Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.1352 · Physical Review A

Reply to “Comment on ‘Optimal probe wave function of weak-value amplification’ ”

Yuki Susa, Yutaka Shikano, Akio Hosoya

Published Apr 12, 2013• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is pointed out that the ``counterexample'' presented in the Comment is a family of probe wave functions which are increasingly broad as the shift becomes large. Furthermore, the author's variational calculation is not correct in the sense that we have to gauge fix the freedom of the phase translation. It is shown that there are two kinds of solutions, normalizable and un-normalizable. The former is our optimal solution, and the latter is what he found. It seems only the former is relevant from a practical point of view.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.87.046102

Related papers

Comment on “Optimal probe wave function of weak-value amplification”

Antonio Di Lorenzo

First, a misconception about the spectrum of a confined particle is evidentiated. Then, the results are shown to be incorrect by means of a counter-example, an explicit preparation for the probe is given that yields an arbitrary amplification, and the source of the error is pointed out.

arXiv:1210.3274•Physical Review A•Apr 12, 2013•8 citations

Reply to comments on "Weak value amplification is suboptimal for estimation and detection"

Christopher Ferrie, Joshua Combes

Kedem's Comment [arXiv:1402.1352] on our Letter [PRL 112, 040406 (2014)] contains only the criticism that we did not consider complex weak values. We point out follow-up work which uses the same analysis as in our Letter, includes any type of weak values and draws the same conclusion. Vaidman's Comment [arXiv:1402.0199] on our Letter can be deconstructed in to two distinct logical fallacies.

arXiv:1402.2954•Feb 12, 2014•4 citations

Reply to "Comment on 'Strong Measurements Give a Better Direct Measurement of the Quantum Wave Function' "

Giuseppe Vallone, Daniele Dequal

This is the reply to [arXiv:1711.00764], in which the authors claim that there is crucial normalization error in PRL 116, 040502 (2016) and that some quantities appearing in the method of PRL 116, 040502 (2016) are not experimentally measurable. We show that the claim of [arXiv:1711.00764] is not correct and that the quantities appearing in PRL 116, 040502 (2016) can be measured.

arXiv:1711.02055•Nov 6, 2017•0 citations

Optimal probe wave function of weak-value amplification

Yuki Susa, Yutaka Shikano, Akio Hosoya

The weak measurement proposed by Aharonov and his colleagues extracts information about a physical quantity of the system by the postselection as shifts of the argument of the probe wave function. The more the postselected state is orthogonal to the preselected state, the larger the shift determined by the weak value becomes. Recently, the signal amplification by the weak measurement has been extensively studied. In the present work, we explicitly obtain the optimal probe wave function and the amplification factor for a given weak value, which is calculated from the experimental setup. It is shown that the amplification factor has no upper bound, in contrast to the Gaussian probe wave function, and that the amplified signal is sharp.

arXiv:1203.0827•Physical Review A•May 11, 2012•61 citations

Optimization of parameter measurement precision with precoupling-assisted weak-value amplification

Manchao Zhang, Jie Zhang, Chun-Wang Wu +4 more

The weak-value amplification is extensively considered in precision metrology in order to achieve a higher sensitivity. Despite the practical benefits in amplifying small physical quantities, its metrological advantage still arouses a broad debate due to the low postselection probability of success. In this paper, by employing the quantum Fisher information metric, we show that the precision of estimating an unknown parameter can be improved by introducing a precoupling process with properly chosen interaction operators. We point out this result is credible for both real and imaginary weak values. By tracking the meter wave functions, we find this enhancement of estimation precision comes from a precoupling induced modulation of the meter wave function, thus the most sensitive regime with respect to the parameter is reached. In addition, the estimation error is investigated by considering the difference between the theoretical and estimated value. The analysis suggests that this kind of error can be effectively suppressed by averaging the estimations resulted from different initial meter states. These results are finally illustrated by an exact numerical simulation where the advantages of our proposal are displayed by the comparison to the standard weak-value amplification scheme.

Physical Review A•Apr 3, 2023•5 citations

Comment on “The variational principle and simple properties of the ground-state wave function,” by J. Mur-Petit, A. Polls, and F. Mazzanti [Am. J. Phys. 70 (8), 808–810 (2002)]

See Kit Foong, David Kiang, Yukihisa Nogami

American Journal of Physics•Jun 11, 2003•2 citations
It is pointed out that the ``counterexample'' presented in the Comment is a family of probe wave functions which are increasingly broad as the shift becomes large. Furthermore, the author's variational calculation is not correct in the sense that we have to gauge fix the freedom of the phase translation. It is shown that there are two kinds of solutions, normalizable and un-normalizable. The former is our optimal solution, and the latter is what he found. It seems only the former is relevant from a practical point of view.
The weak measurement proposed by Aharonov and his colleagues extracts information about a physical quantity of the system by the postselection as shifts of the argument of the probe wave function. The more the postselected state is orthogonal to the preselected state, the larger the shift determined by the weak value becomes. Recently, the signal amplification by the weak measurement has been extensively studied. In the present work, we explicitly obtain the optimal probe wave function and the amplification factor for a given weak value, which is calculated from the experimental setup. It is shown that the amplification factor has no upper bound, in contrast to the Gaussian probe wave function, and that the amplified signal is sharp.
The weak-value amplification is extensively considered in precision metrology in order to achieve a higher sensitivity. Despite the practical benefits in amplifying small physical quantities, its metrological advantage still arouses a broad debate due to the low postselection probability of success. In this paper, by employing the quantum Fisher information metric, we show that the precision of estimating an unknown parameter can be improved by introducing a precoupling process with properly chosen interaction operators. We point out this result is credible for both real and imaginary weak values. By tracking the meter wave functions, we find this enhancement of estimation precision comes from a precoupling induced modulation of the meter wave function, thus the most sensitive regime with respect to the parameter is reached. In addition, the estimation error is investigated by considering the difference between the theoretical and estimated value. The analysis suggests that this kind of error can be effectively suppressed by averaging the estimations resulted from different initial meter states. These results are finally illustrated by an exact numerical simulation where the advantages of our proposal are displayed by the comparison to the standard weak-value amplification scheme.