Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.3190

Heating the coffee by looking at it. Or why quantum measurements are physical processes

P. M. Echenique

Published Feb 13, 2014• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Using a very simple Gedankenexperiment, I remind the reader that (contrary to what happens in classical mechanics) the energy of a quantum system is inevitably increased just by performing (some) textbook measurements on it. As a direct conclusion, this means that some measurements require the expenditure of a finite amount of energy to be carried out. I also argue that this makes it very difficult to regard measurements as disembodied, immaterial, informational operations, and it forces us to look at them as physical processes just like any other one.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1402.3190

Related papers

The importance of being measurement

Esteban Calzetta

Energy exchanges under form of heat is neither the most natural or efficient way to operate an engine in the quantum realm. Recently there have been in the literature several proposals for "quantum measurement engines" where energy is fed into the machine by operations which otherwise would be conducive to quantum measurements on the working substance (henceforth "the system"). In the analysis of the working of these devices, oftentimes it is assumed that the only effect of measurement is to turn the state of the system from whatever prior state to an eigenstate of the measured property, and energy exchanges are determined therefrom. This ignores the intricacies of the quantum measurement process. We propose a simple model of a quantum measurement engine where the measurement process may be analyzed in detail, and therefore energy exchanges, and limitations on their duration, may be traced more fully.

arXiv:1909.13178•Sep 29, 2019•0 citations

Epilogue

Alfred Brian Pippard

As is appropriate in an exposition of the quantum mechanics of vibrators, we started with a quantal calculation and have finished with one; but we have never strayed far from the classical models. We began, indeed, in chapter 13 the task of establishing limits to the validity of classical reasoning, and the very last example of this chapter has been used to demonstrate, somewhat perversely it might be thought, that the method of quantum mechanics can occasionally be applied to systems which physicists and engineers would instinctively regard as classical. So long as the discussions give insight into physical processes and reveal the strengths and weaknesses of the analytical tools available, no apology is needed and no defence is offered except the evidence of the book itself. Even the rather simple systems which provide material for the whole of the volume demonstrate clearly the increased power available to those who can handle both classical and quantal reasoning. The reader who wishes to apply his skill to complex vibratory processes will find his tasks eased if he can use whichever seems advantageous at each stage, and be confident that his understanding of simple processes will enable him to recognize the dangers inherent in both approaches – the danger of carrying classical reasoning too far into the quantum domain, and the danger of forcing over-simplifications on physical systems to make them amenable to the unforgiving methodology of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 16, 1989•0 citations

There is no quantum measurement problem

N. David Mermin

The idea that the collapse of a quantum state is a physical process stems from a misunderstanding of probability and the role it plays in quantum mechanics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2022•32 citations

Quantisation and prediction : another look at the aim and structure of quantum theory

Jean-Michel Delhôtel

It is argued (Part A) that quantum mechanics can be derived as a principle-based dynamical framework, the basic equation of which is an alternative form of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Schrodinger's equation obtains as a result of linearising that equation, and so-called wave functions can be given no straightforward physical interpretation. It is suggested, partly in relation to a theorem by Gromov, that a finite action quantum would make it practically inevitable, for purposes of prediction, to resort to a probabilistic formulation. The structure of the space of square-integrable solutions of the Schrodinger equation happens to lend itself to the introduction of the appropriate kind of predictive scheme. Investigating the nature and scope of such a scheme is the subject of Part B. It is shown that basic features of the formalism of quantum theory, like composition rules for 'amplitudes' or the 'Born' probability rule, can be derived independently of any physical assumptions. A generalisation of the basic formalism using tensor product composition appears to be required if all correlations are to be extracted from locally accessed data. A detailed discussion of quantum teleportation leads to the conclusion that a 'one-shot' account leads to a distorted picture of what is actually achieved. An analogy with classical cryptography is made and the statistical significance of the 'transfer', which does not require introducing any novel form of 'quantum information', is emphasised. Results obtained over the last decade using the extended formalism of positive operator-valued measures are reviewed and discussed. These lend further support to the idea that the set of basic 'quantum' rules functions as a general kind of probabilistic scheme for prediction, the structural features of which are not constrained in any direct way by the underlying physics. On the other hand, the very existence of such a predictive framework hinges on selecting a particular class of solutions of the Schrodinger equation, which selection has been incorrectly interpreted as reflecting a physical necessity.

•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

Calorimetric Test of Landauer-Like Dissipation in Objective Wavefunction Collapse: A Two-Mode Superconducting Circuit Protocol

Bjørn Remseth

Quantum mechanics is remarkably successful, yet it still leaves open a basic question: when a quantum system “collapses” from a superposition into a definite outcome, is that merely a change in our description, or is it a real physical process? If collapse is physical, it should obey the laws of thermodynamics. In this work, we ask a simple but sharp question: would wavefunction collapse produce a tiny, measurable amount of heat? We propose an experiment that can answer this decisively. Either such heat is observed, pointing to new physics, or strong limits are placed on how physical collapse could be. Our key idea is to separate two effects that are usually mixed together. Any nonstandard quantum process can inject energy simply because it does not align with the system’s natural dynamics. This “generic” heating can easily mask more subtle effects. We show how a superconducting circuit can be operated in two carefully chosen modes so that this generic heating is present in one mode but guaranteed to vanish in the other. By comparing the two, any remaining heat signal can be cleanly isolated and tested for a characteristic temperature dependence expected from genuine information loss. Looking ahead, this proposal turns a long-standing foundational debate into a practical experimental program. Using existing superconducting technology, experiments can either discover new physics or establish meaningful bounds. In both cases, the results sharpen our understanding of what quantum measurement means as a physical process.

•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

On quantum measurements

S. A. Granovskij

Is the reduction of the wavefunction a real physical process? A mental experiment providing an answer to this question is considered.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Mar 1, 2007•0 citations
Using a very simple Gedankenexperiment, I remind the reader that (contrary to what happens in classical mechanics) the energy of a quantum system is inevitably increased just by performing (some) textbook measurements on it. As a direct conclusion, this means that some measurements require the expenditure of a finite amount of energy to be carried out. I also argue that this makes it very difficult to regard measurements as disembodied, immaterial, informational operations, and it forces us to look at them as physical processes just like any other one.
Energy exchanges under form of heat is neither the most natural or efficient way to operate an engine in the quantum realm. Recently there have been in the literature several proposals for "quantum measurement engines" where energy is fed into the machine by operations which otherwise would be conducive to quantum measurements on the working substance (henceforth "the system"). In the analysis of the working of these devices, oftentimes it is assumed that the only effect of measurement is to turn the state of the system from whatever prior state to an eigenstate of the measured property, and energy exchanges are determined therefrom. This ignores the intricacies of the quantum measurement process. We propose a simple model of a quantum measurement engine where the measurement process may be analyzed in detail, and therefore energy exchanges, and limitations on their duration, may be traced more fully.
As is appropriate in an exposition of the quantum mechanics of vibrators, we started with a quantal calculation and have finished with one; but we have never strayed far from the classical models. We began, indeed, in chapter 13 the task of establishing limits to the validity of classical reasoning, and the very last example of this chapter has been used to demonstrate, somewhat perversely it might be thought, that the method of quantum mechanics can occasionally be applied to systems which physicists and engineers would instinctively regard as classical. So long as the discussions give insight into physical processes and reveal the strengths and weaknesses of the analytical tools available, no apology is needed and no defence is offered except the evidence of the book itself. Even the rather simple systems which provide material for the whole of the volume demonstrate clearly the increased power available to those who can handle both classical and quantal reasoning. The reader who wishes to apply his skill to complex vibratory processes will find his tasks eased if he can use whichever seems advantageous at each stage, and be confident that his understanding of simple processes will enable him to recognize the dangers inherent in both approaches – the danger of carrying classical reasoning too far into the quantum domain, and the danger of forcing over-simplifications on physical systems to make them amenable to the unforgiving methodology of quantum mechanics.
It is argued (Part A) that quantum mechanics can be derived as a principle-based dynamical framework, the basic equation of which is an alternative form of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. Schrodinger's equation obtains as a result of linearising that equation, and so-called wave functions can be given no straightforward physical interpretation. It is suggested, partly in relation to a theorem by Gromov, that a finite action quantum would make it practically inevitable, for purposes of prediction, to resort to a probabilistic formulation. The structure of the space of square-integrable solutions of the Schrodinger equation happens to lend itself to the introduction of the appropriate kind of predictive scheme. Investigating the nature and scope of such a scheme is the subject of Part B. It is shown that basic features of the formalism of quantum theory, like composition rules for 'amplitudes' or the 'Born' probability rule, can be derived independently of any physical assumptions. A generalisation of the basic formalism using tensor product composition appears to be required if all correlations are to be extracted from locally accessed data. A detailed discussion of quantum teleportation leads to the conclusion that a 'one-shot' account leads to a distorted picture of what is actually achieved. An analogy with classical cryptography is made and the statistical significance of the 'transfer', which does not require introducing any novel form of 'quantum information', is emphasised. Results obtained over the last decade using the extended formalism of positive operator-valued measures are reviewed and discussed. These lend further support to the idea that the set of basic 'quantum' rules functions as a general kind of probabilistic scheme for prediction, the structural features of which are not constrained in any direct way by the underlying physics. On the other hand, the very existence of such a predictive framework hinges on selecting a particular class of solutions of the Schrodinger equation, which selection has been incorrectly interpreted as reflecting a physical necessity.
Quantum mechanics is remarkably successful, yet it still leaves open a basic question: when a quantum system “collapses” from a superposition into a definite outcome, is that merely a change in our description, or is it a real physical process? If collapse is physical, it should obey the laws of thermodynamics. In this work, we ask a simple but sharp question: would wavefunction collapse produce a tiny, measurable amount of heat? We propose an experiment that can answer this decisively. Either such heat is observed, pointing to new physics, or strong limits are placed on how physical collapse could be. Our key idea is to separate two effects that are usually mixed together. Any nonstandard quantum process can inject energy simply because it does not align with the system’s natural dynamics. This “generic” heating can easily mask more subtle effects. We show how a superconducting circuit can be operated in two carefully chosen modes so that this generic heating is present in one mode but guaranteed to vanish in the other. By comparing the two, any remaining heat signal can be cleanly isolated and tested for a characteristic temperature dependence expected from genuine information loss. Looking ahead, this proposal turns a long-standing foundational debate into a practical experimental program. Using existing superconducting technology, experiments can either discover new physics or establish meaningful bounds. In both cases, the results sharpen our understanding of what quantum measurement means as a physical process.