Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2611.03671

Renormalisation of Hydrogen Partition Function and Saha Ionisation Equation

George Savvidy, Pengming Zhang

physics.plasm-phhep-phphysics.atom-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 16, 2026• Announced Nov 4, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An important physical quantity that is part of the Saha ionisation equation is the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. An immense uncertainty is caused by the divergency of the neutral atom partition function arising due to the fast growing degeneracy factor of its excited n-state. We suggested a regularisation and renormalisation procedure for the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. The renormalised partition function is well defined and allows to calculate the population of the energy levels and the ionisation state of the hydrogen plasma as a function of its temperature and pressure. In the low-temperature limit the behaviour of these functions smoothly transforms to the Saha equation, which is used in the description of the low-temperature plasma. At higher temperatures the renormalised ionisation equation describes the deviation from the Saha equation. The application of the renormalised ionisation equation to the solar core and atmosphere is considered.

AI Summary

The paper addresses the divergence of the neutral-hydrogen internal partition function, $Z_{\rm bare}=z_0\sum_{n\geq1}n^2e^{-A(1-1/n^2)}$, where $A=\mathrm{Ry}/kT$, and its consequences for Saha ionisation equilibrium. It proposes a temperature-dependent finite partition function without truncating the isolated atom’s bound-state spectrum. The calculation inserts an exponential regulator $e^{-\epsilon n}$ and expands the regulated sum using polylogarithms. Subtracting $2/\epsilon^3+A/\epsilon-A/2$ before taking $\epsilon\to0$ gives $Z_I=z_0e^{-A}\sum_{m\geq2}\zeta(2m-2)A^m/m!$. A corresponding termwise subtraction defines positive, normalised level populations proportional to $n^2[e^{A/n^2}-1-A/n^2]$. Combining this expression with the usual ionised-state partition function yields a modified Saha relation, with the Boltzmann factor $e^{-A}$ replaced by the reciprocal of the zeta-function series. The ratio $R=Z_I/z_0$ approaches one at low temperature. The paper reports a maximum excess of approximately $3\%$ near $3.2\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}$, followed by $R<1$ above roughly $4.6\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}$. For a solar-core example with $T=10^7\,\mathrm{K}$ and hydrogen density $10^{26}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}$, the predicted ionised fraction is $0.9997$, versus $0.56$ from the ground-state Saha approximation. At photospheric conditions, both give approximately $6.4\times10^{-4}$. The treatment assumes dissociative equilibrium and uses ideal-gas and nonrelativistic expressions; the stated nonrelativistic temperature scale is $5.9\times10^9\,\mathrm{K}$. It distinguishes its single-atom subtraction prescription from interaction-based cutoffs and proposes laboratory tests of the high-temperature deviations.

No sign of AI-generated textUnclear noveltyMissing comparisonOverclaimsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The proposed normalised level populations violate the Gibbs population ratios for the unchanged hydrogen spectrum, so they cannot represent its stated thermal equilibrium populations. The claimed replacement for the Saha equation is not derived from an equilibrium model that justifies treating the subtracted sum as an independent neutral-hydrogen partition function. The printed high-level populations at 6000 K contradict equation populationr, which gives approximately 1.28 × 10⁻¹³, 1.28 × 10⁻¹⁵, and 1.28 × 10⁻¹⁹ for levels 100, 1000, and 100000. The displayed energy-moment formulas menEI and menEIsq omit an exp(−A) factor required to implement the paper's own normalised probabilities.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
17 pages, 1 figure

Related papers

Coherent excitation of hydrogen atoms by proton impact

O Schöller, J S Briggs, R. M. Dreizler

The density matrix describing excitation of the n=2 and n=3 levels of atomic hydrogen under proton impact is calculated, both in the first Born approximation and in a close-coupling expansion in target eigenstates. Various ways in which the properties of the excited state can be characterized in terms of certain linear combinations of density matrix elements are discussed. A new characterisation, based on an extrapolation below threshold of parameters describing the angular distribution of low-velocity ionised electrons, is suggested.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Aug 28, 1986•44 citations

Optimised mean fields for atoms. I. Mean-field methods for the description of N-fermion systems

Klaus Dietz, Olaf Lechtenfeld, G Weymans

Siegert's representation (1960) for the grand canonical partition function of a fermion system with two-particle interactions serves as a starting point for a perturbation expansion around stationary points. It is shown that, in general, the latter are given by solutions of the time-independent Hartree equation. Introducing more general random fields, exchange terms are obtained in the stationarity equation. The procedure is extended to relativistic systems. A perturbative expansion for e.g. the ground-state energy of the N-particle relativistic bound-state problem is obtained which allows, contrary to 'Hamiltonian methods', a straightforward application of standard regularisation and renormalisation procedures.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Dec 14, 1982•35 citations

Renormalised Perturbation Theory of Resonant Multiphoton Ionisation

K. Unnikrishnan

Perturbation theory of multiphoton ionisation due to a classical electromagnetic field is modified to allow for intermediate resonances with bound states. Complex energies, generally associated with resonances, do not enter into this formalism. For a monochromatic field of frequency u, a constant ionisation rate can then be defined unambiguously and only such continuum states are excited which correspond to the absorption of energy in integral multiples of hu. As an application, differential and total cross sections for the two-photon ionisation of hydrogen, for frequencies below the n = 3 resonance region, are obtained in closed form. Existing data for generalised cross sections, calculated numerically using the complex coordinate method, are in good agreement with the present results. Finally, the mean fractional ionisation resulting from a pulse of finite duration is estimated on the basis of the associated power spectrum. For short pulses, the time dependence of ionisation exhibits a departure from that expected of a time-independent rate.

Australian Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1995•0 citations

Ionisation of hydrogen-like atoms by a multiphoton absorption process; Ionisation des atomes hydrogenoides par un processus d'absorption multiphotonique

Yves Gontier, M. Trahin

The general expression for the amplitude of the probability of ionisation by a multiphoton absorption process is derived. Its non-relativistic limit is taken and the bipolar approximation is used for calculating the ionisation cross-section of hydrogen-like atoms. This latter involves the summation over intermediate virtual states by means of: a) a recursion relationship concerning angular functions, b) a particular technique which when applied to radial functions makes it possible to solve a system of inhomogeneous first-order differential equations. (authors) [French] On etablit l'expression generale de l'amplitude de probabilite d'ionisation par un processus d'absorption multiphotonique. On en prend la limite non-relativiste et l'on utilise l'approximation dipolaire avant de calculer la section efficace d'ionisation d'atomes hydrogenoides. Cette derniere fait intervenir des sommations sur des etats virtuels intermediaires effectuees a l'aide: a) d'une relation de recurrence qui concerne les fonctions angulaires, b) d'une technique particuliere qui, appliquee aux fonctions radiales, conduit a resoudre un systeme d'equations differentielles inhomogenes du premier ordre. (auteur)

•Jul 1, 1967•0 citations

Threshold behaviour of multiphoton ionisation of hydrogenic atoms

N. K. Rahman

The threshold behaviour of the multiphoton ionisation cross section is examined analytically for the ground-state hydrogen atom. The cross sections become independent of the electron momentum. Generalisation of the results is indicated.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Oct 14, 1979•6 citations

SPIN-POLARIZED ATOMIC HYDROGEN IN THE STATIC FLUCTUATION APPROXIMATION

B.R. Joudeh, Mohamed K. Al-Sugheir, H. B. Ghassib

In this paper we use the so-called static fluctuation approximation (SFA) to calculate the thermodynamic properties of spin-polarized atomic hydrogen. This approximation is based on the replacement of the square of the local-field operator with its mean value. A closed set of nonlinear integral equations is derived for neutral many-bosonic systems. This set is solved numerically by an iteration method for two triplet-state potentials: a Morse- and Silvera-type potentials. It is found that the mean internal energy per unit volume, the pressure, the entropy per unit volume, and the specific heat per unit volume increase with temperature and decrease with spin polarization in the low-temperature region (<8 mK ); whereas the condensate fraction increases with an applied magnetic field. It is also found that these quantities are nearly independent of spin polarization for high temperatures (>0.1 K ), and that they are independent of the number density up to 10-3Å-3 in the low-temperature region.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Oct 20, 2005•21 citations
An important physical quantity that is part of the Saha ionisation equation is the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. An immense uncertainty is caused by the divergency of the neutral atom partition function arising due to the fast growing degeneracy factor of its excited n-state. We suggested a regularisation and renormalisation procedure for the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. The renormalised partition function is well defined and allows to calculate the population of the energy levels and the ionisation state of the hydrogen plasma as a function of its temperature and pressure. In the low-temperature limit the behaviour of these functions smoothly transforms to the Saha equation, which is used in the description of the low-temperature plasma. At higher temperatures the renormalised ionisation equation describes the deviation from the Saha equation. The application of the renormalised ionisation equation to the solar core and atmosphere is considered.
The paper addresses the divergence of the neutral-hydrogen internal partition function, Zbare=z0∑n≥1n2e−A(1−1/n2)Z_{\rm bare}=z_0\sum_{n\geq1}n^2e^{-A(1-1/n^2)}Zbare​=z0​∑n≥1​n2e−A(1−1/n2), where A=Ry/kTA=\mathrm{Ry}/kTA=Ry/kT, and its consequences for Saha ionisation equilibrium. It proposes a temperature-dependent finite partition function without truncating the isolated atom’s bound-state spectrum.
The calculation inserts an exponential regulator e−ϵne^{-\epsilon n}e−ϵn and expands the regulated sum using polylogarithms. Subtracting 2/ϵ3+A/ϵ−A/22/\epsilon^3+A/\epsilon-A/22/ϵ3+A/ϵ−A/2 before taking ϵ→0\epsilon\to0ϵ→0 gives ZI=z0e−A∑m≥2ζ(2m−2)Am/m!Z_I=z_0e^{-A}\sum_{m\geq2}\zeta(2m-2)A^m/m!ZI​=z0​e−A∑m≥2​ζ(2m−2)Am/m!. A corresponding termwise subtraction defines positive, normalised level populations proportional to n2[eA/n2−1−A/n2]n^2[e^{A/n^2}-1-A/n^2]n2[eA/n2−1−A/n2]. Combining this expression with the usual ionised-state partition function yields a modified Saha relation, with the Boltzmann factor e−Ae^{-A}e−A replaced by the reciprocal of the zeta-function series.
The ratio R=ZI/z0R=Z_I/z_0R=ZI​/z0​ approaches one at low temperature. The paper reports a maximum excess of approximately 3%3\%3% near 3.2×104 K3.2\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}3.2×104K, followed by R<1R<1R<1 above roughly 4.6×104 K4.6\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}4.6×104K. For a solar-core example with T=107 KT=10^7\,\mathrm{K}T=107K and hydrogen density 1026 cm−310^{26}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}1026cm−3, the predicted ionised fraction is 0.99970.99970.9997, versus 0.560.560.56 from the ground-state Saha approximation. At photospheric conditions, both give approximately 6.4×10−46.4\times10^{-4}6.4×10−4.
The treatment assumes dissociative equilibrium and uses ideal-gas and nonrelativistic expressions; the stated nonrelativistic temperature scale is 5.9×109 K5.9\times10^9\,\mathrm{K}5.9×109K. It distinguishes its single-atom subtraction prescription from interaction-based cutoffs and proposes laboratory tests of the high-temperature deviations.
The density matrix describing excitation of the n=2 and n=3 levels of atomic hydrogen under proton impact is calculated, both in the first Born approximation and in a close-coupling expansion in target eigenstates. Various ways in which the properties of the excited state can be characterized in terms of certain linear combinations of density matrix elements are discussed. A new characterisation, based on an extrapolation below threshold of parameters describing the angular distribution of low-velocity ionised electrons, is suggested.
Siegert's representation (1960) for the grand canonical partition function of a fermion system with two-particle interactions serves as a starting point for a perturbation expansion around stationary points. It is shown that, in general, the latter are given by solutions of the time-independent Hartree equation. Introducing more general random fields, exchange terms are obtained in the stationarity equation. The procedure is extended to relativistic systems. A perturbative expansion for e.g. the ground-state energy of the N-particle relativistic bound-state problem is obtained which allows, contrary to 'Hamiltonian methods', a straightforward application of standard regularisation and renormalisation procedures.
Perturbation theory of multiphoton ionisation due to a classical electromagnetic field is modified to allow for intermediate resonances with bound states. Complex energies, generally associated with resonances, do not enter into this formalism. For a monochromatic field of frequency u, a constant ionisation rate can then be defined unambiguously and only such continuum states are excited which correspond to the absorption of energy in integral multiples of hu. As an application, differential and total cross sections for the two-photon ionisation of hydrogen, for frequencies below the n = 3 resonance region, are obtained in closed form. Existing data for generalised cross sections, calculated numerically using the complex coordinate method, are in good agreement with the present results. Finally, the mean fractional ionisation resulting from a pulse of finite duration is estimated on the basis of the associated power spectrum. For short pulses, the time dependence of ionisation exhibits a departure from that expected of a time-independent rate.
The general expression for the amplitude of the probability of ionisation by a multiphoton absorption process is derived. Its non-relativistic limit is taken and the bipolar approximation is used for calculating the ionisation cross-section of hydrogen-like atoms. This latter involves the summation over intermediate virtual states by means of: a) a recursion relationship concerning angular functions, b) a particular technique which when applied to radial functions makes it possible to solve a system of inhomogeneous first-order differential equations. (authors) [French] On etablit l'expression generale de l'amplitude de probabilite d'ionisation par un processus d'absorption multiphotonique. On en prend la limite non-relativiste et l'on utilise l'approximation dipolaire avant de calculer la section efficace d'ionisation d'atomes hydrogenoides. Cette derniere fait intervenir des sommations sur des etats virtuels intermediaires effectuees a l'aide: a) d'une relation de recurrence qui concerne les fonctions angulaires, b) d'une technique particuliere qui, appliquee aux fonctions radiales, conduit a resoudre un systeme d'equations differentielles inhomogenes du premier ordre. (auteur)
In this paper we use the so-called static fluctuation approximation (SFA) to calculate the thermodynamic properties of spin-polarized atomic hydrogen. This approximation is based on the replacement of the square of the local-field operator with its mean value. A closed set of nonlinear integral equations is derived for neutral many-bosonic systems. This set is solved numerically by an iteration method for two triplet-state potentials: a Morse- and Silvera-type potentials. It is found that the mean internal energy per unit volume, the pressure, the entropy per unit volume, and the specific heat per unit volume increase with temperature and decrease with spin polarization in the low-temperature region (<8 mK ); whereas the condensate fraction increases with an applied magnetic field. It is also found that these quantities are nearly independent of spin polarization for high temperatures (>0.1 K ), and that they are independent of the number density up to 10-3Å-3 in the low-temperature region.