Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1307.3746 · Physical Review Letters

Coarsening Measurement References and the Quantum-to-Classical Transition

Hyunseok Jeong, Youngrong Lim, M. S. Kim

Published Jan 6, 2014• 66 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the role of inefficiency in quantum measurements in the quantum-to-classical transition, and consistently observe the quantum-to-classical transition by coarsening the references of the measurements (e.g., when and where to measure). Our result suggests that the definition of measurement precision in quantum theory should include the degree of the observer's ability to precisely control the measurement references.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.112.010402

Related papers

Quantum metrology in coarsened measurement reference

Dong Xie, Chunling Xu, An Min Wang

We investigate the role of coarsened measurement reference, which originates from the coarsened reference time and basis, in quantum metrology. When the measurement is based on one common reference basis, the disadvantage of coarsened measurement can be removed by symmetry. Owing to the coarsened reference basis, the entangled state cannot perform better than the product state for a large number of probe particles in estimating the phase. Given a finite uncertainty of the coarsened reference basis, the optimal number of probe particles is obtained. Finally, we prove that the maximally entangled state always achieves better frequency precision in the case of non-Markovian dephasing than that in the case of Markovian dephasing. The product state is more resistant to the interference of the coarsened reference time than the entangled state.

arXiv:1608.07684•Physical Review A•Jan 17, 2017•6 citations

General coarsened measurement references for revelation of a classical world

Dong Xie, Chunling Xu, An Min Wang

It has been found that the quantum-to-classical transition can be observed independent of macroscopicity of the quantum state for a fixed degree of fuzziness in the coarsened references of measurements. Here, a general situation, that is the degree of fuzziness can change with the rotation angle between two states (different rotation angles represent different references), is researched based on the reason that the fuzziness of reference can come from two kinds: the Hamiltonian (rotation frequency) and the timing (rotation time). Our results show that, for the fuzziness of Hamiltonian alone, the degree of fuzziness for reference will change with the rotation angle between two states and the quantum effects can still be observed no matter how much degree of fuzziness of Hamiltonian; for the fuzziness of timing, the degree of coarsening reference is unchanged with the rotation angle. Moreover, during the rotation of the measurement axis, the decoherence environment can also help the classical-to-quantum transition due to changing the direction of measurement axis.

arXiv:1404.5179•Chinese Physics B•Nov 1, 2016•0 citations

Precision Limit for Observation: The Bridge for Quantum Classical Transitions

Suyu Li, Canneng Liang, Mingxing Jin

Quantum mechanics (QM) is an extremely successful theory; however, there is still no consensus regarding its interpretation. Among the controversies, the quantum classical transitions are the outstanding questions. In this paper, starting from measurement theory, we discuss the role that the precision limit for observation plays in QM and attempt to lubricate the relationship between the precision limit and some unique characters and nature of QM. By reviewing Bohmian mechanics, one of the nonlocal hidden variable theories, we discuss the possibility of restoring determinism in QM. We conclude that it is the existence of the precision limit that makes it impossible to restore determinism in QM, and it is the root that makes QM different from classical physics. Finally, the boundary between the so-called classical and quantum worlds is discussed. We hope these philosophical arguments can provide a kind of epistemic understanding for QM.

Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2025•1 citation

Tensile quantum-to-classical transition of macroscopic entangled states under complete coarse-grained measurements

Laxmi Prasad Naik, Tamal Ghosh, Sumit Mukherjee +2 more

The departure of the quantum world from the classical regime is captured through the observation of nonclassical correlations manifested in the behaviors of subatomic systems. However, once the dimension of the system becomes substantially large, the quantum behavior begins to decline, and subsequently it starts following the predictions of classical physics. The macroscopic limit at which such quantum-to-classical transition occurs remains one of the long-standing questions in the foundations of quantum theory. There are evidences that the macroscopic limit to which the quantumness of a system persists depends on the degree of interaction due to the measurement processes. For instance, with a system having a considerably large Hilbert-space dimension, if the measurement is performed in such a way that the outcome of the measurement only reveals a coarse-grained version of the information about the individual level of the concerned system then the disturbance due to the measurement process can be considered to be infinitesimally small. Based on such coarse-grained measurement the dependence of Bell inequality violation on the degree of coarsening has already been investigated [H. Jeong, Y. Lim, and M. S. Kim, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 010402 (2014)]. In this paper, we first capture the fact that, when local realism is taken to be the defining notion of classicality, the effect of the degree of coarsening on the downfall of quantumness of a macroscopic entangled state can be compensated by testing a Bell inequality of a higher number of settings from a family of symmetric Bell inequalities if the number of settings is odd. However, in contrast, we show that such compensation cannot be seen when we witness such quantum-to-classical transition using symmetric Bell inequalities having an even number of settings. Finally, complementing the above result, we show that, when unsteerability is taken as the classicality, for both odd and even numbers of settings the degree of coarsening at which the quantum-to-classical transition occurs can be consistently pushed ahead by testing a linear steering inequality of a higher number of settings and observing its violation. We further extend our treatment for mixed macroscopic entangled states.

arXiv:2310.10178•Physical Review A•Feb 2, 2024•2 citations

Quantum measurement theory

Kurt A. Jacobs

Introduction and overview Much that is studied in quantum measurement theory, and thus in this book, is very different from that studied in its classical counterpart, Bayesian inference. While quantum measurement theory is in one sense a minimal extension of the latter to quantum states, quantum measurements cause dynamical changes that never need appear in a classical theory. This has a multitude of ramifications, many of which you will find in this book. One such consequence is a limit to the information that can be obtained about the state of a quantum system, and this results in relationships between information gained and dynamics induced that do not exist in classical systems. Because of the limits to information extraction, choosing the right kinds of measurements becomes important in a way that it never was for classical systems. Finding the best measurements for a given purpose, and working out how to realize these measurements, is often nontrivial. The relationship between information and disturbance impacts the control of quantum systems using measurements and feedback, and we discuss this application in Chapter 5. The ability to extract information about quantum systems is also important in using quantum systems to make precise measurements of classical quantities such as time, acceleration, and the strengths of electric and magnetic fields. This subject is referred to as quantum metrology, and we discuss it in Chapter 6.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 14, 2014•10 citations

The measurement problem in the light of the theory of decoherence

Antoine Soulas

Endeavoring to formulate an exhaustive solution to the measurement problem in view of the theory of decoherence leads to a better understanding of the status of the collapse and of the emergence of classicality, thanks to a precise definition of the measurement and some new vocabulary to speak about quantum mechanics. Considering the latter as a probabilistic theory all along allows us to avoid the usual probability problem of the many-worlds interpretations. A thorough verification of the consistency of quantum mechanics at all scales is proposed, as well as a discussion of what can be deemed an observer.

arXiv:2303.03465•Mar 6, 2023•4 citations
We investigate the role of inefficiency in quantum measurements in the quantum-to-classical transition, and consistently observe the quantum-to-classical transition by coarsening the references of the measurements (e.g., when and where to measure). Our result suggests that the definition of measurement precision in quantum theory should include the degree of the observer's ability to precisely control the measurement references.
We investigate the role of coarsened measurement reference, which originates from the coarsened reference time and basis, in quantum metrology. When the measurement is based on one common reference basis, the disadvantage of coarsened measurement can be removed by symmetry. Owing to the coarsened reference basis, the entangled state cannot perform better than the product state for a large number of probe particles in estimating the phase. Given a finite uncertainty of the coarsened reference basis, the optimal number of probe particles is obtained. Finally, we prove that the maximally entangled state always achieves better frequency precision in the case of non-Markovian dephasing than that in the case of Markovian dephasing. The product state is more resistant to the interference of the coarsened reference time than the entangled state.
It has been found that the quantum-to-classical transition can be observed independent of macroscopicity of the quantum state for a fixed degree of fuzziness in the coarsened references of measurements. Here, a general situation, that is the degree of fuzziness can change with the rotation angle between two states (different rotation angles represent different references), is researched based on the reason that the fuzziness of reference can come from two kinds: the Hamiltonian (rotation frequency) and the timing (rotation time). Our results show that, for the fuzziness of Hamiltonian alone, the degree of fuzziness for reference will change with the rotation angle between two states and the quantum effects can still be observed no matter how much degree of fuzziness of Hamiltonian; for the fuzziness of timing, the degree of coarsening reference is unchanged with the rotation angle. Moreover, during the rotation of the measurement axis, the decoherence environment can also help the classical-to-quantum transition due to changing the direction of measurement axis.
Quantum mechanics (QM) is an extremely successful theory; however, there is still no consensus regarding its interpretation. Among the controversies, the quantum classical transitions are the outstanding questions. In this paper, starting from measurement theory, we discuss the role that the precision limit for observation plays in QM and attempt to lubricate the relationship between the precision limit and some unique characters and nature of QM. By reviewing Bohmian mechanics, one of the nonlocal hidden variable theories, we discuss the possibility of restoring determinism in QM. We conclude that it is the existence of the precision limit that makes it impossible to restore determinism in QM, and it is the root that makes QM different from classical physics. Finally, the boundary between the so-called classical and quantum worlds is discussed. We hope these philosophical arguments can provide a kind of epistemic understanding for QM.
The departure of the quantum world from the classical regime is captured through the observation of nonclassical correlations manifested in the behaviors of subatomic systems. However, once the dimension of the system becomes substantially large, the quantum behavior begins to decline, and subsequently it starts following the predictions of classical physics. The macroscopic limit at which such quantum-to-classical transition occurs remains one of the long-standing questions in the foundations of quantum theory. There are evidences that the macroscopic limit to which the quantumness of a system persists depends on the degree of interaction due to the measurement processes. For instance, with a system having a considerably large Hilbert-space dimension, if the measurement is performed in such a way that the outcome of the measurement only reveals a coarse-grained version of the information about the individual level of the concerned system then the disturbance due to the measurement process can be considered to be infinitesimally small. Based on such coarse-grained measurement the dependence of Bell inequality violation on the degree of coarsening has already been investigated [H. Jeong, Y. Lim, and M. S. Kim, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 010402 (2014)]. In this paper, we first capture the fact that, when local realism is taken to be the defining notion of classicality, the effect of the degree of coarsening on the downfall of quantumness of a macroscopic entangled state can be compensated by testing a Bell inequality of a higher number of settings from a family of symmetric Bell inequalities if the number of settings is odd. However, in contrast, we show that such compensation cannot be seen when we witness such quantum-to-classical transition using symmetric Bell inequalities having an even number of settings. Finally, complementing the above result, we show that, when unsteerability is taken as the classicality, for both odd and even numbers of settings the degree of coarsening at which the quantum-to-classical transition occurs can be consistently pushed ahead by testing a linear steering inequality of a higher number of settings and observing its violation. We further extend our treatment for mixed macroscopic entangled states.
Introduction and overview Much that is studied in quantum measurement theory, and thus in this book, is very different from that studied in its classical counterpart, Bayesian inference. While quantum measurement theory is in one sense a minimal extension of the latter to quantum states, quantum measurements cause dynamical changes that never need appear in a classical theory. This has a multitude of ramifications, many of which you will find in this book. One such consequence is a limit to the information that can be obtained about the state of a quantum system, and this results in relationships between information gained and dynamics induced that do not exist in classical systems. Because of the limits to information extraction, choosing the right kinds of measurements becomes important in a way that it never was for classical systems. Finding the best measurements for a given purpose, and working out how to realize these measurements, is often nontrivial. The relationship between information and disturbance impacts the control of quantum systems using measurements and feedback, and we discuss this application in Chapter 5. The ability to extract information about quantum systems is also important in using quantum systems to make precise measurements of classical quantities such as time, acceleration, and the strengths of electric and magnetic fields. This subject is referred to as quantum metrology, and we discuss it in Chapter 6.
Endeavoring to formulate an exhaustive solution to the measurement problem in view of the theory of decoherence leads to a better understanding of the status of the collapse and of the emergence of classicality, thanks to a precise definition of the measurement and some new vocabulary to speak about quantum mechanics. Considering the latter as a probabilistic theory all along allows us to avoid the usual probability problem of the many-worlds interpretations. A thorough verification of the consistency of quantum mechanics at all scales is proposed, as well as a discussion of what can be deemed an observer.