This article was written for the Logic in Computer Science column in the February 2015 issue of the Bulletin of the European Association for Theoretical Computer Science. The intended audience is general computer science audience. The uncertainty principle asserts a limit to the precision with which position x and momentum p of a particle can be known simultaneously. You may know the probability distributions of x and p individually but the joint distribution makes no physical sense. Yet Wigner exhibited such a joint distribution f(x,p). There was, however, a little trouble with it: some of its values were negative. Nevertheless Wigner's discovery attracted attention and found applications. There are other joint distribution, all with negative values, which produce the correct marginal distributions of x and p. But only Wigner's distribution produces the correct marginal distributions for all linear combinations of position and momentum. We offer a simple proof of the uniqueness and discuss related issues.
This article was written for the Logic in Computer Science column in the February 2015 issue of the Bulletin of the European Association for Theoretical Computer Science. The intended audience is general computer science audience. The uncertainty principle asserts a limit to the precision with which position x and momentum p of a particle can be known simultaneously. You may know the probability distributions of x and p individually but the joint distribution makes no physical sense. Yet Wigner exhibited such a joint distribution f(x,p). There was, however, a little trouble with it: some of its values were negative. Nevertheless Wigner's discovery attracted attention and found applications. There are other joint distribution, all with negative values, which produce the correct marginal distributions of x and p. But only Wigner's distribution produces the correct marginal distributions for all linear combinations of position and momentum. We offer a simple proof of the uniqueness and discuss related issues.
Abstract An observation space S is a family of probability distributions P i : i ∈ I sharing a common sample space Ω in a consistent way. A grounding for S is a signed probability distribution P on Ω yielding the correct marginal distribution P i for every i . A wide variety of quantum scenarios can be formalized as observation spaces. We describe all groundings for a number of quantum observation spaces. Our main technical result is a rigorous proof that Wigner’s distribution is the unique signed probability distribution yielding the correct marginal distributions for position and momentum and all their linear combinations.
We show that for any collection of hermitian operators A1...An , and any quantum state there is a unique joint distribution on R^n, with the property that the marginals of all linear combinations of the operators coincide with their quantum counterpart. We call it the Wigner distribution, because for position and momentum this property defines the standard Wigner function. In this note we discuss the application to finite dimensional systems, establish many basic properties and illustrate these by examples. The properties include the support, the location of singularities, positivity, the behaviour under symmetry groups, and informational completeness.
In 1932 Eugene Wigner rewrote the quantum state as a function W(x,p) on classical phase space that returns the exact position and momentum marginals, and founded the quantum-correction programme for thermodynamic equilibrium. I credit that paper at full strength: the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics is exact, its marginals are theorems — re-verified on my own bench to grid grade — and Moyal later recognised the function as the generating object of the full phase-space formalism. Nothing in this paper falsifies the construction or its marginals. What I evaluate is the statistical interpretation used on the object. The function takes negative values — it fails the defining property of a probability density — and no step in 1932 derives why an object failing that property may carry the statistical interpretation the paper puts on it; Wigner himself conceded the function cannot be really interpreted as the simultaneous probability for coordinates and momenta, and asked that this must not hinder its use as an auxiliary function. The negativity is accepted as the cost of the marginals, and the acceptance is the postulate. My bench evaluates that acceptance on declared inputs only. The Gaussian ground state contributes nothing: negative mass 0.000000, total variation 1.000000. The first excited state carries W(0,0) = −0.318310 and a negative mass of 0.213061 exactly (2e^(−1/2) − 1; 0.213062 on the declared grid), with total variation 1.426123. Even cat states carry negative mass 0.021753 at separation 2, 0.223787 at separation 4 and 0.300094 at separation 6 — growing with the interference the state carries. Counted plainly: 1 accepted quasi-probability against 0 derivations in 1932. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**
One of the most profound and unsettling discoveries of the twentieth century is that nature imposes fundamental limits on what we can know about the physical world. This is the essence of the Uncertainty Principle , formulated by Werner Heisenberg in 1927 [Heisenberg (1927)]. The principle states that certain pairs of physical properties cannot be known simultaneously with arbitrary precision. The most famous example is that the more precisely we know a particle's position, the less precisely we can know its momentum, and vice versa as shown in Fig. 12.1. This is not a limitation of our measuring instruments or experimental technique—it is a fundamental property of nature itself at the quantum scale.
The fundamental problem considered is that of the existence of a joint probability distribution for momentum and position at a given instant. The philosophical interest of this problem is that for the potential energy functions (or Hamiltonians) corresponding to many simple experimental situations, the joint “distribution” derived by the methods of Wigner and Moyal is not a genuine probability distribution at all. The implications of these results for the interpretation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle are analyzed. The final section consists of some observations concerning the axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics.
Standard-deviation and entropic formulations of uncertainty principle capture the spread of the probability distribution but say little about the probability itself contained in a small region. We introduce the confidence uncertainty Δcx(θx) as the minimal Lebesgue measure of the support set in which the particle is found with probability at least θx, and the companion interval confidence uncertainty ΔIx(θx) which restricts the support to a single interval. We prove two complementary uncertainty inequalities. (i) For θx+θp≤1 both confidence uncertainties can be made arbitrarily small simultaneously, so that no nontrivial product bound holds; in particular, position and momentum can be jointly localised with probability at least~50%. (ii) For θx+θp>1 a lower bound holds: combining Lenard's projection inequality with the Donoho--Stark operator-norm bound we obtain ΔcxΔcp≥2πℏ(θxθp−(1−θx)(1−θp))2, and for the interval version we obtain the sharp implicit Landau--Pollak bound ΔIxΔIp≥4ℏλ0−1((θxθp−(1−θx)(1−θp))2), where λ0(c) is the largest prolate-spheroidal eigenvalue. We support the analytical bounds with numerical evaluation of λ0(c), provide closed-form small-c and large-c asymptotics, compute the optimal Slepian-superposition states that saturate the interval bound, and compare the resulting product against the variance Heisenberg--Kennard, the Białynicki-Birula--Mycielski entropic, and the Donoho--Stark concentration bounds. The unified picture provides a complete phase diagram on (θx,θp)∈[0,1]2.