Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2303.03465

The measurement problem in the light of the theory of decoherence

Antoine Soulas

Published Mar 6, 2023• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Endeavoring to formulate an exhaustive solution to the measurement problem in view of the theory of decoherence leads to a better understanding of the status of the collapse and of the emergence of classicality, thanks to a precise definition of the measurement and some new vocabulary to speak about quantum mechanics. Considering the latter as a probabilistic theory all along allows us to avoid the usual probability problem of the many-worlds interpretations. A thorough verification of the consistency of quantum mechanics at all scales is proposed, as well as a discussion of what can be deemed an observer.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2303.03465

Related papers

The Quantum Measurement Problem: Foundations, Interpretations, and Recent Developments

Adam Dakhil Nasser

Quantum mechanics famously posits two distinct evolution rules for the state of a system: a deterministic, unitary time evolution under the Schr¨odinger equation, and a probabilistic “collapse” of the wavefunction upon measurement as dictated by the Born rule. The apparent inconsistency of these two dynamical laws – one continuous and one discontinuous – constitutes the quantum measurement problem. This foundational problem, which underlies the emergence of definite outcomes from quantum superpositions, has persisted since the theory’s inception. In this review, we present a comprehensive and rigorous examination of the measurement problem and survey the leading approaches that seek to resolve or circumvent it. We begin by formulating the measurement problem and its conceptual challenges. We then discuss in detail the major interpretations of quantum mechanics and theoretical frameworks addressing the problem: the Copenhagen interpretation, Everett’s many-worlds interpretation, de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, objective collapse models, the role of decoherence and environment-induced superselection, and epistemic approaches such as QBism. For each interpretation, we describe the core principles and mathematical formalism, assessing how (and whether) it attempts to solve the measurement problem. We also review modern developments and experiments relevant to quantum measurements, including tests of Bell inequalities, observations of decoherence and macroscopic superpositions, weak measurements and quantum eraser experiments, and thought experiments ‘a la Wigner’s friend. We highlight how these results inform the ongoing debate. Finally, we discuss open problems and challenges that remain in fully resolving the measurement problem.

•Apr 15, 2025•5 citations

The Measurement Problem, Decoherence andEducation

Ruward A. Mulder

A study is made of the status of measurement, in particular the projection postulate,\nin quantum mechanics. Part of this will be a historical outlook: how was the concept of\nmeasurement viewed by the quantum architects? Then a more systematic investigation is made\non what has been called the measurement problem which poses the question why superpositions\nof quantum states are never observed. Reasons are given why the projection postulate does not\nform a satisfactory solution, namely the non-unitary evolution of time and the lack of a precise\nde?nition of the word `measurement'. Since the 1980's active research has been undertaken\nin the ?eld of decoherence phenonema. Environment-induced decoherence has been proposed\nto solve the measurement problem by looking at open quantum systems instead of closed\nones. It is inquired upon to what extent decoherence is indeed a solution. It has been shown\nthat the fundamental problem survives, but a justi?cation is found for the appearance of\nclassical properties in a universal quantum world. Although the discussion on the decoherence\nsolution has arrived at an approximate equilibrium since the ?rst few years of this century,\nthe terms `decoherence' and `collapse' are still used interchangeably in a vast amount of the\nliterature. This is pointed out to be an uncareful use of words. However, the decoherence\nprogram has inspired a new way of thinking about interpretations, giving preference to some\nmodern interpretations - the non-collapse theories - over the early Copenhagen or subjective\ninterpretations. It seems that the ideas behind decoherence theories have seeped through to\nthe most modern textbooks. However, the textbooks currently in use mostly date back to the\northodox times of the late 1980's. According to the recent textbooks, it seems that a shift in\nteaching interpretational quantum mechanics is to be expected, similar to the impact Bell's\ninequalities made on education in the early 1980's.

•Aug 26, 2014•0 citations

The Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics and Its Solutions—Part I

Andréa Oldofredi

ABSTRACT This essay aims at reviewing one of the major difficulties affecting the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, that is, the well‐known measurement problem. As it will be explained, the latter originates as a consequence of the quantum theory's postulates. Referring to this, we analyze in particular the conceptual issues implied by the projection (or collapse) rule. After having presented the measurement problem, we then illustrate three possible solutions offered by major interpretations of/alternatives to quantum theory: Bohmian mechanics, Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber theories, and the many‐worlds interpretation. As the reader will see, these theoretical frameworks solve this issue by virtue of their unambiguous ontologies and consistent dynamical laws. Finally, a synopsis of the open debates and future perspectives concerning the measurement problem in relativistic contexts concludes the paper.

Philosophy Compass•May 1, 2025•4 citations

The Epistemological Development and New Trend of Quantum Measurement Theory

HE Tian-pin

In allusion to the center issue of philosophical debate of quantum mechanics: how to translate from quantum to classical world in quantum measurement,we discuss some solved and unsolved questions by many mind interpretation,model interpretation and decoherence interpretation,and present a new solution to measurement problem.

Kexue jishu zhexue yanjiu•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics

Bas Hensen

It is the purpose of this essay to review the theory of environment-induced decoherence, and its implications for the traditional problem of quantum measurement, intimately related to the emergence of the classical world from a quantum reality. Additionally we discuss how decoherence fits in with a number of traditional and more recent interpretations of quantum theory.

•May 1, 2010•10 citations

Measurement in Quantum Mechanics: Decoherence and the Pointer Basis

Anu Venugopalan

Quantum Mechanics represents one of the greatest triumphs of the scientific enterprise of the twentieth century. The stunning success of quantum theory has led to many revolutionary inventions and its extraordinary concepts describe the heart of several important real world applications like transistors and lasers. The theory makes accurate predictions about a wide range of physical phenomena and has historically withstood the tests and scrutiny of every experimental investigation. However, inspite of the fact that quantum theory is widely regarded by the scientific establishment as the fundamental theory of nature and is immensly successful and useful, its conceptual framework makes many predictions which are difficult to comprehend “classically. The theory is, pardoxically, powerful and confusing at the same time. Quantum theory’s unusual predictions originate from its basic formailsm which involves concepts like probability amplitudes and the linear superposition principle(Dirac, 1947). The quantum view appears abstract and counterintuitive and at odds with classical perceptions. Many of the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics are encompassed in what is known as the quantum measurement problem(Peres, 1986; von Neumann, 1932; Wheeler & Zurek, 1983). Conventionally, the measurement paradox is supposedly ’resolved’ by forcing a notion of a sudden collapse of the state vector of the system being measured. However, the nature of this mechanism is at odds with the basic tenets of quantum mechanics and hence may lie outside its realm thus questioning the validity of the theory it self. Closely related with the problem of measurement in quantum mechanics is the question of its connection with the emergence of classicality and the elusive boundary between quantum and classical worlds. What is the connection between the ‘classical’ and the ‘quantum’ worlds? Is there a definite relationship? Are classical mechanics and quantum mechanics two mutually exclusive incompatible theories or are they two aspects of the same underlying philosophy? Classical objects are eventually composed of elements of the microworld which can be described quantum mechanically. So, how and where can there be a boundary between the two worlds? In the following section we begin by introducing the quantum measurement problem. In the next section we will discuss attempts to understand and explain away the underlying paradoxes in quantum theory as highlighted in the quantum measurement problem and the question of the quantum-classical connection. From among the various explanations that seek a resolution to the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics, we focus on the ‘environment induced decoherence theory’ an approach that employs the methods developed by several authors to analyse the quantum mechanics of Measurement in Quantum Mechanics: Decoherence and the Pointer Basis

InTech eBooks•Feb 22, 2012•1 citation
Endeavoring to formulate an exhaustive solution to the measurement problem in view of the theory of decoherence leads to a better understanding of the status of the collapse and of the emergence of classicality, thanks to a precise definition of the measurement and some new vocabulary to speak about quantum mechanics. Considering the latter as a probabilistic theory all along allows us to avoid the usual probability problem of the many-worlds interpretations. A thorough verification of the consistency of quantum mechanics at all scales is proposed, as well as a discussion of what can be deemed an observer.
Quantum mechanics famously posits two distinct evolution rules for the state of a system: a deterministic, unitary time evolution under the Schr¨odinger equation, and a probabilistic “collapse” of the wavefunction upon measurement as dictated by the Born rule. The apparent inconsistency of these two dynamical laws – one continuous and one discontinuous – constitutes the quantum measurement problem. This foundational problem, which underlies the emergence of definite outcomes from quantum superpositions, has persisted since the theory’s inception. In this review, we present a comprehensive and rigorous examination of the measurement problem and survey the leading approaches that seek to resolve or circumvent it. We begin by formulating the measurement problem and its conceptual challenges. We then discuss in detail the major interpretations of quantum mechanics and theoretical frameworks addressing the problem: the Copenhagen interpretation, Everett’s many-worlds interpretation, de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory, objective collapse models, the role of decoherence and environment-induced superselection, and epistemic approaches such as QBism. For each interpretation, we describe the core principles and mathematical formalism, assessing how (and whether) it attempts to solve the measurement problem. We also review modern developments and experiments relevant to quantum measurements, including tests of Bell inequalities, observations of decoherence and macroscopic superpositions, weak measurements and quantum eraser experiments, and thought experiments ‘a la Wigner’s friend. We highlight how these results inform the ongoing debate. Finally, we discuss open problems and challenges that remain in fully resolving the measurement problem.
A study is made of the status of measurement, in particular the projection postulate,\nin quantum mechanics. Part of this will be a historical outlook: how was the concept of\nmeasurement viewed by the quantum architects? Then a more systematic investigation is made\non what has been called the measurement problem which poses the question why superpositions\nof quantum states are never observed. Reasons are given why the projection postulate does not\nform a satisfactory solution, namely the non-unitary evolution of time and the lack of a precise\nde?nition of the word `measurement'. Since the 1980's active research has been undertaken\nin the ?eld of decoherence phenonema. Environment-induced decoherence has been proposed\nto solve the measurement problem by looking at open quantum systems instead of closed\nones. It is inquired upon to what extent decoherence is indeed a solution. It has been shown\nthat the fundamental problem survives, but a justi?cation is found for the appearance of\nclassical properties in a universal quantum world. Although the discussion on the decoherence\nsolution has arrived at an approximate equilibrium since the ?rst few years of this century,\nthe terms `decoherence' and `collapse' are still used interchangeably in a vast amount of the\nliterature. This is pointed out to be an uncareful use of words. However, the decoherence\nprogram has inspired a new way of thinking about interpretations, giving preference to some\nmodern interpretations - the non-collapse theories - over the early Copenhagen or subjective\ninterpretations. It seems that the ideas behind decoherence theories have seeped through to\nthe most modern textbooks. However, the textbooks currently in use mostly date back to the\northodox times of the late 1980's. According to the recent textbooks, it seems that a shift in\nteaching interpretational quantum mechanics is to be expected, similar to the impact Bell's\ninequalities made on education in the early 1980's.
ABSTRACT This essay aims at reviewing one of the major difficulties affecting the standard formulation of quantum mechanics, that is, the well‐known measurement problem. As it will be explained, the latter originates as a consequence of the quantum theory's postulates. Referring to this, we analyze in particular the conceptual issues implied by the projection (or collapse) rule. After having presented the measurement problem, we then illustrate three possible solutions offered by major interpretations of/alternatives to quantum theory: Bohmian mechanics, Ghirardi–Rimini–Weber theories, and the many‐worlds interpretation. As the reader will see, these theoretical frameworks solve this issue by virtue of their unambiguous ontologies and consistent dynamical laws. Finally, a synopsis of the open debates and future perspectives concerning the measurement problem in relativistic contexts concludes the paper.
Quantum Mechanics represents one of the greatest triumphs of the scientific enterprise of the twentieth century. The stunning success of quantum theory has led to many revolutionary inventions and its extraordinary concepts describe the heart of several important real world applications like transistors and lasers. The theory makes accurate predictions about a wide range of physical phenomena and has historically withstood the tests and scrutiny of every experimental investigation. However, inspite of the fact that quantum theory is widely regarded by the scientific establishment as the fundamental theory of nature and is immensly successful and useful, its conceptual framework makes many predictions which are difficult to comprehend “classically. The theory is, pardoxically, powerful and confusing at the same time. Quantum theory’s unusual predictions originate from its basic formailsm which involves concepts like probability amplitudes and the linear superposition principle(Dirac, 1947). The quantum view appears abstract and counterintuitive and at odds with classical perceptions. Many of the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics are encompassed in what is known as the quantum measurement problem(Peres, 1986; von Neumann, 1932; Wheeler & Zurek, 1983). Conventionally, the measurement paradox is supposedly ’resolved’ by forcing a notion of a sudden collapse of the state vector of the system being measured. However, the nature of this mechanism is at odds with the basic tenets of quantum mechanics and hence may lie outside its realm thus questioning the validity of the theory it self. Closely related with the problem of measurement in quantum mechanics is the question of its connection with the emergence of classicality and the elusive boundary between quantum and classical worlds. What is the connection between the ‘classical’ and the ‘quantum’ worlds? Is there a definite relationship? Are classical mechanics and quantum mechanics two mutually exclusive incompatible theories or are they two aspects of the same underlying philosophy? Classical objects are eventually composed of elements of the microworld which can be described quantum mechanically. So, how and where can there be a boundary between the two worlds? In the following section we begin by introducing the quantum measurement problem. In the next section we will discuss attempts to understand and explain away the underlying paradoxes in quantum theory as highlighted in the quantum measurement problem and the question of the quantum-classical connection. From among the various explanations that seek a resolution to the conceptual problems of quantum mechanics, we focus on the ‘environment induced decoherence theory’ an approach that employs the methods developed by several authors to analyse the quantum mechanics of Measurement in Quantum Mechanics: Decoherence and the Pointer Basis