Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.01961

Critical Phenomena on the Bethe Lattice

Rudrajit Banerjee, Nicolas Delporte, Saswato Sen, Reiko Toriumi

Published Jan 5, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the critical behavior of a family of $\mathbb{Z}_2$-symmetric scalar field theories on the Bethe lattice (the tree limit of regular hyperbolic tessellations) using both the non-perturbative Functional Renormalization Group and lattice perturbation theory. The family is indexed by the parameter $ζ\in (0,1]$, which determines the range of the theory via the kinetic term constructed from the graph Laplacian raised to the power $ζ$. Specifically, $ζ=1$ is the short-range theory, while $0<ζ<1$ defines the long-range model. Due to the hyperbolic nature of Bethe lattices, the Laplacian lacks a zero mode and exhibits a spectral gap. We find that upon closing this spectral gap by a modification of the Laplacian, the scalar field theories exhibit novel critical behavior in the form of non-trivial fixed points with critical exponents governed by $ζ$ and the spectral dimension $d_s=3$. In particular, our analysis indicates the presence of a Wilson-Fisher fixed point for the short range $ζ=1$ theory. In contrast, the nearest-neighbor Ising model on the Bethe lattice is known to exhibit mean-field critical exponents. To the best of our knowledge, this work provides the first evidence that a scalar $ϕ^4$ theory and the discrete Ising model on the same underlying lattice may lie in distinct universality classes.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2601.01961

Related papers

The long-range Ising CFT: perturbative and nonperturbative approaches

郑则川

The long-range Ising model is the prototype of criticality with power-law interactions. In each dimension its interacting critical points form a one-parameter family of nonlocal conformal field theories, weakly coupled at both ends but not in between. We study this family in one, two and three dimensions from several independent directions. We extend the expansion about the generalized free field from three to eight loops and expand about the short-range end. We show that Hamiltonian truncation applies to this nonlocal theory once a truncation artifact is corrected. Where they can be compared, the resummed expansions, Hamiltonian truncation, the numerical renormalization group and Monte Carlo simulations agree on the dimension of the leading $\mathbb{Z}_2$-even scalar at the sub-percent level, as universality requires.

arXiv:2610.25940•Oct 19, 2026•1 citation

Loop expansion around the Bethe approximation through the M -layer construction

Ada Altieri, Maria Chiara Angelini, Carlo Lucibello +3 more

Abstract For every physical model defined on a generic graph or factor graph, the Bethe M -layer construction allows building a different model for which the Bethe approximation is exact in the large M limit, and coincides with the original model for M = 1 . The 1 / M perturbative series is then expressed by a diagrammatic loop expansion in terms of so-called fat diagrams. Our motivation is to study some important second-order phase transitions that do exist on the Bethe lattice, but are either qualitatively different or absent in the corresponding fully connected case. In this case, the standard approach based on a perturbative expansion around the naive mean field theory (essentially a fully connected model) fails. On physical grounds, we expect that when the construction is applied to a lattice in finite dimension there is a small region of the external parameters, close to the Bethe critical point, where strong deviations from mean-field behavior will be observed. In this region, the 1 / M expansion for the corrections diverges, and can be the starting point for determining the correct non-mean-field critical exponents using renormalization group arguments. In the end, we will show that the critical series for the generic observable can be expressed as a sum of Feynman diagrams with the same numerical prefactors of field theories. However, the contribution of a given diagram is not evaluated by associating Gaussian propagators to its lines, as in field theories: one has to consider the graph as a portion of the original lattice, replacing the internal lines with appropriate one-dimensional chains, and attaching to the internal points the appropriate number of infinite-size Bethe trees to restore the correct local connectivity of the original model. The actual contribution of each (fat) diagram is the so-called line-connected observable, which also includes contributions from sub-diagrams with appropriate prefactors. In order to compute the corrections near to the critical point, Feynman diagrams (with their symmetry factors) can be read directly from the appropriate field-theoretical literature; the computation of momentum integrals is also quite similar; the extra work consists of computing the line-connected observable of the associated fat diagram in the limit of all lines becoming infinitely long.

arXiv:1707.08499•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Nov 1, 2017•31 citations

Quantum Ising transition on the Cayley tree: boundary criticality, universality, and an effective Bethe line

Pietro Richelli, Natalia Chepiga

We investigate quantum criticality in the transverse-field Ising model on finite Cayley trees and demonstrate that their extensive boundary fundamentally changes the nature of the quantum phase transition compared with the infinite, boundary-free Bethe lattice. Using tree tensor-network simulations for systems with up to $N=12286$ sites, we identify a boundary-driven continuous transition at $h_x^c\approx1.76$, distinct from the mean-field Bethe-lattice transition at $h_x^c\approx2.23$. We characterize this transition through finite-size scaling of the magnetization and magnetic susceptibility and extract a consistent set of critical exponents. By introducing next-nearest-neighbor interactions, we demonstrate the robustness of the extracted critical exponents, providing numerical argument for the Ising boundary universality class on the Cayley tree. Furthermore, we show that the physics of the boundary-free Bethe lattice can be efficiently recovered on a finite Cayley tree by fine-tuning a local boundary field. The resulting \textit{effective Bethe line}, whose existence is tied to the mean-field nature of the bulk transition, effectively screens the extensive boundary and restores both the critical point and the mean-field critical scaling of the infinite Bethe lattice.

arXiv:2610.16774•Oct 12, 2026•0 citations

Equivalent-neighbor percolation models in two dimensions: Crossover between mean-field and short-range behavior

Yunqing Ouyang, Youjin Deng, Henk W. J. Blöte

We investigate the influence of the range of interactions in the two-dimensional bond percolation model by means of Monte Carlo simulations. We locate the phase transitions for several interaction ranges, as expressed by the number $z$ of equivalent neighbors. We also consider the $z\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ limit, i.e., the complete graph case, where percolation bonds are allowed between each pair of sites, and the model becomes mean-field-like. All investigated models with finite $z$ are found to belong to the short-range universality class. There is no evidence of a tricritical point separating the short-range and long-range behavior, such as is known to occur for $q=3$ and $q=4$ Potts models. We determine the renormalization exponent describing a finite-range perturbation at the mean-field limit as ${y}_{r}\ensuremath{\approx}2/3$. Its relevance confirms the continuous crossover from mean-field percolation universality to short-range percolation universality. For finite interaction ranges, we find approximate relations between the coordination numbers and the amplitudes of the leading correction terms as found in the finite-size scaling analysis.

arXiv:1808.05812•Physical review. E•Dec 3, 2018•23 citations

Renormalization group domains of the scalar Hamiltonian

C. Bagnuls, Claude Bervillier

Using the local potential approximation of the exact renormalization group (RG) equation, we show the various domains of values of the parameters of the O(1)-symmetric scalar Hamiltonian. In three dimensions, in addition to the usual critical surface $S_{c}$ (attraction domain of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point), we explicitly show the existence of a first-order phase transition domain $S_{f}$ separated from $S_{c}$ by the tricritical surface $S_{t}$ (attraction domain of the Gaussian fixed point). $S_{f}$ and $S_{c}$ are two distinct domains of repulsion for the Gaussian fixed point, but $S_{f}$ is not the basin of attraction of a fixed point. $S_{f}$ is characterized by an endless renormalized trajectory lying entirely in the domain of negative values of the $\phi ^{4}$-coupling. This renormalized trajectory exists also in four dimensions making the Gaussian fixed point ultra-violet stable (and the $\phi_{4}^{4}$ renormalized field theory asymptotically free but with a wrong sign of the perfect action). We also show that very retarded classical-to-Ising crossover may exist in three dimensions (in fact below four dimensions). This could be an explanation of the unexpected classical critical behavior observed in some ionic systems.

arXiv:hep-th/0002254•Feb 29, 2000•9 citations

Critical behavior of the XY model in complex topologies

Miguel Ibáñez-Berganza, Luca Leuzzi

The critical behavior of the $O(2)$ model on dilute L\'evy graphs built on a two-dimensional square lattice is analyzed. Different qualitative cases are probed, varying the exponent $\ensuremath{\rho}$ governing the dependence on the distance of the connectivity probability distribution. The mean-field regime, as well as the long-range and short-range non-mean-field regimes, are investigated by means of high-performance parallel Monte Carlo numerical simulations running on GPUs. The relationship between the long-range $\ensuremath{\rho}$ exponent and the effective dimension of an equivalent short-range system with the same critical behavior is investigated. Evidence is provided for the effective short-range dimension to coincide with the spectral dimension of the L\'evy graph for the $\mathit{XY}$ model in the mean-field regime.

arXiv:1211.3991•Physical Review B•Oct 15, 2013•32 citations
We investigate the critical behavior of a family of Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-symmetric scalar field theories on the Bethe lattice (the tree limit of regular hyperbolic tessellations) using both the non-perturbative Functional Renormalization Group and lattice perturbation theory. The family is indexed by the parameter ζ∈(0,1]ζ\in (0,1]ζ∈(0,1], which determines the range of the theory via the kinetic term constructed from the graph Laplacian raised to the power ζζζ. Specifically, ζ=1ζ=1ζ=1 is the short-range theory, while 0<ζ<10<ζ<10<ζ<1 defines the long-range model. Due to the hyperbolic nature of Bethe lattices, the Laplacian lacks a zero mode and exhibits a spectral gap. We find that upon closing this spectral gap by a modification of the Laplacian, the scalar field theories exhibit novel critical behavior in the form of non-trivial fixed points with critical exponents governed by ζζζ and the spectral dimension ds=3d_s=3ds​=3. In particular, our analysis indicates the presence of a Wilson-Fisher fixed point for the short range ζ=1ζ=1ζ=1 theory. In contrast, the nearest-neighbor Ising model on the Bethe lattice is known to exhibit mean-field critical exponents. To the best of our knowledge, this work provides the first evidence that a scalar ϕ4ϕ^4ϕ4 theory and the discrete Ising model on the same underlying lattice may lie in distinct universality classes.
The long-range Ising model is the prototype of criticality with power-law interactions. In each dimension its interacting critical points form a one-parameter family of nonlocal conformal field theories, weakly coupled at both ends but not in between. We study this family in one, two and three dimensions from several independent directions. We extend the expansion about the generalized free field from three to eight loops and expand about the short-range end. We show that Hamiltonian truncation applies to this nonlocal theory once a truncation artifact is corrected. Where they can be compared, the resummed expansions, Hamiltonian truncation, the numerical renormalization group and Monte Carlo simulations agree on the dimension of the leading Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-even scalar at the sub-percent level, as universality requires.
Abstract For every physical model defined on a generic graph or factor graph, the Bethe M -layer construction allows building a different model for which the Bethe approximation is exact in the large M limit, and coincides with the original model for M = 1 . The 1 / M perturbative series is then expressed by a diagrammatic loop expansion in terms of so-called fat diagrams. Our motivation is to study some important second-order phase transitions that do exist on the Bethe lattice, but are either qualitatively different or absent in the corresponding fully connected case. In this case, the standard approach based on a perturbative expansion around the naive mean field theory (essentially a fully connected model) fails. On physical grounds, we expect that when the construction is applied to a lattice in finite dimension there is a small region of the external parameters, close to the Bethe critical point, where strong deviations from mean-field behavior will be observed. In this region, the 1 / M expansion for the corrections diverges, and can be the starting point for determining the correct non-mean-field critical exponents using renormalization group arguments. In the end, we will show that the critical series for the generic observable can be expressed as a sum of Feynman diagrams with the same numerical prefactors of field theories. However, the contribution of a given diagram is not evaluated by associating Gaussian propagators to its lines, as in field theories: one has to consider the graph as a portion of the original lattice, replacing the internal lines with appropriate one-dimensional chains, and attaching to the internal points the appropriate number of infinite-size Bethe trees to restore the correct local connectivity of the original model. The actual contribution of each (fat) diagram is the so-called line-connected observable, which also includes contributions from sub-diagrams with appropriate prefactors. In order to compute the corrections near to the critical point, Feynman diagrams (with their symmetry factors) can be read directly from the appropriate field-theoretical literature; the computation of momentum integrals is also quite similar; the extra work consists of computing the line-connected observable of the associated fat diagram in the limit of all lines becoming infinitely long.
We investigate quantum criticality in the transverse-field Ising model on finite Cayley trees and demonstrate that their extensive boundary fundamentally changes the nature of the quantum phase transition compared with the infinite, boundary-free Bethe lattice. Using tree tensor-network simulations for systems with up to N=12286N=12286N=12286 sites, we identify a boundary-driven continuous transition at hxc≈1.76h_x^c\approx1.76hxc​≈1.76, distinct from the mean-field Bethe-lattice transition at hxc≈2.23h_x^c\approx2.23hxc​≈2.23. We characterize this transition through finite-size scaling of the magnetization and magnetic susceptibility and extract a consistent set of critical exponents. By introducing next-nearest-neighbor interactions, we demonstrate the robustness of the extracted critical exponents, providing numerical argument for the Ising boundary universality class on the Cayley tree. Furthermore, we show that the physics of the boundary-free Bethe lattice can be efficiently recovered on a finite Cayley tree by fine-tuning a local boundary field. The resulting \textit{effective Bethe line}, whose existence is tied to the mean-field nature of the bulk transition, effectively screens the extensive boundary and restores both the critical point and the mean-field critical scaling of the infinite Bethe lattice.
We investigate the influence of the range of interactions in the two-dimensional bond percolation model by means of Monte Carlo simulations. We locate the phase transitions for several interaction ranges, as expressed by the number zzz of equivalent neighbors. We also consider the $z\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ limit, i.e., the complete graph case, where percolation bonds are allowed between each pair of sites, and the model becomes mean-field-like. All investigated models with finite zzz are found to belong to the short-range universality class. There is no evidence of a tricritical point separating the short-range and long-range behavior, such as is known to occur for q=3q=3q=3 and q=4q=4q=4 Potts models. We determine the renormalization exponent describing a finite-range perturbation at the mean-field limit as ${y}_{r}\ensuremath{\approx}2/3$. Its relevance confirms the continuous crossover from mean-field percolation universality to short-range percolation universality. For finite interaction ranges, we find approximate relations between the coordination numbers and the amplitudes of the leading correction terms as found in the finite-size scaling analysis.
Using the local potential approximation of the exact renormalization group (RG) equation, we show the various domains of values of the parameters of the O(1)-symmetric scalar Hamiltonian. In three dimensions, in addition to the usual critical surface ScS_{c}Sc​ (attraction domain of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point), we explicitly show the existence of a first-order phase transition domain SfS_{f}Sf​ separated from ScS_{c}Sc​ by the tricritical surface StS_{t}St​ (attraction domain of the Gaussian fixed point). SfS_{f}Sf​ and ScS_{c}Sc​ are two distinct domains of repulsion for the Gaussian fixed point, but SfS_{f}Sf​ is not the basin of attraction of a fixed point. SfS_{f}Sf​ is characterized by an endless renormalized trajectory lying entirely in the domain of negative values of the ϕ4\phi ^{4}ϕ4-coupling. This renormalized trajectory exists also in four dimensions making the Gaussian fixed point ultra-violet stable (and the ϕ44\phi_{4}^{4}ϕ44​ renormalized field theory asymptotically free but with a wrong sign of the perfect action). We also show that very retarded classical-to-Ising crossover may exist in three dimensions (in fact below four dimensions). This could be an explanation of the unexpected classical critical behavior observed in some ionic systems.
The critical behavior of the O(2)O(2)O(2) model on dilute L\'evy graphs built on a two-dimensional square lattice is analyzed. Different qualitative cases are probed, varying the exponent $\ensuremath{\rho}$ governing the dependence on the distance of the connectivity probability distribution. The mean-field regime, as well as the long-range and short-range non-mean-field regimes, are investigated by means of high-performance parallel Monte Carlo numerical simulations running on GPUs. The relationship between the long-range $\ensuremath{\rho}$ exponent and the effective dimension of an equivalent short-range system with the same critical behavior is investigated. Evidence is provided for the effective short-range dimension to coincide with the spectral dimension of the L\'evy graph for the XY\mathit{XY}XY model in the mean-field regime.