Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0803.3371

Force, quantum mechanics and approximate energy eigenstates

Chandrachur Das, Bhattacharyya, K.

Published Mar 24, 2008• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The prevalent role of force in traditional quantum mechanics is outlined, with special reference to approximate calculations for stationary states. It will be explored how far this force concept can be made useful in the concerned area. The basic idea is to differentiate the Schroedinger stationary equation once. Thus, one can eliminate the unknown energy as well, and then examine how a force-based approach can be beneficial in providing quickly the nodal information and in assessing the quality of an approximate function. Further, it will be demonstrated how the minimization of a suitable quantity derived from force may constitute a variational principle for bound states. The strategy applies also to Siegert states where traditional energy extremization principle ceases to work. Additionally, the utility of the force concept in semiclassical mechanics will be investigated.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0803.3371

Related papers

The mystery behind Schroedinger's first communication: a non-historical study on the variational approach and its implications

Pui Him Ip

It is well known that Schroedinger first derived his equation via a seemingly ad hoc variational principle. However, he abandoned the approach soon after. In this paper, it is argued that the variational approach can be well motivated physically. In this perspective, the quantum state is found to be conceptually analogous to the role of motion in classical mechanics. Paradoxically, it refers to a real ensemble with fictitious parts. Further, it is argued that due to unobservability, the concept motion in quantum mechanics should be relegated to a lesser role.

•Jun 1, 2013•0 citations

Classical Mechanics Theory and Schrödinger's Equation: A Derivation of Relations

J. Q. Li, Yanchun Yu

This study examines integrating the Schrödinger equation with classical mechanics using a virtual axis-to-dimensional expansion. One-dimensional material fluctuations are viewed in a two-dimensional plane, explaining the random nature of these fluctuations and their spatial and temporal trajectories. A quantum-consistent force field is proposed, with its strength determined by the Planck constant and inversely proportional to the distance from the stationary point. Newton's second law is applied to establish a second-order linear differential equation for material fluctuations, from which the standard one-dimensional Schrödinger equation is derived, showing their equivalence. The study extends the three-dimensional Schrödinger equation to include external forces and explains quantum phenomena like energy levels and transitions through particle trajectory changes. This approach connects classical mechanics and quantum mechanics, offering a concise and intuitive formulation with clear physical significance.

Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences•Sep 23, 2025•1 citation

Time Dependence

Electronic structure is primarily concerned with the lowest-energy state of a system, the ground state. This encompasses many properties, but often we are interested in higher-energy states, and transitions between different states. Up the this point it might appear that the goal of quantum mechanics was to find solutions, or approximate solutions, to the Schroedinger Equation. For the rest of the text we move on to other problems. The parallel in classical mechanics would be first addressing the calculation of normal modes of vibration, and then moving on to trajectories, collisions, and the myriad of other problems an engineer or scientist must deal with. In quantum mechanics the basic premise is still the wave-particle duality, with h' providing the relation between the two, but we now seek the answer to different questions.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2000•0 citations

Quantum Ensembles

Robert H. Swendsen

The study of quantum statistical mechanics begins with a review of the basic principles of quantum mechanics. Schrödinger’s equation is introduced and Eigenstates (or stationary states) are defined. Model probability for quantum statistics is assumed to have a uniform distribution in phases. Wave functions for many-body systems are defined. The density matrix is introduced. The Planck entropy and the microcanonical ensemble are defined. The differences between classical and quantum statistical mechanics are all based on the differing concepts of a microscopic ‘state’. While the classical microscopic state (specified by a point in phase space) determines the exact position and momentum of every particle, the quantum mechanical state determines neither; quantum states can only provide probability distributions for observable quantities.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 10, 2019•0 citations

Conservation of Energy in Classical Mechanics and Its Lack from the Point of View of Quantum Theory

Stanisław Olszewski

It is pointed out that the property of a constant energy characteristic for the circular motions of macroscopic bodies in classical mechanics does not hold when the quantum conditions for the motion are applied. This is so because any macroscopic body—lo-cated in a high-energy quantum state—is in practice forced to change this state to a state having a lower energy. The rate of the energy decrease is usually extremely small which makes its effect uneasy to detect in course of the observations, or experiments. The energy of the harmonic oscillator is thoroughly examined as an example. Here our point is that not only the energy, but also the oscillator amplitude which depends on energy, are changing with time. In result, no constant positions of the turning points of the oscillator can be specified; consequently the well-known variational procedure concerning the calculation of the action function and its properties cannot be applied.

Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2016•2 citations

A Calculus of Finite Precision

Benjamin Liebowitz

Sec. I. This paper inverts certain quantum mechanical ideas by constructing a "probability of presence" from first principles. If ${x}_{i}={f}_{i}(s,{a}_{1},{a}_{2})$ represents a 2-parameter family of curves in 3-dimensional space, the density of the functions ${f}_{i}$ with respect to the parameters ${a}_{1}{a}_{2}$ is defined by means of an expression for the normal cross section of a sheaf of curves. This density plays the role of a probability. Its derivative along a curve of the family is independent of the parameters ${a}_{1}{a}_{2}$. This circumstance permits a special density to be constructed, called the "characteristic" or "smoothest" density, which is independent of the parameters and which can be found by solving a linear second-order partial differential equation. The extension to $n$-dimensional space and ($n\ensuremath{-}1$) parameters is given. Sec. II. The concept of orbital density is the dynamical equivalent of the density of Sec. I. Dividing the orbital density by the velocity of the representative point gives the quantity we call kinematical probability $P$, which satisfies the fundamental equation (2.8), and which has the same force as any other probability of presence. Equation (2.8) is used to derive from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a "wave" equation for $\ensuremath{\surd}P$ for a system of $n$ planets moving around a sun under the condition that the space average of the mutual interactions of the planets is a minimum. This provides a new approach to planetary dynamics and yields an equation that is very much like Schroedinger's equation for the stationary states of $n$ particles, and has the same basic interpretation. Sec. III. A non-conservative system of $n$ particles is assumed to be in a state such that the action function can be written $W=\ensuremath{-}Et+R({x}_{i},t)$ in which $R$ still contains the time explicitly. Starting with the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, using Eq. (2.8), and imposing the condition that the space average of $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}R}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ is a minimum, an equation [viz., (3.10)] is derived which differs from Schroedinger's equation for stationary states only in certain respects that cannot be regarded as fundamental. Despite this basic equivalence of Schroedinger's equation and our equation (3.10), conflicts in interpretation and formalism arise which are briefly discussed. Sec. IV. Complex $U$' s are introduced into Eq. (3.10) in a simple way which fails to bridge the gap between our formalism and that of quantum mechanics. The kinematical probability defined by Eq. (3.10) is shown to have the "smoothest" property. To account physically for the stationary states an electromagnetic wave system is proposed which has the property that a particle moving in it may be in "phase-mechanical" resonance with it. Macroscopic examples of this kind of resonance are given. This concept represents an inversion of physical ideas of quantum mechanics corresponding to the mathematical inversion with which we began.

Physical Review•Dec 1, 1944•5 citations
The prevalent role of force in traditional quantum mechanics is outlined, with special reference to approximate calculations for stationary states. It will be explored how far this force concept can be made useful in the concerned area. The basic idea is to differentiate the Schroedinger stationary equation once. Thus, one can eliminate the unknown energy as well, and then examine how a force-based approach can be beneficial in providing quickly the nodal information and in assessing the quality of an approximate function. Further, it will be demonstrated how the minimization of a suitable quantity derived from force may constitute a variational principle for bound states. The strategy applies also to Siegert states where traditional energy extremization principle ceases to work. Additionally, the utility of the force concept in semiclassical mechanics will be investigated.
It is well known that Schroedinger first derived his equation via a seemingly ad hoc variational principle. However, he abandoned the approach soon after. In this paper, it is argued that the variational approach can be well motivated physically. In this perspective, the quantum state is found to be conceptually analogous to the role of motion in classical mechanics. Paradoxically, it refers to a real ensemble with fictitious parts. Further, it is argued that due to unobservability, the concept motion in quantum mechanics should be relegated to a lesser role.
This study examines integrating the Schrödinger equation with classical mechanics using a virtual axis-to-dimensional expansion. One-dimensional material fluctuations are viewed in a two-dimensional plane, explaining the random nature of these fluctuations and their spatial and temporal trajectories. A quantum-consistent force field is proposed, with its strength determined by the Planck constant and inversely proportional to the distance from the stationary point. Newton's second law is applied to establish a second-order linear differential equation for material fluctuations, from which the standard one-dimensional Schrödinger equation is derived, showing their equivalence. The study extends the three-dimensional Schrödinger equation to include external forces and explains quantum phenomena like energy levels and transitions through particle trajectory changes. This approach connects classical mechanics and quantum mechanics, offering a concise and intuitive formulation with clear physical significance.
Electronic structure is primarily concerned with the lowest-energy state of a system, the ground state. This encompasses many properties, but often we are interested in higher-energy states, and transitions between different states. Up the this point it might appear that the goal of quantum mechanics was to find solutions, or approximate solutions, to the Schroedinger Equation. For the rest of the text we move on to other problems. The parallel in classical mechanics would be first addressing the calculation of normal modes of vibration, and then moving on to trajectories, collisions, and the myriad of other problems an engineer or scientist must deal with. In quantum mechanics the basic premise is still the wave-particle duality, with h' providing the relation between the two, but we now seek the answer to different questions.
The study of quantum statistical mechanics begins with a review of the basic principles of quantum mechanics. Schrödinger’s equation is introduced and Eigenstates (or stationary states) are defined. Model probability for quantum statistics is assumed to have a uniform distribution in phases. Wave functions for many-body systems are defined. The density matrix is introduced. The Planck entropy and the microcanonical ensemble are defined. The differences between classical and quantum statistical mechanics are all based on the differing concepts of a microscopic ‘state’. While the classical microscopic state (specified by a point in phase space) determines the exact position and momentum of every particle, the quantum mechanical state determines neither; quantum states can only provide probability distributions for observable quantities.
It is pointed out that the property of a constant energy characteristic for the circular motions of macroscopic bodies in classical mechanics does not hold when the quantum conditions for the motion are applied. This is so because any macroscopic body—lo-cated in a high-energy quantum state—is in practice forced to change this state to a state having a lower energy. The rate of the energy decrease is usually extremely small which makes its effect uneasy to detect in course of the observations, or experiments. The energy of the harmonic oscillator is thoroughly examined as an example. Here our point is that not only the energy, but also the oscillator amplitude which depends on energy, are changing with time. In result, no constant positions of the turning points of the oscillator can be specified; consequently the well-known variational procedure concerning the calculation of the action function and its properties cannot be applied.
Sec. I. This paper inverts certain quantum mechanical ideas by constructing a "probability of presence" from first principles. If xi=fi(s,a1,a2){x}_{i}={f}_{i}(s,{a}_{1},{a}_{2})xi​=fi​(s,a1​,a2​) represents a 2-parameter family of curves in 3-dimensional space, the density of the functions fi{f}_{i}fi​ with respect to the parameters a1a2{a}_{1}{a}_{2}a1​a2​ is defined by means of an expression for the normal cross section of a sheaf of curves. This density plays the role of a probability. Its derivative along a curve of the family is independent of the parameters a1a2{a}_{1}{a}_{2}a1​a2​. This circumstance permits a special density to be constructed, called the "characteristic" or "smoothest" density, which is independent of the parameters and which can be found by solving a linear second-order partial differential equation. The extension to nnn-dimensional space and ($n\ensuremath{-}1$) parameters is given. Sec. II. The concept of orbital density is the dynamical equivalent of the density of Sec. I. Dividing the orbital density by the velocity of the representative point gives the quantity we call kinematical probability PPP, which satisfies the fundamental equation (2.8), and which has the same force as any other probability of presence. Equation (2.8) is used to derive from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a "wave" equation for $\ensuremath{\surd}P$ for a system of nnn planets moving around a sun under the condition that the space average of the mutual interactions of the planets is a minimum. This provides a new approach to planetary dynamics and yields an equation that is very much like Schroedinger's equation for the stationary states of nnn particles, and has the same basic interpretation. Sec. III. A non-conservative system of nnn particles is assumed to be in a state such that the action function can be written $W=\ensuremath{-}Et+R({x}_{i},t)$ in which RRR still contains the time explicitly. Starting with the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, using Eq. (2.8), and imposing the condition that the space average of $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}R}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ is a minimum, an equation [viz., (3.10)] is derived which differs from Schroedinger's equation for stationary states only in certain respects that cannot be regarded as fundamental. Despite this basic equivalence of Schroedinger's equation and our equation (3.10), conflicts in interpretation and formalism arise which are briefly discussed. Sec. IV. Complex UUU' s are introduced into Eq. (3.10) in a simple way which fails to bridge the gap between our formalism and that of quantum mechanics. The kinematical probability defined by Eq. (3.10) is shown to have the "smoothest" property. To account physically for the stationary states an electromagnetic wave system is proposed which has the property that a particle moving in it may be in "phase-mechanical" resonance with it. Macroscopic examples of this kind of resonance are given. This concept represents an inversion of physical ideas of quantum mechanics corresponding to the mathematical inversion with which we began.