Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Distribution That Goes Negative: Wigner's Phase-Space Function, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 6, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In 1932 Eugene Wigner rewrote the quantum state as a function W(x,p) on classical phase space that returns the exact position and momentum marginals, and founded the quantum-correction programme for thermodynamic equilibrium. I credit that paper at full strength: the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics is exact, its marginals are theorems — re-verified on my own bench to grid grade — and Moyal later recognised the function as the generating object of the full phase-space formalism. Nothing in this paper falsifies the construction or its marginals. What I evaluate is the statistical interpretation used on the object. The function takes negative values — it fails the defining property of a probability density — and no step in 1932 derives why an object failing that property may carry the statistical interpretation the paper puts on it; Wigner himself conceded the function cannot be really interpreted as the simultaneous probability for coordinates and momenta, and asked that this must not hinder its use as an auxiliary function. The negativity is accepted as the cost of the marginals, and the acceptance is the postulate. My bench evaluates that acceptance on declared inputs only. The Gaussian ground state contributes nothing: negative mass 0.000000, total variation 1.000000. The first excited state carries W(0,0) = −0.318310 and a negative mass of 0.213061 exactly (2e^(−1/2) − 1; 0.213062 on the declared grid), with total variation 1.426123. Even cat states carry negative mass 0.021753 at separation 2, 0.223787 at separation 4 and 0.300094 at separation 6 — growing with the interference the state carries. Counted plainly: 1 accepted quasi-probability against 0 derivations in 1932. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23998833

Related papers

The Wigner Distribution

Robert F. O’Connell

In contrast to classical physics, the language of quantum mechanics involves operators and wave functions (or, more generally, density operators). However, in 1932, Wigner formulated quantum mechanics in terms of a distribution function $W(q,p)$, the marginals of which yield the correct quantum probabilities for $q$ and $p$ separately \cite{wigner}. Its usefulness stems from the fact that it provides a re-expression of quantum mechanics in terms of classical concepts so that quantum mechanical expectation values are now expressed as averages over phase-space distribution functions. In other words, statistical information is transferred from the density operator to a quasi-classical (distribution) function.

arXiv:1009.4431•Sep 22, 2010•2 citations

Weighted Phase-Space Paths for Exact Wigner Dynamics

Surachate Limkumnerd, Panat Phanthaphanitkul

A quantum state can be written in phase space, but the resulting object is not generally the probability density of a positive stochastic process on ordinary phase space. We spell this out for Wigner dynamics. If a positive phase-space process is required only to reproduce the Born density after integrating over momentum, the requirement fixes only an integrated current; the local drift and diffusion remain underdetermined. If one instead requires all Weyl-ordered expectation values, the phase-space object is fixed to be the Wigner function. For non-quadratic potentials the Wigner--Moyal generator contains higher-order, signed momentum-transfer terms, so it is not the Fokker--Planck generator of a positive Brownian diffusion. The exact Wigner function must therefore be reconstructed, in a stochastic representation, as a weighted empirical measure \[ \FW(\z,t)=\E_{\Pp}[W_tδ(\z-\z_t)], \qquad \z=(q,p), \] rather than the unweighted density of sampled carrier trajectories. With classical Hamiltonian flow as the carrier, all nonclassical correction beyond classical transport sits in the Moyal residual and can be represented by signed weights or branching events. The same split defines a residual diagnostic that vanishes for quadratic Hamiltonians and measures what classical carrier transport misses in anharmonic dynamics. The formulation also gives a forward--reverse relation for signed Wigner path measures. The ratio of forward and reversed contributions separates into a positive magnitude factor and a sign factor. This sign records the parity of the Wigner interference contribution; it is not a thermodynamic entropy production.

quant-pharXiv:2605.05764•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Phase Space Representations and Their Negativities

Ninnat Dangniam

A classical simulation scheme of quantum computation given a restricted set of states and measurements may be---occasionally, but only occasionally---interpreted naturally as a statistical simulation of positive quasi-probability distributions on a phase space. In this dissertation, we explore phase space representations for finite-dimensional quantum systems and their negativities beyond the usual analogues of the Wigner function. The first line of study focuses on a characterization tool for valid quasi-probability distributions of (possibly mixed) quantum states. A quantum generalization of Bochner's theorem from classical probability theory simultaneously characterizes both the set of valid Wigner functions and the subset of positive ones. We extend this theorem to discrete phase spaces based on projective representations of abelian groups, including the discrete Wigner functions of Gross (J. Math. Phys. 47, 122107 (2006)) and Gibbons et al. (Phys. Rev. A 70, 062101 (2004)). The rest of the dissertation is then dedicated to phase space representations covariant with respect to a general Lie group. This means, in particular, that operators that lie in the same orbit of the group have the same amount of negativity in their quasi-probabilities---a natural requirement if one would like to interpret negativity as non-classicality, and the group action as a classical dynamics. We show that the construction due to Brif and Mann (Phys. Rev. A 59, 971 (1999)) of group covariant phase space representations satisfying the so-called Stratonovich-Weyl correspondence is essentially unique, given the group and an input state in the relevant representation. As an application, we construct quasi-probability representations on a compact phase space of fermionic Gaussian states tailored to a classically simulatable problem of fermionic linear optics and find that, in the first non-trivial case of four fermionic modes, the quasi-probabilities of the Gaussian states exhibit a considerable amount of negativity.

•Jan 1, 2018•1 citation

Time evolution of the Wigner function

Francisco Soto, P. Claverie

In this paper we give a partial answer to the problem: When does an initially non-negative Wigner function remain non-negative under the effect of the time evolution? We show that, for pure states, this is the case for linear systems only; to prove this we use the fact that the Wigner function is non-negative if and only if the wavefunction is Gaussian. We also prove that the Green’s solution of the evolution equation of the Wigner function, which in the framework of probability theory corresponds to the conditional probability density, takes on negative values. We utilize a theorem, about moments, borrowed from Pawula. We conclude that the Wigner phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics cannot receive a genuine probabilistic interpretation.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1983•22 citations

Weyl quantization and Wigner distributions on phase space

R. Wezeman

This thesis describes quantum mechanics in the phase space formulation. We introduce quantization and in particular the Weyl quantization. We study a general class of phase space distribution functions on phase space. The Wigner distribution function is one such distribution function. The Wigner distribution function in general attains negative values and thus can not be interpreted as a real probability density, as opposed to for example the Husimi distribution function. The Husimi distribution however does not yield the correct marginal distribution functions known from quantum mechanics. Properties of the Wigner and Husimi distribution function are studied to more extent. We calculate the Wigner and Husimi distribution function for the energy eigenstates of a particle trapped in a box. We then look at the semi classical limit for this example. The time evolution of Wigner functions are studied by making use of the Moyal bracket. The Moyal bracket and the Poisson bracket are compared in the classical limit. The phase space formulation of quantum mechanics has as advantage that classical concepts can be studied and compared to quantum mechanics. For certain quantum mechanical systems the time evolution of Wigner distribution functions becomes equivalent to the classical time evolution stated in the exact Egerov theorem. Another advantage of using Wigner functions is when one is interested in systems involving mixed states. A disadvantage of the phase space formulation is that for most problems it quickly loses its simplicity and becomes hard to calculate.

•Jan 1, 2014•2 citations

Probabilistic aspects of the Wigner function

Constantin V. Usenko

The Wigner function of quantum systems is an effective instrument for constructing an approximate classical description of the systems for which the classical approximation is possible. In recent years, the Wigner function formalism has been applied as well to seek indications of specific quantum properties of quantum systems leading to the impossibility of constructing the classical approximation. Used most of all as such an indication is the existence of negative values in the Wigner function for specific states of the quantum system being studied. The existence of such values itself prejudices the probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function, though for an arbitrary observable depending jointly on the coordinate and the momentum of the quantum system just the Wigner function provides an effective instrument for calculating the average value and the other statistical characteristics. In this paper, a probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function based on coordinating a theoretical probabilistic definition of the probability density, with restrictions to a physically small domain of phase space due to the uncertainty principle, is proposed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406238•Optics and Spectroscopy•Sep 1, 2005•3 citations
In 1932 Eugene Wigner rewrote the quantum state as a function W(x,p) on classical phase space that returns the exact position and momentum marginals, and founded the quantum-correction programme for thermodynamic equilibrium. I credit that paper at full strength: the phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics is exact, its marginals are theorems — re-verified on my own bench to grid grade — and Moyal later recognised the function as the generating object of the full phase-space formalism. Nothing in this paper falsifies the construction or its marginals. What I evaluate is the statistical interpretation used on the object. The function takes negative values — it fails the defining property of a probability density — and no step in 1932 derives why an object failing that property may carry the statistical interpretation the paper puts on it; Wigner himself conceded the function cannot be really interpreted as the simultaneous probability for coordinates and momenta, and asked that this must not hinder its use as an auxiliary function. The negativity is accepted as the cost of the marginals, and the acceptance is the postulate. My bench evaluates that acceptance on declared inputs only. The Gaussian ground state contributes nothing: negative mass 0.000000, total variation 1.000000. The first excited state carries W(0,0) = −0.318310 and a negative mass of 0.213061 exactly (2e^(−1/2) − 1; 0.213062 on the declared grid), with total variation 1.426123. Even cat states carry negative mass 0.021753 at separation 2, 0.223787 at separation 4 and 0.300094 at separation 6 — growing with the interference the state carries. Counted plainly: 1 accepted quasi-probability against 0 derivations in 1932. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
In contrast to classical physics, the language of quantum mechanics involves operators and wave functions (or, more generally, density operators). However, in 1932, Wigner formulated quantum mechanics in terms of a distribution function W(q,p)W(q,p)W(q,p), the marginals of which yield the correct quantum probabilities for qqq and ppp separately \cite{wigner}. Its usefulness stems from the fact that it provides a re-expression of quantum mechanics in terms of classical concepts so that quantum mechanical expectation values are now expressed as averages over phase-space distribution functions. In other words, statistical information is transferred from the density operator to a quasi-classical (distribution) function.
A quantum state can be written in phase space, but the resulting object is not generally the probability density of a positive stochastic process on ordinary phase space. We spell this out for Wigner dynamics. If a positive phase-space process is required only to reproduce the Born density after integrating over momentum, the requirement fixes only an integrated current; the local drift and diffusion remain underdetermined. If one instead requires all Weyl-ordered expectation values, the phase-space object is fixed to be the Wigner function. For non-quadratic potentials the Wigner--Moyal generator contains higher-order, signed momentum-transfer terms, so it is not the Fokker--Planck generator of a positive Brownian diffusion. The exact Wigner function must therefore be reconstructed, in a stochastic representation, as a weighted empirical measure \[ \FW(\z,t)=\E_{\Pp}[W_tδ(\z-\z_t)], \qquad \z=(q,p), \] rather than the unweighted density of sampled carrier trajectories. With classical Hamiltonian flow as the carrier, all nonclassical correction beyond classical transport sits in the Moyal residual and can be represented by signed weights or branching events. The same split defines a residual diagnostic that vanishes for quadratic Hamiltonians and measures what classical carrier transport misses in anharmonic dynamics. The formulation also gives a forward--reverse relation for signed Wigner path measures. The ratio of forward and reversed contributions separates into a positive magnitude factor and a sign factor. This sign records the parity of the Wigner interference contribution; it is not a thermodynamic entropy production.
A classical simulation scheme of quantum computation given a restricted set of states and measurements may be---occasionally, but only occasionally---interpreted naturally as a statistical simulation of positive quasi-probability distributions on a phase space. In this dissertation, we explore phase space representations for finite-dimensional quantum systems and their negativities beyond the usual analogues of the Wigner function. The first line of study focuses on a characterization tool for valid quasi-probability distributions of (possibly mixed) quantum states. A quantum generalization of Bochner's theorem from classical probability theory simultaneously characterizes both the set of valid Wigner functions and the subset of positive ones. We extend this theorem to discrete phase spaces based on projective representations of abelian groups, including the discrete Wigner functions of Gross (J. Math. Phys. 47, 122107 (2006)) and Gibbons et al. (Phys. Rev. A 70, 062101 (2004)). The rest of the dissertation is then dedicated to phase space representations covariant with respect to a general Lie group. This means, in particular, that operators that lie in the same orbit of the group have the same amount of negativity in their quasi-probabilities---a natural requirement if one would like to interpret negativity as non-classicality, and the group action as a classical dynamics. We show that the construction due to Brif and Mann (Phys. Rev. A 59, 971 (1999)) of group covariant phase space representations satisfying the so-called Stratonovich-Weyl correspondence is essentially unique, given the group and an input state in the relevant representation. As an application, we construct quasi-probability representations on a compact phase space of fermionic Gaussian states tailored to a classically simulatable problem of fermionic linear optics and find that, in the first non-trivial case of four fermionic modes, the quasi-probabilities of the Gaussian states exhibit a considerable amount of negativity.
In this paper we give a partial answer to the problem: When does an initially non-negative Wigner function remain non-negative under the effect of the time evolution? We show that, for pure states, this is the case for linear systems only; to prove this we use the fact that the Wigner function is non-negative if and only if the wavefunction is Gaussian. We also prove that the Green’s solution of the evolution equation of the Wigner function, which in the framework of probability theory corresponds to the conditional probability density, takes on negative values. We utilize a theorem, about moments, borrowed from Pawula. We conclude that the Wigner phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics cannot receive a genuine probabilistic interpretation.
This thesis describes quantum mechanics in the phase space formulation. We introduce quantization and in particular the Weyl quantization. We study a general class of phase space distribution functions on phase space. The Wigner distribution function is one such distribution function. The Wigner distribution function in general attains negative values and thus can not be interpreted as a real probability density, as opposed to for example the Husimi distribution function. The Husimi distribution however does not yield the correct marginal distribution functions known from quantum mechanics. Properties of the Wigner and Husimi distribution function are studied to more extent. We calculate the Wigner and Husimi distribution function for the energy eigenstates of a particle trapped in a box. We then look at the semi classical limit for this example. The time evolution of Wigner functions are studied by making use of the Moyal bracket. The Moyal bracket and the Poisson bracket are compared in the classical limit. The phase space formulation of quantum mechanics has as advantage that classical concepts can be studied and compared to quantum mechanics. For certain quantum mechanical systems the time evolution of Wigner distribution functions becomes equivalent to the classical time evolution stated in the exact Egerov theorem. Another advantage of using Wigner functions is when one is interested in systems involving mixed states. A disadvantage of the phase space formulation is that for most problems it quickly loses its simplicity and becomes hard to calculate.
The Wigner function of quantum systems is an effective instrument for constructing an approximate classical description of the systems for which the classical approximation is possible. In recent years, the Wigner function formalism has been applied as well to seek indications of specific quantum properties of quantum systems leading to the impossibility of constructing the classical approximation. Used most of all as such an indication is the existence of negative values in the Wigner function for specific states of the quantum system being studied. The existence of such values itself prejudices the probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function, though for an arbitrary observable depending jointly on the coordinate and the momentum of the quantum system just the Wigner function provides an effective instrument for calculating the average value and the other statistical characteristics. In this paper, a probabilistic interpretation of the Wigner function based on coordinating a theoretical probabilistic definition of the probability density, with restrictions to a physically small domain of phase space due to the uncertainty principle, is proposed.