arXiv:2611.03671
Renormalisation of Hydrogen Partition Function and Saha Ionisation Equation
George Savvidy, Pengming Zhang
Abstract
An important physical quantity that is part of the Saha ionisation equation is the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. An immense uncertainty is caused by the divergency of the neutral atom partition function arising due to the fast growing degeneracy factor of its excited n-state. We suggested a regularisation and renormalisation procedure for the partition function of the neutral hydrogen atoms. The renormalised partition function is well defined and allows to calculate the population of the energy levels and the ionisation state of the hydrogen plasma as a function of its temperature and pressure. In the low-temperature limit the behaviour of these functions smoothly transforms to the Saha equation, which is used in the description of the low-temperature plasma. At higher temperatures the renormalised ionisation equation describes the deviation from the Saha equation. The application of the renormalised ionisation equation to the solar core and atmosphere is considered.
AI Summary
The paper addresses the divergence of the neutral-hydrogen internal partition function, $Z_{\rm bare}=z_0\sum_{n\geq1}n^2e^{-A(1-1/n^2)}$, where $A=\mathrm{Ry}/kT$, and its consequences for Saha ionisation equilibrium. It proposes a temperature-dependent finite partition function without truncating the isolated atom’s bound-state spectrum. The calculation inserts an exponential regulator $e^{-\epsilon n}$ and expands the regulated sum using polylogarithms. Subtracting $2/\epsilon^3+A/\epsilon-A/2$ before taking $\epsilon\to0$ gives $Z_I=z_0e^{-A}\sum_{m\geq2}\zeta(2m-2)A^m/m!$. A corresponding termwise subtraction defines positive, normalised level populations proportional to $n^2[e^{A/n^2}-1-A/n^2]$. Combining this expression with the usual ionised-state partition function yields a modified Saha relation, with the Boltzmann factor $e^{-A}$ replaced by the reciprocal of the zeta-function series. The ratio $R=Z_I/z_0$ approaches one at low temperature. The paper reports a maximum excess of approximately $3\%$ near $3.2\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}$, followed by $R<1$ above roughly $4.6\times10^4\,\mathrm{K}$. For a solar-core example with $T=10^7\,\mathrm{K}$ and hydrogen density $10^{26}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}$, the predicted ionised fraction is $0.9997$, versus $0.56$ from the ground-state Saha approximation. At photospheric conditions, both give approximately $6.4\times10^{-4}$. The treatment assumes dissociative equilibrium and uses ideal-gas and nonrelativistic expressions; the stated nonrelativistic temperature scale is $5.9\times10^9\,\mathrm{K}$. It distinguishes its single-atom subtraction prescription from interaction-based cutoffs and proposes laboratory tests of the high-temperature deviations.
Central claim may not hold: The proposed normalised level populations violate the Gibbs population ratios for the unchanged hydrogen spectrum, so they cannot represent its stated thermal equilibrium populations. The claimed replacement for the Saha equation is not derived from an equilibrium model that justifies treating the subtracted sum as an independent neutral-hydrogen partition function. The printed high-level populations at 6000 K contradict equation populationr, which gives approximately 1.28 × 10⁻¹³, 1.28 × 10⁻¹⁵, and 1.28 × 10⁻¹⁹ for levels 100, 1000, and 100000. The displayed energy-moment formulas menEI and menEIsq omit an exp(−A) factor required to implement the paper's own normalised probabilities.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 17 pages, 1 figure