Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0706.2603

All quantum expectation values as classical statistical mean values

Antonio Cassa

Published Jun 18, 2007• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Given a physical quantum system described by a Hilbert H, for any bounded quantum observable (a bounded self-adjoint operator) T it is possible to define several ''hidden observable'' functions f:H->R associated to T and for any quantum mixed state (a density matrix) D it is possible to define several ''hidden mixed states'' (probability measures) m on H associated to D in such a way that the following equality is verified: Trace[ b(T). D] =integral[b(f(psi)).dm(psi) whatever is the continuous function b:R->R. This formula gives a general way to express any expectation value computable in a quantum theory as a classical statistical mean value.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0706.2603

Related papers

A probabilistic formulation of quantum theory

Alexander Bach

By means of integration in the Hilbert space H which is associated to a quantum mechanical system we demonstrate that the expectation value of quantum mechanics, EW(A) =tr(WA), can be expressed as EW(A) =ℱH dμW(φ) (1/2) 〈φ‖A‖φ〉 Here μW denotes a probability measure in H which is determined by the statistical operator. We discuss this hidden variables representation of quantum mechanics.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1980•34 citations

Dynamic and Ergodic Properties of the XY-Model

Huzihiro Araki

In quantum mechanics, a physical observable is described by a (linear) operator Q on a Hilbert space H and a (pure) state is described by a unit vector Ψ in H. The expectation value (the average of measured values for a large number of repeated measurements) of the observable Q in the State Ψ is given by 1.1.1 ψ( Q )=( ψQψ ) ]] <![CDATA[$$\psi \left( Q \right) = \left( {\psi ,Q\psi } \right)$$ More general states called mixtures are described by a positive operator ρ of trace 1, called a density matrix, for which the expectation value is 1.1.2 ψ( Q )=trρQ ]] <![CDATA[$$\psi \left( Q \right) = tr\rho Q$$ and is at most countable sum of states of the form (1.1.1). ((1.1.1) is a special case where ρ is a one-dimensional projection operator.)

Birkhäuser Boston eBooks•Jan 1, 1985•1 citation

Sharp values for all dynamical variables via Anti-Wick quantization

Simon Friederich

This paper proposes an approach to interpreting quantum expectation values that may help address the quantum measurement problem. Quantum expectation values are usually calculated via Hilbert space inner products and, thereby, differently from expectation values in classical mechanics, which are weighted phase-space integrals. It is shown that, by using Anti-Wick quantization to associate dynamical variables with self-adjoint linear operators, quantum expectation values can be interpreted as genuine weighted averages over phase space, paralleling their classical counterparts. This interpretation arises naturally in the Segal-Bargmann space, where creation and annihilation operators act as simple multiplication and differentiation operators. In this setting, the Husimi Q-function - the coherent-state representation of the quantum state - can be seen as a true probability density in phase space. Unlike Bohmian mechanics, the present approach retains the standard correspondence between dynamical variables and self-adjoint operators while paving the way for a classical-like probabilistic interpretation of quantum statistics.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07616•Physics Letters A•Dec 9, 2025•0 citations

On the measurements regarding random observables

Spiridon Dumitru, Attila Laszlo Boer

Both classical and respectively quantum observables can be modeled as somewhat similar examples of random variables. In such a model the associated measurements preserve the values spectrum of an observable but change the corresponding probabilistic weights (probability density or respectively the wave function). Such a model ensures theoretical estimations for predicted errors specific to the mean values as well as to the fluctuations of both types of observables. The model stands out of ourdays prevalent opinion that measurement theories must be depicted in entirely different manners in the classical respectively quantum cases.

arXiv:0803.2783•Mar 19, 2008•4 citations

Trace Formalism for Quantum Mechanical Expectation Values

John Langerholc

The trace of a positive bounded operator in a Hilbert space is defined and shown to be independent of the basis used in the definition. The trace of the product WA is defined for bounded A and positive bounded W with unit trace and is also shown to be basis-invariant. An integral representation is derived and used to define Tr(WA) for unbounded A. Linearity, isotony, and continuity with respect to uniform covergence are proved for Tr(WA) as a function of (bounded) A. Several formulas used in statistical mechanics are derived, and it is proved that if A and B are commuting positive operators, then Tr(W(A + B)) = Tr(WA) + Tr(WB). A counter example is given which shows that the commonly used definition of Tr(WA) in terms of an orthonormal basis is not invariant under permutation of the basis vectors even in the case of a very simple unbounded operator A. An expectation-value function M which associates the expectation value M(A) to the operator A is assumed given and subject to certain restrictions. For bounded operators, these include positivity, normalization, additivity, and a condition which may be considered as a requirement of regularity for the probability function induced by M. Modifications of these requirements are imposed for unbounded operators, and von Neumann's statistical formula is proved: there is a unique bounded positive operator W with unit trace for which M(A) = Tr(WA). The requirements placed on M are weaker than those of von Neumann, and are in fact satisfied by Tr(WA) as a function of A.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1965•7 citations

Quantum Information Theory

Yorick Hardy, Willi-Hans Steeb

The concepts of classical information theory can be extended to quantum information theory. Since in general measurement yields a result with probability, we may suggest using these probabilities in classical information theory. However the probabilities do not contain phase information, which cannot be neglected. Thus the definitions are given in terms of the density operator. These probabilities depend on the basis used for measurement. A density operator ρ over a n-dimensional Hilbert space H is a positive operator with unit trace. The trace tr(A) is defined as $$tr(A): = \sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {\left\langle {{\beta _j}|A|{\beta _j}} \right\rangle } $$ where β j for j = 1,..., n is any orthonormal basis in HThus tr(P)=1. The eigenvalues of a density operator are greater than zero. By the spectral theorem every density operator can be represented as a mixture of pure states $$\rho = \sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {Pj|} \left\langle {aj} \right.\langle aj|$$ where α j for j = 1,..., n are the orthonormal eigenvectors of ρ (which form a basis in H and $$pj \in R,{p_j}0,\sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {{p_j}} = 1$$

Birkhäuser Basel eBooks•Jan 1, 2001•8 citations
Given a physical quantum system described by a Hilbert H, for any bounded quantum observable (a bounded self-adjoint operator) T it is possible to define several ''hidden observable'' functions f:H->R associated to T and for any quantum mixed state (a density matrix) D it is possible to define several ''hidden mixed states'' (probability measures) m on H associated to D in such a way that the following equality is verified: Trace[ b(T). D] =integral[b(f(psi)).dm(psi) whatever is the continuous function b:R->R. This formula gives a general way to express any expectation value computable in a quantum theory as a classical statistical mean value.
In quantum mechanics, a physical observable is described by a (linear) operator Q on a Hilbert space H and a (pure) state is described by a unit vector Ψ in H. The expectation value (the average of measured values for a large number of repeated measurements) of the observable Q in the State Ψ is given by 1.1.1 ψ( Q )=( ψQψ ) ]] <![CDATA[ψ(Q)=(ψ,Qψ)\psi \left( Q \right) = \left( {\psi ,Q\psi } \right)ψ(Q)=(ψ,Qψ) More general states called mixtures are described by a positive operator ρ of trace 1, called a density matrix, for which the expectation value is 1.1.2 ψ( Q )=trρQ ]] <![CDATA[ψ(Q)=trρQ\psi \left( Q \right) = tr\rho Qψ(Q)=trρQ and is at most countable sum of states of the form (1.1.1). ((1.1.1) is a special case where ρ is a one-dimensional projection operator.)
This paper proposes an approach to interpreting quantum expectation values that may help address the quantum measurement problem. Quantum expectation values are usually calculated via Hilbert space inner products and, thereby, differently from expectation values in classical mechanics, which are weighted phase-space integrals. It is shown that, by using Anti-Wick quantization to associate dynamical variables with self-adjoint linear operators, quantum expectation values can be interpreted as genuine weighted averages over phase space, paralleling their classical counterparts. This interpretation arises naturally in the Segal-Bargmann space, where creation and annihilation operators act as simple multiplication and differentiation operators. In this setting, the Husimi Q-function - the coherent-state representation of the quantum state - can be seen as a true probability density in phase space. Unlike Bohmian mechanics, the present approach retains the standard correspondence between dynamical variables and self-adjoint operators while paving the way for a classical-like probabilistic interpretation of quantum statistics.
Both classical and respectively quantum observables can be modeled as somewhat similar examples of random variables. In such a model the associated measurements preserve the values spectrum of an observable but change the corresponding probabilistic weights (probability density or respectively the wave function). Such a model ensures theoretical estimations for predicted errors specific to the mean values as well as to the fluctuations of both types of observables. The model stands out of ourdays prevalent opinion that measurement theories must be depicted in entirely different manners in the classical respectively quantum cases.
The trace of a positive bounded operator in a Hilbert space is defined and shown to be independent of the basis used in the definition. The trace of the product WA is defined for bounded A and positive bounded W with unit trace and is also shown to be basis-invariant. An integral representation is derived and used to define Tr(WA) for unbounded A. Linearity, isotony, and continuity with respect to uniform covergence are proved for Tr(WA) as a function of (bounded) A. Several formulas used in statistical mechanics are derived, and it is proved that if A and B are commuting positive operators, then Tr(W(A + B)) = Tr(WA) + Tr(WB). A counter example is given which shows that the commonly used definition of Tr(WA) in terms of an orthonormal basis is not invariant under permutation of the basis vectors even in the case of a very simple unbounded operator A. An expectation-value function M which associates the expectation value M(A) to the operator A is assumed given and subject to certain restrictions. For bounded operators, these include positivity, normalization, additivity, and a condition which may be considered as a requirement of regularity for the probability function induced by M. Modifications of these requirements are imposed for unbounded operators, and von Neumann's statistical formula is proved: there is a unique bounded positive operator W with unit trace for which M(A) = Tr(WA). The requirements placed on M are weaker than those of von Neumann, and are in fact satisfied by Tr(WA) as a function of A.
The concepts of classical information theory can be extended to quantum information theory. Since in general measurement yields a result with probability, we may suggest using these probabilities in classical information theory. However the probabilities do not contain phase information, which cannot be neglected. Thus the definitions are given in terms of the density operator. These probabilities depend on the basis used for measurement. A density operator ρ over a n-dimensional Hilbert space H is a positive operator with unit trace. The trace tr(A) is defined as tr(A):=∑j=1n⟨βj∣A∣βj⟩tr(A): = \sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {\left\langle {{\beta _j}|A|{\beta _j}} \right\rangle } tr(A):=j=1∑n​⟨βj​∣A∣βj​⟩ where β j for j = 1,..., n is any orthonormal basis in HThus tr(P)=1. The eigenvalues of a density operator are greater than zero. By the spectral theorem every density operator can be represented as a mixture of pure states ρ=∑j=1nPj∣⟨aj⟨aj∣\rho = \sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {Pj|} \left\langle {aj} \right.\langle aj|ρ=j=1∑n​Pj∣⟨aj⟨aj∣ where α j for j = 1,..., n are the orthonormal eigenvectors of ρ (which form a basis in H and pj∈R,pj0,∑j=1npj=1pj \in R,{p_j}0,\sum\limits_{j = 1}^n {{p_j}} = 1pj∈R,pj​0,j=1∑n​pj​=1