Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1505.03376

The finite square well: whatever is worth teaching at all is worth teaching well

Kalbe Razi Naqvi, S. Waldenstrøm

Published Apr 24, 2015• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A contemporary physicist would be hard put to agree entirely with the author of a 1959 textbook on quantum mechanics, who wrote: "A second simple, one-dimensional system, somewhat divorced from reality but illustrative of the principles of the theory, is a particle in a box with finite walls." Interest in this prototypic system has not diminished over the years, and is not likely to do so in the near future, because it has now been wedded to reality and seen as a paradigm for quantum wells and other nanosystems. The treatment of this topic in standard textbooks has changed little over the last few decades, and such changes as have come to our notice leave, in our opinion, much to be desired. The purpose of this article is to enable, even encourage, other teachers to give the finite square well the attention that it deserves; to this end, the authors provide a tutorial review that is more instructive and comprehensive than the accounts presented in numerous textbooks and dispensed in still more numerous online resources, but does not make any additional demands on the mathematical abilities of the student. Given the elemental nature of the topic, the authors claim no originality; with nothing more than the winnowing fork in their hands, they can only clear the threshing floor, gather the wheat into the barn, and let others decide whether or no the chaff should be burnt with unquenchable fire.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1505.03376

Related papers

Quantum Mechanical Example: The Infinite Square Well

Andrew J. Larkoski

This original and innovative textbook takes the unique perspective of introducing and solving problems in quantum mechanics using linear algebra methods, to equip readers with a deeper and more practical understanding of this fundamental pillar of contemporary physics. Extensive motivation for the properties of quantum mechanics, Hilbert space, and the Schrödinger equation is provided through analysis of the derivative, while standard topics like the harmonic oscillator, rotations, and the hydrogen atom are covered from within the context of operator methods. Advanced topics forming the basis of modern physics research are also included, such as the density matrix, entropy, and measures of entanglement. Written for an undergraduate audience, this book offers a unique and mathematically self-contained treatment of this hugely important topic. Students are guided gently through the text by the author's engaging writing style, with an extensive glossary provided for reference and numerous homework problems to expand and develop key concepts. Online resources for instructors include a fully worked solutions manual and lecture slides.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 15, 2022•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics Simulations

X. Zotos

This book and the accompanying software (PC Diskette) is a toolbox for performing a set of numerical simulations on simple quantum mechanical problems. It is one in a series of similar books (CUPS) covering different fields in physics from classical mechanics to nuclear and particle physics. Each chapter of the book is written by a different author and deals with a different physical problem. The choice of problems is standard, e.g. bound state and scattering problems in one and three dimensions, quantum mechanical time development; the exceptions are, a study of identical particles and electron states in a one dimensional lattice, an example from solid state physics. Although the chapters are self-contained and can be studied independently (at the expense of some minor duplication of material), care was taken with a uniform style of presentation and similar format in numerical simulations. As a result, it is easy to proceed in the study of the different problems having understood the technical possibilities of one simulation. Each chapter starts with a section presenting the basic theoretical concepts to be studied using the numerical simulation. It is followed by a section with a short description of the numerical technique used and an extensive series of suggestions for problems and quantities to experiment with, using the computer codes provided. A final section describes in detail how to run the computer programs. This book is not, and is not intended to be, a textbook for learning quantum mechanics nor a textbook of numerical analysis. Nevertheless, I find the theoretical presentation clear and straightforward enough for its purpose. The extensive and up to date list of references to books and research articles at the end of each chapter is also very helpful. Technically, I found the software easy to install and, after some initial testing, easy to run. The produced plots are clear and the use of units of atomic dimension gives a touch of reality to the simulations. In contrast to other similar books, this is not a `picture' book of quantum mechanics where results of numerical simulations are illustrated; here the reader is given the necessary means to play and discover for himself the properties of quantum mechanical systems. I believe that this book, used by teachers for demonstrations and students for independent study, provides a versatile tool for numerical experimentation in quantum mechanics.

European Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1996•0 citations

Exercises in Quantum Mechanics: A Collection of Illustrative Problems and Their Solutions

Harry A. Mavromatis

This monograph is written within the framework of the quantum mechanical paradigm. It is modest in scope in that it is restricted to some obser vations and solved illustrative problems not readily available in any of the many standard (and several excellent) texts or books with solved problems that have been written on this subject. Additionally a few more or less standard problems are included for continuity and purposes of comparison. The hope is that the points made and problems solved will give the student some additional insights and a better grasp of this fascinating but mathematically somewhat involved branch of physics. The hundred and fourteen problems discussed have intentionally been chosen to involve a minimum of technical complexity while still illus trating the consequences of the quantum-mechanical formalism. Concerning notation, useful expressions are displayed in rectangular boxes while calculational details which one may wish to skip are included in square brackets.

•Oct 21, 2012•3 citations

Chapter 11. The Finite Square Well

The goal of Quantum Mechanics I, A Problem Text, is to enable students to solve problems appropriate to their first course in quantum mechanics. Significantly detailed solutions to traditionally posed problems dominate. Theory and rationale are addressed in prescript and postscript narratives and/or within the solved problems to guide students; and clarify vocabulary, symbology, and terminology. Applications of the postulates are presented initially using arguments from linear algebra appropriate to discrete systems with low-dimensional vectors and matrix operators, introducing orthogonality, orthonormality, Hermiticity, eigenvectors, eigenvalues, probability, expectation value, and degeneracy. These arguments blend into infinite-dimensional vectors and operators, and calculus-based arguments for continuous systems where delta functions, theta functions, and Fourier transforms are initially discussed. Dirac notation is fully developed within these first five chapters. Chapter six discusses Ehrenfest’s theorem, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations, and Gaussian wave functions and wave packets. Increasingly sophisticated potential energy functions are then treated to include the free particle, the infinite square well, the one-dimensional scattering state, the simple harmonic oscillator, the finite square well, orbital angular momentum, and the hydrogen atom. Ladder operators are featured in the developments of the simple harmonic oscillator and orbital angular momentum. The diversity of narratives and detailed solutions intend

Sciendo eBooks•Sep 1, 2018•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics: A Modern Development

L. E. Ballentine

Although there are many textbooks that deal with the formal apparatus of quantum mechanics (QM) and its application to standard problems, none take into account the developments in the foundations of the subject which have taken place in the last few decades. There are specialized treatises on various aspects of the foundations of QM, but none that integrate those topics with the standard material. This book aims to remove that unfortunate dichotomy, which has divorced the practical aspects of the subject from the interpretation and broader implications of the theory. In this edition a new chapter on quantum information is added. As the topic is still in a state of rapid development, a comprehensive treatment is not feasible. The emphasis is on the fundamental principles and some key applications, including quantum cryptography, teleportation of states, and quantum computing. The impact of quantum information theory on the foundations of quantum mechanics is discussed. In addition, there are minor revisions to several chapters. The book is intended primarily as a graduate level textbook, but it will also be of interest to physicists and philosophers who study the foundations of QM. Parts of it can be used by senior undergraduates too.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 1, 1998•1,020 citations

Understanding quantum phenomena without solving the Schrödinger equation: the case of the finite square well

Victor Bârsan

An approximate formula for the energy levels of the bound states of a particle in a finite square well are obtained, without using the Schrodinger equation. The physics and mathematics involved in this approach are accessible to a gifted high school student.

European Journal of Physics•Aug 28, 2015•4 citations
A contemporary physicist would be hard put to agree entirely with the author of a 1959 textbook on quantum mechanics, who wrote: "A second simple, one-dimensional system, somewhat divorced from reality but illustrative of the principles of the theory, is a particle in a box with finite walls." Interest in this prototypic system has not diminished over the years, and is not likely to do so in the near future, because it has now been wedded to reality and seen as a paradigm for quantum wells and other nanosystems. The treatment of this topic in standard textbooks has changed little over the last few decades, and such changes as have come to our notice leave, in our opinion, much to be desired. The purpose of this article is to enable, even encourage, other teachers to give the finite square well the attention that it deserves; to this end, the authors provide a tutorial review that is more instructive and comprehensive than the accounts presented in numerous textbooks and dispensed in still more numerous online resources, but does not make any additional demands on the mathematical abilities of the student. Given the elemental nature of the topic, the authors claim no originality; with nothing more than the winnowing fork in their hands, they can only clear the threshing floor, gather the wheat into the barn, and let others decide whether or no the chaff should be burnt with unquenchable fire.
This original and innovative textbook takes the unique perspective of introducing and solving problems in quantum mechanics using linear algebra methods, to equip readers with a deeper and more practical understanding of this fundamental pillar of contemporary physics. Extensive motivation for the properties of quantum mechanics, Hilbert space, and the Schrödinger equation is provided through analysis of the derivative, while standard topics like the harmonic oscillator, rotations, and the hydrogen atom are covered from within the context of operator methods. Advanced topics forming the basis of modern physics research are also included, such as the density matrix, entropy, and measures of entanglement. Written for an undergraduate audience, this book offers a unique and mathematically self-contained treatment of this hugely important topic. Students are guided gently through the text by the author's engaging writing style, with an extensive glossary provided for reference and numerous homework problems to expand and develop key concepts. Online resources for instructors include a fully worked solutions manual and lecture slides.
This book and the accompanying software (PC Diskette) is a toolbox for performing a set of numerical simulations on simple quantum mechanical problems. It is one in a series of similar books (CUPS) covering different fields in physics from classical mechanics to nuclear and particle physics. Each chapter of the book is written by a different author and deals with a different physical problem. The choice of problems is standard, e.g. bound state and scattering problems in one and three dimensions, quantum mechanical time development; the exceptions are, a study of identical particles and electron states in a one dimensional lattice, an example from solid state physics. Although the chapters are self-contained and can be studied independently (at the expense of some minor duplication of material), care was taken with a uniform style of presentation and similar format in numerical simulations. As a result, it is easy to proceed in the study of the different problems having understood the technical possibilities of one simulation. Each chapter starts with a section presenting the basic theoretical concepts to be studied using the numerical simulation. It is followed by a section with a short description of the numerical technique used and an extensive series of suggestions for problems and quantities to experiment with, using the computer codes provided. A final section describes in detail how to run the computer programs. This book is not, and is not intended to be, a textbook for learning quantum mechanics nor a textbook of numerical analysis. Nevertheless, I find the theoretical presentation clear and straightforward enough for its purpose. The extensive and up to date list of references to books and research articles at the end of each chapter is also very helpful. Technically, I found the software easy to install and, after some initial testing, easy to run. The produced plots are clear and the use of units of atomic dimension gives a touch of reality to the simulations. In contrast to other similar books, this is not a `picture' book of quantum mechanics where results of numerical simulations are illustrated; here the reader is given the necessary means to play and discover for himself the properties of quantum mechanical systems. I believe that this book, used by teachers for demonstrations and students for independent study, provides a versatile tool for numerical experimentation in quantum mechanics.
This monograph is written within the framework of the quantum mechanical paradigm. It is modest in scope in that it is restricted to some obser vations and solved illustrative problems not readily available in any of the many standard (and several excellent) texts or books with solved problems that have been written on this subject. Additionally a few more or less standard problems are included for continuity and purposes of comparison. The hope is that the points made and problems solved will give the student some additional insights and a better grasp of this fascinating but mathematically somewhat involved branch of physics. The hundred and fourteen problems discussed have intentionally been chosen to involve a minimum of technical complexity while still illus trating the consequences of the quantum-mechanical formalism. Concerning notation, useful expressions are displayed in rectangular boxes while calculational details which one may wish to skip are included in square brackets.
The goal of Quantum Mechanics I, A Problem Text, is to enable students to solve problems appropriate to their first course in quantum mechanics. Significantly detailed solutions to traditionally posed problems dominate. Theory and rationale are addressed in prescript and postscript narratives and/or within the solved problems to guide students; and clarify vocabulary, symbology, and terminology. Applications of the postulates are presented initially using arguments from linear algebra appropriate to discrete systems with low-dimensional vectors and matrix operators, introducing orthogonality, orthonormality, Hermiticity, eigenvectors, eigenvalues, probability, expectation value, and degeneracy. These arguments blend into infinite-dimensional vectors and operators, and calculus-based arguments for continuous systems where delta functions, theta functions, and Fourier transforms are initially discussed. Dirac notation is fully developed within these first five chapters. Chapter six discusses Ehrenfest’s theorem, the Heisenberg uncertainty relations, and Gaussian wave functions and wave packets. Increasingly sophisticated potential energy functions are then treated to include the free particle, the infinite square well, the one-dimensional scattering state, the simple harmonic oscillator, the finite square well, orbital angular momentum, and the hydrogen atom. Ladder operators are featured in the developments of the simple harmonic oscillator and orbital angular momentum. The diversity of narratives and detailed solutions intend
Although there are many textbooks that deal with the formal apparatus of quantum mechanics (QM) and its application to standard problems, none take into account the developments in the foundations of the subject which have taken place in the last few decades. There are specialized treatises on various aspects of the foundations of QM, but none that integrate those topics with the standard material. This book aims to remove that unfortunate dichotomy, which has divorced the practical aspects of the subject from the interpretation and broader implications of the theory. In this edition a new chapter on quantum information is added. As the topic is still in a state of rapid development, a comprehensive treatment is not feasible. The emphasis is on the fundamental principles and some key applications, including quantum cryptography, teleportation of states, and quantum computing. The impact of quantum information theory on the foundations of quantum mechanics is discussed. In addition, there are minor revisions to several chapters. The book is intended primarily as a graduate level textbook, but it will also be of interest to physicists and philosophers who study the foundations of QM. Parts of it can be used by senior undergraduates too.