Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1112.3664 · Physical Review A

Using weak values to experimentally determine “negative probabilities” in a two-photon state with Bell correlations

Brendon L. Higgins, Matthew S. Palsson, Guo‐Yong Xiang, Howard M. Wiseman, Geoff J. Pryde

Published Jan 20, 2015• 36 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bipartite quantum entangled systems can exhibit measurement correlations that violate Bell inequalities, revealing the profoundly counter-intuitive nature of the physical universe. These correlations reflect the impossibility of constructing a joint probability distribution for all values of all the different properties observed in Bell inequality tests. Physically, the impossibility of measuring such a distribution experimentally, as a set of relative frequencies, is due to the quantum back-action of projective measurements. Weakly coupling to a quantum probe, however, produces minimal back-action, and so enables a weak measurement of the projector of one observable, followed by a projective measurement of a noncommuting observable. By this technique it is possible to empirically measure weak-valued probabilities for all of the values of the observables relevant to a Bell test. The marginals of this joint distribution, which we experimentally determine, reproduces all of the observable quantum statistics including a violation of the Bell inequality, which we independently measure. This is possible because our distribution, like the weak values for projectors on which it is built, is not constrained to the interval $[0,1]$. It was first pointed out by Feynman that, for explaining singlet-state correlations within ``a [local] hidden variable view of nature \dots{} everything works fine if we permit negative probabilities.'' However, there are infinitely many such theories. Our method, involving ``weak-valued probabilities,'' singles out a unique set of probabilities, and moreover does so empirically.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.91.012113

Related papers

Measuring Probabilities which Violate "Reality" in a Bell Inequality Experiment

Brendon L. Higgins, Matthew S. Palsson, Guo‐Yong Xiang +2 more

Bipartite quantum entangled systems can exhibit measurement correlations that violate Bell inequalities, revealing the profoundly counter-intuitive nature of the physical universe. These correlations reflect the impossibility of constructing joint probability distribution for all values of all the different properties observed in Bell inequality tests. Physically, the impossibility of measuring such distribution experimentally, as set of relative frequencies, is due to the quantum back-action of projective measurements. Weakly coupling to quantum probe, however, produces minimal back-action, and so enables weak measurement of the projector of one observable, followed by projective measurement of non-commuting observable. By this technique it is possible to empirically measure probabilities for all of the values of the observables relevant to Bell test. The marginals of this joint distribution, which we experimentally determine, reproduces all of the observable quantum statistics including violation of the Bell inequality, which we independently measure. This is possible because our distribution, like the weak values for projectors on which it is built, is not constrained to the interval [0, 1]. It was first pointed out by Feynman that, for explaining singlet-state correlations within a [local] hidden variable view of nature ... everything works fine if we permit negative probabilities. However, there are infinitely many such theories. Our method, involving weak-valued singles out unique set of probabilities, and moreover does so empirically.

•Dec 15, 2011•0 citations

Novel protocols for entanglement characterization and protection

Francesco Atzori

Measurements are a fundamental cornerstone of physics, and in quantum science they play a uniquely central role from both foundational and technological perspectives.It is through measurements that we interact with nature: the way we probe a system determines which properties become accessible, and how they can subsequently be exploited.In quantum mechanics (QM), a measurement is not merely a passive readout of a pre-existing property; it is an active process that, through unavoidable back-action, can shape the very phenomena observed and change the state of the system.From a metrological perspective, the emphasis thus shifts to how measurements are implemented and performed, so that quantum states and correlations can be characterized, verified, and ultimately exploited in ways that are both minimally invasive and practically useful across platforms and networked scenarios.In this work, we take this need as our guiding objective: to turn the study of quantum measurements and resources into concrete, reproducible methods enabling access, characterization and protection of quantum states under realistic conditions.After a brief introduction on QM and related quantum technologies (Chapter 1), Chapter 2 presents a weak measurement (WM) scheme to perform multiple noncommuting measurements on entangled systems without altering their state, a task usually forbidden by the traditional quantum measurement paradigms.A WM is a low-intensity interaction between a quantum system and a measuring device, allowing to extract limited information while keeping the state largely intact.We exploit this property of WMs to realize the first estimation of the entire Bell parameter on a single entangled-photon pair, a task intrinsically forbidden in traditional (projective) quantum measurement frameworks, opening new paths in the field of quantum state estimation.Then, with the same method, we perform the first experimental test of the recently-introduced Relativistic Independence principle, showing how the measurement choice can limit the access to local and nonlocal correlations, demonstrating an interplay and balance between the two.Moreover, we illustrate that, with this scheme, one can access the outcome probabilities for the full set of observables in a Bell test, showing that some probabilities can become intrinsically negative.These works defy traditional, textbook QM paradigms, showing that quantum correlations can be estimated almost

•Feb 20, 2026•0 citations

Testing Bell inequalities with weak measurements

S. Marcovitch, Benni Reznik

Quantum theory is inconsistent with any local hidden variable model as was first shown by Bell. To test Bell inequalities two separated observers extract correlations from a common ensemble of identical systems. Since quantum theory does not allow simultaneous measurements of noncommuting observables, on each system every party measures a single randomly chosen observable out of a given set. Here we suggest a different approach for testing Bell inequalities that is experimentally realizable by current methods. We show that Bell inequalities can be maximally violated even when all observables are measured on each member of the ensemble. This is possible by using weak measurements that produce small disturbance, at the expense of accuracy. However, our approach does not constitute an independent test of quantum nonlocality since the local hidden variables may correlate the noise of the measurement instruments. Nevertheless, by adding a randomly chosen precise measurement at the end of every cycle of weak measurements, the parties can verify that the hidden variables were not interfering with the noise, and thus validate the suggested test.

arXiv:1005.3236•May 18, 2010•11 citations

On the implication of Bell’s probability distribution and proposed experiments of quantum measurement

Hai-Long Zhao

In derivating of Bell’s inequalities, the probability distribution is supposed to be a function only of a hidden variable. We point out that the true implication of the probability distribution of Bell’s correlation function is the distribution of joint measurement outcomes on the two sides. It is therefore a function of both the hidden variable and the settings. In this case, Bell’s inequalities fail. Our further analysis shows that Bell’s locality holds neither for dependent events nor for independent events. We think that the measurements of EPR pairs are dependent events, and hence violation of Bell’s inequalities cannot rule out the existence of local hidden variable. To explain the results of EPR-type experiments, we suppose that a polarization-entangled photon pair can be composed of two circularly or linearly polarized photons with correlated hidden variables, and a couple of experiments of quantum measurement are proposed. The first uses delayed measurement on one photon of the EPR pair to demonstrate directly whether measurement on the other could have any nonlocal influence on it. Then several experiments are suggested to reveal the components of the polarization-entangled photon pair. The last one uses successive polarization measurements on a pair of EPR photons to show that two photons with the same quantum state behave the same under the same measuring conditions.

arXiv:0906.0279•Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Dec 1, 2013•4 citations

On the Implication of Bell's Probability Distribution and Proposed Experiments of Quantum Measurement

Hai-Long Zhao

In the derivation of Bell's inequalities, probability distribution is supposed to be a function of only hidden variable. We point out that the true implication of the probability distribution of Bell's correlation function is the distribution of the joint measurement outcomes on the two sides. So it is a function of both hidden variable and settings. In this case, Bell's inequalities fail. Our further analysis shows that Bell's locality holds neither for dependent events nor for independent events. We think that the measurements of EPR pairs are dependent events, thus violation of Bell's inequalities cannot rule out the existence of local hidden variable. In order to explain the results of EPR-type experiments, we suppose that polarization entangled photon pair can be composed of two circularly or linearly polarized photons with correlated hidden variables, and a couple of experiments of quantum measurement are proposed. The first uses delayed measurement on one photon of the EPR pair to demonstrate directly whether measurement on the other could have any non-local influence on it. Then several experiments are suggested to reveal the components of polarization entangled photon pair. The last one uses successive polarization measurements on a pair of EPR photons to show that two photons with a same quantum state will behave in the same way under the same measuring condition.

•Jun 1, 2009•0 citations

Finite-resolution measurement of the nonclassical polarization statistics of entangled photon pairs

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

By limiting the resolution of quantum measurements, measurement-induced changes of the quantum state can be reduced, permitting subsequent measurements of variables that do not commute with the initially measured property. It is then possible to determine correlations between noncommuting variables experimentally. The application of this method to the polarization statistics of entangled photon pairs reveals that negative conditional probabilities between nonorthogonal polarization components are responsible for the violation of Bell's inequalities. Such negative probabilities can also be observed in finite-resolution measurements of the polarization of a single photon. The violation of Bell's inequalities therefore originates from local properties of the quantum statistics of single-photon polarization.

arXiv:quant-ph/0008122•Physical Review A•Mar 16, 2001•4 citations
Bipartite quantum entangled systems can exhibit measurement correlations that violate Bell inequalities, revealing the profoundly counter-intuitive nature of the physical universe. These correlations reflect the impossibility of constructing a joint probability distribution for all values of all the different properties observed in Bell inequality tests. Physically, the impossibility of measuring such a distribution experimentally, as a set of relative frequencies, is due to the quantum back-action of projective measurements. Weakly coupling to a quantum probe, however, produces minimal back-action, and so enables a weak measurement of the projector of one observable, followed by a projective measurement of a noncommuting observable. By this technique it is possible to empirically measure weak-valued probabilities for all of the values of the observables relevant to a Bell test. The marginals of this joint distribution, which we experimentally determine, reproduces all of the observable quantum statistics including a violation of the Bell inequality, which we independently measure. This is possible because our distribution, like the weak values for projectors on which it is built, is not constrained to the interval [0,1][0,1][0,1]. It was first pointed out by Feynman that, for explaining singlet-state correlations within a [local] hidden variable view of nature \dots{} everything works fine if we permit negative probabilities.'' However, there are infinitely many such theories. Our method, involving weak-valued probabilities,'' singles out a unique set of probabilities, and moreover does so empirically.
Bipartite quantum entangled systems can exhibit measurement correlations that violate Bell inequalities, revealing the profoundly counter-intuitive nature of the physical universe. These correlations reflect the impossibility of constructing joint probability distribution for all values of all the different properties observed in Bell inequality tests. Physically, the impossibility of measuring such distribution experimentally, as set of relative frequencies, is due to the quantum back-action of projective measurements. Weakly coupling to quantum probe, however, produces minimal back-action, and so enables weak measurement of the projector of one observable, followed by projective measurement of non-commuting observable. By this technique it is possible to empirically measure probabilities for all of the values of the observables relevant to Bell test. The marginals of this joint distribution, which we experimentally determine, reproduces all of the observable quantum statistics including violation of the Bell inequality, which we independently measure. This is possible because our distribution, like the weak values for projectors on which it is built, is not constrained to the interval [0, 1]. It was first pointed out by Feynman that, for explaining singlet-state correlations within a [local] hidden variable view of nature ... everything works fine if we permit negative probabilities. However, there are infinitely many such theories. Our method, involving weak-valued singles out unique set of probabilities, and moreover does so empirically.
Measurements are a fundamental cornerstone of physics, and in quantum science they play a uniquely central role from both foundational and technological perspectives.It is through measurements that we interact with nature: the way we probe a system determines which properties become accessible, and how they can subsequently be exploited.In quantum mechanics (QM), a measurement is not merely a passive readout of a pre-existing property; it is an active process that, through unavoidable back-action, can shape the very phenomena observed and change the state of the system.From a metrological perspective, the emphasis thus shifts to how measurements are implemented and performed, so that quantum states and correlations can be characterized, verified, and ultimately exploited in ways that are both minimally invasive and practically useful across platforms and networked scenarios.In this work, we take this need as our guiding objective: to turn the study of quantum measurements and resources into concrete, reproducible methods enabling access, characterization and protection of quantum states under realistic conditions.After a brief introduction on QM and related quantum technologies (Chapter 1), Chapter 2 presents a weak measurement (WM) scheme to perform multiple noncommuting measurements on entangled systems without altering their state, a task usually forbidden by the traditional quantum measurement paradigms.A WM is a low-intensity interaction between a quantum system and a measuring device, allowing to extract limited information while keeping the state largely intact.We exploit this property of WMs to realize the first estimation of the entire Bell parameter on a single entangled-photon pair, a task intrinsically forbidden in traditional (projective) quantum measurement frameworks, opening new paths in the field of quantum state estimation.Then, with the same method, we perform the first experimental test of the recently-introduced Relativistic Independence principle, showing how the measurement choice can limit the access to local and nonlocal correlations, demonstrating an interplay and balance between the two.Moreover, we illustrate that, with this scheme, one can access the outcome probabilities for the full set of observables in a Bell test, showing that some probabilities can become intrinsically negative.These works defy traditional, textbook QM paradigms, showing that quantum correlations can be estimated almost
Quantum theory is inconsistent with any local hidden variable model as was first shown by Bell. To test Bell inequalities two separated observers extract correlations from a common ensemble of identical systems. Since quantum theory does not allow simultaneous measurements of noncommuting observables, on each system every party measures a single randomly chosen observable out of a given set. Here we suggest a different approach for testing Bell inequalities that is experimentally realizable by current methods. We show that Bell inequalities can be maximally violated even when all observables are measured on each member of the ensemble. This is possible by using weak measurements that produce small disturbance, at the expense of accuracy. However, our approach does not constitute an independent test of quantum nonlocality since the local hidden variables may correlate the noise of the measurement instruments. Nevertheless, by adding a randomly chosen precise measurement at the end of every cycle of weak measurements, the parties can verify that the hidden variables were not interfering with the noise, and thus validate the suggested test.
In derivating of Bell’s inequalities, the probability distribution is supposed to be a function only of a hidden variable. We point out that the true implication of the probability distribution of Bell’s correlation function is the distribution of joint measurement outcomes on the two sides. It is therefore a function of both the hidden variable and the settings. In this case, Bell’s inequalities fail. Our further analysis shows that Bell’s locality holds neither for dependent events nor for independent events. We think that the measurements of EPR pairs are dependent events, and hence violation of Bell’s inequalities cannot rule out the existence of local hidden variable. To explain the results of EPR-type experiments, we suppose that a polarization-entangled photon pair can be composed of two circularly or linearly polarized photons with correlated hidden variables, and a couple of experiments of quantum measurement are proposed. The first uses delayed measurement on one photon of the EPR pair to demonstrate directly whether measurement on the other could have any nonlocal influence on it. Then several experiments are suggested to reveal the components of the polarization-entangled photon pair. The last one uses successive polarization measurements on a pair of EPR photons to show that two photons with the same quantum state behave the same under the same measuring conditions.
In the derivation of Bell's inequalities, probability distribution is supposed to be a function of only hidden variable. We point out that the true implication of the probability distribution of Bell's correlation function is the distribution of the joint measurement outcomes on the two sides. So it is a function of both hidden variable and settings. In this case, Bell's inequalities fail. Our further analysis shows that Bell's locality holds neither for dependent events nor for independent events. We think that the measurements of EPR pairs are dependent events, thus violation of Bell's inequalities cannot rule out the existence of local hidden variable. In order to explain the results of EPR-type experiments, we suppose that polarization entangled photon pair can be composed of two circularly or linearly polarized photons with correlated hidden variables, and a couple of experiments of quantum measurement are proposed. The first uses delayed measurement on one photon of the EPR pair to demonstrate directly whether measurement on the other could have any non-local influence on it. Then several experiments are suggested to reveal the components of polarization entangled photon pair. The last one uses successive polarization measurements on a pair of EPR photons to show that two photons with a same quantum state will behave in the same way under the same measuring condition.
By limiting the resolution of quantum measurements, measurement-induced changes of the quantum state can be reduced, permitting subsequent measurements of variables that do not commute with the initially measured property. It is then possible to determine correlations between noncommuting variables experimentally. The application of this method to the polarization statistics of entangled photon pairs reveals that negative conditional probabilities between nonorthogonal polarization components are responsible for the violation of Bell's inequalities. Such negative probabilities can also be observed in finite-resolution measurements of the polarization of a single photon. The violation of Bell's inequalities therefore originates from local properties of the quantum statistics of single-photon polarization.