Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1602.02087 · Physical review. E

Comment on “Nonlocal quartic interactions and universality classes in perovskite manganites”

Hans Werner Diehl

Published Sep 6, 2016• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper [Phys. Rev. E 92, 012123 (2015)], a modified $d$-dimensional ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}^{4}$ model was investigated that differs from the standard one in that the ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}^{4}$ term was replaced by a nonlocal one with a potential $u(\mathbit{x}\ensuremath{-}{\mathbit{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ that depends on a parameter $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and decays exponentially as $|\mathbit{x}\ensuremath{-}{\mathbit{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}}|\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ on a scale ${|m|}^{\ensuremath{-}1}<\ensuremath{\infty}$. The authors claim the upper critical dimension of this model to be ${d}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}=4+2\ensuremath{\sigma}$. Performing a one-loop calculation, they arrive at expansions in powers of ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}={d}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}\ensuremath{-}d$ for critical exponents such as $\ensuremath{\eta}$ and related ones to $O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ whose $O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ coefficients depend on $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and the ratio $w={m}^{2}/{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}^{2}$, where $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}$ is the uv cutoff. It is shown that these claims are unfounded and based on misjudgments and an ill-conceived renormalization-group calculation.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.94.036101

Related papers

Reply to Comment on Nonlocal quartic interactions and universality classes in perovskite manganites

Rohit Singh, Kishore Dutta, Malay Kumar Nandy

Comment [arXiv:cond-mat.stat.mech., 1602.02087v1 (2016)] has raised questions claiming that the nonlocal model Hamiltonian presented in [Phys. Rev. E 92, 012123 (2015)] is equivalent to the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. These claims are based on a low momentum expansion of the interaction vertex that cannot be applied to the vertex factors containing both low and high momenta inside the loop-integrals. Elaborating upon the important steps of the momentum shell decimation scheme, employed in the renormalization-group calculation, we explicitly show the interplay of internal (high) and external (low) momenta determining the loop integrals for self-energy and vertex functions giving rise to corrections (to the bare parameters) different from those of the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. Employing explicit mathematical arguments, we show that this difference persists when the range of interaction is assumed to be long (short) ranged with respect to the lattice constant (correlation-length), yielding the critical exponents as given in the original paper.

arXiv:1608.07404•Aug 26, 2016•0 citations

Critical dynamics of a nonlocal model and critical behavior of perovskite manganites

Rohit Singh, Kishore Dutta, Malay Kumar Nandy

We investigate the nonconserved critical dynamics of a nonlocal model Hamiltonian incorporating screened long-range interactions in the quartic term. Employing dynamic renormalization group analysis at one-loop order, we calculate the dynamic critical exponent $z=2+\ensuremath{\epsilon}{f}_{1}(\ensuremath{\sigma},\ensuremath{\kappa},n)+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ and the linewidth exponent $w=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\sigma}+\ensuremath{\epsilon}{f}_{2}(\ensuremath{\sigma},\ensuremath{\kappa},n)+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ in the leading order of $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}=4\ensuremath{-}d+2\ensuremath{\sigma}$, with $d$ the space dimension, $n$ the number of components in the order parameter, and $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and $\ensuremath{\kappa}$ the parameters coming from the nonlocal interaction term. The resulting values of linewidth exponent $w$ for a wide range of $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ is found to be in good agreement with the existing experimental estimates from spin relaxation measurements in perovskite manganite samples.

Physical review. E•May 18, 2016•5 citations

Nonlocal mode-coupling interactions and phase transition near tricriticality

Rohit Kumar Singh, Kishore Dutta, Malay Kumar Nandy

Employing Wilson's renormalization group scheme, we investigate the critical behaviour of a modified Ginzburg-Landau model with a nonlocal mode-coupling interaction in the quartic term. Carrying out the calculations at one-loop order, we obtain the critical exponents in the leading order of , where ρ is an exponent occurring in the nonlocal interaction term and d is the space dimension. Interestingly, the correlation exponent η is found to be non-zero at one-loop order and the expansion corresponds to an expansion about the tricritical mean-field theory in three dimensions, unlike the conventional theory. The ensuing critical exponents are in good agreement with experimental values for samples close to tricriticality. Our analysis indicates that tricriticality is a feature only in three dimensions.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Apr 1, 2015•8 citations

Comment on “Random-Field Spin Models beyond 1 Loop: A Mechanism for Decreasing the Lower Critical Dimension”

Yoshinori Sakamoto, Hisamitsu Mukaida, Chigak Itoi

A comment on the Letter by Le Doussal and Wiese, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 197202 (2006).

arXiv:cond-mat/0612476•Physical Review Letters•Jun 29, 2007•5 citations

Comment on "High Precision Measurement of the Thermal Exponent for the three-dimensional XY Universality Class"

K. S. D. Beach

A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.

arXiv:cond-mat/0507541•Jul 22, 2005•5 citations

A new functional renormalization group syudy of universality classes with O(N) symmetry

Beretta Tassano, Piero Sebastian

The functional renormalization group (FRG) is a powerful tool that has facilitated the investigation of various strongly interacting theories, encompassing systems characterized by both bosonic and fermionic variables. Specifically, this project focuses on the analysis of theories with O(N) symmetry with bosonic scalar fields. These theories are of particular interest due to their broad applicability in real physical systems. For example, Z2 symmetry (the O(1) model) describes the well-known Ising universality class, which in turn models the liquid-gas transition. On the other hand, the O(2) model belongs to the universality class of the XY model, used to describe the transition from fluid to superfluid in 4 He, while the O(3) model, known as the Heisenberg model, describes the ferromagnetic transition in isotropic materials. Finally the O(0) model is related to the self-avoiding walk (SAW). To characterize these theories, various methods have been implemented within the framework of the renormalization group. Perturbation theory has been applied since the early days of the subject, specifically in the form of the ε-expansion, which has reached high loop order in recent years. Alternatively, a non-perturbative approach can be chosen, which is known as the non-perturbative renormalization group (NPRG). Within the NPRG, there are several approximation schemes, with the derivative expansion being particularly noteworthy. The ultimate goal of these efforts is to calculate the critical exponents, which define the given universality class. The standard non-perturbative method involves solving an equation that depends on a regulator or cut-off, which represents one of the main challenges of this approach. Although the regulators are designed so that the theory does not depend on them at the scales of interest, the results for the critical exponents can vary depending on the regulator used once approximations are made. In this project, we propose an approach that eliminates the need for an explicit mass cut-off significantly simplifying the calculation of critical exponents while mitigating the regulator dependence of the results. In particular, we show that it is possible to use dimensional regularization (DR) beyond the ε-expansion in the context of RG calculations of critical properties. Based on this we propose a new functional RG scheme called Functional Dimensional Regularization (FDR) and apply it to the O(N) model in three dimension, finding excellent agreement with state-of-the-art computations

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations
In a recent paper [Phys. Rev. E 92, 012123 (2015)], a modified ddd-dimensional \ensuremathΦ4{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}^{4}\ensuremathΦ4 model was investigated that differs from the standard one in that the \ensuremathΦ4{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}^{4}\ensuremathΦ4 term was replaced by a nonlocal one with a potential u(\mathbitx\ensuremath−\mathbitx\ensuremath′)u(\mathbit{x}\ensuremath{-}{\mathbit{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}})u(\mathbitx\ensuremath−\mathbitx\ensuremath′) that depends on a parameter \ensuremathσ\ensuremath{\sigma}\ensuremathσ and decays exponentially as ∣\mathbitx\ensuremath−\mathbitx\ensuremath′∣\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞|\mathbit{x}\ensuremath{-}{\mathbit{x}}^{\ensuremath{'}}|\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}∣\mathbitx\ensuremath−\mathbitx\ensuremath′∣\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞ on a scale ∣m∣\ensuremath−1<\ensuremath∞{|m|}^{\ensuremath{-}1}<\ensuremath{\infty}∣m∣\ensuremath−1<\ensuremath∞. The authors claim the upper critical dimension of this model to be d\ensuremathσ=4+2\ensuremathσ{d}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}=4+2\ensuremath{\sigma}d\ensuremathσ​=4+2\ensuremathσ. Performing a one-loop calculation, they arrive at expansions in powers of \ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ=d\ensuremathσ\ensuremath−d{\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}={d}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}\ensuremath{-}d\ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ​=d\ensuremathσ​\ensuremath−d for critical exponents such as \ensuremathη\ensuremath{\eta}\ensuremathη and related ones to O(\ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ)O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}})O(\ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ​) whose O(\ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ)O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}})O(\ensuremathϵ\ensuremathσ​) coefficients depend on \ensuremathσ\ensuremath{\sigma}\ensuremathσ and the ratio w=m2/\ensuremathΛ2w={m}^{2}/{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}}^{2}w=m2/\ensuremathΛ2, where \ensuremathΛ\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}\ensuremathΛ is the uv cutoff. It is shown that these claims are unfounded and based on misjudgments and an ill-conceived renormalization-group calculation.
Comment [arXiv:cond-mat.stat.mech., 1602.02087v1 (2016)] has raised questions claiming that the nonlocal model Hamiltonian presented in [Phys. Rev. E 92, 012123 (2015)] is equivalent to the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. These claims are based on a low momentum expansion of the interaction vertex that cannot be applied to the vertex factors containing both low and high momenta inside the loop-integrals. Elaborating upon the important steps of the momentum shell decimation scheme, employed in the renormalization-group calculation, we explicitly show the interplay of internal (high) and external (low) momenta determining the loop integrals for self-energy and vertex functions giving rise to corrections (to the bare parameters) different from those of the standard (short-ranged) Φ^4 theory. Employing explicit mathematical arguments, we show that this difference persists when the range of interaction is assumed to be long (short) ranged with respect to the lattice constant (correlation-length), yielding the critical exponents as given in the original paper.
We investigate the nonconserved critical dynamics of a nonlocal model Hamiltonian incorporating screened long-range interactions in the quartic term. Employing dynamic renormalization group analysis at one-loop order, we calculate the dynamic critical exponent $z=2+\ensuremath{\epsilon}{f}_{1}(\ensuremath{\sigma},\ensuremath{\kappa},n)+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ and the linewidth exponent $w=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\sigma}+\ensuremath{\epsilon}{f}_{2}(\ensuremath{\sigma},\ensuremath{\kappa},n)+O({\ensuremath{\epsilon}}^{2})$ in the leading order of $\ensuremath{\epsilon}$, where $\ensuremath{\epsilon}=4\ensuremath{-}d+2\ensuremath{\sigma}$, with ddd the space dimension, nnn the number of components in the order parameter, and $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ and $\ensuremath{\kappa}$ the parameters coming from the nonlocal interaction term. The resulting values of linewidth exponent www for a wide range of $\ensuremath{\sigma}$ is found to be in good agreement with the existing experimental estimates from spin relaxation measurements in perovskite manganite samples.
Employing Wilson's renormalization group scheme, we investigate the critical behaviour of a modified Ginzburg-Landau model with a nonlocal mode-coupling interaction in the quartic term. Carrying out the calculations at one-loop order, we obtain the critical exponents in the leading order of , where ρ is an exponent occurring in the nonlocal interaction term and d is the space dimension. Interestingly, the correlation exponent η is found to be non-zero at one-loop order and the expansion corresponds to an expansion about the tricritical mean-field theory in three dimensions, unlike the conventional theory. The ensuing critical exponents are in good agreement with experimental values for samples close to tricriticality. Our analysis indicates that tricriticality is a feature only in three dimensions.
A recent paper [Burovski et al., cond-mat/0507352] reports on a new, high-accuracy simulation of the classical phi^4 model (in the three-dimensional XY universality class). The authors claim that a careful scaling analysis of their data gives nu = 0.6711(1) for the thermal critical exponent. If correct, this would neatly resolve the discrepancy between numerical simulations and experiments on 4He. There is reason, however, to doubt the accuracy of the result. A re-analysis of the data yields a significantly higher value of nu, one that is consistent with other Monte Carlo studies.
The functional renormalization group (FRG) is a powerful tool that has facilitated the investigation of various strongly interacting theories, encompassing systems characterized by both bosonic and fermionic variables. Specifically, this project focuses on the analysis of theories with O(N) symmetry with bosonic scalar fields. These theories are of particular interest due to their broad applicability in real physical systems. For example, Z2 symmetry (the O(1) model) describes the well-known Ising universality class, which in turn models the liquid-gas transition. On the other hand, the O(2) model belongs to the universality class of the XY model, used to describe the transition from fluid to superfluid in 4 He, while the O(3) model, known as the Heisenberg model, describes the ferromagnetic transition in isotropic materials. Finally the O(0) model is related to the self-avoiding walk (SAW). To characterize these theories, various methods have been implemented within the framework of the renormalization group. Perturbation theory has been applied since the early days of the subject, specifically in the form of the ε-expansion, which has reached high loop order in recent years. Alternatively, a non-perturbative approach can be chosen, which is known as the non-perturbative renormalization group (NPRG). Within the NPRG, there are several approximation schemes, with the derivative expansion being particularly noteworthy. The ultimate goal of these efforts is to calculate the critical exponents, which define the given universality class. The standard non-perturbative method involves solving an equation that depends on a regulator or cut-off, which represents one of the main challenges of this approach. Although the regulators are designed so that the theory does not depend on them at the scales of interest, the results for the critical exponents can vary depending on the regulator used once approximations are made. In this project, we propose an approach that eliminates the need for an explicit mass cut-off significantly simplifying the calculation of critical exponents while mitigating the regulator dependence of the results. In particular, we show that it is possible to use dimensional regularization (DR) beyond the ε-expansion in the context of RG calculations of critical properties. Based on this we propose a new functional RG scheme called Functional Dimensional Regularization (FDR) and apply it to the O(N) model in three dimension, finding excellent agreement with state-of-the-art computations