Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Chemical Education

Introducing the Uncertainty Principle Using Diffraction of Light Waves

Pedro L. Muíño

Published Aug 1, 2000• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A thought experiment, in which a light beam is sent through slits of different sizes thereby producing a diffraction pattern, is used to illustrate the uncertainty principle. Attempts to reduce the uncertainty in the measurement of the position of the light beam ( ) succeed, but at the expense of increasing the uncertainty in the measurement of the momentum ( ), so that the product of the two magnitudes, x, is still larger than h, Planck's constant. This experiment introduces the idea that one can know the value of a physical observable with as high a precision as necessary, but the act of measuring this observable has an effect on how much we can know about another observable. This thought experiment can be physically performed using a diode laser and a series of slits. A derivation is presented to relate the uncertainties in position and momentum to variables that can be measured with a ruler in a classroom or laboratory. Data from a typical experiment are also presented.

DOI
10.1021/ed077p1025

Related papers

Verification of the uncertainty principle by using diffraction of light waves

D Nikolic, Lj. Nesic

We described a simple idea for experimental verification of the uncertainty principle for light waves. We used a single-slit diffraction of a laser beam for measuring the angular width of zero-order diffraction maximum and obtained the corresponding wave number uncertainty. We will assume that the uncertainty in position is the slit width. For the acquisition of the experimental data and their further analysis, we used a computer. Because of its simplicity this experiment is very suitable for demonstration, as well as for a quantitative exercise at universities and final year of high school studies.

European Journal of Physics•Feb 2, 2011•10 citations

A simple experimental checking of Heisenberg's uncertainty relations

Selim Pašić, Ozren Gamulin, Zoran Tocilj

We show that the quantum mechanical interpretation of the diffraction of light on a slit, when a wave function is assigned to a photon, can be used for a direct experimental study of Heisenberg’s position-momentum and equivalent position-wave vector uncertainty relation for the photon. Results of an experimental test of the position-wave vector uncertainty relation, where the wavelength is used as the input parameter, are given and they very well confirm our approach. The same experimental results can also be used for a test of the position-momentum uncertainty relation when the momentum p0 of a photon is known as the input parameter. We show that a measurement of p0, independent of the knowledge of the value of the Planck’s constant, is possible. Using that value of p0, a test of the position-momentum uncertainty relation could be regarded as a method for a direct measurement of the Planck’s constant. This is discussed, since the diffraction pattern is also well described by classical electrodynamics in the considered experi-mental conditions. This approach for testing the Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations is very simple and consequently suitable as a quantitative exercise in undergradu-ate experimental courses, as well as a visual and attractive demonstration of the Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle in courses of quantum mechanics.

Fizika A•Nov 10, 2006•2 citations

Experimental verification of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle via Single-Slit Diffraction

Evan Zhang

This experiment investigates the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (HUP) through an optical analogue using Single-slit diffraction of a monochromatic He–Ne laser. The spatial confinement of light through slits of varying width is compared with the resulting diffraction patterns, providing a means to examine the relationship between position uncertainty ∆x and transverse momentum uncertainty ∆px. Diffraction patterns were recorded using a photodiode detector, and the angular positions of the first minima were determined and used to estimate the spread in momentum via the de-Broglie relation. The results demonstrates and are consistent with the expected inverse relationship. The measured diffraction patterns were also found to adhere to the Fraunhofer diffraction relation, supporting the validity of the experimental model and the goodness of fit of the data.The calculated uncertainty products were further found to be consistent with the expected magnitude of Planck's constant. and therefore the the findings support the interpretation of diffraction as a classifcal manifestation of the Foruier relation between position and momentum space. Thus providing a physically intuituve demonstration of Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle.

•Mar 24, 2026•0 citations

Which way are the photons pointing?

Alastair I. M. Rae

The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 26, 2012•0 citations

Which way are the photons pointing?

Alastair I. M. Rae

The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation . In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 7, 2004•0 citations

Single-slit diffraction and the Heisenberg principle for position and momentum

Winfrid Görlich, Ingo Hoffmann, Thomas Schürmann

Monochromatic light is prepared by a single slit of spatial width Δx. The diffraction pattern is considered to obtain the corresponding probability density of the momentum. Let P be the probability weight to measure a momentum in a finite window of width Δp. For small Δp the asymptotic law P ~ ΔxΔp/h is verified, while h is Planck's constant of action.

arXiv:0812.4775•Dec 27, 2008•0 citations
A thought experiment, in which a light beam is sent through slits of different sizes thereby producing a diffraction pattern, is used to illustrate the uncertainty principle. Attempts to reduce the uncertainty in the measurement of the position of the light beam ( ) succeed, but at the expense of increasing the uncertainty in the measurement of the momentum ( ), so that the product of the two magnitudes, x, is still larger than h, Planck's constant. This experiment introduces the idea that one can know the value of a physical observable with as high a precision as necessary, but the act of measuring this observable has an effect on how much we can know about another observable. This thought experiment can be physically performed using a diode laser and a series of slits. A derivation is presented to relate the uncertainties in position and momentum to variables that can be measured with a ruler in a classroom or laboratory. Data from a typical experiment are also presented.
We described a simple idea for experimental verification of the uncertainty principle for light waves. We used a single-slit diffraction of a laser beam for measuring the angular width of zero-order diffraction maximum and obtained the corresponding wave number uncertainty. We will assume that the uncertainty in position is the slit width. For the acquisition of the experimental data and their further analysis, we used a computer. Because of its simplicity this experiment is very suitable for demonstration, as well as for a quantitative exercise at universities and final year of high school studies.
We show that the quantum mechanical interpretation of the diffraction of light on a slit, when a wave function is assigned to a photon, can be used for a direct experimental study of Heisenberg’s position-momentum and equivalent position-wave vector uncertainty relation for the photon. Results of an experimental test of the position-wave vector uncertainty relation, where the wavelength is used as the input parameter, are given and they very well confirm our approach. The same experimental results can also be used for a test of the position-momentum uncertainty relation when the momentum p0 of a photon is known as the input parameter. We show that a measurement of p0, independent of the knowledge of the value of the Planck’s constant, is possible. Using that value of p0, a test of the position-momentum uncertainty relation could be regarded as a method for a direct measurement of the Planck’s constant. This is discussed, since the diffraction pattern is also well described by classical electrodynamics in the considered experi-mental conditions. This approach for testing the Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations is very simple and consequently suitable as a quantitative exercise in undergradu-ate experimental courses, as well as a visual and attractive demonstration of the Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle in courses of quantum mechanics.
This experiment investigates the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle (HUP) through an optical analogue using Single-slit diffraction of a monochromatic He–Ne laser. The spatial confinement of light through slits of varying width is compared with the resulting diffraction patterns, providing a means to examine the relationship between position uncertainty ∆x and transverse momentum uncertainty ∆px. Diffraction patterns were recorded using a photodiode detector, and the angular positions of the first minima were determined and used to estimate the spread in momentum via the de-Broglie relation. The results demonstrates and are consistent with the expected inverse relationship. The measured diffraction patterns were also found to adhere to the Fraunhofer diffraction relation, supporting the validity of the experimental model and the goodness of fit of the data.The calculated uncertainty products were further found to be consistent with the expected magnitude of Planck's constant. and therefore the the findings support the interpretation of diffraction as a classifcal manifestation of the Foruier relation between position and momentum space. Thus providing a physically intuituve demonstration of Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle.
The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation. In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.
The previous chapter surveyed part of the rich variety of physical phenomena that can be understood using the ideas of quantum physics. Now that we are beginning the task of looking more deeply into the subject we shall find it useful to concentrate on examples that are comparatively simple to understand but which still illustrate the fundamental principles and highlight the basic conceptual problems. Some years ago most writers discussing such topics would probably have turned to the example of a ‘particle’ passing through a two-slit apparatus (as in Figure 1.2), whose wave properties are revealed in the interference pattern. Much of the discussion would have been in terms of wave–particle duality and the problems involved in position and momentum measurements, as in the discussion of the uncertainty principle in the last chapter. However, there are essentially an infinite number of places where the particle can be and an infinite number of possible values of its momentum, and this complicates the discussion considerably. We can illustrate all the points of principle we want to discuss by considering situations where a measurement has only a small number of possible outcomes. One such quantity relating to the physics of light beams and photons is known as polarisation . In the next section we discuss it in the context of the classical wave theory of light, and the rest of the chapter extends the concept to situations where the photon nature of light is important.