Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1410.4516

A thought to illustrate the uncertainty principle on the base of Otto-Wiener's experiment

Das, Tapas

Published Oct 6, 2014• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this short paper a new thought experiment has been introduced to illustrate the famous Heisenberg's uncertainty principle based on Otto-Wiener's experiment (1890) associated with standing light waves. This illustration is quite easy as well as far more realizing than all other thought experiments generally found in textbooks. In this work seeding of quantum nature of light has been done with the Otto-Wiener's experiment. May be this new thought experiment will help the students to understand the Heisenberg's principle in a better way and also enhance their interest of learning quantum mechanics from the beginning of their course.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1410.4516

Related papers

Examples of the uncertainty principle

C. G. DARWIN

Abstract 1. In the general synthesis of classical dynamics with the quantum theory, the Uncertainty Principle plays a most useful part. It is of course only one aspect of the new mechanics, but it is a very helpful one since by its means it becomes easy to see where the old classical ideas broke down. The state of affairs in the quantum theory is not unlike that of the early days of relativity, when most of those who studied the subject felt the need of supporting the formal theory by seeing how the old ideas failed in specific cases. Here the formal theory is very abstract and is not easy to follow intuitively, and the Uncertainty Principle plays much the same rôle as did the examples of clocks and rods in relativity theory. For this reason it is more appropriate for illustrative examples, than for any extreme generality, and though a number of examples have been already given by Heisenberg and Bohr, it may not be amiss to have some more. There are probably some who will have shared my experience that it is often by no means easy to detect how the uncertainty enters into a given experiment, though once detected the arguments are usually very simple. In a recent conversation Professor Bohr criticised some rather careless remarks that I had made, and the present work was undertaken to clear matters up. It may be shortly described as a study of the Uncertainty Principle in connection with electrometers and magnetometers. It may be of interest to point out that the Uncertainty Principle can be regarded from a rather different aspect. The "resolving power" of optical instruments was discussed very fully by Rayleigh on wave principles, but as long as matter was regarded in the classical manner, a mechanical instrument could be considered as capable of measuring quantities with absolute accuracy. Now that we know that matter also has wave properties, there is need of a theory of the resolving power of mechanical instruments, and this is exactly what the Uncertainty Principle supplies.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Mar 2, 1931•6 citations

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle demonstrated with an electron diffraction experiment

Gioṙgio Matteucci, L. Ferrari, A. Migliori

An experiment analogous to the classical diffraction of light from a circular aperture has been realized with electrons. The results are used to introduce undergraduate students to the wave behaviour of electrons. The diffraction fringes produced by the circular aperture are compared to those predicted by quantum mechanics and are exploited to present and discuss the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

European Journal of Physics•Aug 31, 2010•14 citations

Simple Uncertainty-Principle Experiment

Charles A. Sawicki

Recent discussions in TPT have considered the pros and cons of an early introduction of students to modern physics.1–4 In this regard, appropriate experiments with classical waves can help students understand some important but counterintuitive aspects of modern physics. I recently taught a summer course that introduced high school seniors who had graduated with some background in physics and algebra to aspects of quantum physics and relativity. In this paper I'll describe a simple experiment I used to introduce these students to uncertainty principles in quantum physics.

The Physics Teacher•Jan 20, 2003•2 citations

A justification of the invariance of the speed of light by quantum theoretical considerations

Michael Cordin

phenomena can often be analysed in a visually clear way by thought experiments. In the present work a new thought experiment is analysed, which describes the emission of a photon by a special mechanism. The analysis leads to the finding, that there is a natural connection between the energy-time uncertainty and the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle. A deeper analysis of this thought experiment, especially with regard to a justification of the Doppler effect from the uncertainty principle, leads to the conclusion, that the speed of light is invariant. Therefore it seems reasonable to assume, that the origin of relativistic laws lies in non-relativistic quantum mechanics.

Scientific Reports•Jan 13, 2021•0 citations

Introducing the Uncertainty Principle Using Diffraction of Light Waves

Pedro L. Muíño

A thought experiment, in which a light beam is sent through slits of different sizes thereby producing a diffraction pattern, is used to illustrate the uncertainty principle. Attempts to reduce the uncertainty in the measurement of the position of the light beam ( ) succeed, but at the expense of increasing the uncertainty in the measurement of the momentum ( ), so that the product of the two magnitudes, x, is still larger than h, Planck's constant. This experiment introduces the idea that one can know the value of a physical observable with as high a precision as necessary, but the act of measuring this observable has an effect on how much we can know about another observable. This thought experiment can be physically performed using a diode laser and a series of slits. A derivation is presented to relate the uncertainties in position and momentum to variables that can be measured with a ruler in a classroom or laboratory. Data from a typical experiment are also presented.

Journal of Chemical Education•Aug 1, 2000•14 citations

Gamma-Ray Telescope and Uncertainty Principle.

T Shivalingaswamy, B. A. Kagali

Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle is one of the important basic principles of quantum mechanics. In most of the books on quantum mechanics, this uncertainty principle is generally illustrated with the help of a gamma ray microscope, wherein neither the image formation criterion nor the lens properties are taken into account. Thus a better illustration is required for the clear understanding of this principle. In this article we illustrate Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle with a new thought experiment that could be called as gamma ray telescope with the inclusion of properties of the lens and quantum nature of light.

European Journal Of Physics Education•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations
In this short paper a new thought experiment has been introduced to illustrate the famous Heisenberg's uncertainty principle based on Otto-Wiener's experiment (1890) associated with standing light waves. This illustration is quite easy as well as far more realizing than all other thought experiments generally found in textbooks. In this work seeding of quantum nature of light has been done with the Otto-Wiener's experiment. May be this new thought experiment will help the students to understand the Heisenberg's principle in a better way and also enhance their interest of learning quantum mechanics from the beginning of their course.
Abstract 1. In the general synthesis of classical dynamics with the quantum theory, the Uncertainty Principle plays a most useful part. It is of course only one aspect of the new mechanics, but it is a very helpful one since by its means it becomes easy to see where the old classical ideas broke down. The state of affairs in the quantum theory is not unlike that of the early days of relativity, when most of those who studied the subject felt the need of supporting the formal theory by seeing how the old ideas failed in specific cases. Here the formal theory is very abstract and is not easy to follow intuitively, and the Uncertainty Principle plays much the same rôle as did the examples of clocks and rods in relativity theory. For this reason it is more appropriate for illustrative examples, than for any extreme generality, and though a number of examples have been already given by Heisenberg and Bohr, it may not be amiss to have some more. There are probably some who will have shared my experience that it is often by no means easy to detect how the uncertainty enters into a given experiment, though once detected the arguments are usually very simple. In a recent conversation Professor Bohr criticised some rather careless remarks that I had made, and the present work was undertaken to clear matters up. It may be shortly described as a study of the Uncertainty Principle in connection with electrometers and magnetometers. It may be of interest to point out that the Uncertainty Principle can be regarded from a rather different aspect. The "resolving power" of optical instruments was discussed very fully by Rayleigh on wave principles, but as long as matter was regarded in the classical manner, a mechanical instrument could be considered as capable of measuring quantities with absolute accuracy. Now that we know that matter also has wave properties, there is need of a theory of the resolving power of mechanical instruments, and this is exactly what the Uncertainty Principle supplies.
Recent discussions in TPT have considered the pros and cons of an early introduction of students to modern physics.1–4 In this regard, appropriate experiments with classical waves can help students understand some important but counterintuitive aspects of modern physics. I recently taught a summer course that introduced high school seniors who had graduated with some background in physics and algebra to aspects of quantum physics and relativity. In this paper I'll describe a simple experiment I used to introduce these students to uncertainty principles in quantum physics.
phenomena can often be analysed in a visually clear way by thought experiments. In the present work a new thought experiment is analysed, which describes the emission of a photon by a special mechanism. The analysis leads to the finding, that there is a natural connection between the energy-time uncertainty and the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle. A deeper analysis of this thought experiment, especially with regard to a justification of the Doppler effect from the uncertainty principle, leads to the conclusion, that the speed of light is invariant. Therefore it seems reasonable to assume, that the origin of relativistic laws lies in non-relativistic quantum mechanics.
A thought experiment, in which a light beam is sent through slits of different sizes thereby producing a diffraction pattern, is used to illustrate the uncertainty principle. Attempts to reduce the uncertainty in the measurement of the position of the light beam ( ) succeed, but at the expense of increasing the uncertainty in the measurement of the momentum ( ), so that the product of the two magnitudes, x, is still larger than h, Planck's constant. This experiment introduces the idea that one can know the value of a physical observable with as high a precision as necessary, but the act of measuring this observable has an effect on how much we can know about another observable. This thought experiment can be physically performed using a diode laser and a series of slits. A derivation is presented to relate the uncertainties in position and momentum to variables that can be measured with a ruler in a classroom or laboratory. Data from a typical experiment are also presented.
Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle is one of the important basic principles of quantum mechanics. In most of the books on quantum mechanics, this uncertainty principle is generally illustrated with the help of a gamma ray microscope, wherein neither the image formation criterion nor the lens properties are taken into account. Thus a better illustration is required for the clear understanding of this principle. In this article we illustrate Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle with a new thought experiment that could be called as gamma ray telescope with the inclusion of properties of the lens and quantum nature of light.