Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1301.2038 · Physical Review B

Time reversal symmetry breaking chiral spin liquids: Projective symmetry group approach of bosonic mean-field theories

Laura Messio, C. Lhuillier, Grégoire Misguich

Published Mar 19, 2013• 83 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Projective symmetry groups are the mathematical tools which make it possible to list and classify mean-field spin liquids (SLs) based on a parton construction. The seminal work of Wen [Phys. Rev. B 65, 165113 (2002)] and its subsequent extension to bosons by Wang and Vishwanath [Phys. Rev. B 74, 174423 (2006)] concerned the so-called symmetric SLs; i.e., states that break neither lattice symmetries nor time reversal invariance. Here we generalize this tool to chiral (time reversal symmetry breaking) SLs described in a Schwinger boson mean-field approach and illustrate it on the triangular lattice, which can harbor nine different weakly symmetric SLs (two symmetric SLs and seven chiral SLs) with nearest neighbor bond operators only. Results for other lattices (square and kagome) are given in the Appendixes. Application of this new approach has recently led to the discovery of two chiral ground states on the kagome lattice [Messio et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 207204 (2012); F\aa{}k et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 037208 (2012)]. The signature of a time reversal symmetry breaking SL is the presence in the ground state of nontrivial fluxes of loop operators that break some lattice point group symmetries. The physical significance of these gauge invariant quantities is discussed both in the classical limit and in the quantum SL and their expressions in terms of spin observables are given.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.87.125127

Related papers

Spin structure factors of chiral quantum spin liquids on the kagome lattice

Jad C. Halimeh, Matthias Punk

We calculate dynamical spin structure factors for gapped chiral spin liquid states in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice using Schwinger-boson mean-field theory. In contrast to static (equal-time) structure factors, the dynamical structure factor shows clear signatures of time-reversal symmetry breaking for chiral spin liquid states. In particular, momentum inversion $\mathbit{k}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{-}\mathbit{k}$ symmetry as well as the sixfold rotation symmetry around the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ point are lost. We highlight other interesting features, such as a relatively flat onset of the two-spinon continuum for the cuboc1 state. Our work is based on the projective symmetry group classification of time-reversal symmetry breaking Schwinger-boson mean-field states by Messio, Lhuillier, and Misguich.

arXiv:1606.07856•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 13, 2016•28 citations

Projective symmetry group classification of chiral spin liquids

Samuel Bieri, C. Lhuillier, Laura Messio

We present a general review of the projective symmetry group classification of fermionic quantum spin liquids for lattice models of spin $S=1/2$. We then introduce a systematic generalization of the approach for symmetric ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ quantum spin liquids to the one of chiral phases (i.e., singlet states that break time reversal and lattice reflection, but conserve their product). We apply this framework to classify and discuss possible chiral spin liquids on triangular and kagome lattices. We give a detailed prescription on how to construct quadratic spinon Hamiltonians and microscopic wave functions for each representation class on these lattices. Among the chiral ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ states, we study the subset of U(1) phases variationally in the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{d}$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice. We discuss static spin structure factors and symmetry constraints on the bulk spectra of these phases.

arXiv:1512.00324•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 30, 2016•107 citations

Z 2 spin liquids in the S = 1 2 Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice: A projective symmetry-group study of Schwinger fermion mean-field states

Yuan-Ming Lu, Ying Ran, Patrick A. Lee

Due to strong geometric frustration and quantum fluctuation, the $S=1/2$ quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the $\text{kagome}$ lattice has long been considered as an ideal platform to realize a spin liquid (SL), a phase exhibiting fractionalized excitations without any symmetry breaking. A recent numerical study (Yan et al., e-print arXiv:1011.6114) of the Heisenberg $S=1/2,\text{kagome}$ lattice model (HKLM) shows, in contrast to earlier results, that the ground state is a singlet-gapped SL with signatures of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order. Motivated by this numerical discovery, we use the projective symmetry group to classify all 20 possible Schwinger fermion mean-field states of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ SLs on the $\text{kagome}$ lattice. Among them we found only one gapped ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ SL (which we call the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}[0,\ensuremath{\pi}]\ensuremath{\beta}$ state) in the neighborhood of the U(1) Dirac SL state. Since its parent state, i.e., the U(1) Dirac SL, was found [Ran et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007)] to be the lowest among many other candidate U(1) SLs, including the uniform resonating-valence-bond states, we propose this ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}[0,\ensuremath{\pi}]\ensuremath{\beta}$ state to be the numerically discovered SL ground state of the HKLM.

arXiv:1104.1432•Physical Review B•Jun 22, 2011•149 citations

Kagome Antiferromagnet: A Chiral Topological Spin Liquid?

Laura Messio, B. Bernu, C. Lhuillier

Inspired by the recent discovery of a new instability towards a chiral phase of the classical Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice, we propose a specific chiral spin liquid that reconciles different, well-established results concerning both the classical and quantum models. This proposal is analyzed in an extended mean-field Schwinger boson framework encompassing time reversal symmetry breaking phases, which allows both a classical and a quantum phase description. At low temperatures, we find that quantum fluctuations favor this chiral phase, which is stable against small perturbations of second- and third-neighbor interactions. For spin-1/2, this phase may be, beyond the mean field, a chiral gapped spin liquid. Such a phase is consistent with the density matrix renormalization group results of Yan et al. [Science 332, 1173 (2011)]. Mysterious features of the low-lying excitations of exact diagonalization spectra also find an explanation in this framework. Moreover, thermal fluctuations compete with quantum ones and induce a transition from this flux phase to a planar zero flux phase at a nonzero value of the renormalized temperature (T/S2), reconciling these results with those obtained for the classical system.

arXiv:1110.5440•Physical Review Letters•May 18, 2012•201 citations

Chirality, Klein duality, and the stability of Kitaev spin liquids on the star lattice

Harsh Raj, Yasir Iqbal

The star lattice hosts the Yao-Kivelson chiral spin liquid, an exactly solvable Kitaev spin liquid that breaks time reversal spontaneously and is non-Abelian or Abelian depending on the ratio of its two couplings. A density-matrix renormalization group study found that an added Heisenberg exchange leaves it a wide stability window for ferromagnetic but only a narrow one for antiferromagnetic Kitaev coupling. Using projective symmetry groups (PSGs) of fermionic partons, we show that the chirality is not a peculiarity of the solvable point: whenever the $π$ spin rotations act on the partons as in the exact solution (spin-gauge locking), a time-reversal-symmetric mean-field state has no amplitude on the triangles, at any range, so a Kitaev-type spin liquid on this lattice must break time reversal. The Abelian and non-Abelian liquids of both signs share a single chiral PSG, within which their transition is a band inversion. The Klein duality, which reverses the Heisenberg coupling, permutes the PSGs and leaves exactly the locked ones unchanged; a $Z_2$ spin-liquid phase mapped onto itself is therefore locked and, if it spans a connected range of couplings, contains a Kitaev point. Unprojected mean-field theory in Kitaev's Majorana representation treats both signs alike. Exact second-order perturbation theory about the Kitaev points locates the asymmetry: the triangles respond identically for both signs, whereas on the bonds between triangles the two off-diagonal Heisenberg terms create the same four visons and interfere constructively for antiferromagnetic and almost destructively for ferromagnetic coupling, admixing a low-energy four-vison state $82$ times more strongly on the antiferromagnetic side. The PSG results rest on a classification of $352$ $Z_2$ PSGs with spin-orbit-coupled amplitudes, which also identifies the fermionic partners of the known Schwinger-boson spin liquids.

arXiv:2610.29278•Oct 21, 2026•0 citations

Mean-field theory and projective symmetry group classifications of quantum spin liquids

Jonas Sonnenschein

Quantum spin liquids are novel phases of matter whose physical properties cannot be captured within the conventional framework of phase transitions. These quantum states are characterized by excitations, called spinons, carrying a fractional value of the integer spin. A description based on a mean-field approximation leads to effective gauge theory. Due to this gauge freedom symmetry group operations act via projective symmetry group (PSG) representations, which can be used to classify quantum states beyond the conventional method. This introducing discussion is found in Chapters 2-6. A preceding PSG classification on the square lattice, which took spin rotational symmetry breaking terms into account, showed that the resulting mean-field states could exhibit topologically non-trivial spinon bands. In Chapter 7, only those el- ements of this Classification are studied, which lead to short-ranged mean-field models. The mutual effect of spinons and visons is scrutinized by adding static configurations of a background gauge field. Spinons and visons form composite ob- jects, which in the case of topological spinon bands, are described by Majorana zero modes. An exact mapping corroborates the relation to topological supercon- ductors and vortices. The effect of multiple visons is investigated, and a possible experimental signature is exposed. Chapter 8 explains how spinon mean-field theory can be used to derive a phe- nomenological effective model for the compound Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 . A material that was recently proposed as a quantum spin liquid. This low-energy theory consists of spinon hopping processes. The underlying bilayer kagome structure can be simpli- fied to an effective honeycomb lattice. The dynamical spin structure factor is calcu- lated and compared to neutron scattering data. It is discussed how f -wave pairing of spinons can explain small deviations from a linear temperature dependency observed in heat capacity measurements at the low temperatures. This pairing mechanism breaks the U (1) invariance group of the pure hopping model and renders a coherent picture of Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 being a Z 2 quantum spin liquid. Chapter 9 carries out a PSG classification for the simple-, body centered-, and face centered cubic lattices. Despite a large number of possible PSG representations, only very few describe short-ranged mean-field states. These mean-field models are constructed up to third neighbor couplings and calculated in a self-consistent manner. It is found that the energy is lower for non-trivial sign patterns induced by non-trivial representations of the symmetry generators. Higher neighbor extensions, including pairing terms, yield lower mean-field ground state energies compared to extensions with only hopping terms. For the fcc lattice, a first neighbor state could be identified, which exhibits symmetry protected zero-energy modes.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations
Projective symmetry groups are the mathematical tools which make it possible to list and classify mean-field spin liquids (SLs) based on a parton construction. The seminal work of Wen [Phys. Rev. B 65, 165113 (2002)] and its subsequent extension to bosons by Wang and Vishwanath [Phys. Rev. B 74, 174423 (2006)] concerned the so-called symmetric SLs; i.e., states that break neither lattice symmetries nor time reversal invariance. Here we generalize this tool to chiral (time reversal symmetry breaking) SLs described in a Schwinger boson mean-field approach and illustrate it on the triangular lattice, which can harbor nine different weakly symmetric SLs (two symmetric SLs and seven chiral SLs) with nearest neighbor bond operators only. Results for other lattices (square and kagome) are given in the Appendixes. Application of this new approach has recently led to the discovery of two chiral ground states on the kagome lattice [Messio et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 207204 (2012); F\aa{}k et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 037208 (2012)]. The signature of a time reversal symmetry breaking SL is the presence in the ground state of nontrivial fluxes of loop operators that break some lattice point group symmetries. The physical significance of these gauge invariant quantities is discussed both in the classical limit and in the quantum SL and their expressions in terms of spin observables are given.
We calculate dynamical spin structure factors for gapped chiral spin liquid states in the spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice using Schwinger-boson mean-field theory. In contrast to static (equal-time) structure factors, the dynamical structure factor shows clear signatures of time-reversal symmetry breaking for chiral spin liquid states. In particular, momentum inversion $\mathbit{k}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{-}\mathbit{k}$ symmetry as well as the sixfold rotation symmetry around the $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ point are lost. We highlight other interesting features, such as a relatively flat onset of the two-spinon continuum for the cuboc1 state. Our work is based on the projective symmetry group classification of time-reversal symmetry breaking Schwinger-boson mean-field states by Messio, Lhuillier, and Misguich.
We present a general review of the projective symmetry group classification of fermionic quantum spin liquids for lattice models of spin S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2. We then introduce a systematic generalization of the approach for symmetric Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ quantum spin liquids to the one of chiral phases (i.e., singlet states that break time reversal and lattice reflection, but conserve their product). We apply this framework to classify and discuss possible chiral spin liquids on triangular and kagome lattices. We give a detailed prescription on how to construct quadratic spinon Hamiltonians and microscopic wave functions for each representation class on these lattices. Among the chiral Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ states, we study the subset of U(1) phases variationally in the antiferromagnetic ${J}_{1}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{2}\text{\ensuremath{-}}{J}_{d}$ Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice. We discuss static spin structure factors and symmetry constraints on the bulk spectra of these phases.
Due to strong geometric frustration and quantum fluctuation, the S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 quantum Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome\text{kagome}kagome lattice has long been considered as an ideal platform to realize a spin liquid (SL), a phase exhibiting fractionalized excitations without any symmetry breaking. A recent numerical study (Yan et al., e-print arXiv:1011.6114) of the Heisenberg S=1/2,kagomeS=1/2,\text{kagome}S=1/2,kagome lattice model (HKLM) shows, in contrast to earlier results, that the ground state is a singlet-gapped SL with signatures of Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order. Motivated by this numerical discovery, we use the projective symmetry group to classify all 20 possible Schwinger fermion mean-field states of Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ SLs on the kagome\text{kagome}kagome lattice. Among them we found only one gapped Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ SL (which we call the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}[0,\ensuremath{\pi}]\ensuremath{\beta}$ state) in the neighborhood of the U(1) Dirac SL state. Since its parent state, i.e., the U(1) Dirac SL, was found [Ran et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 117205 (2007)] to be the lowest among many other candidate U(1) SLs, including the uniform resonating-valence-bond states, we propose this ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}[0,\ensuremath{\pi}]\ensuremath{\beta}$ state to be the numerically discovered SL ground state of the HKLM.
Inspired by the recent discovery of a new instability towards a chiral phase of the classical Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice, we propose a specific chiral spin liquid that reconciles different, well-established results concerning both the classical and quantum models. This proposal is analyzed in an extended mean-field Schwinger boson framework encompassing time reversal symmetry breaking phases, which allows both a classical and a quantum phase description. At low temperatures, we find that quantum fluctuations favor this chiral phase, which is stable against small perturbations of second- and third-neighbor interactions. For spin-1/2, this phase may be, beyond the mean field, a chiral gapped spin liquid. Such a phase is consistent with the density matrix renormalization group results of Yan et al. [Science 332, 1173 (2011)]. Mysterious features of the low-lying excitations of exact diagonalization spectra also find an explanation in this framework. Moreover, thermal fluctuations compete with quantum ones and induce a transition from this flux phase to a planar zero flux phase at a nonzero value of the renormalized temperature (T/S2), reconciling these results with those obtained for the classical system.
The star lattice hosts the Yao-Kivelson chiral spin liquid, an exactly solvable Kitaev spin liquid that breaks time reversal spontaneously and is non-Abelian or Abelian depending on the ratio of its two couplings. A density-matrix renormalization group study found that an added Heisenberg exchange leaves it a wide stability window for ferromagnetic but only a narrow one for antiferromagnetic Kitaev coupling. Using projective symmetry groups (PSGs) of fermionic partons, we show that the chirality is not a peculiarity of the solvable point: whenever the πππ spin rotations act on the partons as in the exact solution (spin-gauge locking), a time-reversal-symmetric mean-field state has no amplitude on the triangles, at any range, so a Kitaev-type spin liquid on this lattice must break time reversal. The Abelian and non-Abelian liquids of both signs share a single chiral PSG, within which their transition is a band inversion. The Klein duality, which reverses the Heisenberg coupling, permutes the PSGs and leaves exactly the locked ones unchanged; a Z2Z_2Z2​ spin-liquid phase mapped onto itself is therefore locked and, if it spans a connected range of couplings, contains a Kitaev point. Unprojected mean-field theory in Kitaev's Majorana representation treats both signs alike. Exact second-order perturbation theory about the Kitaev points locates the asymmetry: the triangles respond identically for both signs, whereas on the bonds between triangles the two off-diagonal Heisenberg terms create the same four visons and interfere constructively for antiferromagnetic and almost destructively for ferromagnetic coupling, admixing a low-energy four-vison state 828282 times more strongly on the antiferromagnetic side. The PSG results rest on a classification of 352352352 Z2Z_2Z2​ PSGs with spin-orbit-coupled amplitudes, which also identifies the fermionic partners of the known Schwinger-boson spin liquids.
Quantum spin liquids are novel phases of matter whose physical properties cannot be captured within the conventional framework of phase transitions. These quantum states are characterized by excitations, called spinons, carrying a fractional value of the integer spin. A description based on a mean-field approximation leads to effective gauge theory. Due to this gauge freedom symmetry group operations act via projective symmetry group (PSG) representations, which can be used to classify quantum states beyond the conventional method. This introducing discussion is found in Chapters 2-6. A preceding PSG classification on the square lattice, which took spin rotational symmetry breaking terms into account, showed that the resulting mean-field states could exhibit topologically non-trivial spinon bands. In Chapter 7, only those el- ements of this Classification are studied, which lead to short-ranged mean-field models. The mutual effect of spinons and visons is scrutinized by adding static configurations of a background gauge field. Spinons and visons form composite ob- jects, which in the case of topological spinon bands, are described by Majorana zero modes. An exact mapping corroborates the relation to topological supercon- ductors and vortices. The effect of multiple visons is investigated, and a possible experimental signature is exposed. Chapter 8 explains how spinon mean-field theory can be used to derive a phe- nomenological effective model for the compound Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 . A material that was recently proposed as a quantum spin liquid. This low-energy theory consists of spinon hopping processes. The underlying bilayer kagome structure can be simpli- fied to an effective honeycomb lattice. The dynamical spin structure factor is calcu- lated and compared to neutron scattering data. It is discussed how f -wave pairing of spinons can explain small deviations from a linear temperature dependency observed in heat capacity measurements at the low temperatures. This pairing mechanism breaks the U (1) invariance group of the pure hopping model and renders a coherent picture of Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 being a Z 2 quantum spin liquid. Chapter 9 carries out a PSG classification for the simple-, body centered-, and face centered cubic lattices. Despite a large number of possible PSG representations, only very few describe short-ranged mean-field states. These mean-field models are constructed up to third neighbor couplings and calculated in a self-consistent manner. It is found that the energy is lower for non-trivial sign patterns induced by non-trivial representations of the symmetry generators. Higher neighbor extensions, including pairing terms, yield lower mean-field ground state energies compared to extensions with only hopping terms. For the fcc lattice, a first neighbor state could be identified, which exhibits symmetry protected zero-energy modes.