Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Heuristics in quantum error correction

Alex Rigby

Published Jan 1, 2021• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Noise is a major obstacle in the development of practical schemes for quantum computation and communication. Similar to the case of classical communication, this noise can be protected against by employing a code, which provides a means for encoding quantum states prior to transmission and allows for errors to be inferred, and hopefully corrected, by a decoder at the receiver. Unfortunately, designing good codes and decoders is typically a difficult problem. This thesis focuses on developing low-complexity heuristic approaches to three such problems: the design of modified belief propagation decoders for quantum low-density parity-check codes, the design of stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels, and the design of codeword stabilized codes. Quantum low-density parity-check codes are stabilizer codes with low-weight generators. Such codes permit low-complexity decoding via the use of belief propagation, which is an iterative message passing algorithm that takes place on a factor graph defined by the code. However, the performance of such a decoder is limited both by code structure and the degenerate nature of quantum errors. To overcome these limitations, at least in part, a number of modifications to belief propagation are developed. Central among these is the augmented decoder, which in the case of a decoding error, iteratively reattempts decoding using modified factor graph. This heuristic modification simply involves the duplication of a randomly selected subset of the graph’s check nodes, which are in one-to-one correspondence with the code’s stabilizer generators. Across a range of codes, it is shown that the decoders developed perform as well as or better than other modified decoders presented in literature. For a number of channels of physical interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these so-called asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be minimized by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, assessing the performance of codes on a given channel is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this complexity, it is shown that the decoding error rate can be accurately approximated using only a small fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. This approximation is then used to identify a number of cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. To further build on this, a heuristic is demonstrated for assessing code performance based on the decoding error rate of an associated classical code. The complexity of calculating this classical error rate is relatively low, and it is shown that it can be used as the basis for a hill-climbing search algorithm. Such searches have yielded a large number of highly performant codes satisfying various structure constraints. The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses both the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. Constructing a standard form codeword stabilized code is a matter of selecting a simple undirected graph and a binary classical code. This makes designing optimal codes difficult as the number of possible graphs grows exponentially with code length, and the clique search required to construct the classical code is NP-hard. To address the exponential growth of the search space, a heuristic is developed for assessing graphs. This heuristic is then employed by a genetic algorithm that also makes use of a novel crossover operation based on spectral bisection, which is show to be superior to more standard crossover operations. With a graph selected, it is demonstrated that the complexity of the clique search required to construct the associated classical code can be mitigated through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. A number of best known codes are presented that have been found using this approach.

DOI
10.25959/100.00037900

Related papers

Optimizing short stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels

Alex Rigby, Jan Corne Olivier, Peter Jarvis

For a number of quantum channels of interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be reduced by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, analyzing the performance of stabilizer codes on these channels is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this, at least for short codes, we demonstrate that the decoding error rate can be approximated by considering only a fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. Using this approximate error rate calculation, we extend a recent result to show that there are a number of $[[5\ensuremath{\le}n\ensuremath{\le}12,1\ensuremath{\le}k\ensuremath{\le}3]]$ cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. We also demonstrate that an indication of a stabilizer code's error rate is given by considering the error rate of a classical binary code related to the stabilizer. This classical error rate is far less complex to calculate, and we use it as the basis for a hill-climbing algorithm, which we show to be effective at optimizing codes for asymmetric channels. Furthermore, we demonstrate that simple modifications can be made to our hill-climbing algorithm to search for codes with desired structure requirements.

arXiv:1911.04196•Physical Review A•Mar 19, 2020•1 citation

High-Rate Quantum Low-Density Parity-Check Codes Assisted by Reliable Qubits

Yuichiro Fujiwara, Alexander Gruner, Peter Vandendriessche

Quantum error correction is an important building block for reliable quantum information processing. A challenging hurdle in the theory of quantum error correction is that it is significantly more difficult to design error-correcting codes with desirable properties for quantum information processing than for traditional digital communications and computation. A typical obstacle to constructing a variety of strong quantum error-correcting codes is the complicated restrictions imposed on the structure of a code. Recently, promising solutions to this problem have been proposed in quantum information science, where in principle any binary linear code can be turned into a quantum error-correcting code by assuming a small number of reliable quantum bits. This paper studies how best to take advantage of these latest ideas to construct desirable quantum error-correcting codes of very high information rate. Our methods exploit structured high-rate low-density parity-check codes available in the classical domain and provide quantum analogues that inherit their characteristic low decoding complexity and high error correction performance even at moderate code lengths. Our approach to designing high-rate quantum error-correcting codes also allows for making direct use of other major syndrome decoding methods for linear codes, making it possible to deal with a situation where promising quantum analogues of low-density parity-check codes are difficult to find.

arXiv:1309.5587•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 30, 2015•17 citations

Trapping Sets of Iterative Decoders for Quantum and Classical Low-Density Parity-Check Codes

Nithin Raveendran

Protecting logical information in the form of a classical bit or a quantum bit (qubit) is an essential step in ensuring fault-tolerant classical or quantum computation. Error correction codes and their decoders perform this step by adding redundant information that aids the decoder to recover or protect the logical information even in the presence of noise. Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes have been one of the most popular error correction candidates in modern communication and data storage systems. Similarly, their quantum analogues, quantum LDPC codes are being actively pursued as excellent prospects for error correction in future fault-tolerant quantum systems due to their asymptotically non-zero rates, sparse parity check matrices, and efficient iterative decoding algorithms. This dissertation deals with failure configurations, known as \emph{trapping sets} of classical and quantum LDPC codes when decoded with iterative message passing decoding algorithms, and the \emph{error floor phenomenon} - the degradation of logical error rate performance at low physical noise regime. The study of quantum trapping sets will enable the construction of better quantum LDPC codes and also help in modifying iterative quantum decoders to achieve higher fault-tolerant thresholds and lower error floors. Towards this goal, the dissertation also presents iterative decoders for classical and quantum LDPC codes using the \emph{deep neural network framework}, novel iterative decoding algorithms, and a decoder-aware \emph{expansion-contraction method} for error floor estimation. In this dissertation, we first establish a systematic methodology by which one can identify and classify \emph{quantum trapping sets} (QTSs) according to their topological structure and decoder used. For this purpose, we leverage the known harmful configurations in the Tanner graph, called \emph{trapping sets} (TSs), from the classical error correction world. The conventional definition of a trapping set of classical LDPC codes is generalized to address the syndrome decoding scenario for quantum LDPC codes. Furthermore, we show that the knowledge of QTSs can be used to design better quantum LDPC codes and decoders. In the context of the development of novel decoders, we extend the stochastic resonance based decoders to quantum LDPC codes, propose iteration-varying message passing decoders with their message update rules learned by neural networks tuned for low logical error rate, and present a syndrome based generalized belief propagation algorithm for tackling convergence failure of iterative decoders due to the presence of short cycles. Our analysis of TSs of a layered decoding architecture clearly reveals the dependence of the harmfulness of TSs (classical or quantum) on the iterative decoder, and thus on the error floor estimates. We present a computationally efficient method for estimating error floors of LDPC codes over the binary symmetric channel without any prior knowledge of its trapping sets. The sub-graph expansion-contraction method is a general procedure for TS characterization, which lists all harmful error patterns up to a given weight for the LDPC code and decoder. Based on this decoder-aware trapping set characterization for LDPC codes, we propose a model-driven deep neural network (DNN) framework that unfolds the decoding iterations, to design the \emph{decoder diversity of finite alphabet iterative decoders (FAIDs)}. Our decoder diversity DNN-FAID delivers excellent waterfall performance along with a low error floor.

•Jan 1, 2021•1 citation

Heuristic construction of codeword stabilized codes

Alex Rigby, Jan Corne Olivier, Peter Jarvis

The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. However, constructing optimal $n$-qubit codeword stabilized codes is made difficult by two main factors. The first of these is the exponential growth with $n$ of the number of graphs on which a code can be based. The second is the NP-hardness of the maximum clique search required to construct a code from a given graph. We address the second of these issues through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. This approach has allowed us to find $((9,97\ensuremath{\le}K\ensuremath{\le}100,2))$ and $((11,387\ensuremath{\le}K\ensuremath{\le}416,2))$ codes, which are larger than any previously known codes. To address the exponential growth of the search space, we demonstrate that graphs that give large codes typically yield clique graphs with a large number of nodes. The number of such nodes can be determined relatively efficiently, and we demonstrate that $n$-node graphs yielding large clique graphs can be found using a genetic algorithm. This algorithm uses a crossover operation based on spectral bisection that we demonstrate to be superior to more standard crossover operations. Using this genetic algorithm approach, we have found ((13, 18, 4)) and ((13, 20, 4)) codes that are larger than any previously known code. We also consider codes for the amplitude damping channel. We demonstrate that for $n\ensuremath{\le}9$, optimal codeword stabilized codes correcting a single amplitude damping error can be found by considering standard form codes that detect one of only three of the ${3}^{n}$ possible equivalent error sets. By combining this error-set selection with the genetic algorithm approach, we have found ((11, 68)) and ((11, 80)) codes capable of correcting a single amplitude damping error and ((11, 4)), ((12, 4)), ((13, 8)), and ((14, 16)) codes capable of correcting two amplitude damping errors.

arXiv:1907.04537•Physical Review A•Dec 2, 2019•4 citations

Quantum stabilizer codes and beyond

Sarvepalli, Pradeep Kiran

The importance of quantum error correction in paving the way to build a practical quantum computer is no longer in doubt. This dissertation makes a threefold contribution to the mathematical theory of quantum error-correcting codes. Firstly, it extends the framework of an important class of quantum codes -- nonbinary stabilizer codes. It clarifies the connections of stabilizer codes to classical codes over quadratic extension fields, provides many new constructions of quantum codes, and develops further the theory of optimal quantum codes and punctured quantum codes. Secondly, it contributes to the theory of operator quantum error correcting codes also called as subsystem codes. These codes are expected to have efficient error recovery schemes than stabilizer codes. This dissertation develops a framework for study and analysis of subsystem codes using character theoretic methods. In particular, this work establishes a close link between subsystem codes and classical codes showing that the subsystem codes can be constructed from arbitrary classical codes. Thirdly, it seeks to exploit the knowledge of noise to design efficient quantum codes and considers more realistic channels than the commonly studied depolarizing channel. It gives systematic constructions of asymmetric quantum stabilizer codes that exploit the asymmetry of errors in certain quantum channels.

arXiv:0810.2574•Oct 14, 2008•9 citations

Quantum Error Correcting Codes

Mikio Nakahara

Quantum computing is a new and exciting field of research that, using the properties of quantum mechanics, has the potential to be a disruptive technology, being able to per form certain computations faster than any classical computer, such as Shor’s factorization algorithm and Grover’s algorithm. Although there are several quantum computer with different underlying technologies, one of the main challenges of quantum computation is the occurence of errors, destroying the information and making computation impossible. Errors may have several different sources namely, thermal noise, faulty gates or incorrect measurements. The present dissertation aims to study and employ methods for reducing the effects of errors during quantum computation and correct them using Stabilizer Codes, which are a very powerful tool to produce circuit encoding networks that can, in theory, protect quantum systems from errors during transmission. A proof of concept algorithm was implemented using Qiskit, a Python based program development language for the IBM Q machines, and tested on both simulators and real systems. The algorithm is capable of, given any stabilizer in standard form, generate the circuit encoding network. Due to technological limitations associated with current quantum computers the results obtained in ibmq_guadalupe fail to show the efficacy of Stabilizer Codes.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 11, 2008•0 citations
Noise is a major obstacle in the development of practical schemes for quantum computation and communication. Similar to the case of classical communication, this noise can be protected against by employing a code, which provides a means for encoding quantum states prior to transmission and allows for errors to be inferred, and hopefully corrected, by a decoder at the receiver. Unfortunately, designing good codes and decoders is typically a difficult problem. This thesis focuses on developing low-complexity heuristic approaches to three such problems: the design of modified belief propagation decoders for quantum low-density parity-check codes, the design of stabilizer codes for asymmetric channels, and the design of codeword stabilized codes. Quantum low-density parity-check codes are stabilizer codes with low-weight generators. Such codes permit low-complexity decoding via the use of belief propagation, which is an iterative message passing algorithm that takes place on a factor graph defined by the code. However, the performance of such a decoder is limited both by code structure and the degenerate nature of quantum errors. To overcome these limitations, at least in part, a number of modifications to belief propagation are developed. Central among these is the augmented decoder, which in the case of a decoding error, iteratively reattempts decoding using modified factor graph. This heuristic modification simply involves the duplication of a randomly selected subset of the graph’s check nodes, which are in one-to-one correspondence with the code’s stabilizer generators. Across a range of codes, it is shown that the decoders developed perform as well as or better than other modified decoders presented in literature. For a number of channels of physical interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these so-called asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be minimized by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, assessing the performance of codes on a given channel is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this complexity, it is shown that the decoding error rate can be accurately approximated using only a small fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. This approximation is then used to identify a number of cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. To further build on this, a heuristic is demonstrated for assessing code performance based on the decoding error rate of an associated classical code. The complexity of calculating this classical error rate is relatively low, and it is shown that it can be used as the basis for a hill-climbing search algorithm. Such searches have yielded a large number of highly performant codes satisfying various structure constraints. The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses both the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. Constructing a standard form codeword stabilized code is a matter of selecting a simple undirected graph and a binary classical code. This makes designing optimal codes difficult as the number of possible graphs grows exponentially with code length, and the clique search required to construct the classical code is NP-hard. To address the exponential growth of the search space, a heuristic is developed for assessing graphs. This heuristic is then employed by a genetic algorithm that also makes use of a novel crossover operation based on spectral bisection, which is show to be superior to more standard crossover operations. With a graph selected, it is demonstrated that the complexity of the clique search required to construct the associated classical code can be mitigated through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. A number of best known codes are presented that have been found using this approach.
For a number of quantum channels of interest, phase-flip errors occur far more frequently than bit-flip errors. When transmitting across these asymmetric channels, the decoding error rate can be reduced by tailoring the code used to the channel. However, analyzing the performance of stabilizer codes on these channels is made difficult by the #P-completeness of optimal decoding. To address this, at least for short codes, we demonstrate that the decoding error rate can be approximated by considering only a fraction of the possible errors caused by the channel. Using this approximate error rate calculation, we extend a recent result to show that there are a number of $[[5\ensuremath{\le}n\ensuremath{\le}12,1\ensuremath{\le}k\ensuremath{\le}3]]$ cyclic stabilizer codes that perform well on two different asymmetric channels. We also demonstrate that an indication of a stabilizer code's error rate is given by considering the error rate of a classical binary code related to the stabilizer. This classical error rate is far less complex to calculate, and we use it as the basis for a hill-climbing algorithm, which we show to be effective at optimizing codes for asymmetric channels. Furthermore, we demonstrate that simple modifications can be made to our hill-climbing algorithm to search for codes with desired structure requirements.
Quantum error correction is an important building block for reliable quantum information processing. A challenging hurdle in the theory of quantum error correction is that it is significantly more difficult to design error-correcting codes with desirable properties for quantum information processing than for traditional digital communications and computation. A typical obstacle to constructing a variety of strong quantum error-correcting codes is the complicated restrictions imposed on the structure of a code. Recently, promising solutions to this problem have been proposed in quantum information science, where in principle any binary linear code can be turned into a quantum error-correcting code by assuming a small number of reliable quantum bits. This paper studies how best to take advantage of these latest ideas to construct desirable quantum error-correcting codes of very high information rate. Our methods exploit structured high-rate low-density parity-check codes available in the classical domain and provide quantum analogues that inherit their characteristic low decoding complexity and high error correction performance even at moderate code lengths. Our approach to designing high-rate quantum error-correcting codes also allows for making direct use of other major syndrome decoding methods for linear codes, making it possible to deal with a situation where promising quantum analogues of low-density parity-check codes are difficult to find.
Protecting logical information in the form of a classical bit or a quantum bit (qubit) is an essential step in ensuring fault-tolerant classical or quantum computation. Error correction codes and their decoders perform this step by adding redundant information that aids the decoder to recover or protect the logical information even in the presence of noise. Low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes have been one of the most popular error correction candidates in modern communication and data storage systems. Similarly, their quantum analogues, quantum LDPC codes are being actively pursued as excellent prospects for error correction in future fault-tolerant quantum systems due to their asymptotically non-zero rates, sparse parity check matrices, and efficient iterative decoding algorithms. This dissertation deals with failure configurations, known as \emph{trapping sets} of classical and quantum LDPC codes when decoded with iterative message passing decoding algorithms, and the \emph{error floor phenomenon} - the degradation of logical error rate performance at low physical noise regime. The study of quantum trapping sets will enable the construction of better quantum LDPC codes and also help in modifying iterative quantum decoders to achieve higher fault-tolerant thresholds and lower error floors. Towards this goal, the dissertation also presents iterative decoders for classical and quantum LDPC codes using the \emph{deep neural network framework}, novel iterative decoding algorithms, and a decoder-aware \emph{expansion-contraction method} for error floor estimation. In this dissertation, we first establish a systematic methodology by which one can identify and classify \emph{quantum trapping sets} (QTSs) according to their topological structure and decoder used. For this purpose, we leverage the known harmful configurations in the Tanner graph, called \emph{trapping sets} (TSs), from the classical error correction world. The conventional definition of a trapping set of classical LDPC codes is generalized to address the syndrome decoding scenario for quantum LDPC codes. Furthermore, we show that the knowledge of QTSs can be used to design better quantum LDPC codes and decoders. In the context of the development of novel decoders, we extend the stochastic resonance based decoders to quantum LDPC codes, propose iteration-varying message passing decoders with their message update rules learned by neural networks tuned for low logical error rate, and present a syndrome based generalized belief propagation algorithm for tackling convergence failure of iterative decoders due to the presence of short cycles. Our analysis of TSs of a layered decoding architecture clearly reveals the dependence of the harmfulness of TSs (classical or quantum) on the iterative decoder, and thus on the error floor estimates. We present a computationally efficient method for estimating error floors of LDPC codes over the binary symmetric channel without any prior knowledge of its trapping sets. The sub-graph expansion-contraction method is a general procedure for TS characterization, which lists all harmful error patterns up to a given weight for the LDPC code and decoder. Based on this decoder-aware trapping set characterization for LDPC codes, we propose a model-driven deep neural network (DNN) framework that unfolds the decoding iterations, to design the \emph{decoder diversity of finite alphabet iterative decoders (FAIDs)}. Our decoder diversity DNN-FAID delivers excellent waterfall performance along with a low error floor.
The family of codeword stabilized codes encompasses the stabilizer codes as well as many of the best known nonadditive codes. However, constructing optimal nnn-qubit codeword stabilized codes is made difficult by two main factors. The first of these is the exponential growth with nnn of the number of graphs on which a code can be based. The second is the NP-hardness of the maximum clique search required to construct a code from a given graph. We address the second of these issues through the use of a heuristic clique finding algorithm. This approach has allowed us to find $((9,97\ensuremath{\le}K\ensuremath{\le}100,2))$ and $((11,387\ensuremath{\le}K\ensuremath{\le}416,2))$ codes, which are larger than any previously known codes. To address the exponential growth of the search space, we demonstrate that graphs that give large codes typically yield clique graphs with a large number of nodes. The number of such nodes can be determined relatively efficiently, and we demonstrate that nnn-node graphs yielding large clique graphs can be found using a genetic algorithm. This algorithm uses a crossover operation based on spectral bisection that we demonstrate to be superior to more standard crossover operations. Using this genetic algorithm approach, we have found ((13, 18, 4)) and ((13, 20, 4)) codes that are larger than any previously known code. We also consider codes for the amplitude damping channel. We demonstrate that for $n\ensuremath{\le}9$, optimal codeword stabilized codes correcting a single amplitude damping error can be found by considering standard form codes that detect one of only three of the 3n{3}^{n}3n possible equivalent error sets. By combining this error-set selection with the genetic algorithm approach, we have found ((11, 68)) and ((11, 80)) codes capable of correcting a single amplitude damping error and ((11, 4)), ((12, 4)), ((13, 8)), and ((14, 16)) codes capable of correcting two amplitude damping errors.
The importance of quantum error correction in paving the way to build a practical quantum computer is no longer in doubt. This dissertation makes a threefold contribution to the mathematical theory of quantum error-correcting codes. Firstly, it extends the framework of an important class of quantum codes -- nonbinary stabilizer codes. It clarifies the connections of stabilizer codes to classical codes over quadratic extension fields, provides many new constructions of quantum codes, and develops further the theory of optimal quantum codes and punctured quantum codes. Secondly, it contributes to the theory of operator quantum error correcting codes also called as subsystem codes. These codes are expected to have efficient error recovery schemes than stabilizer codes. This dissertation develops a framework for study and analysis of subsystem codes using character theoretic methods. In particular, this work establishes a close link between subsystem codes and classical codes showing that the subsystem codes can be constructed from arbitrary classical codes. Thirdly, it seeks to exploit the knowledge of noise to design efficient quantum codes and considers more realistic channels than the commonly studied depolarizing channel. It gives systematic constructions of asymmetric quantum stabilizer codes that exploit the asymmetry of errors in certain quantum channels.
Quantum computing is a new and exciting field of research that, using the properties of quantum mechanics, has the potential to be a disruptive technology, being able to per form certain computations faster than any classical computer, such as Shor’s factorization algorithm and Grover’s algorithm. Although there are several quantum computer with different underlying technologies, one of the main challenges of quantum computation is the occurence of errors, destroying the information and making computation impossible. Errors may have several different sources namely, thermal noise, faulty gates or incorrect measurements. The present dissertation aims to study and employ methods for reducing the effects of errors during quantum computation and correct them using Stabilizer Codes, which are a very powerful tool to produce circuit encoding networks that can, in theory, protect quantum systems from errors during transmission. A proof of concept algorithm was implemented using Qiskit, a Python based program development language for the IBM Q machines, and tested on both simulators and real systems. The algorithm is capable of, given any stabilizer in standard form, generate the circuit encoding network. Due to technological limitations associated with current quantum computers the results obtained in ibmq_guadalupe fail to show the efficacy of Stabilizer Codes.