Decoupled x and t in Probabilities and Free Particle Quantum Mechanics
Francesco R. Ruggeri
A probability of heads/tails for a coin toss or a number for a die is really a frequency in time with no consideration of space. Similarly, a uniform distribution of stationary particles in space with P(x) = 1/L (one dimension restricted to a length L) is a probability in space, with no time appearing. Some phenomena (not necessarily linked to probability) necessarily involve space x and time t, such as a water wave. It is possible to fix x and watch the height of the wave change strictly in t, or take a film such that one sees wave heights at different x points with no reference to time (as one does not have a single crest, but a steady stream of waves). Another observation one may make is to sit on the crest and see x change with t (phase velocity) without any consideration of the wave height changing. The above examples are common in everyday life. We suggest that there is another probability-wave phenomenon which is common (reflection-refraction), but not all details are directly observed for a specific reason, namely because x and t can become decoupled directly at the n1-n2 index of refraction region. Typically, in the classical world one does not decouple x and t. In terms of observation, if one had a math probability given by exp(ipx) for a moving object, with the probability being linked somehow to interaction, then one would not see any changes in time. exp(ipx) is then neither directly visible in space or time, but may exist and have physical consequences. (Its existence would have to be proved experimentally.) The reason that decoupling of x,t may occur is that one does not have a physical measurement, such as a wave height. A physical wave height is described by a periodic function (-wt+kx), for which one cannot decouple t and k because the wave has a physical phase velocity of w/k and the function represents a measurement at x,t even though x,t and t+constant/w and x+ constant/k yield the same functional value. t+constant/w and x+ constant/k must represent another physical wave with the same phase velocity, but based on a different starting x,t, not x=0, t=0. This is because x and t cannot be decoupled as one observes a physical crest. If one has a math function exp(-iEt+ipx), then again one would have x,t marking a certain function value and t+constant/E and x+constant/p marking the same function value. It is certainly possible to have the particle move with a velocity v. In this case, however, the function does not represent an observable in x,t, like the height of a physical wave. In principle, there is no reason why t and x could not be decoupled. This means that the same function value (which presumably has some meaning) could be associated with two different x points for the same t value (or t removed altogether because x and t are decoupled). The question then becomes: How does one reconcile this strange math approach to physical observables? For example, if exp(-iEt+ipx) is considered to be a probability (but not of a measurable object in coupled spacetime which is the usual approach), how does one link this probability to measurements in spacetime? We note that since probabilities may apply only to time or space and noted in the first paragraph, that a decoupled exp(-iEt+ipx) probability lends itself very well to such one variable probabilities. For example, if only space is considered exp(-iEt+ipx) is replaced with exp(ipx) which only pertains to space, just like P(x)=1/L only pertains to space. The latter, however, is based on physical measurements at single points in space, while exp(ipx) is based on the same math function value occurring for two x points (x and x+constant/p) with no time consideration. Normally, one would need a time value directly associated with x, but such is not required for a probability in an OR situation. Different times may be associated with two different events without one needing to one these time values as one is specifically calculating a probability.
•Sep 16, 2026•0 citations