Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.3583 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Sequences of projective measurements in generalized probabilistic models

Matthias Kleinmann

Published Oct 29, 2014• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We define a simple rule that allows us to describe sequences of projective measurements for a broad class of generalized probabilistic models. This class embraces quantum mechanics and classical probability theory, but, for example, also the hypothetical Popescu–Rohrlich box. For quantum mechanics, the definition yields the established Lüders rule, which is the standard rule for updating the quantum state after a measurement. For the general case, it can be seen as being the least disturbing or most coherent way of performing sequential measurements. We show, as an example, that the Spekkens toy model (Spekkens 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032110 ) provides an instance of our definition. We also demonstrate the possibility of strong postquantum correlations as well as the existence of triple-slit correlations for certain nonquantum toy models.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/47/45/455304

Related papers

Beyond the projection postulate and back: Quantum theories with generalized state-update rules

Vincenzo Fiorentino, Stefan Weigert

Are there consistent and physically reasonable alternatives to the projection postulate? Does it have unique properties compared with acceptable alternatives? We answer these questions by systematically investigating hypothetical state-update rules for quantum systems that Nature could have chosen over the Lüders rule. Among other basic properties, any prospective rule must define unique post-measurement states and not allow for superluminal signaling. Particular attention will be paid to consistently defining post-measurement states when performing local measurements in composite systems. Explicit examples of valid unconventional update rules are presented, each resulting in a distinct, well-defined foil of quantum theory. This framework of state-update rules allows us to identify operational properties that distinguish the projective update rule from all others and to put earlier derivations of the projection postulate into perspective.

arXiv:2506.06207•Physical Review A•Dec 5, 2025•3 citations

One simple postulate implies that every polytopic state space is classical

Corsin Pfister

In order to find a physical axiomatization of quantum theory, physical theories are often considered as a special case of a much more general framework of generalized probabilistic theories. We first present a detailed introduction to generalized probabilistic theories before we examine new approaches towards a physical axiomatization of quantum theory. The main result of the thesis is that one postulate concerning post-measurement states (which have gained almost no attention in this context so far) is sufficient to rule out all probabilistic theories with a polytopic state space, except for classical theory. The postulate states that a measurement with a definite outcome does not alter the state. This rules out almost all toy theories considered so far, for instance the PR-box, but is compatible with quantum theory. Thus, this result can be seen as an approach towards a classification of quantum theory in physical terms. It only deals with local state spaces, in contrast to other approaches that are mostly concerned with nonlocality in composite systems.

arXiv:1203.5622•Mar 26, 2012•19 citations

Sequential sharing of entanglement via probabilistic projective measurements

Yanling Wang, Shi-Min Ye, Wei Chen +2 more

Recently, Sasmal et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 170201 (2024)] introduced probabilistic projective measurements (PPMs) for sequential sharing of nonlocality. Here we develop a general framework for sequentially witnessing quantum correlations, including bipartite and genuine multipartite entanglement, via PPMs. We show that a class of positive-operator-valued measures admits a unified PPM realization and present an explicit formula linking the initial state, intermediate channels, and witness operators, providing both computational efficiency and structural insight. Using this framework, we demonstrate unbounded sequential entanglement sharing for pure and certain mixed states, as well as detection of genuine multipartite entanglement in Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type states. Our results highlight the nontrivial role of PPMs in sequential entanglement witnessing and address generalized multipartite sharing, as discussed in a recent review article [Phys. Rep. 1098, 1 (2025)].

Physical Review A•Nov 5, 2025•3 citations

Sufficiency of the counterfactual account of Lüders' rule to rule out ontological models of quantum mechanics

Alisson Tezzin, Bárbara Amaral, Jonte R. Hance

Ontological models, as used in the generalized contextuality literature, play a central role in current research on quantum foundations, providing a framework for defining classicality, constructing classical analogs of key quantum phenomena, and examining the ontology of quantum states. In this work, we show that a counterfactual account of Lüders' rule—which we argue is naturally implied by the mathematical structure of the rule itself—renders such models inherently incompatible with the quantum formalism. This incompatibility arises because the counterfactual update requires ontological models to update their states according to conditional probability, which in turn renders predictions of sequential measurements order-independent. This implies that ontological models, even contextual ones, must either act differently than what we would expect given (this, typically implicitly assumed account of) quantum state update rule, or cannot model quantum behavior.

arXiv:2502.15615•Physical Review A•Nov 10, 2025•7 citations

Incompatibility of deterministic underlying states with a counterfactual account of Lüders' rule

A Tezzin, B Amaral, Jonte R. Hance

In this work, we show that a counterfactual account of Lüders' rule—which we argue is naturally implied by the mathematical structure of the rule itself—rules out underlying-state models of quantum mechanics (a type of hidden-variable model, typically used in the contextuality and nonlocality literature, where quantum states are treated as probability measures over “better-defined states”). This incompatibility arises because the counterfactual update requires ontological models to update their states according to conditional probability, which in turn establishes an equivalence between compatibility and the existence of such models.

•Nov 1, 2025•0 citations

Linear Algebra of Generalized Contextuality in All Prepare-Transform-Measure Scenarios

Theodoros Yianni, Nyan Raess, Farid Shahandeh

Generalized contextuality is a canonical distinguishing property of nonclassical generalized probabilistic theories, in particular quantum mechanics. Methods for certification and characterization of generalized contextuality of a given generalized probabilistic theory are well developed for prepare-measure and single-stage prepare-transform-measure scenarios. In a recent work [arXiv:2512.10000], a bottom-up, statistics-first linear-algebraic framework for contextuality in prepare-measure scenarios was introduced. We extend this approach to operational scenarios with sequential transformations with an arbitrary number of stages. We give a full decision procedure for contextuality of such scenarios within operational theories and analyze its computational complexity. In particular, our decision procedure has a complexity linearly exponential in the minimum generalized probabilistic theory (GPT) dimension, and polynomial in the number of procedures. We demonstrate our framework and approach through multiple examples, including Spekkens' toy theory and the 8-state single-qubit stabilizer theory. In particular, we construct an operational theory in which contextuality manifests itself only in the sequential structure of the transformations. Our findings thus shed new light on the significant role of compositional structures in the phenomenon of generalized contextuality.

quant-pharXiv:2607.26139•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations
We define a simple rule that allows us to describe sequences of projective measurements for a broad class of generalized probabilistic models. This class embraces quantum mechanics and classical probability theory, but, for example, also the hypothetical Popescu–Rohrlich box. For quantum mechanics, the definition yields the established Lüders rule, which is the standard rule for updating the quantum state after a measurement. For the general case, it can be seen as being the least disturbing or most coherent way of performing sequential measurements. We show, as an example, that the Spekkens toy model (Spekkens 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 032110 ) provides an instance of our definition. We also demonstrate the possibility of strong postquantum correlations as well as the existence of triple-slit correlations for certain nonquantum toy models.
Are there consistent and physically reasonable alternatives to the projection postulate? Does it have unique properties compared with acceptable alternatives? We answer these questions by systematically investigating hypothetical state-update rules for quantum systems that Nature could have chosen over the Lüders rule. Among other basic properties, any prospective rule must define unique post-measurement states and not allow for superluminal signaling. Particular attention will be paid to consistently defining post-measurement states when performing local measurements in composite systems. Explicit examples of valid unconventional update rules are presented, each resulting in a distinct, well-defined foil of quantum theory. This framework of state-update rules allows us to identify operational properties that distinguish the projective update rule from all others and to put earlier derivations of the projection postulate into perspective.
In order to find a physical axiomatization of quantum theory, physical theories are often considered as a special case of a much more general framework of generalized probabilistic theories. We first present a detailed introduction to generalized probabilistic theories before we examine new approaches towards a physical axiomatization of quantum theory. The main result of the thesis is that one postulate concerning post-measurement states (which have gained almost no attention in this context so far) is sufficient to rule out all probabilistic theories with a polytopic state space, except for classical theory. The postulate states that a measurement with a definite outcome does not alter the state. This rules out almost all toy theories considered so far, for instance the PR-box, but is compatible with quantum theory. Thus, this result can be seen as an approach towards a classification of quantum theory in physical terms. It only deals with local state spaces, in contrast to other approaches that are mostly concerned with nonlocality in composite systems.
Recently, Sasmal et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 170201 (2024)] introduced probabilistic projective measurements (PPMs) for sequential sharing of nonlocality. Here we develop a general framework for sequentially witnessing quantum correlations, including bipartite and genuine multipartite entanglement, via PPMs. We show that a class of positive-operator-valued measures admits a unified PPM realization and present an explicit formula linking the initial state, intermediate channels, and witness operators, providing both computational efficiency and structural insight. Using this framework, we demonstrate unbounded sequential entanglement sharing for pure and certain mixed states, as well as detection of genuine multipartite entanglement in Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger-type states. Our results highlight the nontrivial role of PPMs in sequential entanglement witnessing and address generalized multipartite sharing, as discussed in a recent review article [Phys. Rep. 1098, 1 (2025)].
Ontological models, as used in the generalized contextuality literature, play a central role in current research on quantum foundations, providing a framework for defining classicality, constructing classical analogs of key quantum phenomena, and examining the ontology of quantum states. In this work, we show that a counterfactual account of Lüders' rule—which we argue is naturally implied by the mathematical structure of the rule itself—renders such models inherently incompatible with the quantum formalism. This incompatibility arises because the counterfactual update requires ontological models to update their states according to conditional probability, which in turn renders predictions of sequential measurements order-independent. This implies that ontological models, even contextual ones, must either act differently than what we would expect given (this, typically implicitly assumed account of) quantum state update rule, or cannot model quantum behavior.
In this work, we show that a counterfactual account of Lüders' rule—which we argue is naturally implied by the mathematical structure of the rule itself—rules out underlying-state models of quantum mechanics (a type of hidden-variable model, typically used in the contextuality and nonlocality literature, where quantum states are treated as probability measures over “better-defined states”). This incompatibility arises because the counterfactual update requires ontological models to update their states according to conditional probability, which in turn establishes an equivalence between compatibility and the existence of such models.
Generalized contextuality is a canonical distinguishing property of nonclassical generalized probabilistic theories, in particular quantum mechanics. Methods for certification and characterization of generalized contextuality of a given generalized probabilistic theory are well developed for prepare-measure and single-stage prepare-transform-measure scenarios. In a recent work [arXiv:2512.10000], a bottom-up, statistics-first linear-algebraic framework for contextuality in prepare-measure scenarios was introduced. We extend this approach to operational scenarios with sequential transformations with an arbitrary number of stages. We give a full decision procedure for contextuality of such scenarios within operational theories and analyze its computational complexity. In particular, our decision procedure has a complexity linearly exponential in the minimum generalized probabilistic theory (GPT) dimension, and polynomial in the number of procedures. We demonstrate our framework and approach through multiple examples, including Spekkens' toy theory and the 8-state single-qubit stabilizer theory. In particular, we construct an operational theory in which contextuality manifests itself only in the sequential structure of the transformations. Our findings thus shed new light on the significant role of compositional structures in the phenomenon of generalized contextuality.