Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0812.4061 · Physical Review A

Physical qubits from charged particles: Infrared divergences in quantum information

Juan León, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

Published May 12, 2009• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider soft-photon effects (ir structure of QED) on the construction of physical qubits. Soft photons appear when we build charged qubits from the asymptotic states of QED. This construction is necessary in order to include the effect of soft photons on entanglement measures. The nonexistence of free charged particles (due to the long range of QED interactions) leads us to question the sense of the very concept of free charged qubit. In this work, using the ``dressing'' formalism, we build physical charged qubits from dressed fields which have the correct asymptotic behavior, are gauge invariant, have propagators with a particle pole structure, and are free from infrared divergences. Finally, we discuss the impact of the soft corrections on the entanglement measures.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.79.052309

Related papers

IR dynamics and entanglement entropy

Theodore N. Tomaras, Nicolaos Toumbas

We consider scattering of Faddeev-Kulish electrons in QED and study the entanglement between the hard and soft particles in the final state at the perturbative level. The soft photon spectrum naturally splits into two parts: (i) soft photons with energies less than a characteristic infrared scale ${E}_{d}$ present in the clouds accompanying the asymptotic charged particles, and (ii) sufficiently low energy photons with energies greater than ${E}_{d}$, comprising the soft part of the emitted radiation. We construct the density matrix associated with tracing over the radiative soft photons and calculate the entanglement entropy perturbatively. We find that the entanglement entropy is free of any infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory. On the other hand, infrared divergences in the perturbative expansion for the entanglement entropy appear upon tracing over the entire spectrum of soft photons, including those in the clouds. To leading order the entanglement entropy is set by the square of the Fock basis amplitude for real single soft photon emission, which leads to a logarithmic infrared divergence when integrated over the photon momentum. We argue that the infrared divergences in the entanglement entropy (per particle flux per unit time) in this latter case persist to all orders in perturbation theory in the infinite volume limit.

arXiv:1910.07847•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 16, 2020•25 citations

On the classical limit and the infrared problem for non-relativistic fermions interacting with the electromagnetic field

F. Ruiz Ruiz, R. F. Álvarez-Estrada

The classical limit and the infrared divergence problem for a non-relativistic charged quantum particle interacting with the quantized electromagnetic field are analized. Overall three momentum conservation is taken into account. A unitary transformation associated to the coherent state corresponding to a particle surrounded by a cloud of soft photons is performed upon the hamiltonian and the particle-field states. The transformed state represnting a moving dressed quantum particle and its energy are given by the Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory. It is shown formally that the quantum energy approaches the classical electromagnetic field at the Plank constant h goes to zero. Moreover,all Feynman diagrams contributing to this quantum energy are infrared finite, without needing add diagrams of the same order in the electric charge to obtain the infrared finiteness. Those properties justify the usefulness of the unitary transformation. The Compton effect in the forward direction is studied using dressed charged particle states after the unitary transformation has been performed. The quantum cross section approaches the classical limit (Thomson´s formula) as h ͢͢͢͢͢ 0, and the Feynman diagrams are free of infrared divergences.

Annales De L Institut Henri Poincare-physique Theorique•Jan 1, 1984•0 citations

Infrared Quantum Information

Daniel Carney, Laurent Chaurette, Dominik Neuenfeld +1 more

We discuss information-theoretic properties of low-energy photons and gravitons in the S matrix. Given an incoming n-particle momentum eigenstate, we demonstrate that unobserved soft photons decohere nearly all outgoing momentum superpositions of charged particles, while the universality of gravity implies that soft gravitons decohere nearly all outgoing momentum superpositions of all the hard particles. Using this decoherence, we compute the entanglement entropy of the soft bosons and show that it is infrared-finite when the leading divergences are resummed in the manner of Bloch and Nordsieck.

arXiv:1706.03782•Physical Review Letters•Oct 30, 2017•92 citations

Soft QED as Open Quantum System: Infrared Cancellation and Soft-Shell Coarse Graining

Soo-Jong Rey

I formulate unresolved soft-photon sector of QED as open quantum system. Resolved charged particles and hard photons form the system, unresolved soft photons form the environment, and basic object is the reduced density matrix. A resolved outcome $f$ of multiple hard particles and photons has probability $P_{f}(i) =\sum_n|\langle f,n|S|i,0\rangle|^2=\langle i|F_f|i\rangle$, with Kraus operators $K_n= {}_{\rm soft} \langle n|S|0 \rangle_{\rm soft}$ and effect $F_f=\sum_nK_n^\daggerΠ_fK_n$. The SK formulation places unresolved virtual and real terms in one doubled-contour expansion. At one loop they carry the same on-shell eikonal kernel with opposite signs. This elegantly organizes the QED probability: for the same observable, perturbative order, diagrams, and phase space, the OQS gives the same infrared-finite terms as the full-QED. The soft-photon evolution is a unitary coherent-state displacement driven by the scattering current. The equal-history identity of influence functional exactly normalizes this soft evolution; together with the soft-photon theorem it removes the IR divergent leading-soft factor from inclusive probability. I also derive explicit leading-soft QED realization of scale-parametrized Lindblad evolution on a fixed hard-branch space. Tracing an infinitesimal soft-photon shell produces diagonal jump operators whose entries are fixed by the corresponding eikonal emission amplitudes. The finite-shell map is a completely positive unital Schur channel and, in the sharp scale-invariant leading-soft regime, a dephasing semigroup of a completely-positive-divisible scale flow. The resulting logarithmic visibility slope and monotonic purity loss are off-diagonal predictions of the reduced-state description. The same controlled-displacement dilation gives the Sudakov probability, Poisson soft-photon multiplicities, and the bremsstrahlung number spectrum.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2606.27498•Jun 29, 2026

Interaction Free Measurements and Weinberg's Soft Photons Theorem

Filipe Barroso

I present a detailed mathematical description and interpretation of Weinberg's Soft Photon Theorem for regularising infrared divergences in Quantum Electrodynamics.The theorem can easily be extended to any low-energy photons, regardless of the degree of detectability, thus deducing the correction factors and probability of emission, the latter mirroring the semiclassical Poisson distribution, for these photons.An explicit calculation of those probabilities for the case of electron-photon scattering leads to the conclusion that, even in the most extreme case of ultrarrelativistic fermions, these photons have an extremely low emission rate if the lower limit allowed to their energies to be nonvanishing.Any photon detector with nonzero minimal threshold for detection energy would only get a negligible correction factor.Perfect detectors are deemed impossible in the subsequent discussion.Finally, I give a Quantum Field description of Interaction Free Measurements, and argue that many of the paradoxical concepts about these interactions in Quantum Mechanics have a satisfactory explanation in this framework.

•Dec 9, 2019•0 citations

Aspects of quantum information in quantum field theory and quantum gravity

Dominik Neuenfeld

In this thesis we discuss applications of quantum information theoretic concepts to quantum gravity and the low-energy regime of quantum field theories. The first part of this thesis is concerned with how quantum information spreads in four-dimensional scattering experiments for theories coupled to quantum electrodynamics or perturbative quantum gravity. In these cases, every scattering process is accompanied by the emission of an infinite number of soft photons or gravitons, which cause infrared divergences in the calculation of scattering probabilities. There are two methods to deal with IR divergences: the inclusive and dressed formalisms. We demonstrate that in the late-time limit, independent of the method, the hard outgoing particles are entangled with soft particles in such a way that the reduced density matrix of the hard particles is essentially completely decohered. Furthermore, we show that the inclusive formalism is ill-suited to describe scattering of wavepackets, requiring the use of the dressed formalism. We construct the Hilbert space for QED in the dressed formalism as a representation of the canonical commutation relations of the photon creation/annihilation algebra, and argue that it splits into superselection sectors which correspond to eigenspaces of the generators of large gauge transformations. In the second part of this thesis, we turn to applications of quantum information theoretic concepts in the AdS/CFT correspondence. In pure AdS, we find an explicit formula for the Ryu-Takayanagi (RT) surface for special subregions in the dual conformal field theory, whose entangling surface lie on a light cone. The explicit form of the RT surface is used to give a holographic proof of Markovicity of the CFT vacuum on a light cone. Relative entropy of a state on such special subregions is dual to a novel measure of energy associated with a timelike vector flow between the causal and entanglement wedge. Positivity and monotonicity of relative entropy imply positivity and monotonicity of this energy, which yields a consistency conditions for solutions to quantum gravity.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations
We consider soft-photon effects (ir structure of QED) on the construction of physical qubits. Soft photons appear when we build charged qubits from the asymptotic states of QED. This construction is necessary in order to include the effect of soft photons on entanglement measures. The nonexistence of free charged particles (due to the long range of QED interactions) leads us to question the sense of the very concept of free charged qubit. In this work, using the ``dressing'' formalism, we build physical charged qubits from dressed fields which have the correct asymptotic behavior, are gauge invariant, have propagators with a particle pole structure, and are free from infrared divergences. Finally, we discuss the impact of the soft corrections on the entanglement measures.
We consider scattering of Faddeev-Kulish electrons in QED and study the entanglement between the hard and soft particles in the final state at the perturbative level. The soft photon spectrum naturally splits into two parts: (i) soft photons with energies less than a characteristic infrared scale Ed{E}_{d}Ed​ present in the clouds accompanying the asymptotic charged particles, and (ii) sufficiently low energy photons with energies greater than Ed{E}_{d}Ed​, comprising the soft part of the emitted radiation. We construct the density matrix associated with tracing over the radiative soft photons and calculate the entanglement entropy perturbatively. We find that the entanglement entropy is free of any infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory. On the other hand, infrared divergences in the perturbative expansion for the entanglement entropy appear upon tracing over the entire spectrum of soft photons, including those in the clouds. To leading order the entanglement entropy is set by the square of the Fock basis amplitude for real single soft photon emission, which leads to a logarithmic infrared divergence when integrated over the photon momentum. We argue that the infrared divergences in the entanglement entropy (per particle flux per unit time) in this latter case persist to all orders in perturbation theory in the infinite volume limit.
The classical limit and the infrared divergence problem for a non-relativistic charged quantum particle interacting with the quantized electromagnetic field are analized. Overall three momentum conservation is taken into account. A unitary transformation associated to the coherent state corresponding to a particle surrounded by a cloud of soft photons is performed upon the hamiltonian and the particle-field states. The transformed state represnting a moving dressed quantum particle and its energy are given by the Brillouin-Wigner perturbation theory. It is shown formally that the quantum energy approaches the classical electromagnetic field at the Plank constant h goes to zero. Moreover,all Feynman diagrams contributing to this quantum energy are infrared finite, without needing add diagrams of the same order in the electric charge to obtain the infrared finiteness. Those properties justify the usefulness of the unitary transformation. The Compton effect in the forward direction is studied using dressed charged particle states after the unitary transformation has been performed. The quantum cross section approaches the classical limit (Thomson´s formula) as h ͢͢͢͢͢ 0, and the Feynman diagrams are free of infrared divergences.
We discuss information-theoretic properties of low-energy photons and gravitons in the S matrix. Given an incoming n-particle momentum eigenstate, we demonstrate that unobserved soft photons decohere nearly all outgoing momentum superpositions of charged particles, while the universality of gravity implies that soft gravitons decohere nearly all outgoing momentum superpositions of all the hard particles. Using this decoherence, we compute the entanglement entropy of the soft bosons and show that it is infrared-finite when the leading divergences are resummed in the manner of Bloch and Nordsieck.
I formulate unresolved soft-photon sector of QED as open quantum system. Resolved charged particles and hard photons form the system, unresolved soft photons form the environment, and basic object is the reduced density matrix. A resolved outcome fff of multiple hard particles and photons has probability Pf(i)=∑n∣⟨f,n∣S∣i,0⟩∣2=⟨i∣Ff∣i⟩P_{f}(i) =\sum_n|\langle f,n|S|i,0\rangle|^2=\langle i|F_f|i\ranglePf​(i)=∑n​∣⟨f,n∣S∣i,0⟩∣2=⟨i∣Ff​∣i⟩, with Kraus operators Kn=soft⟨n∣S∣0⟩softK_n= {}_{\rm soft} \langle n|S|0 \rangle_{\rm soft}Kn​=soft​⟨n∣S∣0⟩soft​ and effect Ff=∑nKn†ΠfKnF_f=\sum_nK_n^\daggerΠ_fK_nFf​=∑n​Kn†​Πf​Kn​. The SK formulation places unresolved virtual and real terms in one doubled-contour expansion. At one loop they carry the same on-shell eikonal kernel with opposite signs. This elegantly organizes the QED probability: for the same observable, perturbative order, diagrams, and phase space, the OQS gives the same infrared-finite terms as the full-QED. The soft-photon evolution is a unitary coherent-state displacement driven by the scattering current. The equal-history identity of influence functional exactly normalizes this soft evolution; together with the soft-photon theorem it removes the IR divergent leading-soft factor from inclusive probability. I also derive explicit leading-soft QED realization of scale-parametrized Lindblad evolution on a fixed hard-branch space. Tracing an infinitesimal soft-photon shell produces diagonal jump operators whose entries are fixed by the corresponding eikonal emission amplitudes. The finite-shell map is a completely positive unital Schur channel and, in the sharp scale-invariant leading-soft regime, a dephasing semigroup of a completely-positive-divisible scale flow. The resulting logarithmic visibility slope and monotonic purity loss are off-diagonal predictions of the reduced-state description. The same controlled-displacement dilation gives the Sudakov probability, Poisson soft-photon multiplicities, and the bremsstrahlung number spectrum.
I present a detailed mathematical description and interpretation of Weinberg's Soft Photon Theorem for regularising infrared divergences in Quantum Electrodynamics.The theorem can easily be extended to any low-energy photons, regardless of the degree of detectability, thus deducing the correction factors and probability of emission, the latter mirroring the semiclassical Poisson distribution, for these photons.An explicit calculation of those probabilities for the case of electron-photon scattering leads to the conclusion that, even in the most extreme case of ultrarrelativistic fermions, these photons have an extremely low emission rate if the lower limit allowed to their energies to be nonvanishing.Any photon detector with nonzero minimal threshold for detection energy would only get a negligible correction factor.Perfect detectors are deemed impossible in the subsequent discussion.Finally, I give a Quantum Field description of Interaction Free Measurements, and argue that many of the paradoxical concepts about these interactions in Quantum Mechanics have a satisfactory explanation in this framework.
In this thesis we discuss applications of quantum information theoretic concepts to quantum gravity and the low-energy regime of quantum field theories. The first part of this thesis is concerned with how quantum information spreads in four-dimensional scattering experiments for theories coupled to quantum electrodynamics or perturbative quantum gravity. In these cases, every scattering process is accompanied by the emission of an infinite number of soft photons or gravitons, which cause infrared divergences in the calculation of scattering probabilities. There are two methods to deal with IR divergences: the inclusive and dressed formalisms. We demonstrate that in the late-time limit, independent of the method, the hard outgoing particles are entangled with soft particles in such a way that the reduced density matrix of the hard particles is essentially completely decohered. Furthermore, we show that the inclusive formalism is ill-suited to describe scattering of wavepackets, requiring the use of the dressed formalism. We construct the Hilbert space for QED in the dressed formalism as a representation of the canonical commutation relations of the photon creation/annihilation algebra, and argue that it splits into superselection sectors which correspond to eigenspaces of the generators of large gauge transformations. In the second part of this thesis, we turn to applications of quantum information theoretic concepts in the AdS/CFT correspondence. In pure AdS, we find an explicit formula for the Ryu-Takayanagi (RT) surface for special subregions in the dual conformal field theory, whose entangling surface lie on a light cone. The explicit form of the RT surface is used to give a holographic proof of Markovicity of the CFT vacuum on a light cone. Relative entropy of a state on such special subregions is dual to a novel measure of energy associated with a timelike vector flow between the causal and entanglement wedge. Positivity and monotonicity of relative entropy imply positivity and monotonicity of this energy, which yields a consistency conditions for solutions to quantum gravity.