Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

A Calculus of Finite Precision

Benjamin Liebowitz

Published Dec 1, 1944• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Sec. I. This paper inverts certain quantum mechanical ideas by constructing a "probability of presence" from first principles. If ${x}_{i}={f}_{i}(s,{a}_{1},{a}_{2})$ represents a 2-parameter family of curves in 3-dimensional space, the density of the functions ${f}_{i}$ with respect to the parameters ${a}_{1}{a}_{2}$ is defined by means of an expression for the normal cross section of a sheaf of curves. This density plays the role of a probability. Its derivative along a curve of the family is independent of the parameters ${a}_{1}{a}_{2}$. This circumstance permits a special density to be constructed, called the "characteristic" or "smoothest" density, which is independent of the parameters and which can be found by solving a linear second-order partial differential equation. The extension to $n$-dimensional space and ($n\ensuremath{-}1$) parameters is given. Sec. II. The concept of orbital density is the dynamical equivalent of the density of Sec. I. Dividing the orbital density by the velocity of the representative point gives the quantity we call kinematical probability $P$, which satisfies the fundamental equation (2.8), and which has the same force as any other probability of presence. Equation (2.8) is used to derive from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a "wave" equation for $\ensuremath{\surd}P$ for a system of $n$ planets moving around a sun under the condition that the space average of the mutual interactions of the planets is a minimum. This provides a new approach to planetary dynamics and yields an equation that is very much like Schroedinger's equation for the stationary states of $n$ particles, and has the same basic interpretation. Sec. III. A non-conservative system of $n$ particles is assumed to be in a state such that the action function can be written $W=\ensuremath{-}Et+R({x}_{i},t)$ in which $R$ still contains the time explicitly. Starting with the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, using Eq. (2.8), and imposing the condition that the space average of $\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}R}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}$ is a minimum, an equation [viz., (3.10)] is derived which differs from Schroedinger's equation for stationary states only in certain respects that cannot be regarded as fundamental. Despite this basic equivalence of Schroedinger's equation and our equation (3.10), conflicts in interpretation and formalism arise which are briefly discussed. Sec. IV. Complex $U$' s are introduced into Eq. (3.10) in a simple way which fails to bridge the gap between our formalism and that of quantum mechanics. The kinematical probability defined by Eq. (3.10) is shown to have the "smoothest" property. To account physically for the stationary states an electromagnetic wave system is proposed which has the property that a particle moving in it may be in "phase-mechanical" resonance with it. Macroscopic examples of this kind of resonance are given. This concept represents an inversion of physical ideas of quantum mechanics corresponding to the mathematical inversion with which we began.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.66.343

Related papers

A CLASSICAL MECHANICS OF FINITE PRECISION AND ITS RELATION TO THE SCHROEDINGER EQUATIONS.

Benjamin Liebowitz

•Jan 1, 1968•0 citations

Unified Propagation of Massive Particles: Phase Dynamics, Gauge Structure, and Generalized Refraction

Kaisheng Li, Longji Li

Wave mechanics, geometrical optics, classical Hamilton--Jacobi dynamics, electron optics, and gauge-coupled quantum mechanics are usually introduced as conceptually distinct frameworks. Yet they share a common mathematical structure: an environment modifies a local phase relation, the phase defines a local propagation momentum, and the resulting momentum field determines characteristic curves along which propagation occurs. This paper develops a propagation-first synthesis of these structures for particles with nonzero rest mass. For a nonrelativistic spinless particle with wave function\[\Psi(\mathbf r,t)=R(\mathbf r,t)e^{iS(\mathbf r,t)/\hbar},\]the Schrödinger equation in scalar and electromagnetic potentials is exactly equivalent, wherever the amplitude is sufficiently regular, to a continuity equation and a quantum Hamilton--Jacobi equation,\[\frac{\partial R^2}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left[R^2\frac{\nabla S-q\mathbf A}{m}\right]=0,\]\[\frac{\partial S}{\partial t}+\frac{(\nabla S-q\mathbf A)^2}{2m}+q\phi+U+Q=0,\]where\[Q=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\nabla^2R}{R}.\] The gauge-invariant kinetic propagation momentum is therefore\[\boldsymbol{\Pi}=\nabla S-q\mathbf A,\]and the associated local propagation velocity is\[\mathbf v=\frac{\boldsymbol{\Pi}}{m}.\] We call this coupled amplitude--phase representation the \textbf{Unified Propagation System}. The name denotes an organizational framework rather than a new fundamental equation. Within this framework, external interactions can be interpreted as modifications of a local phase--dispersion structure. For static scalar potentials, spatial variation of the local propagation momentum defines an effective matter-wave refractive index and reproduces the optical--mechanical analogy familiar from Hamiltonian and electron optics. Electromagnetic vector potentials generalize this picture: they enter directly into the gauge-invariant phase gradient and therefore modify propagation direction in a manner that cannot in general be represented by a scalar refractive index. This motivates a generalized definition of refraction: \textbf{refraction is the bending of propagation characteristics caused by spatial or temporal variation of the local phase--dispersion relation}. In the semiclassical limit this definition reduces directly to geometrical ray bending. Beyond that limit, the full amplitude-dependent term \(Q\) provides an additional modification of the propagation structure. The same equations can be written in a second-order form,\[m\frac{d\mathbf v}{dt}=q(\mathbf E+\mathbf v\times\mathbf B)-\nabla U-\nabla Q,\]showing that force-based and propagation-based descriptions can represent the same dynamics at different levels. We therefore propose that electromagnetic deflection, potential scattering, and matter-wave refraction may be regarded as different manifestations of a common propagation principle rather than as fundamentally unrelated mechanisms. The paper deliberately avoids a deeper ontological claim. It does not assert that the wave function, electromagnetic field, and particle arise from a common physical substrate. It instead identifies the propagation structure that any such deeper account would have to reproduce. A relativistic extension based on the gauge-covariant Hamilton--Jacobi equation suggests that the same architecture survives beyond the nonrelativistic Schrödinger regime.

•Sep 22, 2026•0 citations

Quantization of a one-dimensional system by means of the quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation

M. Fusco Girard

The numerical version of the Hamilton-Jacobi quantization method, recently proposed, is applied to the one dimensional quartic oscillator. A suitable quantization condition is formulated and various energy levels and wave functions are computed. The results very well agree with those obtained by means of the Schroedinger equation, and confirm that the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi approach, which is the exact version of the semiclassical WKB scheme, is a self-contained quantization procedure, equivalent and independent from the Schoedinger's one but more general. Indeed, with respect to this latter, the Quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation can be used to investigate the limit h->0, where the Schroedinger equation loses its significance, and explains how the fundamental quantities of the classical mechanics, the Hamilton's characteristic function and the classical momentum, are generated from the corresponding quantum ones.

arXiv:1711.09552•Nov 27, 2017•3 citations

Interpreting the Schrödinger Equation

Abstract In stark contrast to classical Newtonian mechanics, the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics associates the Schrödinger wavefunction, not in a determ- inistic way with definite predictions about a specific, individual experimental result, but only in a probabilistic manner, with |ψ(x, t )|2 acting as a probability density, in this case, for position measurements. Before analyzing this approach in more detail, we will find it profitable to briefly review some of the basic concepts of discrete and

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 13, 2006•0 citations

On the first Schröedinger’s derivation of his time-independent equation using statistical mechanics and extremizing the energy of the hydrogen atom

Mladen Abramovic

Abstract This paper intends to provide instruction for a single lesson in an introductory course on quantum mechanics by tying together probabilistic methods from statistical mechanics, the use of complex numbers, and a more founded explanation for the derivation of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation. Here presented derivation strongly supports the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics. Niels Bohr suggested a hydrogen atom model (similar to Kepler’s sun-planet model), where the negatively-charged electron moves in orbit around the heavy positively charged nucleus, this electron having some kinetic and potential energy. Starting from Hamilton’s differential equation for Kepler like atomic model, Schrödinger introduced a new unknown real function ψ in his derivation of time-independent equation (initially, he did not recognize it as the wave function). We show that hypothetical statistical spread of action on many (indefinite) levels is mandatory for the derivation of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation. The result of this hypothesis, the statistical probability constraint formula, is used in this derivation as we look for a minimum of probability for the electron energy distribution E ψ in the whole space. The Euler–Lagrange equation, with normalization of ψ as a constraint limitation, then gives Schrödinger’s time-independent equation for real numbers. A closer inspection of the normalized function ψ shows that it could be complex and is related to the de Broglie–Bohr model of the hydrogen atom. It can be postulated that the classical solution of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation should be a normalized complex function ψ .

European Journal of Physics•May 21, 2025•0 citations

Exact computation of quantum wave functions for nonlinear potentials

Winfried Loghmiller, Jean-Jacques Slotine

Recent work shows that the Schrödinger equation can be solved exactly based only on classical least action. The computation is based on first computing the multi-valued action solutions of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, computing the classical propagated density along all stationary action multipaths, and finally constructing the exact kernel and wave function based on these classical multi-valued quantities alone. The method requires that the propagated classical square root density along each stationary action path is harmonic, as is the case for basic examples such as e.g., the double-slit, quantum tunneling, or the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen experiment. For more complex cases, residual Bohm-like quantum potentials along each stationary action path can be eliminated through a time-rescaling. This paper proposes an extended version of the above construction which avoids the need for time-rescaling even in the most general cases. This is achieved by introducing in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a real viscosity term, which classically simply corresponds to replacing a lumped parameter model with a continuum model including a volumetric stress tensor. This keeps the earlier construction unchanged, except that the real stationary action multipaths are now real stationary viscous action multipaths defined with respect to an associated modified Lagrangian. As in the earlier version, the construction extends straightforwardly to the special and general relativistic contexts, thus describing in a common language the quantum, classical, and relativistic cases. Note that the global Bohm potential term in the lumped Hamilton-Jacobi equation associated with a Madelung transform does not have a classical equivalent, while the volumetric stress tensor term in our viscous Hamilton-Jacobi equation directly represents the real paths of a classical deformed particle field.

quant-pharXiv:2609.14480•Sep 15, 2026•0 citations
Sec. I. This paper inverts certain quantum mechanical ideas by constructing a "probability of presence" from first principles. If xi=fi(s,a1,a2){x}_{i}={f}_{i}(s,{a}_{1},{a}_{2})xi​=fi​(s,a1​,a2​) represents a 2-parameter family of curves in 3-dimensional space, the density of the functions fi{f}_{i}fi​ with respect to the parameters a1a2{a}_{1}{a}_{2}a1​a2​ is defined by means of an expression for the normal cross section of a sheaf of curves. This density plays the role of a probability. Its derivative along a curve of the family is independent of the parameters a1a2{a}_{1}{a}_{2}a1​a2​. This circumstance permits a special density to be constructed, called the "characteristic" or "smoothest" density, which is independent of the parameters and which can be found by solving a linear second-order partial differential equation. The extension to nnn-dimensional space and (n\ensuremath−1n\ensuremath{-}1n\ensuremath−1) parameters is given. Sec. II. The concept of orbital density is the dynamical equivalent of the density of Sec. I. Dividing the orbital density by the velocity of the representative point gives the quantity we call kinematical probability PPP, which satisfies the fundamental equation (2.8), and which has the same force as any other probability of presence. Equation (2.8) is used to derive from the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a "wave" equation for \ensuremath√P\ensuremath{\surd}P\ensuremath√P for a system of nnn planets moving around a sun under the condition that the space average of the mutual interactions of the planets is a minimum. This provides a new approach to planetary dynamics and yields an equation that is very much like Schroedinger's equation for the stationary states of nnn particles, and has the same basic interpretation. Sec. III. A non-conservative system of nnn particles is assumed to be in a state such that the action function can be written W=\ensuremath−Et+R(xi,t)W=\ensuremath{-}Et+R({x}_{i},t)W=\ensuremath−Et+R(xi​,t) in which RRR still contains the time explicitly. Starting with the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, using Eq. (2.8), and imposing the condition that the space average of \ensuremath∂R\ensuremath∂t\frac{\ensuremath{\partial}R}{\ensuremath{\partial}t}\ensuremath∂t\ensuremath∂R​ is a minimum, an equation [viz., (3.10)] is derived which differs from Schroedinger's equation for stationary states only in certain respects that cannot be regarded as fundamental. Despite this basic equivalence of Schroedinger's equation and our equation (3.10), conflicts in interpretation and formalism arise which are briefly discussed. Sec. IV. Complex UUU' s are introduced into Eq. (3.10) in a simple way which fails to bridge the gap between our formalism and that of quantum mechanics. The kinematical probability defined by Eq. (3.10) is shown to have the "smoothest" property. To account physically for the stationary states an electromagnetic wave system is proposed which has the property that a particle moving in it may be in "phase-mechanical" resonance with it. Macroscopic examples of this kind of resonance are given. This concept represents an inversion of physical ideas of quantum mechanics corresponding to the mathematical inversion with which we began.
Wave mechanics, geometrical optics, classical Hamilton--Jacobi dynamics, electron optics, and gauge-coupled quantum mechanics are usually introduced as conceptually distinct frameworks. Yet they share a common mathematical structure: an environment modifies a local phase relation, the phase defines a local propagation momentum, and the resulting momentum field determines characteristic curves along which propagation occurs. This paper develops a propagation-first synthesis of these structures for particles with nonzero rest mass. For a nonrelativistic spinless particle with wave functionΨ(r,t)=R(r,t)eiS(r,t)/ℏ,\Psi(\mathbf r,t)=R(\mathbf r,t)e^{iS(\mathbf r,t)/\hbar},Ψ(r,t)=R(r,t)eiS(r,t)/ℏ,the Schrödinger equation in scalar and electromagnetic potentials is exactly equivalent, wherever the amplitude is sufficiently regular, to a continuity equation and a quantum Hamilton--Jacobi equation,∂R2∂t+∇⋅[R2∇S−qAm]=0,\frac{\partial R^2}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot\left[R^2\frac{\nabla S-q\mathbf A}{m}\right]=0,∂t∂R2​+∇⋅[R2m∇S−qA​]=0,∂S∂t+(∇S−qA)22m+qϕ+U+Q=0,\frac{\partial S}{\partial t}+\frac{(\nabla S-q\mathbf A)^2}{2m}+q\phi+U+Q=0,∂t∂S​+2m(∇S−qA)2​+qϕ+U+Q=0,whereQ=−ℏ22m∇2RR.Q=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\nabla^2R}{R}.Q=−2mℏ2​R∇2R​. The gauge-invariant kinetic propagation momentum is thereforeΠ=∇S−qA,\boldsymbol{\Pi}=\nabla S-q\mathbf A,Π=∇S−qA,and the associated local propagation velocity isv=Πm.\mathbf v=\frac{\boldsymbol{\Pi}}{m}.v=mΠ​. We call this coupled amplitude--phase representation the \textbf{Unified Propagation System}. The name denotes an organizational framework rather than a new fundamental equation. Within this framework, external interactions can be interpreted as modifications of a local phase--dispersion structure. For static scalar potentials, spatial variation of the local propagation momentum defines an effective matter-wave refractive index and reproduces the optical--mechanical analogy familiar from Hamiltonian and electron optics. Electromagnetic vector potentials generalize this picture: they enter directly into the gauge-invariant phase gradient and therefore modify propagation direction in a manner that cannot in general be represented by a scalar refractive index. This motivates a generalized definition of refraction: \textbf{refraction is the bending of propagation characteristics caused by spatial or temporal variation of the local phase--dispersion relation}. In the semiclassical limit this definition reduces directly to geometrical ray bending. Beyond that limit, the full amplitude-dependent term QQQ provides an additional modification of the propagation structure. The same equations can be written in a second-order form,mdvdt=q(E+v×B)−∇U−∇Q,m\frac{d\mathbf v}{dt}=q(\mathbf E+\mathbf v\times\mathbf B)-\nabla U-\nabla Q,mdtdv​=q(E+v×B)−∇U−∇Q,showing that force-based and propagation-based descriptions can represent the same dynamics at different levels. We therefore propose that electromagnetic deflection, potential scattering, and matter-wave refraction may be regarded as different manifestations of a common propagation principle rather than as fundamentally unrelated mechanisms. The paper deliberately avoids a deeper ontological claim. It does not assert that the wave function, electromagnetic field, and particle arise from a common physical substrate. It instead identifies the propagation structure that any such deeper account would have to reproduce. A relativistic extension based on the gauge-covariant Hamilton--Jacobi equation suggests that the same architecture survives beyond the nonrelativistic Schrödinger regime.
The numerical version of the Hamilton-Jacobi quantization method, recently proposed, is applied to the one dimensional quartic oscillator. A suitable quantization condition is formulated and various energy levels and wave functions are computed. The results very well agree with those obtained by means of the Schroedinger equation, and confirm that the Quantum Hamilton Jacobi approach, which is the exact version of the semiclassical WKB scheme, is a self-contained quantization procedure, equivalent and independent from the Schoedinger's one but more general. Indeed, with respect to this latter, the Quantum Hamilton-Jacobi equation can be used to investigate the limit h->0, where the Schroedinger equation loses its significance, and explains how the fundamental quantities of the classical mechanics, the Hamilton's characteristic function and the classical momentum, are generated from the corresponding quantum ones.
Abstract In stark contrast to classical Newtonian mechanics, the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics associates the Schrödinger wavefunction, not in a determ- inistic way with definite predictions about a specific, individual experimental result, but only in a probabilistic manner, with |ψ(x, t )|2 acting as a probability density, in this case, for position measurements. Before analyzing this approach in more detail, we will find it profitable to briefly review some of the basic concepts of discrete and
Abstract This paper intends to provide instruction for a single lesson in an introductory course on quantum mechanics by tying together probabilistic methods from statistical mechanics, the use of complex numbers, and a more founded explanation for the derivation of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation. Here presented derivation strongly supports the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics. Niels Bohr suggested a hydrogen atom model (similar to Kepler’s sun-planet model), where the negatively-charged electron moves in orbit around the heavy positively charged nucleus, this electron having some kinetic and potential energy. Starting from Hamilton’s differential equation for Kepler like atomic model, Schrödinger introduced a new unknown real function ψ in his derivation of time-independent equation (initially, he did not recognize it as the wave function). We show that hypothetical statistical spread of action on many (indefinite) levels is mandatory for the derivation of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation. The result of this hypothesis, the statistical probability constraint formula, is used in this derivation as we look for a minimum of probability for the electron energy distribution E ψ in the whole space. The Euler–Lagrange equation, with normalization of ψ as a constraint limitation, then gives Schrödinger’s time-independent equation for real numbers. A closer inspection of the normalized function ψ shows that it could be complex and is related to the de Broglie–Bohr model of the hydrogen atom. It can be postulated that the classical solution of Schrödinger’s time-independent equation should be a normalized complex function ψ .
Recent work shows that the Schrödinger equation can be solved exactly based only on classical least action. The computation is based on first computing the multi-valued action solutions of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, computing the classical propagated density along all stationary action multipaths, and finally constructing the exact kernel and wave function based on these classical multi-valued quantities alone. The method requires that the propagated classical square root density along each stationary action path is harmonic, as is the case for basic examples such as e.g., the double-slit, quantum tunneling, or the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen experiment. For more complex cases, residual Bohm-like quantum potentials along each stationary action path can be eliminated through a time-rescaling. This paper proposes an extended version of the above construction which avoids the need for time-rescaling even in the most general cases. This is achieved by introducing in the Hamilton-Jacobi equation a real viscosity term, which classically simply corresponds to replacing a lumped parameter model with a continuum model including a volumetric stress tensor. This keeps the earlier construction unchanged, except that the real stationary action multipaths are now real stationary viscous action multipaths defined with respect to an associated modified Lagrangian. As in the earlier version, the construction extends straightforwardly to the special and general relativistic contexts, thus describing in a common language the quantum, classical, and relativistic cases. Note that the global Bohm potential term in the lumped Hamilton-Jacobi equation associated with a Madelung transform does not have a classical equivalent, while the volumetric stress tensor term in our viscous Hamilton-Jacobi equation directly represents the real paths of a classical deformed particle field.