Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1509.05547

Realism-Completeness-Universality interpretation of quantum mechanics

Petr Hájíček

Published Sep 18, 2015• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The paper reviews and discusses four ideas scattered in previous papers of the author. First, objective properties of quantum systems are not associated with observables but are defined by preparations. Second, measurable results of classical theories are not sharp. All such results can be obtained as high-entropy limits of quantum mechanics. Third, a careful study of exchange symmetry requires a modification of the theory of measurement. Fourth, screens and detectors are closely associated with state reduction. A new, rather improved understanding of quantum mechanics is achieved without any deep changes of the theory itself. In the framework of a model approach to the philosophy of science, the RCU interpretation is developed step by step by adding specific supplementary hypotheses to the Minimum Interpretation of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1509.05547

Related papers

Quantum Models of Classical World

Petr Hájíček

This paper is a review of our recent work on three notorious problems of non-relativistic quantum mechanics: realist interpretation, quantum theory of classical properties, and the problem of quantum measurement. A considerable progress has been achieved, based on four distinct new ideas. First, objective properties are associated with states rather than with values of observables. Second, all classical properties are selected properties of certain high entropy quantum states of macroscopic systems. Third, registration of a quantum system is strongly disturbed by systems of the same type in the environment. Fourth, detectors must be distinguished from ancillas and the states of registered systems are partially dissipated and lost in the detectors. The paper has two aims: a clear explanation of all new results and a coherent and contradiction-free account of the whole quantum mechanics including all necessary changes of its current textbook version.

arXiv:1212.2400•Entropy•Feb 27, 2013•2 citations

Emergence of classical theories from quantum mechanics

Petr Hájíček

Three problems stand in the way of deriving classical theories from quantum mechanics: those of realist interpretation, of classical properties and of quantum measurement. Recently, we have identified some tacit assumptions that lie at the roots of these problems. Thus, a realist interpretation is hindered by the assumption that the only properties of quantum systems are values of observables. If one simply postulates the properties to be objective that are uniquely defined by preparation then all difficulties disappear. As for classical properties, the wrong assumption is that there are arbitrarily sharp classical trajectories. It turns out that fuzzy classical trajectories can be obtained from quantum mechanics by taking the limit of high entropy. Finally, standard quantum mechanics implies that any registration on a quantum system is disturbed by all quantum systems of the same kind existing somewhere in the universe. If one works out systematically how quantum mechanics must be corrected so that there is no such disturbance, one finds a new interpretation of von Neumann's "first kind of dynamics", and so a new way to a solution of the quantum measurement problem. The present paper gives a very short review of this work.

arXiv:1201.0615•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 10, 2012•1 citation

Realist model approach to quantum mechanics

Petr Hájíček

The paper proves that quantum mechanics is compatible with the constructive realism of modern philosophy of science. The proof is based on the observation that properties of quantum systems that are uniquely determined by their preparations can be assumed objective without the difficulties that are encountered by the same assumption about values of observables. The resulting realist interpretation of quantum mechanics is made rigorous by studying the space of quantum states—the convex set of state operators. Prepared states are classified according to their statistical structure into indecomposable and decomposable instead of pure and mixed. Simple objective properties are defined and showed to form a Boolean lattice.

arXiv:1212.4631•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 10, 2013•1 citation

Properties, states, measurement outcomes and effective states

Pieter E. Vermaas

Starting with a more philosophical review, I discuss how modal interpretations describe reality. Firstly, it is shown that they describe states of affairs which need not be observable. Secondly, I underpin my position that in order to be metaphysically tenable, interpretations need only to satisfy the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Thirdly, I analyse how properties, states and measurement outcomes are related to one another within the modal descriptions of reality. Finally, I show how modal interpretations recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics if one defines, in addition to the true states, so-called effective states of systems. Noumenal states of affairs The aim of an interpretation of quantum mechanics is, as I said in the introduction, to provide a description of what reality would be like if quantum mechanics were true. This formulation underlines two aspects of interpretations. Firstly, interpretations intend to construe quantum mechanics in terms of a description of reality and not merely in terms of the outcomes of measurements. Secondly, this description need not be correct. The objective is only to prove that there exists a construal of quantum mechanics which yields an acceptable description of reality. And because it is already difficult enough to give such a proof of existence, it is not (yet) the aim of interpretations to provide the one and only correct description of reality. The above formulation, however, disregards another aspect of interpretations of quantum mechanics, namely that they describe states of affairs which need not always be observable.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations

A Philosopher's Understanding of Quantum Mechanics: Possibilities and Impossibilities of a Modal Interpretation

Pieter E. Vermaas

This book is about how to understand quantum mechanics by means of a modal interpretation. Modal interpretations provide a general framework within which quantum mechanics can be considered as a theory that describes reality in terms of physical systems possessing definite properties. Quantum mechanics is standardly understood to be a theory about probabilities with which measurements have outcomes. Modal interpretations are relatively new attempts to present quantum mechanics as a theory which, like other physical theories, describes an observer-independent reality. In this book, Pieter Vermaas summarises the results of this work. The book will be of great value to undergraduates, graduate students and researchers in philosophy of science, and physics departments with an interest in learning about modal interpretations of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2000•7 citations

On a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics

Arnold Neumaier

The best mathematical arguments against a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics - that gives definite but partially unknown values to all observables - are analysed and shown to be based on reasoning that is not compelling. This opens the door for an interpretation that, while respecting the indeterministic nature of quantum mechanics, allows to speak of definite values for all observables at any time that are, however, only partially measurable. The analysis also suggests new ways to test the foundations of quantum theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908071•Aug 22, 1999•1 citation
The paper reviews and discusses four ideas scattered in previous papers of the author. First, objective properties of quantum systems are not associated with observables but are defined by preparations. Second, measurable results of classical theories are not sharp. All such results can be obtained as high-entropy limits of quantum mechanics. Third, a careful study of exchange symmetry requires a modification of the theory of measurement. Fourth, screens and detectors are closely associated with state reduction. A new, rather improved understanding of quantum mechanics is achieved without any deep changes of the theory itself. In the framework of a model approach to the philosophy of science, the RCU interpretation is developed step by step by adding specific supplementary hypotheses to the Minimum Interpretation of quantum mechanics.
This paper is a review of our recent work on three notorious problems of non-relativistic quantum mechanics: realist interpretation, quantum theory of classical properties, and the problem of quantum measurement. A considerable progress has been achieved, based on four distinct new ideas. First, objective properties are associated with states rather than with values of observables. Second, all classical properties are selected properties of certain high entropy quantum states of macroscopic systems. Third, registration of a quantum system is strongly disturbed by systems of the same type in the environment. Fourth, detectors must be distinguished from ancillas and the states of registered systems are partially dissipated and lost in the detectors. The paper has two aims: a clear explanation of all new results and a coherent and contradiction-free account of the whole quantum mechanics including all necessary changes of its current textbook version.
Three problems stand in the way of deriving classical theories from quantum mechanics: those of realist interpretation, of classical properties and of quantum measurement. Recently, we have identified some tacit assumptions that lie at the roots of these problems. Thus, a realist interpretation is hindered by the assumption that the only properties of quantum systems are values of observables. If one simply postulates the properties to be objective that are uniquely defined by preparation then all difficulties disappear. As for classical properties, the wrong assumption is that there are arbitrarily sharp classical trajectories. It turns out that fuzzy classical trajectories can be obtained from quantum mechanics by taking the limit of high entropy. Finally, standard quantum mechanics implies that any registration on a quantum system is disturbed by all quantum systems of the same kind existing somewhere in the universe. If one works out systematically how quantum mechanics must be corrected so that there is no such disturbance, one finds a new interpretation of von Neumann's "first kind of dynamics", and so a new way to a solution of the quantum measurement problem. The present paper gives a very short review of this work.
The paper proves that quantum mechanics is compatible with the constructive realism of modern philosophy of science. The proof is based on the observation that properties of quantum systems that are uniquely determined by their preparations can be assumed objective without the difficulties that are encountered by the same assumption about values of observables. The resulting realist interpretation of quantum mechanics is made rigorous by studying the space of quantum states—the convex set of state operators. Prepared states are classified according to their statistical structure into indecomposable and decomposable instead of pure and mixed. Simple objective properties are defined and showed to form a Boolean lattice.
Starting with a more philosophical review, I discuss how modal interpretations describe reality. Firstly, it is shown that they describe states of affairs which need not be observable. Secondly, I underpin my position that in order to be metaphysically tenable, interpretations need only to satisfy the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Thirdly, I analyse how properties, states and measurement outcomes are related to one another within the modal descriptions of reality. Finally, I show how modal interpretations recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics if one defines, in addition to the true states, so-called effective states of systems. Noumenal states of affairs The aim of an interpretation of quantum mechanics is, as I said in the introduction, to provide a description of what reality would be like if quantum mechanics were true. This formulation underlines two aspects of interpretations. Firstly, interpretations intend to construe quantum mechanics in terms of a description of reality and not merely in terms of the outcomes of measurements. Secondly, this description need not be correct. The objective is only to prove that there exists a construal of quantum mechanics which yields an acceptable description of reality. And because it is already difficult enough to give such a proof of existence, it is not (yet) the aim of interpretations to provide the one and only correct description of reality. The above formulation, however, disregards another aspect of interpretations of quantum mechanics, namely that they describe states of affairs which need not always be observable.
This book is about how to understand quantum mechanics by means of a modal interpretation. Modal interpretations provide a general framework within which quantum mechanics can be considered as a theory that describes reality in terms of physical systems possessing definite properties. Quantum mechanics is standardly understood to be a theory about probabilities with which measurements have outcomes. Modal interpretations are relatively new attempts to present quantum mechanics as a theory which, like other physical theories, describes an observer-independent reality. In this book, Pieter Vermaas summarises the results of this work. The book will be of great value to undergraduates, graduate students and researchers in philosophy of science, and physics departments with an interest in learning about modal interpretations of quantum mechanics.
The best mathematical arguments against a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics - that gives definite but partially unknown values to all observables - are analysed and shown to be based on reasoning that is not compelling. This opens the door for an interpretation that, while respecting the indeterministic nature of quantum mechanics, allows to speak of definite values for all observables at any time that are, however, only partially measurable. The analysis also suggests new ways to test the foundations of quantum theory.