Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1310.3235 · IEEE Transactions on Information Theory

Hardness of Decoding Quantum Stabilizer Codes

Pavithran Sridharan Iyer, David Poulin

Published Apr 28, 2015• 129 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we address the computational hardness of optimally decoding a quantum stabilizer code. Much like classical linear codes, errors are detected by measuring certain check operators which yield an error syndrome, and the decoding problem consists of determining the most likely recovery given the syndrome. The corresponding classical problem is known to be NP-complete, and are appropriate a similar decoding problem for quantum codes is also known to be NP-complete. However, this decoding strategy is not optimal in the quantum setting as it does not consider error degeneracy, which causes distinct errors to have the same effect on the code. Here, we show that optimal decoding of stabilizer codes (previously known to be NP-hard) is in fact computationally much harder than optimal decoding of classical linear codes, it is #P-complete.

DOI
10.1109/tit.2015.2422294

Related papers

Hardness of decoding stabilizer codes

Pavithran Sridharan Iyer

This thesis deals with the study of computational complexity of decoding stabilizer codes. The first three chapters contain all the necessary background to understand the main result of this thesis. First, we explain the necessary notions in computational complexity, introducing P, NP, #P classes of problems, along with some examples intended for physicists. Then, we explain the decoding problem in classical error correction, for linear codes on the binary symmetric channel and discuss the celebrated result of Mcleicee et al., in [1]. In the third chapter, we study the problem of quantum communication, over Pauli channels. Here, using the stabilizer formalism, we discuss the concept of degenerate errors. The decoding problem for stabilizer codes, which simply neglects the presence of degenerate errors, is called quantum maximum likelihood decoding (QMLD) and it was shown to be NP-complete, by Min Hseiu Heish et al., in [2]. We focus on the problem of optimal decoding, called degenerate quantum maximum likelihood decoding (DQMLD), which accounts for the presence of degenerate errors. We will highlight some instances of stabilizer codes, where the presence of degenerate errors causes drastic variations between the performances of DQMLD and QMLD. The main contribution of this thesis is to demonstrate that the optimal decoding problem for stabilizer codes is much harder than what the previous results had anticipated. In the last chapter, we present our own result (in Thm. 5.1.1), establishing that the optimal decoding problem for stabilizer codes, is #P-complete. To prove this, we demonstrate that the problem of evaluating the weight enumerator of a binary linear code, which is #P-complete, can be reduced (in polynomial time) to the DQMLD problem, see (Sec. 5.1). Our principal result is also presented as an article in [3], which is currently under review for publication in IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. In addition to the main result, we also show that under certain conditions, the outputs of DQMLD and QMLD always agree. We consider the conditions developed by us to be an improvement over the ones in [4, 5].

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

On the hardness of decoding quantum stabilizer codes under the depolarizing channel

Kao-Yueh Kuo, Chung-Chin Lu

We classify the complexity classes of several important decoding problems for quantum stabilizer codes. First, regardless of the channel model, quantum bounded distance decoding is shown to be NP-hard, like what Berlekamp, McEliece and Tilborg did for classical binary linear codes in 1978. Then under the depolarizing channel, the decoding problems for finding a most likely error and for minimizing the decoding error probability are also shown to be NP-hard. Our results indicate that finding a polynomial-time decoding algorithm for general stabilizer codes may not be possible, but this, on the other hand, strengthens the foundation of quantum code-based cryptography.

International Symposium on Information Theory and its Applications•Oct 1, 2012•7 citations

NP-hardness of decoding quantum error-correction codes

Min-Hsiu Hsieh, François Le Gall

Although the theory of quantum error correction is intimately related to classical coding theory and, in particular, one can construct quantum error-correction codes (QECCs) from classical codes with the dual-containing property, this does not necessarily imply that the computational complexity of decoding QECCs is the same as their classical counterparts. Instead, decoding QECCs can be very much different from decoding classical codes due to the degeneracy property. Intuitively, one expects degeneracy would simplify the decoding since two different errors might not and need not be distinguished in order to correct them. However, we show that general quantum decoding problem is NP-hard regardless of the quantum codes being degenerate or nondegenerate. This finding implies that no considerably fast decoding algorithm exists for the general quantum decoding problems and suggests the existence of a quantum cryptosystem based on the hardness of decoding QECCs.

arXiv:1009.1319•Physical Review A•May 31, 2011•80 citations

On the Hardness of the Minimum Distance Problem of Quantum Codes

Upendra Kapshikar, Srijita Kundu

We study the hardness of the problem of finding the distance of quantum error-correcting codes. The analogous problem for classical codes is known to be NP-hard, even in approximate form. For quantum codes, various problems related to decoding are known to be NP-hard, but the hardness of the distance problem has not been studied before. In this work, we show that finding the minimum distance of stabilizer quantum codes exactly or approximately is NP-hard. This result is obtained by reducing the classical minimum distance problem to the quantum problem, using the CWS framework for quantum codes, which constructs a quantum code using a classical code and a graph. A main technical tool used for our result is a lower bound on the so-called graph state distance of 4-cycle free graphs. In particular, we show that for a 4-cycle free graph$G$, its graph state distance is either$\delta $or$\delta +1$, where$\delta $is the minimum vertex degree of$G$. Due to a well-known reduction from stabilizer codes to CSS codes, our results also imply that finding the minimum distance of CSS codes is also NP-hard.

arXiv:2203.04262•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jun 16, 2023•23 citations

Is A Quantum Stabilizer Code Degenerate or Nondegenerate for Pauli Channel?

Fangying Xiao, Hanwu Chen

Mapping an error syndrome to the error operator is the core of quantum decoding network and is also the key step of recovery. The definitions of the bit-flip error syndrome matrix and the phase-flip error syndrome matrix were presented, and then the error syndromes of quantum errors were expressed in terms of the columns of the bit-flip error syndrome matrix and the phase-flip error syndrome matrix. It also showed that the error syndrome matrices of a stabilizer code are determined by its check matrix, which is similar to the classical case. So, the error-detection and recovery techniques of classical linear codes can be applied to quantum stabilizer codes after some modifications. Some necessary and/or sufficient conditions for the stabilizer code over GF(2) is degenerate or nondegenerate for Pauli channel based on the relationship between the error syndrome matrices and the check matrix was presented. A new way to find the minimum distance of the quantum stabilizer codes based on their check matrices was presented, and followed from which we proved that the performance of degenerate quantum code outperform (at least have the same performance) nondegenerate quantum code for Pauli channel.

arXiv:1009.3539•Sep 18, 2010•0 citations

Heuristics in quantum error correction

Alex Rigby

Noise is a major obstacle in the development of practical schemes for quantum computation and communication. Similar to the case of classical communication, this noise can be protected against by employing a code, which provides a means for encoding quantum states prior to transmission and allows for errors to be inferred, and hopefully corrected, by a decoder at the receiver. Unfortunately, designing good codes and decoders is typically a difficult problem. This thesis focuses on developing low-complexity heuristic approaches to three such problems: the design of modified belief propagation decoders for quantum low-density parity-check codes, the design of stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels, and the design of codeword stabilized codes. Quantum low-density parity-check codes are stabilizer codes with low-weight generators. Such codes permit low-complexity decoding via the use of belief propagation, which is an iterative message passing algorithm that takes place on a factor graph defined by the code. However, the performance of such a decoder is limited both by code structure and the degenerate nature of quantum errors. To overcome these limitations, at least in part, a number of modifications to belief propagation are developed. Central among these is the augmented decoder, which in the case of a decoding error, iteratively reattempts decoding using modified factor graph. This heuristic modification simply involves the duplication of a randomly selected subset of the graph’s check nodes, which are in one-to-one correspondence with the code’s stabilizer generators. Across a range of codes, it is shown that the decoders developed perform as well as or better than other modified decoders presented in literature. For a number of channels of physical interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these so-called asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be minimized by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, assessing the performance of codes on a given channel is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this complexity, it is shown that the decoding error rate can be accurately approximated using only a small fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. This approximation is then used to identify a number of cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. To further build on this, a heuristic is demonstrated for assessing code performance based on the decoding error rate of an associated classical code. The complexity of calculating this classical error rate is relatively low, and it is shown that it can be used as the basis for a hill-climbing search algorithm. Such searches have yielded a large number of highly performant codes satisfying various structure constraints. The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses both the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. Constructing a standard form codeword stabilized code is a matter of selecting a simple undirected graph and a binary classical code. This makes designing optimal codes difficult as the number of possible graphs grows exponentially with code length, and the clique search required to construct the classical code is NP-hard. To address the exponential growth of the search space, a heuristic is developed for assessing graphs. This heuristic is then employed by a genetic algorithm that also makes use of a novel crossover operation based on spectral bisection, which is show to be superior to more standard crossover operations. With a graph selected, it is demonstrated that the complexity of the clique search required to construct the associated classical code can be mitigated through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. A number of best known codes are presented that have been found using this approach.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations
In this paper, we address the computational hardness of optimally decoding a quantum stabilizer code. Much like classical linear codes, errors are detected by measuring certain check operators which yield an error syndrome, and the decoding problem consists of determining the most likely recovery given the syndrome. The corresponding classical problem is known to be NP-complete, and are appropriate a similar decoding problem for quantum codes is also known to be NP-complete. However, this decoding strategy is not optimal in the quantum setting as it does not consider error degeneracy, which causes distinct errors to have the same effect on the code. Here, we show that optimal decoding of stabilizer codes (previously known to be NP-hard) is in fact computationally much harder than optimal decoding of classical linear codes, it is #P-complete.
This thesis deals with the study of computational complexity of decoding stabilizer codes. The first three chapters contain all the necessary background to understand the main result of this thesis. First, we explain the necessary notions in computational complexity, introducing P, NP, #P classes of problems, along with some examples intended for physicists. Then, we explain the decoding problem in classical error correction, for linear codes on the binary symmetric channel and discuss the celebrated result of Mcleicee et al., in [1]. In the third chapter, we study the problem of quantum communication, over Pauli channels. Here, using the stabilizer formalism, we discuss the concept of degenerate errors. The decoding problem for stabilizer codes, which simply neglects the presence of degenerate errors, is called quantum maximum likelihood decoding (QMLD) and it was shown to be NP-complete, by Min Hseiu Heish et al., in [2]. We focus on the problem of optimal decoding, called degenerate quantum maximum likelihood decoding (DQMLD), which accounts for the presence of degenerate errors. We will highlight some instances of stabilizer codes, where the presence of degenerate errors causes drastic variations between the performances of DQMLD and QMLD. The main contribution of this thesis is to demonstrate that the optimal decoding problem for stabilizer codes is much harder than what the previous results had anticipated. In the last chapter, we present our own result (in Thm. 5.1.1), establishing that the optimal decoding problem for stabilizer codes, is #P-complete. To prove this, we demonstrate that the problem of evaluating the weight enumerator of a binary linear code, which is #P-complete, can be reduced (in polynomial time) to the DQMLD problem, see (Sec. 5.1). Our principal result is also presented as an article in [3], which is currently under review for publication in IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. In addition to the main result, we also show that under certain conditions, the outputs of DQMLD and QMLD always agree. We consider the conditions developed by us to be an improvement over the ones in [4, 5].
We classify the complexity classes of several important decoding problems for quantum stabilizer codes. First, regardless of the channel model, quantum bounded distance decoding is shown to be NP-hard, like what Berlekamp, McEliece and Tilborg did for classical binary linear codes in 1978. Then under the depolarizing channel, the decoding problems for finding a most likely error and for minimizing the decoding error probability are also shown to be NP-hard. Our results indicate that finding a polynomial-time decoding algorithm for general stabilizer codes may not be possible, but this, on the other hand, strengthens the foundation of quantum code-based cryptography.
Although the theory of quantum error correction is intimately related to classical coding theory and, in particular, one can construct quantum error-correction codes (QECCs) from classical codes with the dual-containing property, this does not necessarily imply that the computational complexity of decoding QECCs is the same as their classical counterparts. Instead, decoding QECCs can be very much different from decoding classical codes due to the degeneracy property. Intuitively, one expects degeneracy would simplify the decoding since two different errors might not and need not be distinguished in order to correct them. However, we show that general quantum decoding problem is NP-hard regardless of the quantum codes being degenerate or nondegenerate. This finding implies that no considerably fast decoding algorithm exists for the general quantum decoding problems and suggests the existence of a quantum cryptosystem based on the hardness of decoding QECCs.
We study the hardness of the problem of finding the distance of quantum error-correcting codes. The analogous problem for classical codes is known to be NP-hard, even in approximate form. For quantum codes, various problems related to decoding are known to be NP-hard, but the hardness of the distance problem has not been studied before. In this work, we show that finding the minimum distance of stabilizer quantum codes exactly or approximately is NP-hard. This result is obtained by reducing the classical minimum distance problem to the quantum problem, using the CWS framework for quantum codes, which constructs a quantum code using a classical code and a graph. A main technical tool used for our result is a lower bound on the so-called graph state distance of 4-cycle free graphs. In particular, we show that for a 4-cycle free graphGGG, its graph state distance is either$\delta ororor\delta +1,where, where,where\delta istheminimumvertexdegreeofis the minimum vertex degree ofistheminimumvertexdegreeofG$. Due to a well-known reduction from stabilizer codes to CSS codes, our results also imply that finding the minimum distance of CSS codes is also NP-hard.
Mapping an error syndrome to the error operator is the core of quantum decoding network and is also the key step of recovery. The definitions of the bit-flip error syndrome matrix and the phase-flip error syndrome matrix were presented, and then the error syndromes of quantum errors were expressed in terms of the columns of the bit-flip error syndrome matrix and the phase-flip error syndrome matrix. It also showed that the error syndrome matrices of a stabilizer code are determined by its check matrix, which is similar to the classical case. So, the error-detection and recovery techniques of classical linear codes can be applied to quantum stabilizer codes after some modifications. Some necessary and/or sufficient conditions for the stabilizer code over GF(2) is degenerate or nondegenerate for Pauli channel based on the relationship between the error syndrome matrices and the check matrix was presented. A new way to find the minimum distance of the quantum stabilizer codes based on their check matrices was presented, and followed from which we proved that the performance of degenerate quantum code outperform (at least have the same performance) nondegenerate quantum code for Pauli channel.
Noise is a major obstacle in the development of practical schemes for quantum computation and communication. Similar to the case of classical communication, this noise can be protected against by employing a code, which provides a means for encoding quantum states prior to transmission and allows for errors to be inferred, and hopefully corrected, by a decoder at the receiver. Unfortunately, designing good codes and decoders is typically a difficult problem. This thesis focuses on developing low-complexity heuristic approaches to three such problems: the design of modified belief propagation decoders for quantum low-density parity-check codes, the design of stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels, and the design of codeword stabilized codes. Quantum low-density parity-check codes are stabilizer codes with low-weight generators. Such codes permit low-complexity decoding via the use of belief propagation, which is an iterative message passing algorithm that takes place on a factor graph defined by the code. However, the performance of such a decoder is limited both by code structure and the degenerate nature of quantum errors. To overcome these limitations, at least in part, a number of modifications to belief propagation are developed. Central among these is the augmented decoder, which in the case of a decoding error, iteratively reattempts decoding using modified factor graph. This heuristic modification simply involves the duplication of a randomly selected subset of the graph’s check nodes, which are in one-to-one correspondence with the code’s stabilizer generators. Across a range of codes, it is shown that the decoders developed perform as well as or better than other modified decoders presented in literature. For a number of channels of physical interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these so-called asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be minimized by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, assessing the performance of codes on a given channel is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this complexity, it is shown that the decoding error rate can be accurately approximated using only a small fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. This approximation is then used to identify a number of cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. To further build on this, a heuristic is demonstrated for assessing code performance based on the decoding error rate of an associated classical code. The complexity of calculating this classical error rate is relatively low, and it is shown that it can be used as the basis for a hill-climbing search algorithm. Such searches have yielded a large number of highly performant codes satisfying various structure constraints. The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses both the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. Constructing a standard form codeword stabilized code is a matter of selecting a simple undirected graph and a binary classical code. This makes designing optimal codes difficult as the number of possible graphs grows exponentially with code length, and the clique search required to construct the classical code is NP-hard. To address the exponential growth of the search space, a heuristic is developed for assessing graphs. This heuristic is then employed by a genetic algorithm that also makes use of a novel crossover operation based on spectral bisection, which is show to be superior to more standard crossover operations. With a graph selected, it is demonstrated that the complexity of the clique search required to construct the associated classical code can be mitigated through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. A number of best known codes are presented that have been found using this approach.