Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1207.5305 · Physical Review A

Nonlocal signaling in the configuration space model of quantum-classical interactions

Michael J. W. Hall, Marcel Reginatto, Craig M. Savage

Published Nov 8, 2012• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When interactions are turned off, the theory of interacting quantum and classical ensembles due to Hall and Reginatto is shown to suffer from a nonlocal signaling effect that is effectively action at a distance. This limits the possible applicability of the theory. In its present form, it is restricted to those situations in which interactions are always on, such as classical gravity interacting with quantized matter.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.86.054101

Related papers

Interacting classical and quantum ensembles

Michael J. W. Hall, Marcel Reginatto

A consistent description of interactions between classical and quantum systems is relevant to quantum measurement theory and to calculations in quantum chemistry and quantum gravity. A solution is offered here to this long-standing problem, based on a universally applicable formalism for ensembles on configuration space. This approach overcomes difficulties arising in previous attempts and in particular allows for a back reaction on the classical ensemble, conservation of probability and energy, and the correct classical equations of motion in the limit of no interaction. Applications include automatic decoherence for quantum ensembles interacting with classical measurement apparatuses, a generalization of coherent states to hybrid harmonic oscillators, and an equation for describing the interaction of quantum matter fields with classical gravity, which implies that the radius of a Robertson-Walker universe containing a quantum massive scalar field can be sharply defined only for particular ``quantized'' values.

arXiv:quant-ph/0509134•Physical Review A•Dec 9, 2005•104 citations

Interacting classical and quantum particles

Alvin J. K. Chua, Michael J. W. Hall, Craig M. Savage

We apply Hall and Reginatto's theory of interacting classical and quantum ensembles to harmonically coupled particles, with a view to understanding its experimental implications. This hybrid theory has no free parameters and makes distinctive predictions that should allow it to be experimentally distinguished from quantum mechanics. It also bears on the questions of quantum measurement and quantum gravity.

arXiv:1109.3925•Physical Review A•Feb 7, 2012•16 citations

Nonlocality

George Jaroszkiewicz

Introduction Our concern in this chapter is locality in quantum mechanics (QM). Locality is a heuristic physics principle based on the following propositions. No Action-at-a-Distance All the evidence points to the principle that physical actions, taken within restricted (localized) regions of space and time by observers or other agencies such as systems under observation (SUOs), do not cause instantly observable effects on other SUOs at large distances. This does not apply to mathematical/ metaphysical concepts such as quantum wave functions or correlations, as these are conceptual objects (Scarani et al., 2000). Statements about instantaneous wave function collapse are vacuous (have no empirical significance) and are therefore not an issue of significance in physics. Such statements are an issue to theorists who objectivize wave functions, as in Hidden Variables (HV) theory. Action-at-a-distance is generally regarded as anathema by most physicists. For example, Newton's law of universal gravitation is well known for mathematically encoding action-at-a-distance. There is direct evidence, however, in the form of a letter written by Newton to Bentley, that Newton believed that gravity acting “at a distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else” was an absurdity (Newton, 2006). The no action-at-a-distance principle is encoded in quantized detector networks (QDN) by the requirement that labstate preparation and consequent signal detection never occur at the same stage. Causal Transmission All physically observable consequences of local actions taken by an observer or SUO are transmitted by identifiable physical processes, such as electromagnetic waves or neutrinos. There is no such thing as magic or action-at-a-distance . In QDN this proposition is taken into account implicitly in the labstate outcome amplitudes at each stage, as these model how information is propagated from stage to stage. When necessary, the information void can be modeled as if there were fields and/or particles propagating through it, giving scope for different mathematical models, such as Euclidean space, curved spacetime, noncommuting spacetimes, and so on. The structure of the information void is essentially a discussion of whatever modules have to be taken into account between labstate preparation and signal detection.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2017•0 citations

Quantum nonlocality and the end of classical spacetime

Shreya Banerjee, Sayantani Bera, Tejinder P. Singh

Quantum nonlocal correlations and the acausal, spooky action at a distance suggest a discord between quantum theory and special relativity. We propose a resolution for this discord by first observing that there is a problem of time in quantum theory. There should exist a reformulation of quantum theory which does not refer to classical time. Such a reformulation is obtained by suggesting that spacetime is fundamentally noncommutative. Quantum theory without classical time is the equilibrium statistical thermodynamics of the underlying noncommutative relativity. Stochastic fluctuations about equilibrium give rise to the classical limit and ordinary spacetime geometry. However, measurement on an entangled state can be correctly described only in the underlying noncommutative spacetime, where there is no causality violation, nor a spooky action at a distance.

arXiv:1605.06022•International Journal of Modern Physics D•Jul 28, 2016•17 citations

Comment on "Vindication of entanglement-based witnesses of non-classicality in hybrid systems"

Michael J. W. Hall, Marcel Reginatto

Models of quantum-classical interactions fall into two classes: those which allow the generation of quantum entanglement via a classical mediator (such as gravity), and those which do not. Marconato and Marletto have recently sought to distinguish between these classes by claiming that known members of the first class (based on the configuration-ensemble formalism introduced by us) fail to model the mediator as a 'classical' system, and are nonlocal. We explicitly show that this claim is incorrect, and expose a large number of errors and misconceptions in their reasoning. We also point to a very simple and transparent example of the generation of entanglement between two qubits via a classical bit. It follows that there are models permitting the generation of entanglement via quantum-classical interactions that lie outside the remit of the theorem cited by Marconato and Marletto. We clarify the reasons for the limited applicability of various no-go theorems for entanglement generation.

arXiv:2111.05033•Nov 9, 2021•8 citations

Effective information bounds in modified quantum mechanics

S. Aghababaei, Hooman Moradpour, Salman Sajad Wani +3 more

Abstract A common feature of collapse models and an expected signature of the quantization of gravity at energies well below the Planck scale is the deviation from ordinary quantum-mechanical behavior. Here, we analyze the general consequences of such modifications from the point of view of quantum information theory and we anticipate applications to different quantum systems. We show that quantum systems undergo corrections to the quantum speed limit which, in turn, imply the modification of the Heisenberg limit for parameter estimation. Our results hold for a wide class of scenarios beyond ordinary quantum mechanics. For some nonlocal models inspired by quantum gravity, the bounds are found to oscillate in time, an effect that could be tested in future high-precision quantum experiments.

arXiv:2211.09227•The European Physical Journal C•Apr 18, 2024•4 citations
When interactions are turned off, the theory of interacting quantum and classical ensembles due to Hall and Reginatto is shown to suffer from a nonlocal signaling effect that is effectively action at a distance. This limits the possible applicability of the theory. In its present form, it is restricted to those situations in which interactions are always on, such as classical gravity interacting with quantized matter.
A consistent description of interactions between classical and quantum systems is relevant to quantum measurement theory and to calculations in quantum chemistry and quantum gravity. A solution is offered here to this long-standing problem, based on a universally applicable formalism for ensembles on configuration space. This approach overcomes difficulties arising in previous attempts and in particular allows for a back reaction on the classical ensemble, conservation of probability and energy, and the correct classical equations of motion in the limit of no interaction. Applications include automatic decoherence for quantum ensembles interacting with classical measurement apparatuses, a generalization of coherent states to hybrid harmonic oscillators, and an equation for describing the interaction of quantum matter fields with classical gravity, which implies that the radius of a Robertson-Walker universe containing a quantum massive scalar field can be sharply defined only for particular ``quantized'' values.
Introduction Our concern in this chapter is locality in quantum mechanics (QM). Locality is a heuristic physics principle based on the following propositions. No Action-at-a-Distance All the evidence points to the principle that physical actions, taken within restricted (localized) regions of space and time by observers or other agencies such as systems under observation (SUOs), do not cause instantly observable effects on other SUOs at large distances. This does not apply to mathematical/ metaphysical concepts such as quantum wave functions or correlations, as these are conceptual objects (Scarani et al., 2000). Statements about instantaneous wave function collapse are vacuous (have no empirical significance) and are therefore not an issue of significance in physics. Such statements are an issue to theorists who objectivize wave functions, as in Hidden Variables (HV) theory. Action-at-a-distance is generally regarded as anathema by most physicists. For example, Newton's law of universal gravitation is well known for mathematically encoding action-at-a-distance. There is direct evidence, however, in the form of a letter written by Newton to Bentley, that Newton believed that gravity acting “at a distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else” was an absurdity (Newton, 2006). The no action-at-a-distance principle is encoded in quantized detector networks (QDN) by the requirement that labstate preparation and consequent signal detection never occur at the same stage. Causal Transmission All physically observable consequences of local actions taken by an observer or SUO are transmitted by identifiable physical processes, such as electromagnetic waves or neutrinos. There is no such thing as magic or action-at-a-distance . In QDN this proposition is taken into account implicitly in the labstate outcome amplitudes at each stage, as these model how information is propagated from stage to stage. When necessary, the information void can be modeled as if there were fields and/or particles propagating through it, giving scope for different mathematical models, such as Euclidean space, curved spacetime, noncommuting spacetimes, and so on. The structure of the information void is essentially a discussion of whatever modules have to be taken into account between labstate preparation and signal detection.
Quantum nonlocal correlations and the acausal, spooky action at a distance suggest a discord between quantum theory and special relativity. We propose a resolution for this discord by first observing that there is a problem of time in quantum theory. There should exist a reformulation of quantum theory which does not refer to classical time. Such a reformulation is obtained by suggesting that spacetime is fundamentally noncommutative. Quantum theory without classical time is the equilibrium statistical thermodynamics of the underlying noncommutative relativity. Stochastic fluctuations about equilibrium give rise to the classical limit and ordinary spacetime geometry. However, measurement on an entangled state can be correctly described only in the underlying noncommutative spacetime, where there is no causality violation, nor a spooky action at a distance.
Models of quantum-classical interactions fall into two classes: those which allow the generation of quantum entanglement via a classical mediator (such as gravity), and those which do not. Marconato and Marletto have recently sought to distinguish between these classes by claiming that known members of the first class (based on the configuration-ensemble formalism introduced by us) fail to model the mediator as a 'classical' system, and are nonlocal. We explicitly show that this claim is incorrect, and expose a large number of errors and misconceptions in their reasoning. We also point to a very simple and transparent example of the generation of entanglement between two qubits via a classical bit. It follows that there are models permitting the generation of entanglement via quantum-classical interactions that lie outside the remit of the theorem cited by Marconato and Marletto. We clarify the reasons for the limited applicability of various no-go theorems for entanglement generation.
Abstract A common feature of collapse models and an expected signature of the quantization of gravity at energies well below the Planck scale is the deviation from ordinary quantum-mechanical behavior. Here, we analyze the general consequences of such modifications from the point of view of quantum information theory and we anticipate applications to different quantum systems. We show that quantum systems undergo corrections to the quantum speed limit which, in turn, imply the modification of the Heisenberg limit for parameter estimation. Our results hold for a wide class of scenarios beyond ordinary quantum mechanics. For some nonlocal models inspired by quantum gravity, the bounds are found to oscillate in time, an effect that could be tested in future high-precision quantum experiments.