Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Nonlocality

George Jaroszkiewicz

Published Nov 28, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Introduction Our concern in this chapter is locality in quantum mechanics (QM). Locality is a heuristic physics principle based on the following propositions. No Action-at-a-Distance All the evidence points to the principle that physical actions, taken within restricted (localized) regions of space and time by observers or other agencies such as systems under observation (SUOs), do not cause instantly observable effects on other SUOs at large distances. This does not apply to mathematical/ metaphysical concepts such as quantum wave functions or correlations, as these are conceptual objects (Scarani et al., 2000). Statements about instantaneous wave function collapse are vacuous (have no empirical significance) and are therefore not an issue of significance in physics. Such statements are an issue to theorists who objectivize wave functions, as in Hidden Variables (HV) theory. Action-at-a-distance is generally regarded as anathema by most physicists. For example, Newton's law of universal gravitation is well known for mathematically encoding action-at-a-distance. There is direct evidence, however, in the form of a letter written by Newton to Bentley, that Newton believed that gravity acting “at a distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else” was an absurdity (Newton, 2006). The no action-at-a-distance principle is encoded in quantized detector networks (QDN) by the requirement that labstate preparation and consequent signal detection never occur at the same stage. Causal Transmission All physically observable consequences of local actions taken by an observer or SUO are transmitted by identifiable physical processes, such as electromagnetic waves or neutrinos. There is no such thing as magic or action-at-a-distance . In QDN this proposition is taken into account implicitly in the labstate outcome amplitudes at each stage, as these model how information is propagated from stage to stage. When necessary, the information void can be modeled as if there were fields and/or particles propagating through it, giving scope for different mathematical models, such as Euclidean space, curved spacetime, noncommuting spacetimes, and so on. The structure of the information void is essentially a discussion of whatever modules have to be taken into account between labstate preparation and signal detection.

DOI
10.1017/9781316477182.017

Related papers

Events and processes in the quantum world

Abner Shimony

PROSPECTIVE The concern of this paper will be different from that of most studies of quantum gravity. There will be no discussion of the problem of quantizing the gravitational field equations, hence nothing about the modifications which quantization requires of space-time structure at distances of the order of the Planck length (∼ 10 −33 cm). The emphasis will be rather upon the implications of quantum mechanics for certain general properties of events and processes which occur in the theatre of space-time, specifically with non-locality and nonlinearity . Quantum mechanics is undoubtedly a non-local theory when it treats correlated spatially separated systems. When one examines closely the character of this non-locality, however, one does not find reasons for modifying the causal structure of space-time as described by special or general relativity theory, but rather reasons for refining the concept of an event. The occurrence of definite outcomes of measurements implies that there are processes in nature governed by nonlinear laws. Nonlinearity is very peculiar from the standpoint of quantum mechanics, since it is contrary to the linearity of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, which is commonly assumed to govern the dynamics of any isolated physical system. Hence it is necessary to inquire whether a rational treatment of the occurrence of outcomes is possible without some modifications of current quantum mechanics. Whatever decision is reached on this question, however, it does not appear to bear directly on space-time structure, but rather on the general character of processes.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•119 citations

Action at a distance: From Newton’s gravity to quantum theory

Lina Jansson

Abstract Isaac Newton’s theory of gravity seems to postulate action at a distance. Two distant massive bodies act on one another gravitationally instantaneously without a causal mechanism to mediate the action. This paper will argue that a strategy found in the Principia that allows Newton’s theory to be explanatory without providing a causal explanation can be extended to the quantum case. However, while causal action at a distance can be avoided, the explanatory cost of avoiding any form of nonlocality is higher in the quantum case than in the case of Newton’s theory of universal gravitation.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2024•0 citations

Introduction

George Jaroszkiewicz

Motivation The aim of this book is to introduce, develop, and apply quantized detector networks (QDN), an information-based, observer-centric approach to quantum mechanics (QM). Six reasons motivating our development of QDN are the following. Avoidance of Metaphysical Speculation There is such a variety of unproven (and unprovable) speculation concerning the interpretation of QM that the subject of this book, QDN, may appear at first sight to be yet another in this growing branch of metaphysics. In fact, our motivation is precisely the opposite. QDN was intended from the outset to reduce the level of metaphysics in the application of QM. To achieve this, our strategy is to move the traditional focus of attention away from systems under observation (SUOs) and toward the observers of those SUOs. In QDN, wave functions represent not states of SUOs but states of apparatus. We shall call such states labstates , to distinguish them from states of SUOs (which do have a place in QDN). It is only labstates that observers can ever deal with directly. In this respect, QDN is an attempt at a more laboratory-based description of quantum physics than standard QM, focusing as much on how an experiment is done as on the results of that experiment. For example, instead of talking about the wave function of an electron, QDN talks about the labstate of the signal detectors that allow us to say anything about that electron in the first place. That is all, there is nothing deeper. Whether or not electrons actually “exist” is thereby relegated to an inessential metaphysical issue that we can choose to ignore. It is important to understand what QDN does not say as much as what it does say. QDN does not say that electrons do not “exist”. QDN merely asks for an empirical definition of “existence”. QM Is Much More Than a Calculational Device Many physicists hold the utilitarian view that the success of quantum theory in predicting experimental data is sufficient for their purposes, and that further inquiry is really the business of metaphysics and therefore outside the scope of science proper. We cannot say that this is entirely unreasonable. However, we take the view that QM represents such a radical departure from the principles of classical mechanics (CM) that this pragmatical view cannot be all there is to the subject.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2017•0 citations

Non-locality and special relativity

W. Michael Dickson

Thus far I have been primarily concerned with how an interpretation of quantum mechanics might, or might not, be local. This question is traditionally not sharply distinguished from the question of whether quantum mechanics is consistent with the theory of relativity. However, the two questions are indeed quite distinct, and should be recognized as such explicitly. The theory of relativity What does relativity require? As a first approximation, we may make the distinction by noting that the requirements of the theory of relativity are themselves unclear. Minimally, relativity seems to require that there be no way to distinguish one reference frame from another – i.e., that there be no experimental procedure that can determine which of two inertial observers is ‘really’ moving, or more generally that there be no way to discover an observer's absolute velocity. Most authors are willing to find in (special) relativity a stronger requirement: namely, Lorentz-invariance. They say that relativity requires that in fact there is no such thing as absolute velocity. This requirement goes beyond the minimum – it might be that there is an absolute rest frame (so that absolute velocities are given by motion relative to this frame) while there is no way to find it. (As I will discuss in chapter 9, exactly this situation occurs in Bohm's theory.)

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 2, 1998•0 citations

Lessons of Bell's Theorem: Nonlocality, Yes; Action at a Distance, Not Necessarily

Wayne C. Myrvold

Fifty years after the publication of Bell's theorem, there remains some controversy regarding what the theorem is telling us about quantum mechanics, and what the experimental violations of Bell inequalities are telling us about the world. This chapter represents my best attempt to be clear about what I think the lessons are. In brief: there is some sort of nonlocality inherent in any quantum theory, and, moreover, in any theory that reproduces, even approximately, the quantum probabilities for the outcomes of experiments. But not all forms of nonlocality are the same; there is a distinction to be made between action at a distance and other forms of nonlocality, and I will argue that the nonlocality required to violate the Bell inequalities need not involve action at a distance. Furthermore, the distinction between forms of nonlocality makes a difference when it comes to compatibility with relativistic causal structure.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Aug 31, 2016•16 citations

Modules

George Jaroszkiewicz

Modules ModulesIn this chapter, we discuss important modules such as Wollaston prisms, Newtonian prisms, beam splitters, phase shifters, mirrors, and null modules.Modules are pieces of apparatus placed at various strategic positions in the information void and are designed to influence labstate amplitudes at signal detectors.Modules are therefore a critical component in the quantized detector network (QDN) approach to quantum mechanics (QM).Modules are not classified as either real or virtual detectors, because no information is extracted from them.Their function is solely to influence quantum amplitude propagation between stages in specific ways.Even empty space (the vacuum) can be regarded as a module, for the propagation of signals through nominally "empty" space is a fundamental subject in its own right.A particularly important example illustrating how nontrivial that can be is the Hubble-Doppler red shift of light from distant galaxies.In the QDN description of the double-slit (DS) experiment, shown in Figure 10.2, the stage Σ 1 detectors labeled 1 1 and 2 1 may be considered as on the V 2 side of the wall W , where V 2 is the information void between stages Σ 1 and Σ 2 .Viewed in this way, the wall may be interpreted as a part of the apparatus that is positioned in the information void region V 1 so as to influence the signals obtained at detectors 1 1 and 2 1 .Virtually all experiments have similar components of apparatus in the information void.We shall call any such piece of apparatus a module.Modules are necessary to the architecture of the experiment, are situated in the information void, and therefore are not detectors.Examples of modules are Stern-Gerlach (SG) inhomogeneous field magnets, Wollaston prisms, mirrors, phase changers, and so on.Even empty space, otherwise known as the vacuum, should be regarded as a module.Each module has its own physical properties.These include the number of detectors feeding amplitudes into that module and the number of detectors that

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 13, 2023•0 citations
Introduction Our concern in this chapter is locality in quantum mechanics (QM). Locality is a heuristic physics principle based on the following propositions. No Action-at-a-Distance All the evidence points to the principle that physical actions, taken within restricted (localized) regions of space and time by observers or other agencies such as systems under observation (SUOs), do not cause instantly observable effects on other SUOs at large distances. This does not apply to mathematical/ metaphysical concepts such as quantum wave functions or correlations, as these are conceptual objects (Scarani et al., 2000). Statements about instantaneous wave function collapse are vacuous (have no empirical significance) and are therefore not an issue of significance in physics. Such statements are an issue to theorists who objectivize wave functions, as in Hidden Variables (HV) theory. Action-at-a-distance is generally regarded as anathema by most physicists. For example, Newton's law of universal gravitation is well known for mathematically encoding action-at-a-distance. There is direct evidence, however, in the form of a letter written by Newton to Bentley, that Newton believed that gravity acting “at a distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else” was an absurdity (Newton, 2006). The no action-at-a-distance principle is encoded in quantized detector networks (QDN) by the requirement that labstate preparation and consequent signal detection never occur at the same stage. Causal Transmission All physically observable consequences of local actions taken by an observer or SUO are transmitted by identifiable physical processes, such as electromagnetic waves or neutrinos. There is no such thing as magic or action-at-a-distance . In QDN this proposition is taken into account implicitly in the labstate outcome amplitudes at each stage, as these model how information is propagated from stage to stage. When necessary, the information void can be modeled as if there were fields and/or particles propagating through it, giving scope for different mathematical models, such as Euclidean space, curved spacetime, noncommuting spacetimes, and so on. The structure of the information void is essentially a discussion of whatever modules have to be taken into account between labstate preparation and signal detection.
PROSPECTIVE The concern of this paper will be different from that of most studies of quantum gravity. There will be no discussion of the problem of quantizing the gravitational field equations, hence nothing about the modifications which quantization requires of space-time structure at distances of the order of the Planck length (∼ 10 −33 cm). The emphasis will be rather upon the implications of quantum mechanics for certain general properties of events and processes which occur in the theatre of space-time, specifically with non-locality and nonlinearity . Quantum mechanics is undoubtedly a non-local theory when it treats correlated spatially separated systems. When one examines closely the character of this non-locality, however, one does not find reasons for modifying the causal structure of space-time as described by special or general relativity theory, but rather reasons for refining the concept of an event. The occurrence of definite outcomes of measurements implies that there are processes in nature governed by nonlinear laws. Nonlinearity is very peculiar from the standpoint of quantum mechanics, since it is contrary to the linearity of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, which is commonly assumed to govern the dynamics of any isolated physical system. Hence it is necessary to inquire whether a rational treatment of the occurrence of outcomes is possible without some modifications of current quantum mechanics. Whatever decision is reached on this question, however, it does not appear to bear directly on space-time structure, but rather on the general character of processes.
Abstract Isaac Newton’s theory of gravity seems to postulate action at a distance. Two distant massive bodies act on one another gravitationally instantaneously without a causal mechanism to mediate the action. This paper will argue that a strategy found in the Principia that allows Newton’s theory to be explanatory without providing a causal explanation can be extended to the quantum case. However, while causal action at a distance can be avoided, the explanatory cost of avoiding any form of nonlocality is higher in the quantum case than in the case of Newton’s theory of universal gravitation.
Motivation The aim of this book is to introduce, develop, and apply quantized detector networks (QDN), an information-based, observer-centric approach to quantum mechanics (QM). Six reasons motivating our development of QDN are the following. Avoidance of Metaphysical Speculation There is such a variety of unproven (and unprovable) speculation concerning the interpretation of QM that the subject of this book, QDN, may appear at first sight to be yet another in this growing branch of metaphysics. In fact, our motivation is precisely the opposite. QDN was intended from the outset to reduce the level of metaphysics in the application of QM. To achieve this, our strategy is to move the traditional focus of attention away from systems under observation (SUOs) and toward the observers of those SUOs. In QDN, wave functions represent not states of SUOs but states of apparatus. We shall call such states labstates , to distinguish them from states of SUOs (which do have a place in QDN). It is only labstates that observers can ever deal with directly. In this respect, QDN is an attempt at a more laboratory-based description of quantum physics than standard QM, focusing as much on how an experiment is done as on the results of that experiment. For example, instead of talking about the wave function of an electron, QDN talks about the labstate of the signal detectors that allow us to say anything about that electron in the first place. That is all, there is nothing deeper. Whether or not electrons actually “exist” is thereby relegated to an inessential metaphysical issue that we can choose to ignore. It is important to understand what QDN does not say as much as what it does say. QDN does not say that electrons do not “exist”. QDN merely asks for an empirical definition of “existence”. QM Is Much More Than a Calculational Device Many physicists hold the utilitarian view that the success of quantum theory in predicting experimental data is sufficient for their purposes, and that further inquiry is really the business of metaphysics and therefore outside the scope of science proper. We cannot say that this is entirely unreasonable. However, we take the view that QM represents such a radical departure from the principles of classical mechanics (CM) that this pragmatical view cannot be all there is to the subject.
Thus far I have been primarily concerned with how an interpretation of quantum mechanics might, or might not, be local. This question is traditionally not sharply distinguished from the question of whether quantum mechanics is consistent with the theory of relativity. However, the two questions are indeed quite distinct, and should be recognized as such explicitly. The theory of relativity What does relativity require? As a first approximation, we may make the distinction by noting that the requirements of the theory of relativity are themselves unclear. Minimally, relativity seems to require that there be no way to distinguish one reference frame from another – i.e., that there be no experimental procedure that can determine which of two inertial observers is ‘really’ moving, or more generally that there be no way to discover an observer's absolute velocity. Most authors are willing to find in (special) relativity a stronger requirement: namely, Lorentz-invariance. They say that relativity requires that in fact there is no such thing as absolute velocity. This requirement goes beyond the minimum – it might be that there is an absolute rest frame (so that absolute velocities are given by motion relative to this frame) while there is no way to find it. (As I will discuss in chapter 9, exactly this situation occurs in Bohm's theory.)
Fifty years after the publication of Bell's theorem, there remains some controversy regarding what the theorem is telling us about quantum mechanics, and what the experimental violations of Bell inequalities are telling us about the world. This chapter represents my best attempt to be clear about what I think the lessons are. In brief: there is some sort of nonlocality inherent in any quantum theory, and, moreover, in any theory that reproduces, even approximately, the quantum probabilities for the outcomes of experiments. But not all forms of nonlocality are the same; there is a distinction to be made between action at a distance and other forms of nonlocality, and I will argue that the nonlocality required to violate the Bell inequalities need not involve action at a distance. Furthermore, the distinction between forms of nonlocality makes a difference when it comes to compatibility with relativistic causal structure.
Modules ModulesIn this chapter, we discuss important modules such as Wollaston prisms, Newtonian prisms, beam splitters, phase shifters, mirrors, and null modules.Modules are pieces of apparatus placed at various strategic positions in the information void and are designed to influence labstate amplitudes at signal detectors.Modules are therefore a critical component in the quantized detector network (QDN) approach to quantum mechanics (QM).Modules are not classified as either real or virtual detectors, because no information is extracted from them.Their function is solely to influence quantum amplitude propagation between stages in specific ways.Even empty space (the vacuum) can be regarded as a module, for the propagation of signals through nominally "empty" space is a fundamental subject in its own right.A particularly important example illustrating how nontrivial that can be is the Hubble-Doppler red shift of light from distant galaxies.In the QDN description of the double-slit (DS) experiment, shown in Figure 10.2, the stage Σ 1 detectors labeled 1 1 and 2 1 may be considered as on the V 2 side of the wall W , where V 2 is the information void between stages Σ 1 and Σ 2 .Viewed in this way, the wall may be interpreted as a part of the apparatus that is positioned in the information void region V 1 so as to influence the signals obtained at detectors 1 1 and 2 1 .Virtually all experiments have similar components of apparatus in the information void.We shall call any such piece of apparatus a module.Modules are necessary to the architecture of the experiment, are situated in the information void, and therefore are not detectors.Examples of modules are Stern-Gerlach (SG) inhomogeneous field magnets, Wollaston prisms, mirrors, phase changers, and so on.Even empty space, otherwise known as the vacuum, should be regarded as a module.Each module has its own physical properties.These include the number of detectors feeding amplitudes into that module and the number of detectors that