Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9912112

The Double Quantum Dot Feline Cousin of Schroedinger's Cat: An Experimental Testbed for a Discourse of Quantum Measurement Dichotomies

Supriyo Bandyopadhyay

Published Dec 27, 1999• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Intriguing dichotomies in quantum measurement theory involving the role of the obersever, objective reality, collapse of wavefunctions and actualization of a measurement outcome are cast into a patholigical gedanken experiment involving a single electron in a double quantum dot system coupled via a weak link.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.quant-ph/9912112

Related papers

The Double Quantum Dot Feline Cousin of Schrödinger's Cat : An Experimental Test bed for a Discourse of Quantum Measurement Dichotomies

S. Bandyopadhyay

Intriguing dichotomies in quantum measurement theory involving the role of the obersever, objective reality, collapse of wavefunctions and actualization of a measurement outcome are cast into a patholigical gedanken experiment involving a single electron in a double quantum dot system coupled via a weak link.

•Dec 28, 1999•0 citations

The Double Quantum Dot Feline Cousin of Schrödinger's Cat

Somshubhro Bandyopadhyay

•Dec 28, 1999•0 citations

Quantum erasing the nature of reality: or, perhaps, the reality of nature?

Paul G. Kwiat, Berthold‐Georg Englert

The quantum measurement problem – how does an apparently "classical" definite world arise out of the random world of quantum superpositions – was and continues to be one of the fundamental philosophical issues in quantum mechanics. What we mean by a classical world, for example, is one in which macroscopic objects are not in superposition states of being simultaneously in several locations at once, and cats are never in coherent superpositions of being alive and dead. This lack of coherence is actually a loss of the coherence that exists at the level of the isolated quanta, but somehow does not survive the transition to the classical level of measuring apparatus. Such incoherent states are known as mixed states. Therefore, to study the quantum–classical interface, or even to investigate whether such an interface exists at all other than in the minds of "classical sympathizers," one should look carefully at mixed states, how they arise and how they behave. Here we describe a set of experiments, both real and gedanken, investigating the subtleties of quantum interference when mixed states are involved. We start by describing the well-known double-slit experiment, and the loss of interference when which-path information can be had.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 2004•12 citations

Entanglement, decoherence, and measurement

Art Hobson

The fully entangled Schrodinger cat state obtained immediately upon measurement of a superposed two state quantum system by a detector is often said to paradoxically predict macroscopically different outcomes simultaneously. However, nonlocal interferometry experiments and their accompanying quantum theoretical analyses, testing momentum entangled photon pairs over the full range of phases, demonstrate that the cat state does not fit this description. This state instead represents two nonlocally coherent correlations between its subsystems. Even if the detector is a cat, this state is not paradoxical. Furthermore, standard quantum theory correctly predicts the experimentally observed nonparadoxical outcomes. Thus both quantum theory and quantum experiments show there is no Schrodinger cat paradox associated with measurement. This resolves the problem of definite outcomes and, with it, the measurement problem. Upon entanglement with a detector, superpositions collapse nonlocally and unitarily to one definite macroscopic outcome. No special collapse postulate is needed.

•Apr 10, 2019•1 citation

Re-assessment of the state of Schroedinger's cat, final version

Art Hobson

The quantum state of Schroedinger's cat is usually incorrectly described as a superposition of "dead" and "alive," despite an argument by Rinner and Werner that, locally, the cat should be considered to be in a mixture of non-superposed states. Here, it is rigorously proven that the cat is not in a superposition. This is central to the measurement problem. Nonlocal two-photon interferometry experiments throw further light on the measurement state by probing the effect of a variable phase factor inserted between its superposed terms. These experiments demonstrate that both subsystems really are in locally mixed states rather than superpositions, and they tell us what the measurement state superposition actually superposes. They show that measurement transfers the coherence in Schroedinger's nuclear superposition neither to the cat nor to the nucleus, but only to the correlations between them. This explains the collapse process--but not its subsequent irreversible dissipation--within the context of unitary dynamics with no need for external entities such as the environment, a human mind, other worlds, or collapse mechanisms.

arXiv:1206.5189•Jun 21, 2012•0 citations

More on the quantum measurement problem

Art Hobson

In his June 2022 Quick Study (page 62), David Mermin argues that “the quantum state of a system expresses only the belief of the particular physicist who assigns it to the system.” Applying that to quantum measurements, he finds that “the acquisition of further information by that physicist … can lead to an abrupt change in those probabilities and thus to an updating of the quantum state that the physicist uses to represent them. There is no quantum measurement problem.”But wavefunctions have been collapsing ever since the Big Bang, with no assistance from physicists. An apparatus’s display of a measurement outcome occurs even if the experimenters happen to be out of the room. When a cosmic-ray proton strikes a sand grain on Mars and moves the grain, a quantum measurement occurs and the proton’s wavefunction collapses regardless of the absence of humans.Roger Carpenter and Andrew Anderson of the University of Cambridge performed a “Schrödinger’s cat” experiment that demolishes Mermin’s interpretation. Instead of connecting a Geiger counter to a cat-killing device, they mercifully connected it to a hammer that would fall without harm. Their strategy was to split information about the experimental result between two observers in such a way that neither observer can know the outcome. The observers learn the outcome later by sharing their information. The question is then, Did the hammer fall at the time of the experiment or later, when the observers became conscious of the outcome? The result: The hammer fell when the nucleus decayed, not later when the observers became conscious of the outcome. I think nearly all physicists would have predicted that. My hat is off to Carpenter and Anderson, who reported it with a straight face.11. R. H. S. Carpenter, A. J. Anderson, Ann. Fond. Louis de Broglie 31, 45 (2006).Humans and their consciousness have nothing to do with quantum physics. Photons, electrons, and the like, as well as their states, are real configurations of fields that have existed throughout the universe since the Big Bang.22. A. Hobson, Am. J. Phys. 81, 211 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4789885Nevertheless, I agree with Mermin’s title: There is no quantum measurement problem, because quantum physics, with no special interpretation and without a collapse postulate, logically implies that superpositions collapse nonlocally to a single definite outcome.33. A. Hobson, Quantum Eng. 2022, 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5889159ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. H. S. Carpenter, A. J. Anderson, Ann. Fond. Louis de Broglie 31, 45 (2006). Google Scholar2. A. Hobson, Am. J. Phys. 81, 211 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4789885, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. A. Hobson, Quantum Eng. 2022, 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5889159, Google ScholarCrossref© 2022 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Nov 1, 2022•1 citation
The quantum measurement problem – how does an apparently "classical" definite world arise out of the random world of quantum superpositions – was and continues to be one of the fundamental philosophical issues in quantum mechanics. What we mean by a classical world, for example, is one in which macroscopic objects are not in superposition states of being simultaneously in several locations at once, and cats are never in coherent superpositions of being alive and dead. This lack of coherence is actually a loss of the coherence that exists at the level of the isolated quanta, but somehow does not survive the transition to the classical level of measuring apparatus. Such incoherent states are known as mixed states. Therefore, to study the quantum–classical interface, or even to investigate whether such an interface exists at all other than in the minds of "classical sympathizers," one should look carefully at mixed states, how they arise and how they behave. Here we describe a set of experiments, both real and gedanken, investigating the subtleties of quantum interference when mixed states are involved. We start by describing the well-known double-slit experiment, and the loss of interference when which-path information can be had.
The fully entangled Schrodinger cat state obtained immediately upon measurement of a superposed two state quantum system by a detector is often said to paradoxically predict macroscopically different outcomes simultaneously. However, nonlocal interferometry experiments and their accompanying quantum theoretical analyses, testing momentum entangled photon pairs over the full range of phases, demonstrate that the cat state does not fit this description. This state instead represents two nonlocally coherent correlations between its subsystems. Even if the detector is a cat, this state is not paradoxical. Furthermore, standard quantum theory correctly predicts the experimentally observed nonparadoxical outcomes. Thus both quantum theory and quantum experiments show there is no Schrodinger cat paradox associated with measurement. This resolves the problem of definite outcomes and, with it, the measurement problem. Upon entanglement with a detector, superpositions collapse nonlocally and unitarily to one definite macroscopic outcome. No special collapse postulate is needed.
The quantum state of Schroedinger's cat is usually incorrectly described as a superposition of "dead" and "alive," despite an argument by Rinner and Werner that, locally, the cat should be considered to be in a mixture of non-superposed states. Here, it is rigorously proven that the cat is not in a superposition. This is central to the measurement problem. Nonlocal two-photon interferometry experiments throw further light on the measurement state by probing the effect of a variable phase factor inserted between its superposed terms. These experiments demonstrate that both subsystems really are in locally mixed states rather than superpositions, and they tell us what the measurement state superposition actually superposes. They show that measurement transfers the coherence in Schroedinger's nuclear superposition neither to the cat nor to the nucleus, but only to the correlations between them. This explains the collapse process--but not its subsequent irreversible dissipation--within the context of unitary dynamics with no need for external entities such as the environment, a human mind, other worlds, or collapse mechanisms.
In his June 2022 Quick Study (page 62), David Mermin argues that “the quantum state of a system expresses only the belief of the particular physicist who assigns it to the system.” Applying that to quantum measurements, he finds that “the acquisition of further information by that physicist … can lead to an abrupt change in those probabilities and thus to an updating of the quantum state that the physicist uses to represent them. There is no quantum measurement problem.”But wavefunctions have been collapsing ever since the Big Bang, with no assistance from physicists. An apparatus’s display of a measurement outcome occurs even if the experimenters happen to be out of the room. When a cosmic-ray proton strikes a sand grain on Mars and moves the grain, a quantum measurement occurs and the proton’s wavefunction collapses regardless of the absence of humans.Roger Carpenter and Andrew Anderson of the University of Cambridge performed a “Schrödinger’s cat” experiment that demolishes Mermin’s interpretation. Instead of connecting a Geiger counter to a cat-killing device, they mercifully connected it to a hammer that would fall without harm. Their strategy was to split information about the experimental result between two observers in such a way that neither observer can know the outcome. The observers learn the outcome later by sharing their information. The question is then, Did the hammer fall at the time of the experiment or later, when the observers became conscious of the outcome? The result: The hammer fell when the nucleus decayed, not later when the observers became conscious of the outcome. I think nearly all physicists would have predicted that. My hat is off to Carpenter and Anderson, who reported it with a straight face.11. R. H. S. Carpenter, A. J. Anderson, Ann. Fond. Louis de Broglie 31, 45 (2006).Humans and their consciousness have nothing to do with quantum physics. Photons, electrons, and the like, as well as their states, are real configurations of fields that have existed throughout the universe since the Big Bang.22. A. Hobson, Am. J. Phys. 81, 211 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4789885Nevertheless, I agree with Mermin’s title: There is no quantum measurement problem, because quantum physics, with no special interpretation and without a collapse postulate, logically implies that superpositions collapse nonlocally to a single definite outcome.33. A. Hobson, Quantum Eng. 2022, 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5889159ReferencesSection:ChooseTop of pageReferences <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. H. S. Carpenter, A. J. Anderson, Ann. Fond. Louis de Broglie 31, 45 (2006). Google Scholar2. A. Hobson, Am. J. Phys. 81, 211 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4789885, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. A. Hobson, Quantum Eng. 2022, 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5889159, Google ScholarCrossref© 2022 American Institute of Physics.