Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1009.3417 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Exact asymptotic expansions for the thermodynamics of hydrogen gas in the Saha regime

Angel Alastuey, V. Ballenegger

Published May 8, 2009• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the hydrogen quantum plasma in the Saha regime, where it almost reduces to a partially ionized atomic gas. We briefly review the construction of systematic expansions of thermodynamical functions beyond Saha theory, which describes an ideal mixture of ionized protons, ionized electrons and hydrogen atoms in their ground-state. Thanks to the existence of rigorous results, we first identify the simultaneous low-temperature and low-density limit in which Saha theory becomes asymptotically exact. Then, we argue that the screened cluster representation is well suited for calculating corrections, since that formalism accounts for all screening and recombination phenomena at work in a more tractable way than other many-body methods. We sketch the corresponding diagrammatical analysis, which leads to an exact asymptotic expansion for the equation of state. That scaled low-temperature expansion improves the analytical knowledge of the phase diagram. It also provides reliable numerical values over a rather wide range of temperatures and densities, as confirmed by comparisons to quantum Monte Carlo data.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/42/21/214031

Related papers

Renormalisation of Hydrogen Partition Function and Saha Ionisation Equation

George Savvidy, Pengming Zhang

An important physical quantity that is part of the Saha ionisation equation is the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. An immense uncertainty is caused by the divergency of the neutral atom partition function arising due to the fast growing degeneracy factor of its excited n-state. We suggested a regularisation and renormalisation procedure for the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. The renormalised partition function is well defined and allows to calculate the population of the energy levels and the ionisation state of the hydrogen plasma as a function of its temperature and pressure. In the low-temperature limit the behaviour of these functions smoothly transforms to the Saha equation, which is used in the description of the low-temperature plasma. At higher temperatures the renormalised ionisation equation describes the deviation from the Saha equation. The application of the renormalised ionisation equation to the solar core and atmosphere is considered.

physics.plasm-phCross-listedarXiv:2611.03671•Nov 4, 2026

Bound states of the hydrogen-like atomic systems in plasma environments

Fatma Zohra Khaled, Mustafa Moumni, Mokhtar Falek

We conduct a non-relativistic study of plasma screening effects on hydrogen-like atomic systems using the Screened Coulomb Potential (SCP i.e. Yukawa potential). The radial Schrödinger equation is first reduced to a bi-confluent Heun (BCH) equation for the Killingbeck potential which is the truncated version of the SCP, and we write the exact BCH eigenfunctions and eigenenergies. We then study the limitations of these BCH solutions and obtain an analytic description valid for weak to moderate screening using the BCH functional form. The corrected eigenfunctions are constructed order by order up to O(k^3); they are expressed in terms of the Laguerre polynomials and reduces exactly to Coulomb eigenfunctions when k=0. Using these Functions, the energy spectrum is computed via two analytic methods: (i) direct evaluation of the full Yukawa Hamiltonian expectation value, and (ii) the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, yielding integral representation. All methods presented here provide explicit analytical formulas for both wavefunctions and eigenenergies valid for different ranges of the screening. These methods establish a powerful analytic framework for studying confined quantum systems. The thermodynamic properties are also derived using the BCH formulation.

quant-pharXiv:2607.19601•Jul 23, 2026

EFFECTIVE RANGE THEORY AND MANY-BODY PERTURBATION THEORY APPLIED TO ELECTRON SPIN-POLARIZED ATOMIC HYDROGEN (H+)

Yea-Hwang Uang, W. C. Stwalley

Accurate scattering lengths and effective ranges for hydrogen atomic collisions are determined from effective range theory. The precise ab initio b3Σ+u potential energy curve values of H2 calculated by Kolos and Wolniewicz and C6, C8, C10 long-range expansion coefficients are used in obtaining accurate representation of the two-body interaction potential. The s-wave scattering length obtained for this potential (A =1/33455 ao) is used to calculate the zero temperature energy as a function of density of electron spin-polarized ("spin-aligned") atomic hydrogen (H+) using previous many-body perturbation theory results for bosons. Neglecting small potential shape dependent terms, one obtains E/N (energy per particle ) as a function of density, which may be compared with similar results obtained from Monte-Carlo or variational calculations. The scattering lengths and effective ranges for the other hydrogen isotopic systems are also presented. It is shown that the first bound state for the b3Σ+u potential (within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation) only exists for a hypothetical isotopic species with mass larger than a value m = 3.258176 g/mole (where the scattering length becomes infinite). In terms of the quantum parameter, η ≡ [MATH]2/ (2µεσ2), two-body binding occurs in the b3Σ+u potential only for η < 0.17094. The second order liquid-to-gas transition (corresponding to the onset of infinite-body binding) occurs at the accurately determined critical value of the quantum parameter ηCB = 0.43891. This corresponds to zero scattering length.

Le Journal de Physique Colloques•Jul 1, 1980•0 citations

Low-energy spectrum and dynamics of the weakly interacting Bose gas

Lea Boßmann

We consider a gas of N bosons with interactions in the mean-field scaling regime. We review the proof of an asymptotic expansion of its low-energy spectrum, eigenstates, and dynamics, which provides corrections to Bogoliubov theory to all orders in 1/N. This is based on joint works with Petrat, Pickl, Seiringer, and Soffer. In addition, we derive a full asymptotic expansion of the ground state one-body reduced density matrix.

arXiv:2203.00730•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2022•5 citations

Universal correlations at low density

Fabian H. L. Eßler, Holger Frahm, Frank Göhmann +2 more

In Chapter 9 we developed the picture of the asymptotics of the correlation functions of the Hubbard model for the phases with gapless excitations, i.e., for the phases with ground states belonging to regions II and IV of the ground state phase diagram discussed in Chapter 6.3 (see figures 6.4, 6.5). Our results relied on the predictions of conformal field theory which are expected to hold for a whole universality class of models related to the Hubbard model and which only need the finite size data calculated in Chapter 8 as input parameters. Correlation functions at half-filling (phase V) were considered in the previous chapter on the basis of a special continuum limit and the predictions of certain integrable quantum field theories. Here we shall consider correlation functions in the phase whose ground state is the empty band (phase I in the ground state phase diagram, figures 6.4, 6.5). At zero temperature the boundary of this phase in the μ- B plane (see figure 6.5) is determined by equation (6.20): μ < μ 0 ( B ). For small finite temperature a small number of particles is populating the system. They form a dilute, thermodynamically ideal gas with pressure proportional to the temperature (see below). We shall say the system is in the gas phase [176] and shall give a more precise meaning to this statement later.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 7, 2005•0 citations

Integrating dynamical mean-field theory and diagrammatic Monte Carlo

Johan Carlström

Dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) is one of the most widely used theoretical methods for electronic structure calculations, providing self-consistent solutions even in low-temperature regimes, which are exact in the limit of infinite dimension. The principal limitation of this method is that it neglects spatial fluctuations, which become important in finite dimensions. Diagrammatic Monte Carlo (diagMC), by contrast, provides results that are asymptotically exact for a convergent or resummable series, but are typically limited to high temperature as they depend on the analytic structure of the expansion. In this work, we present a framework for integrating these two methods so that the diagrammatic expansion is conducted around the DMFT solution. This results in a series expansion conducted only in terms that explicitly depend on nonlocal correlations, and which is asymptotically exact.

arXiv:2309.00674•Sep 1, 2023•2 citations
We consider the hydrogen quantum plasma in the Saha regime, where it almost reduces to a partially ionized atomic gas. We briefly review the construction of systematic expansions of thermodynamical functions beyond Saha theory, which describes an ideal mixture of ionized protons, ionized electrons and hydrogen atoms in their ground-state. Thanks to the existence of rigorous results, we first identify the simultaneous low-temperature and low-density limit in which Saha theory becomes asymptotically exact. Then, we argue that the screened cluster representation is well suited for calculating corrections, since that formalism accounts for all screening and recombination phenomena at work in a more tractable way than other many-body methods. We sketch the corresponding diagrammatical analysis, which leads to an exact asymptotic expansion for the equation of state. That scaled low-temperature expansion improves the analytical knowledge of the phase diagram. It also provides reliable numerical values over a rather wide range of temperatures and densities, as confirmed by comparisons to quantum Monte Carlo data.
An important physical quantity that is part of the Saha ionisation equation is the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. An immense uncertainty is caused by the divergency of the neutral atom partition function arising due to the fast growing degeneracy factor of its excited n-state. We suggested a regularisation and renormalisation procedure for the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. The renormalised partition function is well defined and allows to calculate the population of the energy levels and the ionisation state of the hydrogen plasma as a function of its temperature and pressure. In the low-temperature limit the behaviour of these functions smoothly transforms to the Saha equation, which is used in the description of the low-temperature plasma. At higher temperatures the renormalised ionisation equation describes the deviation from the Saha equation. The application of the renormalised ionisation equation to the solar core and atmosphere is considered.
We conduct a non-relativistic study of plasma screening effects on hydrogen-like atomic systems using the Screened Coulomb Potential (SCP i.e. Yukawa potential). The radial Schrödinger equation is first reduced to a bi-confluent Heun (BCH) equation for the Killingbeck potential which is the truncated version of the SCP, and we write the exact BCH eigenfunctions and eigenenergies. We then study the limitations of these BCH solutions and obtain an analytic description valid for weak to moderate screening using the BCH functional form. The corrected eigenfunctions are constructed order by order up to O(k^3); they are expressed in terms of the Laguerre polynomials and reduces exactly to Coulomb eigenfunctions when k=0. Using these Functions, the energy spectrum is computed via two analytic methods: (i) direct evaluation of the full Yukawa Hamiltonian expectation value, and (ii) the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, yielding integral representation. All methods presented here provide explicit analytical formulas for both wavefunctions and eigenenergies valid for different ranges of the screening. These methods establish a powerful analytic framework for studying confined quantum systems. The thermodynamic properties are also derived using the BCH formulation.
Accurate scattering lengths and effective ranges for hydrogen atomic collisions are determined from effective range theory. The precise ab initio b3Σ+u potential energy curve values of H2 calculated by Kolos and Wolniewicz and C6, C8, C10 long-range expansion coefficients are used in obtaining accurate representation of the two-body interaction potential. The s-wave scattering length obtained for this potential (A =1/33455 ao) is used to calculate the zero temperature energy as a function of density of electron spin-polarized ("spin-aligned") atomic hydrogen (H+) using previous many-body perturbation theory results for bosons. Neglecting small potential shape dependent terms, one obtains E/N (energy per particle ) as a function of density, which may be compared with similar results obtained from Monte-Carlo or variational calculations. The scattering lengths and effective ranges for the other hydrogen isotopic systems are also presented. It is shown that the first bound state for the b3Σ+u potential (within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation) only exists for a hypothetical isotopic species with mass larger than a value m = 3.258176 g/mole (where the scattering length becomes infinite). In terms of the quantum parameter, η ≡ [MATH]2/ (2µεσ2), two-body binding occurs in the b3Σ+u potential only for η < 0.17094. The second order liquid-to-gas transition (corresponding to the onset of infinite-body binding) occurs at the accurately determined critical value of the quantum parameter ηCB = 0.43891. This corresponds to zero scattering length.
In Chapter 9 we developed the picture of the asymptotics of the correlation functions of the Hubbard model for the phases with gapless excitations, i.e., for the phases with ground states belonging to regions II and IV of the ground state phase diagram discussed in Chapter 6.3 (see figures 6.4, 6.5). Our results relied on the predictions of conformal field theory which are expected to hold for a whole universality class of models related to the Hubbard model and which only need the finite size data calculated in Chapter 8 as input parameters. Correlation functions at half-filling (phase V) were considered in the previous chapter on the basis of a special continuum limit and the predictions of certain integrable quantum field theories. Here we shall consider correlation functions in the phase whose ground state is the empty band (phase I in the ground state phase diagram, figures 6.4, 6.5). At zero temperature the boundary of this phase in the μ- B plane (see figure 6.5) is determined by equation (6.20): μ < μ 0 ( B ). For small finite temperature a small number of particles is populating the system. They form a dilute, thermodynamically ideal gas with pressure proportional to the temperature (see below). We shall say the system is in the gas phase [176] and shall give a more precise meaning to this statement later.
Dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) is one of the most widely used theoretical methods for electronic structure calculations, providing self-consistent solutions even in low-temperature regimes, which are exact in the limit of infinite dimension. The principal limitation of this method is that it neglects spatial fluctuations, which become important in finite dimensions. Diagrammatic Monte Carlo (diagMC), by contrast, provides results that are asymptotically exact for a convergent or resummable series, but are typically limited to high temperature as they depend on the analytic structure of the expansion. In this work, we present a framework for integrating these two methods so that the diagrammatic expansion is conducted around the DMFT solution. This results in a series expansion conducted only in terms that explicitly depend on nonlocal correlations, and which is asymptotically exact.