Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0904.3390 · Physical Review A

Quantification of nonclassicality

C. Gehrke, Jan Sperling, W. Vogel

Published Nov 26, 2012• 75 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

To quantify single-mode nonclassicality, we start from an operational approach. A positive semidefinite observable is introduced to describe a measurement setup. The quantification is based on the negativity of the normally ordered version of this observable. Perfect operational quantumness corresponds to the quantum-noise-free measurement of the chosen observable. Surprisingly, even moderately squeezed states may exhibit perfect quantumness for a properly designed measurement. The quantification is also considered from an axiomatic viewpoint, based on the algebraic structure of the quantum states and the quantum superposition principle. Basic conclusions from both approaches are consistent with this fundamental principle of the quantum world.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.86.052118

Related papers

Unified quantification of nonclassicality and entanglement

W. Vogel, Jan Sperling

The nonclassicality of single-mode quantum states is studied in relation to the entanglement created by a beam splitter. It is shown that properly defined quantifications---based on the quantum superposition principle---of the amounts of nonclassicality and entanglement are strictly related to each other. This can be generalized to the amount of genuine multipartite entanglement, created from a nonclassical state by an $N$ splitter. As a consequence, a single-mode state of a given amount of nonclassicality is fully equivalent, as a resource, to exactly the same amount of entanglement. This relation is also considered in the context of multipartite entanglement and multimode nonclassicality.

arXiv:1401.5222•Physical Review A•May 7, 2014•171 citations

Quantum non-Gaussianity and quantification of nonclassicality

B. Kühn, W. Vogel

The algebraic quantification of nonclassicality, which naturally arises from the quantum superposition principle, is related to properties of regular nonclassicality quasiprobabilities. The latter are obtained by non-Gaussian filtering of the Glauber-Sudarshan $P$ function. They yield lower bounds for the degree of nonclassicality. We also derive bounds for convex combinations of Gaussian states for certifying quantum non-Gaussianity directly from the experimentally accessible nonclassicality quasiprobabilities. Other quantum-state representations, such as $s$-parametrized quasiprobabilities, insufficiently indicate or even fail to directly uncover detailed information on the properties of quantum states. As an example, our approach is applied to multi-photon-added squeezed vacuum states.

arXiv:1803.03133•Physical Review A•May 17, 2018•32 citations

Quantum states as observables: Their variance and nonclassicality

Yue Zhang, Shunlong Luo

Two basic ingredients in the quantum formalism are the concepts of states and observables, and apart from the average value (which includes the Born probability as a paramountly important case), the variance is the most fundamental and prominent quantity arising from the coupling of a state and an observable. Given the simplicity and ubiquity of the variance, it seems surprising that we can still exploit the variance to gain conceptually different insight into the quantum substratum. The purpose of the present work is to advocate the following idea: By inputting a general quantum state as the observable in the variance and incorporating a resolution of identity induced by coherent states, we obtain a mathematically simple and physically intuitive method for quantifying nonclassicality. We reveal its fundamental properties and highlight its connection with phase-space quantification of nonclassicality. The idea further suggests a whole family of appealing quantifiers of nonclassicality involving deep mathematical subtlety and an intriguing conjecture with physical significance. Some prototypical examples are worked out to illustrate the concept. This approach of regarding states as observables presents an opportunity for investigating quantum features from an alternative perspective of uncertainty.

Physical Review A•Dec 17, 2020•27 citations

Convex ordering and quantification of quantumness

Jan Sperling, W Vogel

Abstract The characterization of physical systems requires a comprehensive understanding of quantum effects. One aspect is a proper quantification of the strength of such quantum phenomena. Here, a general convex ordering of quantum states will be introduced which is based on the algebraic definition of classical states. This definition resolves the ambiguity of the quantumness quantification using topological distance measures. Classical operations on quantum states will be considered to further generalize the ordering prescription. Our technique can be used for a natural and unambiguous quantification of general quantum properties whose classical reference has a convex structure. We apply this method to typical scenarios in quantum optics and quantum information theory to study measures which are based on the fundamental quantum superposition principle.

arXiv:1004.1944•Physica Scripta•Jun 1, 2015•80 citations

Statistical mixtures of states can be more quantum than their superpositions: Comparison of nonclassicality measures for single-qubit states

Adam Miranowicz, Karol Bartkiewicz, Anirban Pathak +3 more

A bosonic state is commonly considered nonclassical (or quantum) if its Glauber-Sudarshan $P$ function is not a classical probability density, which implies that only coherent states and their statistical mixtures are classical. We quantify the nonclassicality of a single qubit, defined by the vacuum and single-photon states, by applying the following four well-known measures of nonclassicality: (1) the nonclassical depth, $\ensuremath{\tau}$, related to the minimal amount of Gaussian noise which changes a nonpositive $P$ function into a positive one; (2) the nonclassical distance $D$, defined as the Bures distance of a given state to the closest classical state, which is the vacuum for the single-qubit Hilbert space; together with (3) the negativity potential (NP), and (4) concurrence potential, which are the nonclassicality measures corresponding to the entanglement measures (i.e., the negativity and concurrence, respectively) for the state generated by mixing a single-qubit state with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We show that complete statistical mixtures of the vacuum and single-photon states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states regarding the distance $D$ for a fixed value of both the depth $\ensuremath{\tau}$ and NP in the whole range $[0,1]$ of their values, as well as the NP for a given value of $\ensuremath{\tau}$ such that $\ensuremath{\tau}>0.315\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}4$. Conversely, pure states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states with respect to $\ensuremath{\tau}$ for a given $D$, NP versus $D$, and $\ensuremath{\tau}$ versus NP. We also show the ``relativity'' of these nonclassicality measures by comparing pairs of single-qubit states: if a state is less nonclassical than another state according to some measure then it might be more nonclassical according to another measure. Moreover, we find that the concurrence potential is equal to the nonclassical distance for single-qubit states. This implies an operational interpretation of the nonclassical distance as the potential for the entanglement of formation.

arXiv:1502.04523•Physical Review A•Apr 8, 2015•69 citations

Wehrl-entropy-based quantification of nonclassicality for single-mode quantum optical states

Soumyakanti Bose

Abstract Nonclassical states of a quantized light are described in terms of Glauber–Sudarshan distribution, which is not a genuine classical probability distribution. Despite several attempts, defining a uniform measure of nonclassicality (NC) for the single-mode quantum states of light remains an open task. In our previous work Bose and Sanjay Kumar (2017 Phys. Rev . A 95 012330), we have shown that the existing well-known measures fail to quantify the NC of single-mode states that are generated under multiple NC-inducing operations. In this paper, we propose a new quantification of NC for the single-mode quantum states as the difference between the total Wehrl entropy of the state and the maximum Wehrl entropy arising due to its classical characteristics. The classical reference state is chosen at the same randomness, given by the von-Neumann entropy, as the state itself. We further suggest operational interpretation of the proposed measure in terms of phase-space sampling entropy, as well as potential to generate entanglement in the case of pure states. We obtain analytic expressions of NC for pure states and Gaussian mixed states. We show that, along with the states generated under single NC-inducing operations as well as the broader class of states that are generated under multiple NC-inducing operations, our quantification enumerates the NC consistently. However, the evaluation of NC for the non-Gaussian mixed states is subject to extensive numerical computation that lies beyond the scope of the current work. We finally conclude with certain open questions.

arXiv:1701.00064•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 6, 2018•9 citations
To quantify single-mode nonclassicality, we start from an operational approach. A positive semidefinite observable is introduced to describe a measurement setup. The quantification is based on the negativity of the normally ordered version of this observable. Perfect operational quantumness corresponds to the quantum-noise-free measurement of the chosen observable. Surprisingly, even moderately squeezed states may exhibit perfect quantumness for a properly designed measurement. The quantification is also considered from an axiomatic viewpoint, based on the algebraic structure of the quantum states and the quantum superposition principle. Basic conclusions from both approaches are consistent with this fundamental principle of the quantum world.
The nonclassicality of single-mode quantum states is studied in relation to the entanglement created by a beam splitter. It is shown that properly defined quantifications---based on the quantum superposition principle---of the amounts of nonclassicality and entanglement are strictly related to each other. This can be generalized to the amount of genuine multipartite entanglement, created from a nonclassical state by an NNN splitter. As a consequence, a single-mode state of a given amount of nonclassicality is fully equivalent, as a resource, to exactly the same amount of entanglement. This relation is also considered in the context of multipartite entanglement and multimode nonclassicality.
The algebraic quantification of nonclassicality, which naturally arises from the quantum superposition principle, is related to properties of regular nonclassicality quasiprobabilities. The latter are obtained by non-Gaussian filtering of the Glauber-Sudarshan PPP function. They yield lower bounds for the degree of nonclassicality. We also derive bounds for convex combinations of Gaussian states for certifying quantum non-Gaussianity directly from the experimentally accessible nonclassicality quasiprobabilities. Other quantum-state representations, such as sss-parametrized quasiprobabilities, insufficiently indicate or even fail to directly uncover detailed information on the properties of quantum states. As an example, our approach is applied to multi-photon-added squeezed vacuum states.
Two basic ingredients in the quantum formalism are the concepts of states and observables, and apart from the average value (which includes the Born probability as a paramountly important case), the variance is the most fundamental and prominent quantity arising from the coupling of a state and an observable. Given the simplicity and ubiquity of the variance, it seems surprising that we can still exploit the variance to gain conceptually different insight into the quantum substratum. The purpose of the present work is to advocate the following idea: By inputting a general quantum state as the observable in the variance and incorporating a resolution of identity induced by coherent states, we obtain a mathematically simple and physically intuitive method for quantifying nonclassicality. We reveal its fundamental properties and highlight its connection with phase-space quantification of nonclassicality. The idea further suggests a whole family of appealing quantifiers of nonclassicality involving deep mathematical subtlety and an intriguing conjecture with physical significance. Some prototypical examples are worked out to illustrate the concept. This approach of regarding states as observables presents an opportunity for investigating quantum features from an alternative perspective of uncertainty.
Abstract The characterization of physical systems requires a comprehensive understanding of quantum effects. One aspect is a proper quantification of the strength of such quantum phenomena. Here, a general convex ordering of quantum states will be introduced which is based on the algebraic definition of classical states. This definition resolves the ambiguity of the quantumness quantification using topological distance measures. Classical operations on quantum states will be considered to further generalize the ordering prescription. Our technique can be used for a natural and unambiguous quantification of general quantum properties whose classical reference has a convex structure. We apply this method to typical scenarios in quantum optics and quantum information theory to study measures which are based on the fundamental quantum superposition principle.
A bosonic state is commonly considered nonclassical (or quantum) if its Glauber-Sudarshan PPP function is not a classical probability density, which implies that only coherent states and their statistical mixtures are classical. We quantify the nonclassicality of a single qubit, defined by the vacuum and single-photon states, by applying the following four well-known measures of nonclassicality: (1) the nonclassical depth, $\ensuremath{\tau}$, related to the minimal amount of Gaussian noise which changes a nonpositive PPP function into a positive one; (2) the nonclassical distance DDD, defined as the Bures distance of a given state to the closest classical state, which is the vacuum for the single-qubit Hilbert space; together with (3) the negativity potential (NP), and (4) concurrence potential, which are the nonclassicality measures corresponding to the entanglement measures (i.e., the negativity and concurrence, respectively) for the state generated by mixing a single-qubit state with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We show that complete statistical mixtures of the vacuum and single-photon states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states regarding the distance DDD for a fixed value of both the depth $\ensuremath{\tau}$ and NP in the whole range [0,1][0,1][0,1] of their values, as well as the NP for a given value of $\ensuremath{\tau}$ such that $\ensuremath{\tau}>0.315\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}4$. Conversely, pure states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states with respect to $\ensuremath{\tau}$ for a given DDD, NP versus DDD, and $\ensuremath{\tau}$ versus NP. We also show the ``relativity'' of these nonclassicality measures by comparing pairs of single-qubit states: if a state is less nonclassical than another state according to some measure then it might be more nonclassical according to another measure. Moreover, we find that the concurrence potential is equal to the nonclassical distance for single-qubit states. This implies an operational interpretation of the nonclassical distance as the potential for the entanglement of formation.
Abstract Nonclassical states of a quantized light are described in terms of Glauber–Sudarshan distribution, which is not a genuine classical probability distribution. Despite several attempts, defining a uniform measure of nonclassicality (NC) for the single-mode quantum states of light remains an open task. In our previous work Bose and Sanjay Kumar (2017 Phys. Rev . A 95 012330), we have shown that the existing well-known measures fail to quantify the NC of single-mode states that are generated under multiple NC-inducing operations. In this paper, we propose a new quantification of NC for the single-mode quantum states as the difference between the total Wehrl entropy of the state and the maximum Wehrl entropy arising due to its classical characteristics. The classical reference state is chosen at the same randomness, given by the von-Neumann entropy, as the state itself. We further suggest operational interpretation of the proposed measure in terms of phase-space sampling entropy, as well as potential to generate entanglement in the case of pure states. We obtain analytic expressions of NC for pure states and Gaussian mixed states. We show that, along with the states generated under single NC-inducing operations as well as the broader class of states that are generated under multiple NC-inducing operations, our quantification enumerates the NC consistently. However, the evaluation of NC for the non-Gaussian mixed states is subject to extensive numerical computation that lies beyond the scope of the current work. We finally conclude with certain open questions.