-correcting codes is a computationally challenging task.

arXiv:2108.04738•Physical Review Research•Dec 20, 2021•1 citation
In order to use quantum error-correcting codes to improve the performance of a quantum computer, it is necessary to be able to perform operations fault-tolerantly on encoded states. I present a theory of fault-tolerant operations on stabilizer codes based on symmetries of the code stabilizer. This allows a straightforward determination of which operations can be performed fault-tolerantly on a given code. I demonstrate that fault-tolerant universal computation is possible for any stabilizer code. I discuss a number of examples in more detail, including the five-quantum-bit code.
Fault-tolerant quantum computation requires error-correcting codes that not only protect quantum information but also support useful logical operations with practical physical realizations. Here we develop a general framework in which the stabilizer syndromes of commuting Pauli rotations directly organize logical-gate design. We derive an exact codespace-preservation condition valid at arbitrary rotation angles, providing a common stabilizer-level description for CSS and non-CSS codes and for both Clifford and non-Clifford operations. A particularly useful equal-syndrome specialization reduces Clifford gate design to stabilizer factorization, yields a general generator weight bound of ⌈d/2⌉\lceil d/2\rceil⌈d/2⌉ for distance-ddd codes, and systematically extends to logical rotations higher in the Clifford hierarchy. Applied to bivariate-bicycle (BB) and non-CSS Mirror qLDPC codes, the framework gives explicit low-weight Clifford and controlled-phase gates. Our implementations yield new low-weight gates, including an addressed TTT gate on the [[16,4,4]][[16,4,4]][[16,4,4]] BB code, TTT-type rotations on the [[64,8,8]][[64,8,8]][[64,8,8]] BB code, and CCZ-, CS-, and TTT-type operations on the [[36,6,6]][[36,6,6]][[36,6,6]] Mirror code. We also develop analytic constructions using Clifford algebra bases, which turn the syndrome constraints into explicit algebraic relations and provide a systematic route to logical addressability. We use this approach to analytically construct addressed CNOT, SWAP, controlled, and CCZ-type gates on recursive hypercube codes. An independent construction on middle quantum Reed--Muller codes yields Cr{}^rrZ gates that saturate the equal-syndrome weight bound. These results establish stabilizer syndromes as a constructive link between the stabilizer structure of a quantum code, the logical computations it can directly support, and the fault-tolerance properties of their physical realizations.
Controlling operational errors and decoherence is one of the major challenges facing the field of quantum computation and other attempts to create specified many-particle entangled states. The field of quantum error correction has developed to meet this challenge. A group-theoretical structure and associated subclass of quantum codes, the stabilizer codes, has proved particularly fruitful in producing codes and in understanding the structure of both specific codes and classes of codes. I will give an overview of the field of quantum error correction and the formalism of stabilizer codes. In the context of stabilizer codes, I will discuss a number of known codes, the capacity of a quantum channel, bounds on quantum codes, and fault-tolerant quantum computation.
For the past two and a half decades, a subset of the physics community has been focused on building a new type of computer, one that exploits the superposition, interference, and entanglement of quantum states to compute faster than a classical computer on select tasks. Manipulating quantum systems requires great care, however, as they are quite sensitive to many sources of noise. Surpassing the limits of hardware fabrication and control, quantum error-correcting codes can reduce error-rates to arbitrarily low levels, albeit with some overhead. This thesis takes another look at several aspects of stabilizer code quantum error-correction to discover solutions to the practical problems of choosing a code, using it to correct errors, and performing fault-tolerant operations. Our first result looks at limitations on the simplest implementation of fault-tolerant operations, transversality. By defining a new property of stabilizer codes, the disjointness, we find transversal operations on stabilizer codes are limited to the Clifford hierarchy and thus are not universal for computation. Next, we address these limitations by designing non-transversal fault-tolerant operations that can be used to universally compute on some codes. The key idea in our constructions is that error-correction is performed at various points partway through the non-transversal operation (even at points when the code is not-necessarily still a stabilizer code) to catch errors before they spread. Since the operation is thus divided into pieces, we dub this pieceable fault-tolerance. In applying pieceable fault tolerance to the Bacon-Shor family of codes, we find an interesting tradeoff between space and time, where a fault-tolerant controlled-controlled-Z operation takes less time as the code becomes more asymmetric, eventually becoming transversal. Further, with a novel error-correction procedure designed to preserve the coherence of errors, we design a reasonably practical implementation of the controlled-controlled-Z operation on the smallest Bacon-Shor code. Our last contribution is a new family of topological quantum codes, the triangle codes, which operate within the limits of a 2-dimensional plane. These codes can perform all encoded Clifford operations within the plane. Moreover, we describe how to do the same for the popular family of surface codes, by relation to the triangle codes.
The disjointness of a stabilizer code is a quantity used to constrain the level of the logical Clifford hierarchy attainable by transversal gates and constant-depth quantum circuits. We show that for any positive integer constant ccc, the problem of calculating the ccc-disjointness, or even approximating it to within a constant multiplicative factor, is NP-complete. We provide bounds on the disjointness for various code families, including the Calderbank-Shor-Steane codes, concatenated codes, and hypergraph product codes. We also describe numerical methods of finding the disjointness, which can be readily used to rule out the existence of any transversal gate implementing some non-Clifford logical operation in small stabilizer codes. Our results indicate that finding fault-tolerant logical gates for generic quantum error-correcting codes is a computationally challenging task.