Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.5098 · Physical Review B

Absence of Goldstone bosons on the Bethe lattice

Chris R. Laumann, S. A. Parameswaran, Shivaji L. Sondhi

Published Oct 19, 2009• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss symmetry breaking quantum phase transitions on the oft studied Bethe lattice in the context of the ferromagnetic scalar spherical model or, equivalently, the infinite ${N}_{f}$ limit of ferromagnetic models with $O({N}_{f})$ symmetry. We show that the approach to quantum criticality is characterized by the vanishing of a gap to just the global modes so that all local correlation functions continue to exhibit massive behavior. This behavior persists into the broken symmetry phase even as the order parameter develops an expectation value and thus there are no massless Goldstone bosons in the spectrum. We relate this feature to a spectral property of the graph Laplacian shared by the set of ``expander'' graphs, and argue that our results apply to symmetry breaking transitions on such graphs quite generally.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.80.144415

Related papers

Quantum Phase Transition in the Coupled-Top Model: From Z2 to U(1) Symmetry Breaking

Wen-Jian Mao, Ye F. Tian, Liwei Duan +1 more

We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.

arXiv:2502.09394•Entropy•Apr 27, 2025•0 citations

Critical Phenomena on the Bethe Lattice

Rudrajit Banerjee, Nicolas Delporte, Saswato Sen +1 more

We investigate the critical behavior of a family of $\mathbb{Z}_2$-symmetric scalar field theories on the Bethe lattice (the tree limit of regular hyperbolic tessellations) using both the non-perturbative Functional Renormalization Group and lattice perturbation theory. The family is indexed by the parameter $ζ\in (0,1]$, which determines the range of the theory via the kinetic term constructed from the graph Laplacian raised to the power $ζ$. Specifically, $ζ=1$ is the short-range theory, while $0<ζ<1$ defines the long-range model. Due to the hyperbolic nature of Bethe lattices, the Laplacian lacks a zero mode and exhibits a spectral gap. We find that upon closing this spectral gap by a modification of the Laplacian, the scalar field theories exhibit novel critical behavior in the form of non-trivial fixed points with critical exponents governed by $ζ$ and the spectral dimension $d_s=3$. In particular, our analysis indicates the presence of a Wilson-Fisher fixed point for the short range $ζ=1$ theory. In contrast, the nearest-neighbor Ising model on the Bethe lattice is known to exhibit mean-field critical exponents. To the best of our knowledge, this work provides the first evidence that a scalar $ϕ^4$ theory and the discrete Ising model on the same underlying lattice may lie in distinct universality classes.

arXiv:2601.01961•Jan 5, 2026•2 citations

Critical behavior of the Higgs- and Goldstone-mass gaps for the two-dimensional S=1 XY model

Yoshihiro Nishiyama

Spectral properties for the two-dimensional quantum S=1 XY model were investigated with the exact diagonalization method. In the symmetry-broken phase, there appear the massive Higgs and massless Goldstone excitations, which correspond to the longitudinal and transverse modes of the spontaneous magnetic moment, respectively. The former excitation branch is embedded in the continuum of the latter, and little attention has been paid to the details, particularly, in proximity to the critical point. The finite-size-scaling behavior is improved by extending the interaction parameters. An analysis of the critical amplitude ratio for these mass gaps is made.

arXiv:1506.04199•Nuclear Physics B•Jun 12, 2015•9 citations

Instantonic condensates in many-body systems: breakdown of Goldstone's theorem

Sergei I. Mukhin

In accord with Nambu-Goldstone theorem spontaneous breaking of a global continuous symmetry of the system by a mean-field parameter causes appearance of massless Goldstone bosons, called also gapless Goldstone modes. It is demonstrated below that the theorem can be violated, i.e. the Goldstone modes possess finite gap, in the case of a novel (quantum ordered) state of interacting fermions, that was proposed recently {mukhin 2011}. This result may lead to the important consequences when considered in combination with another peculiar properties of the quantum parameter (QOP) that where recently found: QOP's Green's function is finite and periodic along the Matsubara's axis, but Wick-rotated to the axis of real frequencies, possesses infinite periodic chain of \it{second poles} along this axis {mukhin 2011}. This property of QOP leads to a remarkable physical consequence: \it{QOP does not scatter anything in Minkowski world} ! Hence, the present theory, we believe, may naturally indicate that two effects: hidden order revealed in ARPES spectra of fermi-excitations and neutron resonance feature at finite frequency in the magnetic (bosonic) excitations spectrum in lightly hole-doped copper oxides, could be emerging fingerprints of the Euclidian crystal state. A peculiar manifestation of the QOP self-consistent solution in the form of non-classical phonon states is described for an Euclidian predicted recently {mukhin,fistul 2013} in the array of Josephson junctions coupled via electromagnetic field in the superconducting resonator. It is demonstrated that it may constitute a stable state of the system, that, for a particular quantum disordering model, exists inside the stability domain of the classical photonic condensate delimited by the critical value of the quantum disordering strength.

arXiv:1305.6125•May 27, 2013•0 citations

Quantum fluctuations inhibit symmetry breaking in the Hamiltonian mean-field model

Ryan Plestid, James Lambert

It is widely believed that mean-field theory is exact for a wide range of classical long-range interacting systems. Is this also true once quantum fluctuations have been accounted for? As a test case we study the Hamiltonian mean-field (HMF) model for a system of bosons which is predicted (according to mean-field theory) to undergo a second-order quantum phase transition at zero temperature. The ordered phase is characterized by a spontaneously broken O(2) symmetry, which, despite occurring in a one-dimensional model, is not ruled out by the Mermin-Wagner theorem due to the presence of long-range interactions. Nevertheless, a spontaneously broken symmetry implies gapless Goldstone modes whose large fluctuations can restore broken symmetries. In this work we study the influence of quantum fluctuations by projecting the Hamiltonian onto the continuous subspace of symmetry-breaking mean-field states. We find that the energetic cost of gradients in the center-of-mass wave function inhibits the breaking of the O(2) symmetry, but that the energetic cost is very small, scaling as O(1/N^{2}). Nevertheless, for any finite N, no matter how large, this implies that the ground state has a restored O(2) symmetry. Implications for the finite-temperature phases, as well as the classical limit, of the HMF model are discussed.

arXiv:1909.05347•Physical review. E•Jan 31, 2020•2 citations

Spontaneous symmetry breaking and frustrated phases

Heitor Casasola, Carlos A. Hernaski, Pedro R. S. Gomes +1 more

We study a system involving a single quantum degree of freedom per site of the lattice interacting with a few neighbors (up to second neighbors), with the interactions chosen so as to produce frustration. At zero temperature, this system undergoes several quantum phase transitions from both gapped to gapless and gapless to gapless phases, providing a very rich phase structure with disordered, homogeneous, and modulated ordered phases meeting in a quantum Lifshitz point. The gapless phases spontaneously break spatial lattice translations as well as internal symmetries of the form U(1)^{N_{c}}, where N_{c} is the number of independent pitch vectors that arise in the homogeneous and modulated ordered phases. We carry out a detailed analysis of the quantum critical behavior, discussing the mechanism leading to the phase transitions. We also discuss a proper characterization of all the gapless phases as well as the nature of the Goldstone excitations. We study the behavior of the correlation functions and identify regions in the phase diagram where the system exhibits generalized symmetries such as polynomial shift symmetry. This type of symmetry plays an important role in the so-called fractonic phase, which is an exotic form of matter recently discovered.

arXiv:2105.08740•Physical review. E•Sep 23, 2021•2 citations
We discuss symmetry breaking quantum phase transitions on the oft studied Bethe lattice in the context of the ferromagnetic scalar spherical model or, equivalently, the infinite Nf{N}_{f}Nf​ limit of ferromagnetic models with O(Nf)O({N}_{f})O(Nf​) symmetry. We show that the approach to quantum criticality is characterized by the vanishing of a gap to just the global modes so that all local correlation functions continue to exhibit massive behavior. This behavior persists into the broken symmetry phase even as the order parameter develops an expectation value and thus there are no massless Goldstone bosons in the spectrum. We relate this feature to a spectral property of the graph Laplacian shared by the set of ``expander'' graphs, and argue that our results apply to symmetry breaking transitions on such graphs quite generally.
We investigate the coupled-top model, which describes two large spins interacting along both x and y directions. By tuning coupling strengths along distinct directions, the system exhibits different symmetries, ranging from a discrete Z2 to a continuous U(1) symmetry. The anisotropic coupled-top model displays a discrete Z2 symmetry, and the symmetry breaking induced by strong coupling drives a quantum phase transition from a disordered paramagnetic phase to an ordered ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic phase. In particular, the isotropic coupled-top model possesses a continuous U(1) symmetry, whose breaking gives rise to the Goldstone mode. The phase boundary can be well captured by the mean-field approach, characterized by the distinct behaviors of the order parameter. Higher-order quantum effects beyond the mean-field contribution can be achieved by mapping the large spins to bosonic operators via the Holstein–Primakoff transformation. For the anisotropic coupled-top model with Z2 symmetry, the energy gap closes, and both quantum fluctuations and entanglement entropy diverge near the critical point, signaling the onset of second-order quantum phase transitions. Strikingly, when U(1) symmetry is broken, the energy gap vanishes beyond the critical point, yielding a novel critical exponent of 1, rather than 1/2 for Z2 symmetry breaking. The rich symmetry structure of the coupled-top model underpins its role as a paradigmatic model for studying quantum phase transitions and exploring associated physical phenomena.
We investigate the critical behavior of a family of Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-symmetric scalar field theories on the Bethe lattice (the tree limit of regular hyperbolic tessellations) using both the non-perturbative Functional Renormalization Group and lattice perturbation theory. The family is indexed by the parameter ζ∈(0,1]ζ\in (0,1]ζ∈(0,1], which determines the range of the theory via the kinetic term constructed from the graph Laplacian raised to the power ζζζ. Specifically, ζ=1ζ=1ζ=1 is the short-range theory, while 0<ζ<10<ζ<10<ζ<1 defines the long-range model. Due to the hyperbolic nature of Bethe lattices, the Laplacian lacks a zero mode and exhibits a spectral gap. We find that upon closing this spectral gap by a modification of the Laplacian, the scalar field theories exhibit novel critical behavior in the form of non-trivial fixed points with critical exponents governed by ζζζ and the spectral dimension ds=3d_s=3ds​=3. In particular, our analysis indicates the presence of a Wilson-Fisher fixed point for the short range ζ=1ζ=1ζ=1 theory. In contrast, the nearest-neighbor Ising model on the Bethe lattice is known to exhibit mean-field critical exponents. To the best of our knowledge, this work provides the first evidence that a scalar ϕ4ϕ^4ϕ4 theory and the discrete Ising model on the same underlying lattice may lie in distinct universality classes.
Spectral properties for the two-dimensional quantum S=1 XY model were investigated with the exact diagonalization method. In the symmetry-broken phase, there appear the massive Higgs and massless Goldstone excitations, which correspond to the longitudinal and transverse modes of the spontaneous magnetic moment, respectively. The former excitation branch is embedded in the continuum of the latter, and little attention has been paid to the details, particularly, in proximity to the critical point. The finite-size-scaling behavior is improved by extending the interaction parameters. An analysis of the critical amplitude ratio for these mass gaps is made.
In accord with Nambu-Goldstone theorem spontaneous breaking of a global continuous symmetry of the system by a mean-field parameter causes appearance of massless Goldstone bosons, called also gapless Goldstone modes. It is demonstrated below that the theorem can be violated, i.e. the Goldstone modes possess finite gap, in the case of a novel (quantum ordered) state of interacting fermions, that was proposed recently {mukhin 2011}. This result may lead to the important consequences when considered in combination with another peculiar properties of the quantum parameter (QOP) that where recently found: QOP's Green's function is finite and periodic along the Matsubara's axis, but Wick-rotated to the axis of real frequencies, possesses infinite periodic chain of \it{second poles} along this axis {mukhin 2011}. This property of QOP leads to a remarkable physical consequence: \it{QOP does not scatter anything in Minkowski world} ! Hence, the present theory, we believe, may naturally indicate that two effects: hidden order revealed in ARPES spectra of fermi-excitations and neutron resonance feature at finite frequency in the magnetic (bosonic) excitations spectrum in lightly hole-doped copper oxides, could be emerging fingerprints of the Euclidian crystal state. A peculiar manifestation of the QOP self-consistent solution in the form of non-classical phonon states is described for an Euclidian predicted recently {mukhin,fistul 2013} in the array of Josephson junctions coupled via electromagnetic field in the superconducting resonator. It is demonstrated that it may constitute a stable state of the system, that, for a particular quantum disordering model, exists inside the stability domain of the classical photonic condensate delimited by the critical value of the quantum disordering strength.
It is widely believed that mean-field theory is exact for a wide range of classical long-range interacting systems. Is this also true once quantum fluctuations have been accounted for? As a test case we study the Hamiltonian mean-field (HMF) model for a system of bosons which is predicted (according to mean-field theory) to undergo a second-order quantum phase transition at zero temperature. The ordered phase is characterized by a spontaneously broken O(2) symmetry, which, despite occurring in a one-dimensional model, is not ruled out by the Mermin-Wagner theorem due to the presence of long-range interactions. Nevertheless, a spontaneously broken symmetry implies gapless Goldstone modes whose large fluctuations can restore broken symmetries. In this work we study the influence of quantum fluctuations by projecting the Hamiltonian onto the continuous subspace of symmetry-breaking mean-field states. We find that the energetic cost of gradients in the center-of-mass wave function inhibits the breaking of the O(2) symmetry, but that the energetic cost is very small, scaling as O(1/N^{2}). Nevertheless, for any finite N, no matter how large, this implies that the ground state has a restored O(2) symmetry. Implications for the finite-temperature phases, as well as the classical limit, of the HMF model are discussed.
We study a system involving a single quantum degree of freedom per site of the lattice interacting with a few neighbors (up to second neighbors), with the interactions chosen so as to produce frustration. At zero temperature, this system undergoes several quantum phase transitions from both gapped to gapless and gapless to gapless phases, providing a very rich phase structure with disordered, homogeneous, and modulated ordered phases meeting in a quantum Lifshitz point. The gapless phases spontaneously break spatial lattice translations as well as internal symmetries of the form U(1)^{N_{c}}, where N_{c} is the number of independent pitch vectors that arise in the homogeneous and modulated ordered phases. We carry out a detailed analysis of the quantum critical behavior, discussing the mechanism leading to the phase transitions. We also discuss a proper characterization of all the gapless phases as well as the nature of the Goldstone excitations. We study the behavior of the correlation functions and identify regions in the phase diagram where the system exhibits generalized symmetries such as polynomial shift symmetry. This type of symmetry plays an important role in the so-called fractonic phase, which is an exotic form of matter recently discovered.