Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mean-field theory and projective symmetry group classifications of quantum spin liquids

Jonas Sonnenschein

Published Jan 1, 2020• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quantum spin liquids are novel phases of matter whose physical properties cannot be captured within the conventional framework of phase transitions. These quantum states are characterized by excitations, called spinons, carrying a fractional value of the integer spin. A description based on a mean-field approximation leads to effective gauge theory. Due to this gauge freedom symmetry group operations act via projective symmetry group (PSG) representations, which can be used to classify quantum states beyond the conventional method. This introducing discussion is found in Chapters 2-6. A preceding PSG classification on the square lattice, which took spin rotational symmetry breaking terms into account, showed that the resulting mean-field states could exhibit topologically non-trivial spinon bands. In Chapter 7, only those el- ements of this Classification are studied, which lead to short-ranged mean-field models. The mutual effect of spinons and visons is scrutinized by adding static configurations of a background gauge field. Spinons and visons form composite ob- jects, which in the case of topological spinon bands, are described by Majorana zero modes. An exact mapping corroborates the relation to topological supercon- ductors and vortices. The effect of multiple visons is investigated, and a possible experimental signature is exposed. Chapter 8 explains how spinon mean-field theory can be used to derive a phe- nomenological effective model for the compound Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 . A material that was recently proposed as a quantum spin liquid. This low-energy theory consists of spinon hopping processes. The underlying bilayer kagome structure can be simpli- fied to an effective honeycomb lattice. The dynamical spin structure factor is calcu- lated and compared to neutron scattering data. It is discussed how f -wave pairing of spinons can explain small deviations from a linear temperature dependency observed in heat capacity measurements at the low temperatures. This pairing mechanism breaks the U (1) invariance group of the pure hopping model and renders a coherent picture of Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 being a Z 2 quantum spin liquid. Chapter 9 carries out a PSG classification for the simple-, body centered-, and face centered cubic lattices. Despite a large number of possible PSG representations, only very few describe short-ranged mean-field states. These mean-field models are constructed up to third neighbor couplings and calculated in a self-consistent manner. It is found that the energy is lower for non-trivial sign patterns induced by non-trivial representations of the symmetry generators. Higher neighbor extensions, including pairing terms, yield lower mean-field ground state energies compared to extensions with only hopping terms. For the fcc lattice, a first neighbor state could be identified, which exhibits symmetry protected zero-energy modes.

DOI
10.17169/refubium-28220

Related papers

Projective symmetry group classifications of quantum spin liquids on the simple cubic, body centered cubic, and face centered cubic lattices

Jonas Sonnenschein, Aishwarya Chauhan, Yasir Iqbal +1 more

We perform extensive classifications of ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ quantum spin liquids on the simple cubic, body centered cubic, and face centered cubic (fcc) lattices using a spin-rotation-invariant fermionic projective symmetry group approach. Taking into account that all three lattices share the same point group ${O}_{h}$, we apply an efficient gauge where the classification for the simple cubic lattice can be partially carried over to the other two lattices. We identify hundreds of projective representations for each of the three lattices, however, when constructing short-range mean-field models for the fermionic partons (spinons) these phases collapse to only very few relevant cases. We self-consistently calculate the corresponding mean-field parameters for frustrated Heisenberg models on all three lattices with up to third-neighbor spin interactions and discuss the spinon dispersions, ground-state energies, and dynamical spin structure factors. Our results indicate that phases with nonuniform spinon hopping or pairing amplitudes are energetically favored. An unusual situation is identified for the fcc lattice where the spinon dispersion minimizing the mean-field energy features a network of symmetry-protected linelike zero modes in reciprocal space. We further discuss characteristic fingerprints of these phases in the dynamical spin structure factor which may help to identify and distinguish them in future numerical or experimental studies.

arXiv:2007.02589•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 22, 2020•16 citations

Projective symmetry group classification of Abrikosov fermion mean-field ansätze on the square-octagon lattice

Atanu Maity, Francesco Ferrari, Ronny Thomale +2 more

We perform a projective symmetry group (PSG) classification of symmetric quantum spin liquids with different gauge groups on the square-octagon lattice. Employing the Abrikosov fermion representation for spin $\frac{1}{2}$, we obtain $32\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{SU}(2), 1808\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{U}(1),$ and $384\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ algebraic PSGs. Constraining ourselves to mean-field parton ans\"atze with short-range amplitudes, the classification reduces to a limited number, with 4 $\text{SU}(2)$, 24 $\text{U}(1),$ and 36 ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$, distinct phases. We discuss their ground-state properties and spinon dispersions within a self-consistent treatment of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian with frustrating couplings.

arXiv:2212.09554•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 27, 2023•8 citations

Gapped and gapless quantum spin liquids on the ruby lattice

Atanu Maity, Rhine Samajdar, Yasir Iqbal

The ruby lattice has been the subject of much interest recently due to its realization in Rydberg atom arrays, where its rich variety of frustrated interactions gives rise to topologically ordered quantum spin liquids. Similarly, numerical studies of ruby-lattice spin models, with both isotropic and anisotropic interactions, have provided evidence of gapped and gapless spin-liquid ground states with different low-energy gauge structures. Motivated by these findings, we perform a projective symmetry group (PSG) classification of U(1) and $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ fermionic spinon mean-field theories$\unicode{x2014}$respecting space-group and time-reversal symmetries$\unicode{x2014}$for $S=1/2$ spins. We obtain a total of 50 U(1) and 64 $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ PSGs, and upon restricting their realization via mean-field $\textit{Ansätze}$ with up to second-nearest-neighbor singlet amplitudes (relevant to the models studied here), only 8 U(1) and 18 $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ distinct states are obtained. We present the singlet fields for all $\textit{Ansätze}$ up to third-nearest-neighboring bonds and discuss their spinon dispersions as well as their dynamical spin structure factors. Building on this information, we also obtain the phase diagram of the Heisenberg model in the presence of first- ($J_{1}$), second- ($J_{1}'$), and third- ($J_{2}$) neighbor antiferromagnetic couplings within a self-consistent mean-field approximation.

arXiv:2409.16344•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 4, 2026•9 citations

Mean-Field Theory of Spin Liquids and Quantum Order

Xiao-Gang Wen

Topological order, as a generic phenomenon, not only appears in FQH systems, it can also appear in quantum spin systems. Quantum spin systems even allow the more general quantum order. This chapter develops a mean-field theory for the topological/quantum order in strongly interacting quantum spin systems. The mean-field theory is based on the projective construction (or the slave-particle construction). The chapter introduces the notion of projective symmetry group (PSG) to describe distinct phases that have exactly the same symmetry. PSG allows for the introduction of the notion of quantum order, which is more general then the notion of topological order. Using the mean-field theory, it calculates the phase diagram and phase transitions for quantum spin systems that do not involve change of symmetry. In fact, many phases that are studied do not break any symmetry and correspond to quantum spin liquids. The mean-field theory shows that those spin liquids can have some very exotic properties such as fractionalization, spin-charge separation, emergent gauge bosons and fermions, interacting gapless exactions, etc. The chapter finds that in addition to the symmetry breaking mechanism, PSG and quantum order is another way to produce and protect gapless excitations.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 6, 2007•0 citations

Classification of spin- 1 2 fermionic quantum spin liquids on the trillium lattice

Ming-Hao Li, Sounak Biswas, S. A. Parameswaran

We study fermionic quantum spin liquids (QSLs) on the three-dimensional trillium lattice of corner-sharing triangles. We are motivated by recent experimental and theoretical investigations that have explored various classical and quantum spin liquid states on similar networks of triangular motifs with strong geometric frustration. Using the framework of projective symmetry groups (PSG), we obtain a classification of all symmetric Z 2 and U ( 1 ) QSLs on the trillium lattice. We find two Z 2 spin-liquids, and a single U ( 1 ) spin-liquid that is proximate to one of the Z 2 states. The small number of solutions reflects the constraints imposed by the nonsymmorphic symmetries in the space group of the trillium lattice. Using self-consistency conditions of the mean-field equations, we obtain the spinon band-structure and spin structure factors corresponding to these states. All three of our spin liquids are gapless at their saddle points: one of the two Z 2 QSLs is nodal, while the U ( 1 ) case hosts a spinon Fermi surface. One of our Z 2 spin liquids hosts a stable gapless nodal star that is protected by projective symmetries against additions of further neighbor terms in the mean-field ansatz. We comment on directions for further work.

arXiv:2409.02898•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 17, 2025•6 citations

Classification of spin liquids on the square lattice with strong spin-orbit coupling

Johannes Reuther, Shu-Ping Lee, Jason Alicea

Spin liquids represent exotic types of quantum matter that evade conventional symmetry-breaking order even at zero temperature. Exhaustive classifications of spin liquids have been carried out in several systems, particularly in the presence of full SU(2) spin-rotation symmetry. Real magnetic compounds, however, generically break SU(2) spin symmetry as a result of spin-orbit coupling---which in many materials provides an ``order one'' effect. We generalize previous works by using the projective symmetry group method to classify ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids on the square lattice when SU(2) spin symmetry is maximally lifted. We find that, counterintuitively, the lifting of spin symmetry actually results in vastly more spin-liquid phases compared to SU(2)-invariant systems. A generic feature of the SU(2)-broken case is that the spinons naturally undergo $p+ip$ pairing; consequently, many of these ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ spin liquids feature a topologically nontrivial spinon band structure supporting gapless Majorana edge states. We study in detail several spin-liquid phases with varying numbers of gapless edge states and discuss their topological protection. The edge states are often protected by a combination of time reversal and lattice symmetries and hence resemble recently proposed topological crystalline superconductors.

arXiv:1407.4124•Physical Review B•Nov 14, 2014•29 citations
Quantum spin liquids are novel phases of matter whose physical properties cannot be captured within the conventional framework of phase transitions. These quantum states are characterized by excitations, called spinons, carrying a fractional value of the integer spin. A description based on a mean-field approximation leads to effective gauge theory. Due to this gauge freedom symmetry group operations act via projective symmetry group (PSG) representations, which can be used to classify quantum states beyond the conventional method. This introducing discussion is found in Chapters 2-6. A preceding PSG classification on the square lattice, which took spin rotational symmetry breaking terms into account, showed that the resulting mean-field states could exhibit topologically non-trivial spinon bands. In Chapter 7, only those el- ements of this Classification are studied, which lead to short-ranged mean-field models. The mutual effect of spinons and visons is scrutinized by adding static configurations of a background gauge field. Spinons and visons form composite ob- jects, which in the case of topological spinon bands, are described by Majorana zero modes. An exact mapping corroborates the relation to topological supercon- ductors and vortices. The effect of multiple visons is investigated, and a possible experimental signature is exposed. Chapter 8 explains how spinon mean-field theory can be used to derive a phe- nomenological effective model for the compound Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 . A material that was recently proposed as a quantum spin liquid. This low-energy theory consists of spinon hopping processes. The underlying bilayer kagome structure can be simpli- fied to an effective honeycomb lattice. The dynamical spin structure factor is calcu- lated and compared to neutron scattering data. It is discussed how f -wave pairing of spinons can explain small deviations from a linear temperature dependency observed in heat capacity measurements at the low temperatures. This pairing mechanism breaks the U (1) invariance group of the pure hopping model and renders a coherent picture of Ca 10 Cr 7 O 28 being a Z 2 quantum spin liquid. Chapter 9 carries out a PSG classification for the simple-, body centered-, and face centered cubic lattices. Despite a large number of possible PSG representations, only very few describe short-ranged mean-field states. These mean-field models are constructed up to third neighbor couplings and calculated in a self-consistent manner. It is found that the energy is lower for non-trivial sign patterns induced by non-trivial representations of the symmetry generators. Higher neighbor extensions, including pairing terms, yield lower mean-field ground state energies compared to extensions with only hopping terms. For the fcc lattice, a first neighbor state could be identified, which exhibits symmetry protected zero-energy modes.
We perform extensive classifications of Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ quantum spin liquids on the simple cubic, body centered cubic, and face centered cubic (fcc) lattices using a spin-rotation-invariant fermionic projective symmetry group approach. Taking into account that all three lattices share the same point group Oh{O}_{h}Oh​, we apply an efficient gauge where the classification for the simple cubic lattice can be partially carried over to the other two lattices. We identify hundreds of projective representations for each of the three lattices, however, when constructing short-range mean-field models for the fermionic partons (spinons) these phases collapse to only very few relevant cases. We self-consistently calculate the corresponding mean-field parameters for frustrated Heisenberg models on all three lattices with up to third-neighbor spin interactions and discuss the spinon dispersions, ground-state energies, and dynamical spin structure factors. Our results indicate that phases with nonuniform spinon hopping or pairing amplitudes are energetically favored. An unusual situation is identified for the fcc lattice where the spinon dispersion minimizing the mean-field energy features a network of symmetry-protected linelike zero modes in reciprocal space. We further discuss characteristic fingerprints of these phases in the dynamical spin structure factor which may help to identify and distinguish them in future numerical or experimental studies.
We perform a projective symmetry group (PSG) classification of symmetric quantum spin liquids with different gauge groups on the square-octagon lattice. Employing the Abrikosov fermion representation for spin 12\frac{1}{2}21​, we obtain 32SU(2),1808U(1),32\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{SU}(2), 1808\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}\text{U}(1),32SU(2),1808U(1), and 384Z2384\phantom{\rule{4pt}{0ex}}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}384Z2​ algebraic PSGs. Constraining ourselves to mean-field parton ans\"atze with short-range amplitudes, the classification reduces to a limited number, with 4 SU(2)\text{SU}(2)SU(2), 24 U(1),\text{U}(1),U(1), and 36 Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​, distinct phases. We discuss their ground-state properties and spinon dispersions within a self-consistent treatment of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian with frustrating couplings.
The ruby lattice has been the subject of much interest recently due to its realization in Rydberg atom arrays, where its rich variety of frustrated interactions gives rise to topologically ordered quantum spin liquids. Similarly, numerical studies of ruby-lattice spin models, with both isotropic and anisotropic interactions, have provided evidence of gapped and gapless spin-liquid ground states with different low-energy gauge structures. Motivated by these findings, we perform a projective symmetry group (PSG) classification of U(1) and Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ fermionic spinon mean-field theories$\unicode{x2014}$respecting space-group and time-reversal symmetries$\unicode{x2014}$for S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 spins. We obtain a total of 50 U(1) and 64 Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ PSGs, and upon restricting their realization via mean-field Ansa¨tze\textit{Ansätze}Ansa¨tze with up to second-nearest-neighbor singlet amplitudes (relevant to the models studied here), only 8 U(1) and 18 Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}Z2​ distinct states are obtained. We present the singlet fields for all Ansa¨tze\textit{Ansätze}Ansa¨tze up to third-nearest-neighboring bonds and discuss their spinon dispersions as well as their dynamical spin structure factors. Building on this information, we also obtain the phase diagram of the Heisenberg model in the presence of first- (J1J_{1}J1​), second- (J1′J_{1}'J1′​), and third- (J2J_{2}J2​) neighbor antiferromagnetic couplings within a self-consistent mean-field approximation.
Topological order, as a generic phenomenon, not only appears in FQH systems, it can also appear in quantum spin systems. Quantum spin systems even allow the more general quantum order. This chapter develops a mean-field theory for the topological/quantum order in strongly interacting quantum spin systems. The mean-field theory is based on the projective construction (or the slave-particle construction). The chapter introduces the notion of projective symmetry group (PSG) to describe distinct phases that have exactly the same symmetry. PSG allows for the introduction of the notion of quantum order, which is more general then the notion of topological order. Using the mean-field theory, it calculates the phase diagram and phase transitions for quantum spin systems that do not involve change of symmetry. In fact, many phases that are studied do not break any symmetry and correspond to quantum spin liquids. The mean-field theory shows that those spin liquids can have some very exotic properties such as fractionalization, spin-charge separation, emergent gauge bosons and fermions, interacting gapless exactions, etc. The chapter finds that in addition to the symmetry breaking mechanism, PSG and quantum order is another way to produce and protect gapless excitations.
We study fermionic quantum spin liquids (QSLs) on the three-dimensional trillium lattice of corner-sharing triangles. We are motivated by recent experimental and theoretical investigations that have explored various classical and quantum spin liquid states on similar networks of triangular motifs with strong geometric frustration. Using the framework of projective symmetry groups (PSG), we obtain a classification of all symmetric Z 2 and U ( 1 ) QSLs on the trillium lattice. We find two Z 2 spin-liquids, and a single U ( 1 ) spin-liquid that is proximate to one of the Z 2 states. The small number of solutions reflects the constraints imposed by the nonsymmorphic symmetries in the space group of the trillium lattice. Using self-consistency conditions of the mean-field equations, we obtain the spinon band-structure and spin structure factors corresponding to these states. All three of our spin liquids are gapless at their saddle points: one of the two Z 2 QSLs is nodal, while the U ( 1 ) case hosts a spinon Fermi surface. One of our Z 2 spin liquids hosts a stable gapless nodal star that is protected by projective symmetries against additions of further neighbor terms in the mean-field ansatz. We comment on directions for further work.
Spin liquids represent exotic types of quantum matter that evade conventional symmetry-breaking order even at zero temperature. Exhaustive classifications of spin liquids have been carried out in several systems, particularly in the presence of full SU(2) spin-rotation symmetry. Real magnetic compounds, however, generically break SU(2) spin symmetry as a result of spin-orbit coupling---which in many materials provides an ``order one'' effect. We generalize previous works by using the projective symmetry group method to classify Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids on the square lattice when SU(2) spin symmetry is maximally lifted. We find that, counterintuitively, the lifting of spin symmetry actually results in vastly more spin-liquid phases compared to SU(2)-invariant systems. A generic feature of the SU(2)-broken case is that the spinons naturally undergo p+ipp+ipp+ip pairing; consequently, many of these Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ spin liquids feature a topologically nontrivial spinon band structure supporting gapless Majorana edge states. We study in detail several spin-liquid phases with varying numbers of gapless edge states and discuss their topological protection. The edge states are often protected by a combination of time reversal and lattice symmetries and hence resemble recently proposed topological crystalline superconductors.