Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1602.03754

Comment on the paper "The finite square well: whatever is worth teaching at all is worth teaching well ", arXiv:1505.03376v2 [physics.ed-ph] by K. Razi Naqvi and S. Waldenstrøm

Victor Bârsan

Published Feb 10, 2016• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the aforementioned paper, the authors claim that my results concerning the consequent application of Garrett's method for obtaining approximate expressions of the bound states energy of a particle in a finite rectangular well are incorrect. I shall show hat this is not the case, and demonstrate that both their and my results lead to the same conclusion, i.e. that the consequent application of Garrett's method is equivalent to Barker's approximation.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1602.03754

Related papers

The finite square well: whatever is worth teaching at all is worth teaching well

Kalbe Razi Naqvi, S. Waldenstrøm

A contemporary physicist would be hard put to agree entirely with the author of a 1959 textbook on quantum mechanics, who wrote: "A second simple, one-dimensional system, somewhat divorced from reality but illustrative of the principles of the theory, is a particle in a box with finite walls." Interest in this prototypic system has not diminished over the years, and is not likely to do so in the near future, because it has now been wedded to reality and seen as a paradigm for quantum wells and other nanosystems. The treatment of this topic in standard textbooks has changed little over the last few decades, and such changes as have come to our notice leave, in our opinion, much to be desired. The purpose of this article is to enable, even encourage, other teachers to give the finite square well the attention that it deserves; to this end, the authors provide a tutorial review that is more instructive and comprehensive than the accounts presented in numerous textbooks and dispensed in still more numerous online resources, but does not make any additional demands on the mathematical abilities of the student. Given the elemental nature of the topic, the authors claim no originality; with nothing more than the winnowing fork in their hands, they can only clear the threshing floor, gather the wheat into the barn, and let others decide whether or no the chaff should be burnt with unquenchable fire.

arXiv:1505.03376•Apr 24, 2015•7 citations

Understanding quantum phenomena without solving the Schrödinger equation: the case of the finite square well

Victor Bârsan

An approximate formula for the energy levels of the bound states of a particle in a finite square well are obtained, without using the Schrodinger equation. The physics and mathematics involved in this approach are accessible to a gifted high school student.

European Journal of Physics•Aug 28, 2015•4 citations

Comment on: “Bound-State Energies of a Particle in a Finite Square Well”

James J. Murphy

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1971•1 citation

A simpler graphical solution and an approximate formula for energy eigenvalues in finite square quantum wells

F. M. S. Lima

The computation of allowed energy levels for a particle bounded to a finite square well potential is ubiquitous in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics textbooks. For stationary bound states, the matching conditions for the wave functions lead to a pair of transcendental equations whose roots correspond to the energy eigenvalues. However, the graphical solutions available do not make clear the dependence of the energies on the well potential parameters. In this note, I present a simpler graphical solution involving only one dimensionless parameter that determines a straight-line crossing identical sinusoidal curves. I then reduce this solution to a single cosine curve, and from a three-point interpolation, I derive an approximate formula for all energy levels valid for any square quantum well and that demands only a pocket calculator.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 21, 2020•13 citations

Bound-State Energies of a Particle in a Finite Square Well: An Improved Graphical Solution

Cyrus D. Cantrell

The energy eigenvalues for a particle bound in a finite or semi-infinite square-well potential are shown to be determined by the points of intersection of two straight lines with sine or cosine curves. This construction, which is simple enough for students to remember, can also be used to determine the number of bound states for a given potential strength, and to obtain approximate values for the energies of low-lying states in a deep square well.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1971•15 citations

Bound state energies of a particle in a finite square well: A simple approximation

Steven L. Garrett

American Journal of Physics•Feb 1, 1979•24 citations
In the aforementioned paper, the authors claim that my results concerning the consequent application of Garrett's method for obtaining approximate expressions of the bound states energy of a particle in a finite rectangular well are incorrect. I shall show hat this is not the case, and demonstrate that both their and my results lead to the same conclusion, i.e. that the consequent application of Garrett's method is equivalent to Barker's approximation.
A contemporary physicist would be hard put to agree entirely with the author of a 1959 textbook on quantum mechanics, who wrote: "A second simple, one-dimensional system, somewhat divorced from reality but illustrative of the principles of the theory, is a particle in a box with finite walls." Interest in this prototypic system has not diminished over the years, and is not likely to do so in the near future, because it has now been wedded to reality and seen as a paradigm for quantum wells and other nanosystems. The treatment of this topic in standard textbooks has changed little over the last few decades, and such changes as have come to our notice leave, in our opinion, much to be desired. The purpose of this article is to enable, even encourage, other teachers to give the finite square well the attention that it deserves; to this end, the authors provide a tutorial review that is more instructive and comprehensive than the accounts presented in numerous textbooks and dispensed in still more numerous online resources, but does not make any additional demands on the mathematical abilities of the student. Given the elemental nature of the topic, the authors claim no originality; with nothing more than the winnowing fork in their hands, they can only clear the threshing floor, gather the wheat into the barn, and let others decide whether or no the chaff should be burnt with unquenchable fire.
The computation of allowed energy levels for a particle bounded to a finite square well potential is ubiquitous in modern physics and introductory quantum mechanics textbooks. For stationary bound states, the matching conditions for the wave functions lead to a pair of transcendental equations whose roots correspond to the energy eigenvalues. However, the graphical solutions available do not make clear the dependence of the energies on the well potential parameters. In this note, I present a simpler graphical solution involving only one dimensionless parameter that determines a straight-line crossing identical sinusoidal curves. I then reduce this solution to a single cosine curve, and from a three-point interpolation, I derive an approximate formula for all energy levels valid for any square quantum well and that demands only a pocket calculator.