Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Interaction Free Measurements and Weinberg's Soft Photons Theorem

Filipe Barroso

Published Dec 9, 2019• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

I present a detailed mathematical description and interpretation of Weinberg's Soft Photon Theorem for regularising infrared divergences in Quantum Electrodynamics.The theorem can easily be extended to any low-energy photons, regardless of the degree of detectability, thus deducing the correction factors and probability of emission, the latter mirroring the semiclassical Poisson distribution, for these photons.An explicit calculation of those probabilities for the case of electron-photon scattering leads to the conclusion that, even in the most extreme case of ultrarrelativistic fermions, these photons have an extremely low emission rate if the lower limit allowed to their energies to be nonvanishing.Any photon detector with nonzero minimal threshold for detection energy would only get a negligible correction factor.Perfect detectors are deemed impossible in the subsequent discussion.Finally, I give a Quantum Field description of Interaction Free Measurements, and argue that many of the paradoxical concepts about these interactions in Quantum Mechanics have a satisfactory explanation in this framework.

DOI
10.34626/znqj-eh38

Related papers

Experimental realization of interaction-free measurements

Harald Weinfurter, Paul G. Kwiat, Thomas Herzog +2 more

Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.

Quantum Electronics and Laser Science Conference•May 22, 1995•8 citations

Quantum Theory finally reconciled with Special Relativity

Daniele Tommasini

In 1935 Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) pointed out that Quantum Mechanics apparently implied some mysterious, instantaneous action at a distance. This paradox is supposed to be related to the probabilistic nature of the theory, but since deterministic alternatives involving "Hidden Variables" hardly agree with the experiments, the scientific community is now accepting this ``quantum nonlocality" as if it were a reality. However, I have argued recently that Quantum Electrodynamics is free from the EPR paradox, due to an indetermination on the number of the unobserved "soft photons" that can be present in any step of any experiment. Here, I will provide a more general proof, based on an approach to the "problem of measurement" that implies the full reconciliation of Quantum Field Theory with Special Relativity. I will then conclude with some considerations on the interpretation of the Quantum Theory itself.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111083•Nov 15, 2001•2 citations

Quantum Electrodynamics is free from the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox

Daniele Tommasini

I show that Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) predicts a sort of uncertainty principle on the number of the "soft photons" that can be produced in coincidence with the particles that are observed in any EPR experiment. This result is argued to be sufficient to remove the original EPR paradox. A signature of this soft-photons solution of the EPR paradox would be the observation of apparent symmetry violation in single events. On the other hand, in the case of the EPR experiments that have actually been realized, the QED correlations are argued to be very close to those calculated by the previous, incomplete treatment, which showed a good agreement with the data. Finally, the usual interpretation of the correlations themselves as a real sign of nonlocality is also criticized.

arXiv:quant-ph/0110059•Oct 9, 2001•4 citations

Open Systems

E R Pike frs, Sarben Sarkar

Abstract In the interactions of electromagnetic radiation with matter which we have considered so far, we have almost invariably known accurately the state of the system before interaction. As a result the notion of an open system with an external environment did not have to be systematically discussed. In the quantum electrodynamics of elementary particles, the scattering events are predominantly affected by only few-body interactions and the concepts of temperature and environment are irrelevant. (The resolution of the problem of infra-red divergences is an exception where the environment of soft photons is crucial.) For very small numbers of atoms it may be possible to know the initial state of the system, but in a macroscopic device this is essentially impossible. Although for transitions at optical frequencies the temperature of the environment may be negligible, this will not necessarily be the case for microwave transitions. We have already seen how atomic linewidths can be produced by interactions with the bath of photons at zero temperature. In the general case a quantum-mechanical system will show not only fluctuations due to the non-commutative nature of quantum theory but also thermal fluctuations and dissipation due to interactions with the environment. For complicated systems it will not be possible to know with certainty the initial state of the system, and so the approach of studying the evolution of a state vector through the Schrodinger equation has to be replaced by a consideration of the time evolution of the density operator introduced in Chapter 4. We will formulate a systematic way of treating the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical open system interacting with a heat bath, which will be illustrated with important examples.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 7, 1995•0 citations

Wigner-PDC description of photon entanglement as a local-realistic theory

David Rodríguez

Regardless of past proposals (already disproved in experimental work by Brida et al), the Wigner picture of Parametric Down Conversion (works by Casado et al) can be interpreted as a local-realistic formalism, without the need to depart from quantum mechanical predictions at any step, at least for the relevant subset of QED-states. This involves reinterpreting the expressions for the detection probabilities, by means of an additional mathematical manipulation; though such manipulation seemingly provides enough freedom to guarantee consistency with the expectable, experimentally testable behavior of detectors, this is, in any case, irrelevant in relation to our main result, of a purely mathematical nature. Besides, the Wigner-PDC approach opens clear room to explain the elusive nature of a loop-hole free proof of the incompatibility of nature with that local-realism, without the need to assume hypothetical technological inefficiencies yet to overcome after several decades of experimental work. In relation to this, we also address the consequences of this framework in relation to typical Bell experiments. Additionally, we also propose an extremely simple interpretation on that apparently awkward "subtraction" of the average ZPF intensity at the Wigner image of the detection process.

arXiv:1111.3898•Nov 16, 2011•1 citation

IR dynamics and entanglement entropy

Theodore N. Tomaras, Nicolaos Toumbas

We consider scattering of Faddeev-Kulish electrons in QED and study the entanglement between the hard and soft particles in the final state at the perturbative level. The soft photon spectrum naturally splits into two parts: (i) soft photons with energies less than a characteristic infrared scale ${E}_{d}$ present in the clouds accompanying the asymptotic charged particles, and (ii) sufficiently low energy photons with energies greater than ${E}_{d}$, comprising the soft part of the emitted radiation. We construct the density matrix associated with tracing over the radiative soft photons and calculate the entanglement entropy perturbatively. We find that the entanglement entropy is free of any infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory. On the other hand, infrared divergences in the perturbative expansion for the entanglement entropy appear upon tracing over the entire spectrum of soft photons, including those in the clouds. To leading order the entanglement entropy is set by the square of the Fock basis amplitude for real single soft photon emission, which leads to a logarithmic infrared divergence when integrated over the photon momentum. We argue that the infrared divergences in the entanglement entropy (per particle flux per unit time) in this latter case persist to all orders in perturbation theory in the infinite volume limit.

arXiv:1910.07847•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Mar 16, 2020•25 citations
I present a detailed mathematical description and interpretation of Weinberg's Soft Photon Theorem for regularising infrared divergences in Quantum Electrodynamics.The theorem can easily be extended to any low-energy photons, regardless of the degree of detectability, thus deducing the correction factors and probability of emission, the latter mirroring the semiclassical Poisson distribution, for these photons.An explicit calculation of those probabilities for the case of electron-photon scattering leads to the conclusion that, even in the most extreme case of ultrarrelativistic fermions, these photons have an extremely low emission rate if the lower limit allowed to their energies to be nonvanishing.Any photon detector with nonzero minimal threshold for detection energy would only get a negligible correction factor.Perfect detectors are deemed impossible in the subsequent discussion.Finally, I give a Quantum Field description of Interaction Free Measurements, and argue that many of the paradoxical concepts about these interactions in Quantum Mechanics have a satisfactory explanation in this framework.
Recently, it has been pointed out that it is possible to make a quantum-mechanical interaction-free measurement (IFM), in which the existence of an object in a given region of space may be determined seemingly without interacting with it.1,2 In the embodiment first proposed by Elitzur and Vaidman,3 a standard Michelson interferometer is aligned so that incident single photons (obtained in our experiment by using parametric downconversion; see Fig. 1) must exit by the same port in which they entered, in the absence of any object within the interferometer. The presence of an object (e.g., the mirror leading to detector DB) in one of the arms completely changes the possible outcomes because the constructive interference is interrupted. Now it is possible that the photon will exit from the other exit port, to detector DIfm. By detecting the photon in this case, one can claim with certainty that an object was within the interferometer, even though the photon could not have interacted with it. If the beam splitter has a very low reflectivity, then the fraction of IFMs approaches 1/2.
In 1935 Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) pointed out that Quantum Mechanics apparently implied some mysterious, instantaneous action at a distance. This paradox is supposed to be related to the probabilistic nature of the theory, but since deterministic alternatives involving "Hidden Variables" hardly agree with the experiments, the scientific community is now accepting this ``quantum nonlocality" as if it were a reality. However, I have argued recently that Quantum Electrodynamics is free from the EPR paradox, due to an indetermination on the number of the unobserved "soft photons" that can be present in any step of any experiment. Here, I will provide a more general proof, based on an approach to the "problem of measurement" that implies the full reconciliation of Quantum Field Theory with Special Relativity. I will then conclude with some considerations on the interpretation of the Quantum Theory itself.
I show that Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) predicts a sort of uncertainty principle on the number of the "soft photons" that can be produced in coincidence with the particles that are observed in any EPR experiment. This result is argued to be sufficient to remove the original EPR paradox. A signature of this soft-photons solution of the EPR paradox would be the observation of apparent symmetry violation in single events. On the other hand, in the case of the EPR experiments that have actually been realized, the QED correlations are argued to be very close to those calculated by the previous, incomplete treatment, which showed a good agreement with the data. Finally, the usual interpretation of the correlations themselves as a real sign of nonlocality is also criticized.
Abstract In the interactions of electromagnetic radiation with matter which we have considered so far, we have almost invariably known accurately the state of the system before interaction. As a result the notion of an open system with an external environment did not have to be systematically discussed. In the quantum electrodynamics of elementary particles, the scattering events are predominantly affected by only few-body interactions and the concepts of temperature and environment are irrelevant. (The resolution of the problem of infra-red divergences is an exception where the environment of soft photons is crucial.) For very small numbers of atoms it may be possible to know the initial state of the system, but in a macroscopic device this is essentially impossible. Although for transitions at optical frequencies the temperature of the environment may be negligible, this will not necessarily be the case for microwave transitions. We have already seen how atomic linewidths can be produced by interactions with the bath of photons at zero temperature. In the general case a quantum-mechanical system will show not only fluctuations due to the non-commutative nature of quantum theory but also thermal fluctuations and dissipation due to interactions with the environment. For complicated systems it will not be possible to know with certainty the initial state of the system, and so the approach of studying the evolution of a state vector through the Schrodinger equation has to be replaced by a consideration of the time evolution of the density operator introduced in Chapter 4. We will formulate a systematic way of treating the dynamics of a quantum-mechanical open system interacting with a heat bath, which will be illustrated with important examples.
Regardless of past proposals (already disproved in experimental work by Brida et al), the Wigner picture of Parametric Down Conversion (works by Casado et al) can be interpreted as a local-realistic formalism, without the need to depart from quantum mechanical predictions at any step, at least for the relevant subset of QED-states. This involves reinterpreting the expressions for the detection probabilities, by means of an additional mathematical manipulation; though such manipulation seemingly provides enough freedom to guarantee consistency with the expectable, experimentally testable behavior of detectors, this is, in any case, irrelevant in relation to our main result, of a purely mathematical nature. Besides, the Wigner-PDC approach opens clear room to explain the elusive nature of a loop-hole free proof of the incompatibility of nature with that local-realism, without the need to assume hypothetical technological inefficiencies yet to overcome after several decades of experimental work. In relation to this, we also address the consequences of this framework in relation to typical Bell experiments. Additionally, we also propose an extremely simple interpretation on that apparently awkward "subtraction" of the average ZPF intensity at the Wigner image of the detection process.
We consider scattering of Faddeev-Kulish electrons in QED and study the entanglement between the hard and soft particles in the final state at the perturbative level. The soft photon spectrum naturally splits into two parts: (i) soft photons with energies less than a characteristic infrared scale Ed{E}_{d}Ed​ present in the clouds accompanying the asymptotic charged particles, and (ii) sufficiently low energy photons with energies greater than Ed{E}_{d}Ed​, comprising the soft part of the emitted radiation. We construct the density matrix associated with tracing over the radiative soft photons and calculate the entanglement entropy perturbatively. We find that the entanglement entropy is free of any infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory. On the other hand, infrared divergences in the perturbative expansion for the entanglement entropy appear upon tracing over the entire spectrum of soft photons, including those in the clouds. To leading order the entanglement entropy is set by the square of the Fock basis amplitude for real single soft photon emission, which leads to a logarithmic infrared divergence when integrated over the photon momentum. We argue that the infrared divergences in the entanglement entropy (per particle flux per unit time) in this latter case persist to all orders in perturbation theory in the infinite volume limit.