Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0711.1404

More Detailed Descriptions of Locality and Realism

Ping‐Xing Chen, Shi-Yao Zhu

Published Nov 9, 2007• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many experiments have shown that locality-realism theory is at variance with quantum mechanics predictions. Although locality and realism, which are two different conceptions, are given respective definition, the descriptions of the both are a little of abstract when they are applied to real experimental situations. The abstract descriptions result in difficulty for one to judge whether the variance come from locality or realism or both. Here we provide more detailed descriptions of locality and realism, and show that any system being in a pure state or a non-maximally mixed state has property of non-realism. We also present experimental schemes feasible under current technologies to test the non-locality realsim. The connections between non-locality and entanglement and correlation are also discussed.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0711.1404

Related papers

Nonlocal realism considered for entangled photons

Reinhard K. Erdmann, Michael L. Fanto, Corey J. Peters +3 more

Experimental measurements of entangled photons have enabled effective probing of foundational principles of physical law, Quantum Mechanics (QM) in particular. When it was noted that QM is non-local and precludes certain real properties, change in the description of basic phenomena was required. Bell's Inequality work clarified this conflict with Local-Realistic descriptions but left open whether locality, realism, or both should be abandoned. More recent investigations consider models that maintain forms of non-local realism as alternatives to QM. Problems with those are illustrated here, and support a non-local QM description of entangled photons having non-determinate properties.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 1, 2012•1 citation

On Realism and Quantum Mechanics

Giuliani, Giuseppe

A discussion of the quantum mechanical use of superposition or entangled states shows that descriptions containing only statements about state vectors and experiments outputs are the most suitable for Quantum Mechanics. In particular, it is shown that statements about the undefined values of physical quantities before measurement can be dropped without changing the predictions of the theory. If we apply these ideas to EPR issues, we find that the concept of non-locality with its 'instantaneous action at a distance' evaporates. Finally, it is argued that usual treatments of philosophical realist positions end up in the construction of theories whose major role is that of being disproved by experiment. This confutation proves simply that the theories are wrong; no conclusion about realism (or any other philosophical position) can be drawn, since experiments deal always with theories and these are never logical consequences of philosophical positions.

arXiv:quant-ph/0507028•NCimB•Jul 4, 2005•4 citations

Quantum Non-locality, QuantumContextuality and Marco-Realism

Debashis Saha

The descriptions of the quantum realm and the macroscopic classical world di�er signi �cantly not only in their mathematical formulations, but also in their foundational concepts and philosophical consequences. The assumptions of local realism, non-contextuality and macroscopic realism (macro-realism) along with the quantum mechanical violations of these assumptions are discussed. A complete generalization is provided of Wigner's argument inferring quantum nonlocality, originally restricted for the EPR-Bohm entangled state, based on assuming joint probability distributions for all the relevant dichotomic observables. Such Generalized Wigner Inequality (GWI) turns out to be the N-partite local realist inequality which is violated by quantum mechanics for all pure entangled states for any N. We then exploit the non-trivial manifestation of quantum non-locality via local contextuality on three qubit system. Here, we propose an experimental scheme to realize this feature by deriving a new local realist inequality. The way quantum entanglement can be used for global contextual value assigning is discussed in a quantum pseudo-telepathy game. In the second part of this report, we formulate Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) in terms of joint probability and demonstrate its quantum mechanical violation for two state oscillation, which is initial state dependent, unlike the case of standard LGI. It has been shown that, the newly formulated LGI reveals robustness against unsharp measurement for testing compatibility between macro-realism and quantum mechanics. Finally we show that, the recently proposed No-signaling in time condition, contradicts with quantum mechanical predictions for any degree of unsharpness in measurement.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Experimental test of nonlocal causality

Martin Ringbauer, Christina Giarmatzi, Rafael Chaves +3 more

Explaining observations in terms of cause-and-effect (causal) relations is central to empirical science. However, in his seminal 1964 work [1], John Bell showed that the correlations between entangled quantum systems cannot be explained in terms of, possibly hidden, cause and effect relations. After four decades of experimental effort, Bell's prediction has recently been confirmed in an unambiguous way by a series of loophole-free Bell-test experiments [2-4]. These experiments, however, cannot reveal where exactly quantum mechanics breaks with our classical notion of cause and effect. Specifically, Bell's theorem is based on the central assumptions of realism and local causality. Realism posits that physical systems have real, objective properties, independent of whether we observe them or not, and local causality assumes that causal influences cannot propagate faster than the speed of light.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 1, 2017•13 citations

On the problem of non-locality in quantum mechanics

Diederik Aerts, Reignier, J.

Many experimental results and theoretical reasonings on gedanken experiments suggest that quantum entities behave in a non-local . In order to make the discussion more precise, we propose an operational definition of non-locality . We discuss two examples of spin superposition experiments which illustrate the use of this definition. They show that quantum entities like a neutron or an atom are non-local. We make an analysis of the difficulty to imagine such non-local entities and to conciliate this non-locality with the locality of classical entities

Helvetica Physica Acta (Switzerland)•Jul 5, 1991•13 citations

Completing Quantum Mechanics within the Framework of Local Realism

Guang-Liang Li

In the Einstein-Bohr debate, Einstein considered quantum mechanics incomplete and disagreed with Born’s probabilistic interpretation of wave-functions. Observers in the axioms of quantum mechanics also bothered Einstein. Inspired by Einstein, Bell and his followers intended to complete quantum mechanics within the framework of local realism. Regrettably, the deterministic correlation between distant components of a separable system in Einstein’s local-realist description of the world is mistaken for non-locality in the world described by Bell’s theorem, leading to incorrect interpretations of experimental results obtained by testing Bell inequalities. This article introduces a new principle, the general principle of measurements, which is proved as a mathematical theorem and allows quantum mechanics to be completed within the framework of local realism while keeping the formal axiomatic definition of a general Hilbert space unchanged. The completed theory can provide the same probabilistic predictions of empirical results as those provided by the current theory. Using disjunction (“or”) as the logical relation between superposed orthonormal vectors, the completed theory precludes observers in the axioms of the current theory and inexplicable collapses of wave-functions, thus it is intuitively comprehensible and alleviates much difficulty in understanding quantum mechanics. Among various world views, Einstein’s local-realist world view is correct.

•Jun 11, 2025•0 citations
Many experiments have shown that locality-realism theory is at variance with quantum mechanics predictions. Although locality and realism, which are two different conceptions, are given respective definition, the descriptions of the both are a little of abstract when they are applied to real experimental situations. The abstract descriptions result in difficulty for one to judge whether the variance come from locality or realism or both. Here we provide more detailed descriptions of locality and realism, and show that any system being in a pure state or a non-maximally mixed state has property of non-realism. We also present experimental schemes feasible under current technologies to test the non-locality realsim. The connections between non-locality and entanglement and correlation are also discussed.
Experimental measurements of entangled photons have enabled effective probing of foundational principles of physical law, Quantum Mechanics (QM) in particular. When it was noted that QM is non-local and precludes certain real properties, change in the description of basic phenomena was required. Bell's Inequality work clarified this conflict with Local-Realistic descriptions but left open whether locality, realism, or both should be abandoned. More recent investigations consider models that maintain forms of non-local realism as alternatives to QM. Problems with those are illustrated here, and support a non-local QM description of entangled photons having non-determinate properties.
A discussion of the quantum mechanical use of superposition or entangled states shows that descriptions containing only statements about state vectors and experiments outputs are the most suitable for Quantum Mechanics. In particular, it is shown that statements about the undefined values of physical quantities before measurement can be dropped without changing the predictions of the theory. If we apply these ideas to EPR issues, we find that the concept of non-locality with its 'instantaneous action at a distance' evaporates. Finally, it is argued that usual treatments of philosophical realist positions end up in the construction of theories whose major role is that of being disproved by experiment. This confutation proves simply that the theories are wrong; no conclusion about realism (or any other philosophical position) can be drawn, since experiments deal always with theories and these are never logical consequences of philosophical positions.
The descriptions of the quantum realm and the macroscopic classical world di�er signi �cantly not only in their mathematical formulations, but also in their foundational concepts and philosophical consequences. The assumptions of local realism, non-contextuality and macroscopic realism (macro-realism) along with the quantum mechanical violations of these assumptions are discussed. A complete generalization is provided of Wigner's argument inferring quantum nonlocality, originally restricted for the EPR-Bohm entangled state, based on assuming joint probability distributions for all the relevant dichotomic observables. Such Generalized Wigner Inequality (GWI) turns out to be the N-partite local realist inequality which is violated by quantum mechanics for all pure entangled states for any N. We then exploit the non-trivial manifestation of quantum non-locality via local contextuality on three qubit system. Here, we propose an experimental scheme to realize this feature by deriving a new local realist inequality. The way quantum entanglement can be used for global contextual value assigning is discussed in a quantum pseudo-telepathy game. In the second part of this report, we formulate Leggett-Garg inequality (LGI) in terms of joint probability and demonstrate its quantum mechanical violation for two state oscillation, which is initial state dependent, unlike the case of standard LGI. It has been shown that, the newly formulated LGI reveals robustness against unsharp measurement for testing compatibility between macro-realism and quantum mechanics. Finally we show that, the recently proposed No-signaling in time condition, contradicts with quantum mechanical predictions for any degree of unsharpness in measurement.
Explaining observations in terms of cause-and-effect (causal) relations is central to empirical science. However, in his seminal 1964 work [1], John Bell showed that the correlations between entangled quantum systems cannot be explained in terms of, possibly hidden, cause and effect relations. After four decades of experimental effort, Bell's prediction has recently been confirmed in an unambiguous way by a series of loophole-free Bell-test experiments [2-4]. These experiments, however, cannot reveal where exactly quantum mechanics breaks with our classical notion of cause and effect. Specifically, Bell's theorem is based on the central assumptions of realism and local causality. Realism posits that physical systems have real, objective properties, independent of whether we observe them or not, and local causality assumes that causal influences cannot propagate faster than the speed of light.
Many experimental results and theoretical reasonings on gedanken experiments suggest that quantum entities behave in a non-local . In order to make the discussion more precise, we propose an operational definition of non-locality . We discuss two examples of spin superposition experiments which illustrate the use of this definition. They show that quantum entities like a neutron or an atom are non-local. We make an analysis of the difficulty to imagine such non-local entities and to conciliate this non-locality with the locality of classical entities
In the Einstein-Bohr debate, Einstein considered quantum mechanics incomplete and disagreed with Born’s probabilistic interpretation of wave-functions. Observers in the axioms of quantum mechanics also bothered Einstein. Inspired by Einstein, Bell and his followers intended to complete quantum mechanics within the framework of local realism. Regrettably, the deterministic correlation between distant components of a separable system in Einstein’s local-realist description of the world is mistaken for non-locality in the world described by Bell’s theorem, leading to incorrect interpretations of experimental results obtained by testing Bell inequalities. This article introduces a new principle, the general principle of measurements, which is proved as a mathematical theorem and allows quantum mechanics to be completed within the framework of local realism while keeping the formal axiomatic definition of a general Hilbert space unchanged. The completed theory can provide the same probabilistic predictions of empirical results as those provided by the current theory. Using disjunction (“or”) as the logical relation between superposed orthonormal vectors, the completed theory precludes observers in the axioms of the current theory and inexplicable collapses of wave-functions, thus it is intuitively comprehensible and alleviates much difficulty in understanding quantum mechanics. Among various world views, Einstein’s local-realist world view is correct.