Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1307.2026 · Scientific Reports

Quantum probability assignment limited by relativistic causality

Yeong Deok Han, Taeseung Choi

Published Mar 14, 2016• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum theory has nonlocal correlations, which bothered Einstein, but found to satisfy relativistic causality. Correlation for a shared quantum state manifests itself, in the standard quantum framework, by joint probability distributions that can be obtained by applying state reduction and probability assignment that is called Born rule. Quantum correlations, which show nonlocality when the shared state has an entanglement, can be changed if we apply different probability assignment rule. As a result, the amount of nonlocality in quantum correlation will be changed. The issue is whether the change of the rule of quantum probability assignment breaks relativistic causality. We have shown that Born rule on quantum measurement is derived by requiring relativistic causality condition. This shows how the relativistic causality limits the upper bound of quantum nonlocality through quantum probability assignment.

DOI
10.1038/srep22986

Related papers

Limits on Quantum Probability Rule by no-Signaling Principle

Yeong Deok Han, Taeseung Choi

We have studied the possibility of post-quantum theories more nonlocal than the (standard) quantum theory using the modification of the quantum probability rule under the no-signaling condition. For this purpose we have considered the situation that two spacelike separate parties Alice and Bob share an entangled two qubit system. We have modified the quantum probability rule as small as possible such that the first local measurements are governed by the usual Born rule and the second measurement by the modified quantum probability rule. We have shown that only the maximally entangled states can have higher nonlocality than the quantum upper bound while satisfying the no-signaling condition. This fact could be a partial explanation for why the nonlocality of the quantum theory is limited. As a by-product we have found the systematic way to obtain a variety of nonlocal boxes.

arXiv:1208.2814•Aug 14, 2012•0 citations

Consistent theory for causal non-locality beyond the Born’s rule

Wonmin Son

According to the theory of relativity and causality, a special type of correlation beyond quantum mechanics is possible in principle under the name of a non-local box . The concept has been introduced from the principle of non-locality, which satisfies relativistic causality. In this paper, we show that a correlation leading to the non-local box can be derived consistently if we release one of major axioms in quantum mechanics, Born’s rule . This allows us to obtain a theory that in one end of the spectrum agrees with the classical probability and in the other end agrees with the theory of non-local causality. At the same time, we argue that the correlation lies in a space with special mathematical constraints such that a physical realization of the correlation through a probability measure is not possible in one direction of its limit, but is possible in the other limit.

arXiv:1401.1012•Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Feb 1, 2014•6 citations

Entanglement without the Entangled State: A Local Theory of Qubits with an Extended Born Rule

Sermet Yücel

Entangled qubits are interconnected at any separation. Quantum mechanics represents the interconnection by one unfactorizable entangled state. A measurement at one station collapses the entangled state and fixes the state assigned to the other qubit, depending on the outcome. Interpreted as physics, the entangled state and wavefunction collapse conflict with Einstein's separability and locality. We resolve the conflict by Corpuscular Quantum Mechanics, which replaces the entangled state with source constraints and reproduces the quantum joint probabilities exactly. Each qubit leaves the source carrying one of two definite states and an unshared random variable. An extended Born rule assigns a generally complex coefficient to the transition from the source-assigned state to the recorded outcome, using only what the qubit carries and the locally chosen measurement direction. Averaging products of the coefficients over the source ensemble returns the joint probabilities. Nothing is fitted. An exact identity maps the amplitudes of any pure n-qubit state to the source constraints. We prove the random variables admit a positive distribution meeting the constraints. The identity yields the joint probabilities of the Bell, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger, Eberhard, W, Hardy, and Dicke states for arbitrary directions. The resolution requires no action at a distance, no collapse, and no outcomes for unperformed measurements. The one change is that the event-level quantity is a transition coefficient, not a probability. Bell's theorem therefore does not apply. Quantum mechanics is thus one recipe for computing the correlations, and the entangled state is a feature of the recipe, not of nature.

•Sep 14, 2026•0 citations

A measurable physical theory of hyper-correlations beyond quantum mechanics

Tristan Farrow, Vlatko Vedral, Wonmin Son

Abstract A unique characteristic of quantum mechanics is entanglement describing correlations between particles irrespective of their locations. This property, called non-locality, has no classical analogue. Over the past few years, quantum physicists have reached a consensus that we lack a physical theory to account for a class of states whose non-local character exceeds the bounds allowed by quantum mechanics. Motivated by our observation that an extension of the Schrödinger equation with non-linear terms is directly linked to a relaxation of Born’s rule, an axiom of quantum mechanics, we derive a physical theory that accounts for such hyper-correlated states and modifies Born’s rule. We model correlated particles with a generalized probability theory whose dynamics are described with a non-linear version of Schrödinger’s equation and demonstrate how that deviates from the standard formulation of quantum mechanics in experimental probability-prediction. We show also that the violation of the Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality, the amount of non-locality, is proportional to the degree of non-linearity, which can be experimentally tested.

Physica Scripta•Oct 29, 2020•0 citations

Nonlocality as an axiom for quantum theory

Daniel Rohrlich, Sandu Popescu

Quantum mechanics and relativistic causality together imply nonlocality: nonlocal correlations (that violate the CHSH inequality) and nonlocal equations of motion (the Aharonov-Bohm effect). Can we invert the logical order? We consider a conjecture that nonlocality and relativistic causality together imply quantum mechanics. We show that correlations preserving relativistic causality can violate the CHSH inequality more strongly than quantum correlations. Also, we describe nonlocal equations of motion, preserving relativistic causality, that do not arise in quantum mechanics. In these nonlocal equations of motion, an experimenter ``jams" nonlocal correlations between quantum systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/9508009•Aug 9, 1995•63 citations

The Explanation of Entanglement in Quantum Mechanics

H. S. Perlman

It is shown that quantum mechanics is, like thermodynamics, a phenomenological theory i.e., not a causal theory, ( not because it is a statistical theory - statistical theories with caused probability distributions can be regarded as causal) but because pure states, i.e., probability distributions of measurement values, cannot inhere in elementary particles and therefore cannot change when their world tubes intersect and hence they cannot be regarded as interacting causally. By a causal theory is meant a theory that specifies the changes in time of the states of causally interacting entities in its domain. The areas in quantum mechanics in which causal interactions are relevant include, though not explicitly, measurement and therefore the Born rule, and, explicitly, the unitary Schrodinger time development of states. The Born rule probabilities are shown to to refer not to conjoint superpositions of eigenstates but to classical mixtures of mutually exclusive eigenvalues and the Schrodinger time development of states is shown to refer to the time development of the states of non-causally interacting elementary particles and hence cannot be regarded as as a causal time development equation, appearances to the contrary notwithstanding. The recognition that quantum mechanics is not a causal theory but a phenomenological theory like thermodynamics does not affect the way it is employed to calculate an predict and hence preserves its empirical success but it does allow a typically simple phenomenological theory explanation of entanglement and other apparently non-local phenomena.

arXiv:2305.01525•Apr 28, 2023•0 citations
Quantum theory has nonlocal correlations, which bothered Einstein, but found to satisfy relativistic causality. Correlation for a shared quantum state manifests itself, in the standard quantum framework, by joint probability distributions that can be obtained by applying state reduction and probability assignment that is called Born rule. Quantum correlations, which show nonlocality when the shared state has an entanglement, can be changed if we apply different probability assignment rule. As a result, the amount of nonlocality in quantum correlation will be changed. The issue is whether the change of the rule of quantum probability assignment breaks relativistic causality. We have shown that Born rule on quantum measurement is derived by requiring relativistic causality condition. This shows how the relativistic causality limits the upper bound of quantum nonlocality through quantum probability assignment.
We have studied the possibility of post-quantum theories more nonlocal than the (standard) quantum theory using the modification of the quantum probability rule under the no-signaling condition. For this purpose we have considered the situation that two spacelike separate parties Alice and Bob share an entangled two qubit system. We have modified the quantum probability rule as small as possible such that the first local measurements are governed by the usual Born rule and the second measurement by the modified quantum probability rule. We have shown that only the maximally entangled states can have higher nonlocality than the quantum upper bound while satisfying the no-signaling condition. This fact could be a partial explanation for why the nonlocality of the quantum theory is limited. As a by-product we have found the systematic way to obtain a variety of nonlocal boxes.
According to the theory of relativity and causality, a special type of correlation beyond quantum mechanics is possible in principle under the name of a non-local box . The concept has been introduced from the principle of non-locality, which satisfies relativistic causality. In this paper, we show that a correlation leading to the non-local box can be derived consistently if we release one of major axioms in quantum mechanics, Born’s rule . This allows us to obtain a theory that in one end of the spectrum agrees with the classical probability and in the other end agrees with the theory of non-local causality. At the same time, we argue that the correlation lies in a space with special mathematical constraints such that a physical realization of the correlation through a probability measure is not possible in one direction of its limit, but is possible in the other limit.
Entangled qubits are interconnected at any separation. Quantum mechanics represents the interconnection by one unfactorizable entangled state. A measurement at one station collapses the entangled state and fixes the state assigned to the other qubit, depending on the outcome. Interpreted as physics, the entangled state and wavefunction collapse conflict with Einstein's separability and locality. We resolve the conflict by Corpuscular Quantum Mechanics, which replaces the entangled state with source constraints and reproduces the quantum joint probabilities exactly. Each qubit leaves the source carrying one of two definite states and an unshared random variable. An extended Born rule assigns a generally complex coefficient to the transition from the source-assigned state to the recorded outcome, using only what the qubit carries and the locally chosen measurement direction. Averaging products of the coefficients over the source ensemble returns the joint probabilities. Nothing is fitted. An exact identity maps the amplitudes of any pure n-qubit state to the source constraints. We prove the random variables admit a positive distribution meeting the constraints. The identity yields the joint probabilities of the Bell, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger, Eberhard, W, Hardy, and Dicke states for arbitrary directions. The resolution requires no action at a distance, no collapse, and no outcomes for unperformed measurements. The one change is that the event-level quantity is a transition coefficient, not a probability. Bell's theorem therefore does not apply. Quantum mechanics is thus one recipe for computing the correlations, and the entangled state is a feature of the recipe, not of nature.
Abstract A unique characteristic of quantum mechanics is entanglement describing correlations between particles irrespective of their locations. This property, called non-locality, has no classical analogue. Over the past few years, quantum physicists have reached a consensus that we lack a physical theory to account for a class of states whose non-local character exceeds the bounds allowed by quantum mechanics. Motivated by our observation that an extension of the Schrödinger equation with non-linear terms is directly linked to a relaxation of Born’s rule, an axiom of quantum mechanics, we derive a physical theory that accounts for such hyper-correlated states and modifies Born’s rule. We model correlated particles with a generalized probability theory whose dynamics are described with a non-linear version of Schrödinger’s equation and demonstrate how that deviates from the standard formulation of quantum mechanics in experimental probability-prediction. We show also that the violation of the Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequality, the amount of non-locality, is proportional to the degree of non-linearity, which can be experimentally tested.
Quantum mechanics and relativistic causality together imply nonlocality: nonlocal correlations (that violate the CHSH inequality) and nonlocal equations of motion (the Aharonov-Bohm effect). Can we invert the logical order? We consider a conjecture that nonlocality and relativistic causality together imply quantum mechanics. We show that correlations preserving relativistic causality can violate the CHSH inequality more strongly than quantum correlations. Also, we describe nonlocal equations of motion, preserving relativistic causality, that do not arise in quantum mechanics. In these nonlocal equations of motion, an experimenter ``jams" nonlocal correlations between quantum systems.
It is shown that quantum mechanics is, like thermodynamics, a phenomenological theory i.e., not a causal theory, ( not because it is a statistical theory - statistical theories with caused probability distributions can be regarded as causal) but because pure states, i.e., probability distributions of measurement values, cannot inhere in elementary particles and therefore cannot change when their world tubes intersect and hence they cannot be regarded as interacting causally. By a causal theory is meant a theory that specifies the changes in time of the states of causally interacting entities in its domain. The areas in quantum mechanics in which causal interactions are relevant include, though not explicitly, measurement and therefore the Born rule, and, explicitly, the unitary Schrodinger time development of states. The Born rule probabilities are shown to to refer not to conjoint superpositions of eigenstates but to classical mixtures of mutually exclusive eigenvalues and the Schrodinger time development of states is shown to refer to the time development of the states of non-causally interacting elementary particles and hence cannot be regarded as as a causal time development equation, appearances to the contrary notwithstanding. The recognition that quantum mechanics is not a causal theory but a phenomenological theory like thermodynamics does not affect the way it is employed to calculate an predict and hence preserves its empirical success but it does allow a typically simple phenomenological theory explanation of entanglement and other apparently non-local phenomena.