Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:quant-ph/9910081 · Physical Review A

Quantum to classical phase transition in noisy quantum computers

Dorit Aharonov

Published Nov 14, 2000• 123 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The fundamental problem of the transition from quantum to classical physics is usually explained by decoherence, and viewed as a gradual process. The study of entanglement, or quantum correlations, in noisy quantum computers implies that in some cases the transition from quantum to classical is actually a phase transition. We define the notion of entanglement length in d-dimensional noisy quantum computers, and show that a phase transition in entanglement occurs at a critical noise rate where the entanglement length transforms from infinite to finite. Above the critical noise rate, macroscopic classical behavior is expected, whereas, below the critical noise rate, subsystems that are macroscopically distant one from another can be entangled. The macroscopic classical behavior in the supercritical phase is shown to hold not only for quantum computers but for any quantum system composed of macroscopically many finite state particles, with local interactions and local decoherence, subjected to some additional conditions. This phenomenon provides a possible explanation for the emergence of classical behavior in such systems. A simple formula for an upper bound on the entanglement length of any such system in the supercritical phase is given, and in principle can be tested experimentally.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.62.062311

Related papers

Decoherence and the (non)emergence of classicality

Steven J. Weinstein

We consider the claim that decoherence explains the emergence of classicality in quantum systems, and conclude that it does not. We show that, given a randomly chosen universe composed of a variety of subsystems, some of which are macroscopic and subject to decoherence-inducing interactions, and some of which are microscopic, the macroscopic subsystems will not display any distinctively classical behavior. Therefore, a universe in which macroscopic and microscopic do display distinct behavior must be in a very special, highly nongeneric quantum state.

arXiv:0807.3376•Jul 22, 2008•2 citations

Decoherence and the Emergence of Classicality

Steven J. Weinstein

We consider the claim that decoherence explains the emergence of classicality in quantum systems, and conclude that it cannot. We show that, given a universe composed of a variety of subsystems, some of which are macroscopic and subject to decoherence-inducing interactions, and some of which are microscopic, the macroscopic subsystems do not display any distinctively classical behavior. Therefore, a universe in which macroscopic and microscopic do display distinct behavior must be in a very special, highly nongeneric quantum state.

•Jan 1, 2009•1 citation

ENTANGLEMENT PERCOLATION IN QUANTUM NETWORKS: HOW TO ESTABLISH LARGE DISTANCE QUANTUM CORRELATIONS?

Antonio Acín, Maciej Lewenstein, J. I. Cirac

Quantum communication networks consist of N distant nodes sharing a quantum state. By means of local operation in each node assisted by classical communication, the nodes try to transform the initial state into perfect quantum correlations, that later will be used to perform a quantum information task, such as quantum teleportation or quantum cryptography. Given a network, defined by a geometry of nodes and connections, it is crucial to understand whether it is possible to establish long-distance quantum correlations, in the sense that the correlations between two end points of the network do not decrease exponentially with the number of intermediate connections. In this contribution, we present our recent findings on the distribution of entanglement through quantum networks. In the case of one-dimensional chains of connected quantum systems, the results are hardly surprising: a non-exponential decay is possible only when the entanglement in the connections between nodes is larger than a maximally entangled state of two qubits. The picture becomes much richer and interesting for networks of dimension larger than one: long-distance correlations can be established even when the connecting nodes are not maximally entangled. Actually, the problem of establishing maximally entangled states between nodes is related to classical percolation in statistical mechanics. We show, then, that statistical concepts, such as percolation and phase transitions, can be used to optimize the entanglement distribution through quantum networks. Remarkably, the quantum features allow going beyond the known results for classical percolation, giving rise to a new type of critical phenomenon that we call entanglement percolation.

Recent Progress in Many-Body Theories•Jun 1, 2008•0 citations

Long-range quantum entanglement in noisy cluster states

Robert Raussendorf, Sergey B. Bravyi, Jim Harrington

We describe a phase transition for long-range entanglement in a three-dimensional cluster state affected by noise. The partially decohered state is modeled by the thermal state of a short-range translation-invariant Hamiltonian. We find that the temperature at which the entanglement length changes from infinite to finite is nonzero. We give an upper and lower bound to this transition temperature.

arXiv:quant-ph/0407255•Physical Review A•Jun 14, 2005•214 citations

Phase transition in a noisy Kitaev toric code model

Mohammad Hossein Zarei, Afshin Montakhab

Many aspects of the well-known mapping between the partition function of a classical spin model and the quantum entangled state have been studied in recent years. However, the consequences of the existence of a classical (critical) phase transition on the corresponding quantum state have been mostly ignored. In this paper, we consider this problem for an important example of the Kitaev toric code model which has been shown to correspond to the two-dimensional (2D) Ising model though a duality transformation. We show that the temperature on the classical side is mapped to bit-flip noise on the quantum side. It is then shown that a transition from a coherent superposition of a given quantum state to a noncoherent mixture corresponds exactly to paramagnetic-ferromagnetic phase transition in the Ising model. To identify such a transition further, we define an order parameter to characterize the decoherence of such a mixture and show that it behaves similar to the order parameter (magnetization) of the 2D Ising model, a behavior that is interpreted as a robust coherence in the toric code model. Furthermore, we consider other properties of the noisy toric code model exactly at the critical point. We show that there is a relative stability to noise for the toric code state at the critical noise which is revealed by a relative reduction in susceptibility to noise.

arXiv:1902.06100•Physical Review A•May 9, 2019•9 citations

Quantum phase transition in the Dicke model with critical and noncritical entanglement

L. Bakemeier, Andreas Alvermann, Holger Fehske

We study the quantum phase transition of the Dicke model in the classical oscillator limit, where it occurs already for finite spin length. In contrast to the classical spin limit, for which spin-oscillator entanglement diverges at the transition, entanglement in the classical oscillator limit remains small. We derive the quantum phase transition with identical critical behavior in the two classical limits and explain the differences with respect to quantum fluctuations around the mean-field ground state through an effective model for the oscillator degrees of freedom. With numerical data for the full quantum model we study convergence to the classical limits. We contrast the classical oscillator limit with the dual limit of a high-frequency oscillator, where the spin degrees of freedom are described by the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. An alternative limit can be defined for the Rabi case of spin length one-half, in which spin frequency renormalization replaces the quantum phase transition.

arXiv:1205.1234•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2012•105 citations
The fundamental problem of the transition from quantum to classical physics is usually explained by decoherence, and viewed as a gradual process. The study of entanglement, or quantum correlations, in noisy quantum computers implies that in some cases the transition from quantum to classical is actually a phase transition. We define the notion of entanglement length in d-dimensional noisy quantum computers, and show that a phase transition in entanglement occurs at a critical noise rate where the entanglement length transforms from infinite to finite. Above the critical noise rate, macroscopic classical behavior is expected, whereas, below the critical noise rate, subsystems that are macroscopically distant one from another can be entangled. The macroscopic classical behavior in the supercritical phase is shown to hold not only for quantum computers but for any quantum system composed of macroscopically many finite state particles, with local interactions and local decoherence, subjected to some additional conditions. This phenomenon provides a possible explanation for the emergence of classical behavior in such systems. A simple formula for an upper bound on the entanglement length of any such system in the supercritical phase is given, and in principle can be tested experimentally.
We consider the claim that decoherence explains the emergence of classicality in quantum systems, and conclude that it does not. We show that, given a randomly chosen universe composed of a variety of subsystems, some of which are macroscopic and subject to decoherence-inducing interactions, and some of which are microscopic, the macroscopic subsystems will not display any distinctively classical behavior. Therefore, a universe in which macroscopic and microscopic do display distinct behavior must be in a very special, highly nongeneric quantum state.
We consider the claim that decoherence explains the emergence of classicality in quantum systems, and conclude that it cannot. We show that, given a universe composed of a variety of subsystems, some of which are macroscopic and subject to decoherence-inducing interactions, and some of which are microscopic, the macroscopic subsystems do not display any distinctively classical behavior. Therefore, a universe in which macroscopic and microscopic do display distinct behavior must be in a very special, highly nongeneric quantum state.
Quantum communication networks consist of N distant nodes sharing a quantum state. By means of local operation in each node assisted by classical communication, the nodes try to transform the initial state into perfect quantum correlations, that later will be used to perform a quantum information task, such as quantum teleportation or quantum cryptography. Given a network, defined by a geometry of nodes and connections, it is crucial to understand whether it is possible to establish long-distance quantum correlations, in the sense that the correlations between two end points of the network do not decrease exponentially with the number of intermediate connections. In this contribution, we present our recent findings on the distribution of entanglement through quantum networks. In the case of one-dimensional chains of connected quantum systems, the results are hardly surprising: a non-exponential decay is possible only when the entanglement in the connections between nodes is larger than a maximally entangled state of two qubits. The picture becomes much richer and interesting for networks of dimension larger than one: long-distance correlations can be established even when the connecting nodes are not maximally entangled. Actually, the problem of establishing maximally entangled states between nodes is related to classical percolation in statistical mechanics. We show, then, that statistical concepts, such as percolation and phase transitions, can be used to optimize the entanglement distribution through quantum networks. Remarkably, the quantum features allow going beyond the known results for classical percolation, giving rise to a new type of critical phenomenon that we call entanglement percolation.
Many aspects of the well-known mapping between the partition function of a classical spin model and the quantum entangled state have been studied in recent years. However, the consequences of the existence of a classical (critical) phase transition on the corresponding quantum state have been mostly ignored. In this paper, we consider this problem for an important example of the Kitaev toric code model which has been shown to correspond to the two-dimensional (2D) Ising model though a duality transformation. We show that the temperature on the classical side is mapped to bit-flip noise on the quantum side. It is then shown that a transition from a coherent superposition of a given quantum state to a noncoherent mixture corresponds exactly to paramagnetic-ferromagnetic phase transition in the Ising model. To identify such a transition further, we define an order parameter to characterize the decoherence of such a mixture and show that it behaves similar to the order parameter (magnetization) of the 2D Ising model, a behavior that is interpreted as a robust coherence in the toric code model. Furthermore, we consider other properties of the noisy toric code model exactly at the critical point. We show that there is a relative stability to noise for the toric code state at the critical noise which is revealed by a relative reduction in susceptibility to noise.
We study the quantum phase transition of the Dicke model in the classical oscillator limit, where it occurs already for finite spin length. In contrast to the classical spin limit, for which spin-oscillator entanglement diverges at the transition, entanglement in the classical oscillator limit remains small. We derive the quantum phase transition with identical critical behavior in the two classical limits and explain the differences with respect to quantum fluctuations around the mean-field ground state through an effective model for the oscillator degrees of freedom. With numerical data for the full quantum model we study convergence to the classical limits. We contrast the classical oscillator limit with the dual limit of a high-frequency oscillator, where the spin degrees of freedom are described by the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model. An alternative limit can be defined for the Rabi case of spin length one-half, in which spin frequency renormalization replaces the quantum phase transition.