Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1502.04523 · Physical Review A

Statistical mixtures of states can be more quantum than their superpositions: Comparison of nonclassicality measures for single-qubit states

Adam Miranowicz, Karol Bartkiewicz, Anirban Pathak, Jan Peřina, Yueh-Nan Chen, Franco Nori

Published Apr 8, 2015• 69 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A bosonic state is commonly considered nonclassical (or quantum) if its Glauber-Sudarshan $P$ function is not a classical probability density, which implies that only coherent states and their statistical mixtures are classical. We quantify the nonclassicality of a single qubit, defined by the vacuum and single-photon states, by applying the following four well-known measures of nonclassicality: (1) the nonclassical depth, $\ensuremath{\tau}$, related to the minimal amount of Gaussian noise which changes a nonpositive $P$ function into a positive one; (2) the nonclassical distance $D$, defined as the Bures distance of a given state to the closest classical state, which is the vacuum for the single-qubit Hilbert space; together with (3) the negativity potential (NP), and (4) concurrence potential, which are the nonclassicality measures corresponding to the entanglement measures (i.e., the negativity and concurrence, respectively) for the state generated by mixing a single-qubit state with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We show that complete statistical mixtures of the vacuum and single-photon states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states regarding the distance $D$ for a fixed value of both the depth $\ensuremath{\tau}$ and NP in the whole range $[0,1]$ of their values, as well as the NP for a given value of $\ensuremath{\tau}$ such that $\ensuremath{\tau}>0.315\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}4$. Conversely, pure states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states with respect to $\ensuremath{\tau}$ for a given $D$, NP versus $D$, and $\ensuremath{\tau}$ versus NP. We also show the ``relativity'' of these nonclassicality measures by comparing pairs of single-qubit states: if a state is less nonclassical than another state according to some measure then it might be more nonclassical according to another measure. Moreover, we find that the concurrence potential is equal to the nonclassical distance for single-qubit states. This implies an operational interpretation of the nonclassical distance as the potential for the entanglement of formation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.91.042309

Related papers

Increasing relative nonclassicality quantified by standard entanglement potentials by dissipation and unbalanced beam splitting

Adam Miranowicz, Karol Bartkiewicz, Neill Lambert +2 more

If a single-mode nonclassical light is combined with the vacuum on a beam splitter, then the output state is entangled. As proposed in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 173602 (2005)], by measuring this output-state entanglement for a balanced lossless beam splitter, one can quantify the input-state nonclassicality. These measures of nonclassicality (referred to as entanglement potentials) can be based, in principle, on various entanglement measures, leading to the negativity (NP) and concurrence (CP) potentials, and the potential for the relative entropy of entanglement (REEP). We search for the maximal relative nonclassicality, which can be achieved by comparing two entanglement measures for (i) arbitrary two-qubit states and (ii) those which can be generated from a photon-number qubit via a balanced lossless beam splitter, where the qubit basis states are the vacuum and single-photon states. Surprisingly, we find that the maximal relative nonclassicality, measured by the REEP for a given value of the NP, can be increased (if $\mathrm{NP}<0.527$) by using either a tunable beam splitter or by amplitude damping of the output state of the balanced beam splitter. We also show that the maximal relative nonclassicality, measured by the NP for a given value of the REEP, can be increased by phase damping (dephasing). Note that the entanglement itself is not increased by these losses (since they act locally), but the possible ratios of different measures are affected. Moreover, we show that partially dephased states can be more nonclassical than both pure states and completely dephased states, by comparing the NP for a given value of the REEP. Thus, one can conclude that not all standard entanglement measures can be used as entanglement potentials. Alternatively, one can infer that a single balanced lossless beam splitter is not always transferring the whole nonclassicality of its input state into the entanglement of its output modes. The application of a lossy beam splitter can solve this problem, at least for the cases analyzed in this paper.

arXiv:1507.08587•Physical Review A•Dec 8, 2015•42 citations

Nonclassical character of statistical mixtures of the single-photon and vacuum optical states

Alexander I. Lvovsky, Jeffrey H. Shapiro

We demonstrate, theoretically and experimentally, that statistical mixtures of the vacuum state $|0〉$ and the single-photon Fock state $|1〉$ are nonclassical according to the Vogel criterion [W. Vogel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1849 (2000)], regardless of the vacuum fraction. The ensembles are synthesized via conditional measurements on biphotons generated by means of parametric down conversion, and their quadrature statistics are measured using balanced homodyne detection. A comparative review of various quantum state nonclassicality criteria is presented.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109057•Physical Review A•Feb 28, 2002•79 citations

Quantifying nonclassicality of vacuum-one-photon superpositions via potentials for Bell nonlocality, quantum steering, and entanglement

Adam Miranowicz, Josef Kadlec, Karol Bartkiewicz +4 more

Entanglement potentials are popular measures of the nonclassicality of single-mode optical fields. These potentials are defined by the amount of entanglement (measured by, e.g., the negativity or concurrence) of the two-mode field generated by mixing a given single-mode field with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We generalize this concept to define the potentials for Bell nonlocality and quantum steering in specific measurement scenarios, in order to quantify single-mode nonclassicality in a more refined way. Thus, we can study the hierarchy of three types of potentials in close analogy to the well-known hierarchy of the corresponding two-mode quantum correlations. For clarity of our presentation, we focus on the analysis of the nonclassicality potentials for arbitrary vacuum-one-photon superpositions (VOPSs), corresponding to a photon-number qubit. We discuss experimentally feasible implementations for the generation of single-mode VOPS states, their mixing with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter, and their two-mode Wigner-function reconstruction using homodyne tomography to determine the potentials. We analyze the effects of imperfections, including phase damping and unbalanced beam splitting on the quality of the reconstructed two-mode states and nonclassicality potentials. Although we focus on the analysis of VOPS states, single-mode potentials can also be applied to study the nonclassicality of qudits or continuous-variable systems.

arXiv:2309.12930•Sep 22, 2023•7 citations

Single- and two-mode quantumness at a beam splitter

Matteo Brunelli, Claudia Benedetti, Stefano Olivares +2 more

In the context of bipartite bosonic systems, two notions of classicality of correlations can be defined: $P$ classicality, based on the properties of the Glauber-Sudarshan $P$ function; and $C$ classicality, based on the entropic quantum discord. It has been shown that these two notions are maximally inequivalent in a static (metric) sense, as they coincide only on a set of states of zero measure. We extend and reinforce quantitatively this inequivalence by addressing the dynamical relation between these types of nonclassicality in a paradigmatic quantum-optical setting: the linear mixing at a beam splitter of a single-mode Gaussian state with a thermal reference state. Specifically, we show that almost all $P$-classical input states generate outputs that are not $C$ classical. Indeed, for the case of zero thermal reference photons, the more $P$-classical resources at the input the less $C$ classicality at the output. In addition, we show that the $P$ classicality at the input---as quantified by the nonclassical depth---does instead determine quantitatively the potential of generating output entanglement. This endows the nonclassical depth with a new operational interpretation: it gives the maximum number of thermal reference photons that can be mixed at a beam splitter without destroying the output entanglement.

arXiv:1502.04996•Physical Review A•Jun 11, 2015•30 citations

Nonclassicality measures of single-mode quantum states

Adélcio C. Oliveira

What is the most effective metric for quantifying the nonclassical characteristics of an individual quantum state? Our answer to this question is that it depends on what will be used for. Here we present some of the most widely used measures, as well as some promising ones. In this discussion, we analyze the question and ultimately determine that there is no singular superior metric. However, a mix of measures can provide a comprehensive understanding of the situation. Each measure has a potential application, some can be classified as a general nonclassicality measure, while others are dedicated measures. Some measures have a practical physical meaning, while others are justified by the results. We show that the negativity of the Wigner function, Mandel’s Q parameter and Hilbert–Schmidt distance are good dedicated measures, while Roughness is a general one, like Skewness in this case for pure states.

International Journal of Quantum Information•Mar 6, 2025•3 citations

Experimental hierarchy of the nonclassicality of single-qubit states via potentials for entanglement, steering, and Bell nonlocality

Josef Kadlec, Karol Bartkiewicz, Antonín Černoch +2 more

Entanglement potentials are a promising way to quantify the nonclassicality of single-mode states. They are defined by the amount of entanglement (expressed by, e.g., the Wootters concurrence) obtained after mixing the examined single-mode state with a purely classical state; such as the vacuum or a coherent state. We generalize the idea of entanglement potentials to other quantum correlations: the EPR steering and Bell nonlocality, thus enabling us to study mutual hierarchies of these nonclassicality potentials. Instead of the usual vacuum and one-photon superposition states, we experimentally test this concept using specially tailored polarization-encoded single-photon states. One polarization encodes a given nonclassical single-mode state, while the other serves as the vacuum place-holder. This technique proves to be experimentally more convenient in comparison to the vacuum and a one-photon superposition as it does not require the vacuum detection.

arXiv:2309.12878•Optics Express•Nov 17, 2023•11 citations
A bosonic state is commonly considered nonclassical (or quantum) if its Glauber-Sudarshan PPP function is not a classical probability density, which implies that only coherent states and their statistical mixtures are classical. We quantify the nonclassicality of a single qubit, defined by the vacuum and single-photon states, by applying the following four well-known measures of nonclassicality: (1) the nonclassical depth, \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ, related to the minimal amount of Gaussian noise which changes a nonpositive PPP function into a positive one; (2) the nonclassical distance DDD, defined as the Bures distance of a given state to the closest classical state, which is the vacuum for the single-qubit Hilbert space; together with (3) the negativity potential (NP), and (4) concurrence potential, which are the nonclassicality measures corresponding to the entanglement measures (i.e., the negativity and concurrence, respectively) for the state generated by mixing a single-qubit state with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We show that complete statistical mixtures of the vacuum and single-photon states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states regarding the distance DDD for a fixed value of both the depth \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ and NP in the whole range [0,1][0,1][0,1] of their values, as well as the NP for a given value of \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ such that \ensuremathτ>0.3154\ensuremath{\tau}>0.315\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}4\ensuremathτ>0.3154. Conversely, pure states are the most nonclassical single-qubit states with respect to \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ for a given DDD, NP versus DDD, and \ensuremathτ\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremathτ versus NP. We also show the ``relativity'' of these nonclassicality measures by comparing pairs of single-qubit states: if a state is less nonclassical than another state according to some measure then it might be more nonclassical according to another measure. Moreover, we find that the concurrence potential is equal to the nonclassical distance for single-qubit states. This implies an operational interpretation of the nonclassical distance as the potential for the entanglement of formation.
If a single-mode nonclassical light is combined with the vacuum on a beam splitter, then the output state is entangled. As proposed in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 173602 (2005)], by measuring this output-state entanglement for a balanced lossless beam splitter, one can quantify the input-state nonclassicality. These measures of nonclassicality (referred to as entanglement potentials) can be based, in principle, on various entanglement measures, leading to the negativity (NP) and concurrence (CP) potentials, and the potential for the relative entropy of entanglement (REEP). We search for the maximal relative nonclassicality, which can be achieved by comparing two entanglement measures for (i) arbitrary two-qubit states and (ii) those which can be generated from a photon-number qubit via a balanced lossless beam splitter, where the qubit basis states are the vacuum and single-photon states. Surprisingly, we find that the maximal relative nonclassicality, measured by the REEP for a given value of the NP, can be increased (if NP<0.527\mathrm{NP}<0.527NP<0.527) by using either a tunable beam splitter or by amplitude damping of the output state of the balanced beam splitter. We also show that the maximal relative nonclassicality, measured by the NP for a given value of the REEP, can be increased by phase damping (dephasing). Note that the entanglement itself is not increased by these losses (since they act locally), but the possible ratios of different measures are affected. Moreover, we show that partially dephased states can be more nonclassical than both pure states and completely dephased states, by comparing the NP for a given value of the REEP. Thus, one can conclude that not all standard entanglement measures can be used as entanglement potentials. Alternatively, one can infer that a single balanced lossless beam splitter is not always transferring the whole nonclassicality of its input state into the entanglement of its output modes. The application of a lossy beam splitter can solve this problem, at least for the cases analyzed in this paper.
We demonstrate, theoretically and experimentally, that statistical mixtures of the vacuum state ∣0〉|0〉∣0〉 and the single-photon Fock state ∣1〉|1〉∣1〉 are nonclassical according to the Vogel criterion [W. Vogel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1849 (2000)], regardless of the vacuum fraction. The ensembles are synthesized via conditional measurements on biphotons generated by means of parametric down conversion, and their quadrature statistics are measured using balanced homodyne detection. A comparative review of various quantum state nonclassicality criteria is presented.
Entanglement potentials are popular measures of the nonclassicality of single-mode optical fields. These potentials are defined by the amount of entanglement (measured by, e.g., the negativity or concurrence) of the two-mode field generated by mixing a given single-mode field with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter. We generalize this concept to define the potentials for Bell nonlocality and quantum steering in specific measurement scenarios, in order to quantify single-mode nonclassicality in a more refined way. Thus, we can study the hierarchy of three types of potentials in close analogy to the well-known hierarchy of the corresponding two-mode quantum correlations. For clarity of our presentation, we focus on the analysis of the nonclassicality potentials for arbitrary vacuum-one-photon superpositions (VOPSs), corresponding to a photon-number qubit. We discuss experimentally feasible implementations for the generation of single-mode VOPS states, their mixing with the vacuum on a balanced beam splitter, and their two-mode Wigner-function reconstruction using homodyne tomography to determine the potentials. We analyze the effects of imperfections, including phase damping and unbalanced beam splitting on the quality of the reconstructed two-mode states and nonclassicality potentials. Although we focus on the analysis of VOPS states, single-mode potentials can also be applied to study the nonclassicality of qudits or continuous-variable systems.
In the context of bipartite bosonic systems, two notions of classicality of correlations can be defined: PPP classicality, based on the properties of the Glauber-Sudarshan PPP function; and CCC classicality, based on the entropic quantum discord. It has been shown that these two notions are maximally inequivalent in a static (metric) sense, as they coincide only on a set of states of zero measure. We extend and reinforce quantitatively this inequivalence by addressing the dynamical relation between these types of nonclassicality in a paradigmatic quantum-optical setting: the linear mixing at a beam splitter of a single-mode Gaussian state with a thermal reference state. Specifically, we show that almost all PPP-classical input states generate outputs that are not CCC classical. Indeed, for the case of zero thermal reference photons, the more PPP-classical resources at the input the less CCC classicality at the output. In addition, we show that the PPP classicality at the input---as quantified by the nonclassical depth---does instead determine quantitatively the potential of generating output entanglement. This endows the nonclassical depth with a new operational interpretation: it gives the maximum number of thermal reference photons that can be mixed at a beam splitter without destroying the output entanglement.
What is the most effective metric for quantifying the nonclassical characteristics of an individual quantum state? Our answer to this question is that it depends on what will be used for. Here we present some of the most widely used measures, as well as some promising ones. In this discussion, we analyze the question and ultimately determine that there is no singular superior metric. However, a mix of measures can provide a comprehensive understanding of the situation. Each measure has a potential application, some can be classified as a general nonclassicality measure, while others are dedicated measures. Some measures have a practical physical meaning, while others are justified by the results. We show that the negativity of the Wigner function, Mandel’s Q parameter and Hilbert–Schmidt distance are good dedicated measures, while Roughness is a general one, like Skewness in this case for pure states.
Entanglement potentials are a promising way to quantify the nonclassicality of single-mode states. They are defined by the amount of entanglement (expressed by, e.g., the Wootters concurrence) obtained after mixing the examined single-mode state with a purely classical state; such as the vacuum or a coherent state. We generalize the idea of entanglement potentials to other quantum correlations: the EPR steering and Bell nonlocality, thus enabling us to study mutual hierarchies of these nonclassicality potentials. Instead of the usual vacuum and one-photon superposition states, we experimentally test this concept using specially tailored polarization-encoded single-photon states. One polarization encodes a given nonclassical single-mode state, while the other serves as the vacuum place-holder. This technique proves to be experimentally more convenient in comparison to the vacuum and a one-photon superposition as it does not require the vacuum detection.